An ex-senior executive at S4C has settled her court claim against the Welsh-language public broadcaster and its former chairman. Llinos Griffin-Williams has received an undisclosed payout – which she described as a reminder that women “do not have to endure mistreatment and abuse of power, and should not be intimidated into silence”.
In 2023 Ms Griffin-Williams was dismissed from her role as chief content officer for “gross misconduct”. It came after allegations she had been drunk and verbally abused former rugby player Mike Phillips while attending the Rugby World Cup in France in a work capacity.
Ms Griffin-Williams “categorically denied” she made the comments to Mr Phillips that have been attributed to her, and claimed the star “did not make a complaint” about her.
She brought a £565,000 claim to the High Court against S4C and its former chairman, Rhodri Williams, who had sacked her. The parties have now reached a settlement. Make sure you never miss Wales’ biggest updates by getting our daily newsletter
A spokeswoman for Ms Griffin-Williams said: “The settlement includes compensation with which she is satisfied. S4C and Rhodri Williams have requested that the terms be kept confidential.”
READ MORE: Plans still of track for Wales’ first dedicated museum of contemporary artREAD MORE: Senedd Election manifesto from the Tories far more pro-business than Labour
Ms Griffin-Williams is the second former S4C executive to reach a settlement with the broadcaster and Mr Williams in recent months.
Ex-chief executive Sian Doyle, who was dismissed the month after Ms Griffin-Williams, received an undisclosed payout last October after a claim involving a “truly extraordinary and inappropriate period of mistreatment”, according to Mrs Doyle’s lawyers.
And a third woman who was part of the same senior management team, ex-director of platforms Amanda Rees, filed a High Court claim against the broadcaster in February.
Ms Griffin-Williams sought damages from S4C and Mr Williams for “the egregious way in which she was treated and for the harm caused by repeated leaks of private information to the press”, said her spokeswoman.
“Several months before her dismissal, Griffin-Williams made a formal complaint about Rhodri Williams’ conduct,” the spokeswoman added.
“An independent HR investigation upheld her complaint, acknowledging that Rhodri Williams had ‘acted inappropriately towards her’, and had shown a serious ‘disregard for her known health condition’, a life-threatening heart disorder resulting from treatment for stage four cancer in her twenties.
“On the day of her sacking in October 2023, Llinos Griffin-Williams was removed from a high-profile presentation she was giving to around 100 stakeholders in the Welsh media sector, and dismissed on the spot by Rhodri Williams. This was done despite his role as a non-operational, also known as a non-executive, chair.”
She accused the broadcaster of carrying out “a biased, unlawful and unfair investigation” into claims about her conduct at an S4C function during the Rugby World Cup in Nantes.
The spokeswoman continued: “Her dismissal and the allegations against her were reported in the media before the full S4C board had been consulted.
“In her claim, Llinos Griffin-Williams highlighted a series of procedural failings including her immediate dismissal rather than suspension, and reliance on hearsay evidence from individuals not present at the Nantes event.”
According to Ms Griffin-Williams’ court claim, she was given no prior notice of the allegations or right to respond.
She also claimed she was denied any right to appeal and was refused repeated requests to see evidence of the investigation ahead of the High Court claim.
Her spokeswoman said: “In the summer of 2023, Griffin-Williams was signed off work for six weeks due to the stress she was experiencing at S4C, including stress-induced cardiac issues. An occupational health assessment sent to S4C’s head of HR noted that Griffin-Williams’ cardiac condition was such that she would be ‘advised to avoid significant psychological or physical stress’.
“Despite this warning, once Griffin-Williams was dismissed press briefings continued. This prompted a second health professional to write to the broadcaster, stating that Griffin-Williams was ‘suffering from tremendous physical and mental health problems as a result of continued publicity despite her having departed S4C over three months ago’. Again, the briefings continued.
“Griffin-Williams’ condition deteriorated and she required open-heart surgery, followed by a period in intensive care.”
In April 2023, the Bectu broadcasting union made allegations of bullying and a toxic workplace at S4C, prompting Mr Williams to commission an investigation by Cardiff-based Capital Law, costing £564,000.
The spokeswoman for Ms Griffin-Williams claimed the full version of the Capital Law report was not provided to the wider board, adding: “The report was said to contain alleged ‘evidence’, yet allegations were never put to any individual for their response as the inquiry made no formal recommendations.
“Llinos Griffin-Williams claimed that the Capital Law investigation breached S4C’s legal, HR and communications processes and the report’s own terms of reference. Despite this, the ‘findings’ in the report were used retrospectively to justify decisions about dismissals.
“A summarised version of the Capital Law report was provided to the board and was leaked to the press, breaching an embargo.”
The day after the leak, Sian Doyle took an overdose. Mrs Doyle’s husband described the report as the “last straw” and “an assassination of her character”, adding that she had been “torn apart in the media after an exceptional 30-year international career because of a one-sided report”.
Ms Griffin-Williams claims that S4C and Mr Williams agreed to settle her claim as her lawyers were filing an application seeking the release of the Capital Law report in full.
S4C, which will receive £97.6m from the TV licence fee this year, has faced criticism over its culture dating back to a 2011 University of Wales report which described elements of the organisation as “secret, arrogant and politically naïve” and “the worst example of how to behave as a public service broadcaster”.
Ms Griffin-Williams said: “I am pleased that this terrible chapter has finally come to an end after two and a half years. A publicly funded broadcaster should operate with integrity and transparency. What I experienced fell far short of those standards.
“We live in a world where powerful men can feel they have the right to humiliate and destroy women. Here, a public service broadcaster allowed that to happen. I am profoundly saddened that a channel of such cultural importance to Wales proved so devastatingly incapable of protecting the values it was meant to uphold.
“This has been an extremely difficult period for my family and me. No amount of financial compensation can take away the pain and trauma my children and I have suffered. I tried hard to resolve this matter privately, but was forced to pursue justice through the courts. Reaching this settlement now allows me to focus on my recovery and rebuild my life.
“If there is one thing I hope comes from this, it is that women are reminded they do not have to endure mistreatment and abuse of power, and should not be intimidated into silence.”
Her lawyer Emma Linch, of Simons Muirhead Burton, added: “Despite her serious ongoing health problems and the quite appalling way she was treated, Llinos has displayed true strength and resilience.”
And S4C said in a statement: “S4C and Rhodri Williams have, through their respective insurers, reached an agreement with Llinos Griffin-Williams. This brings all proceedings by Ms Griffin-Williams against S4C and Rhodri Williams to an end.
“The terms of the agreement are confidential, and the settlement has been reached without any admission of liability. The parties have concluded that it is in everyone’s interests to resolve the dispute to avoid protracted litigation. They are pleased to have reached a resolution which enables everyone to move forward. S4C will be making no further comment on this matter.”
If you have information about a story we should be investigating, you can contact us at conor.gogarty@walesonline.co.uk








You must be logged in to post a comment Login