WARNING: DISTRESSING CONTENT Schlosser used a knife to cut off both of her 11-month-old daughter’s arms before attempting to kill herself, in an incident that shocked police and the wider public
When the police operator picked up Dena Schlosser’s call, they would never have expected from her relaxed demeanour and calm tone that something utterly tragic had happened.
When asked if there was an emergency, she showed no panic or hysteria, and was in fact so quiet that the sound of a hymn playing softly in the background could be heard during the 2004 call.
When asked by the 911 operator why she was calling and what had happened to her baby, Schlosser’s answered simply: “Yes.” I cut her arms off.”
Police rushed to an apartment in Plano, Texas, where they found a scene so disturbing it would stay with investigators for years. Schlosser sat quietly in the living room, covered head to toe in blood.
Nearby, her baby daughter lay in a crib, catastrophically injured. The child was rushed to hospital but sadly died shortly afterwards from her injuries.
Schlosser had used a knife to cut off both of her 11-month-old daughter’s arms before attempting to kill herself. Somehow, she had survived a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head.
As officers secured the apartment, Christian music continued to play. Those at the scene would later say Schlosser appeared eerily peaceful, even humming hymns as she was taken into custody.
What made the case even harder to comprehend was how normal everything had seemed before it happened.
Neighbours described Schlosser as seeming attentive and even affectionate. She pushed her baby around the neighbourhood most afternoons, she took her children swimming, even stopping to engage in cheery conversations with those she bumped into.
“There were never any red flags,” one neighbour said. “She looked like a great mum.”
But behind closed doors, things had been unraveling.
Earlier that year, Schlosser had suffered a severe psychotic episode following childbirth and was diagnosed with postpartum mental illness.
Child protection services had investigated the family after she was hospitalised, but the case was later closed when she appeared stable and compliant with treatment.
On the day of the killing, something in Schlosser’s brain clearly went very, very wrong.
Psychologists later testified Schlosser believed she was receiving direct instructions from God, becoming convinced her baby was part of a divine plan connected to the apocalypse, and that she was being commanded to mutilate herself and her child.
Hours after her arrest, officers reported hearing her whisper prayers, repeatedly thanking Jesus.
She was initally charged with murder, before medical experts concluded Schlosser was suffering from a profound psychotic break and was incapable of understanding the reality or consequences of her actions.
She was found not guilty by reason of insanity and committed to a state psychiatric hospital. The remainder of her children were removed from the home and she was permanently barred from ever seeing them again.

