Paul Quinn, 51, is accused of raping the woman at a remote embankment near the M61 motorway bridge between Little Hulton and Farnworth back in 2003.

A trial at Manchester Crown Court was told Quinn had avoided justice, and that instead, security guard Andrew Malkinson went to prison for 17 years for a crime he had not committed.

John Price KC, prosecuting, said: “It is the prosecution’s case before you, as you may have realised, that Andrew Malkinson was the victim of a most terrible miscarriage of justice, one of the worst there has been.”

He told the jury of seven women and five men that DNA evidence showed that it was Quinn and not Mr Malkinson who raped the woman back in 2003.

The trial opened at Manchester Crown Court (Image: Anthony Moss)

Quinn, who wore a black jumper and white shirt in the dock, listened in silence as Mr Price opened the case.

Mr Price said the real rapist was a stranger to the victim when he attacked on the morning of Saturday, July 19, 2003, by dragging her from Cleggs Lane down the embankment.

She was found around an hour afterwards by a witness from Farnworth who had been out walking his dog before work, with blood on her face and her clothing in a state of “disarray”.

Mr Price said testing showed the woman had been raped twice, after having been strangled until she was unconscious and beaten about the face.

The witness took the victim to his home in Farnworth and called the police straight away, and she was taken to Royal Bolton Hospital.

The jury was shown images of the injuries to the left side of the woman’s face, which the prosecution says Quinn had inflicted on her.

Mr Price said that her attacker appeared to have fractured the woman’s left cheekbone after she was already unconscious.

He told the jury they would later have to think for themselves about why he had done this.

Speaking to a police officer, PC Deborah Davidson, she described her attacker as a “Gypsy type, muscular, dark hair, off-white shirt, hanging off.”

In a formal statement, she described her attacker as “male, white, olive-skinned” with a “shiny, hairless chest” and dark brown to black, thick hair.

She said his accent was “local to Bolton with a slight trace of another accent”.

A later witness statement the woman gave to police said that the attacker had told her he had a gun

Her statement said: “As I got towards the end of the railings where the houses start, I heard a male voice coming from the wooded area. ‘I think you should come into the bushes, I have a gun pointed at your head’.

“The voice sounded very close and was a local accent.”

She said that as she walked away to the motorway bridge, she felt an “almighty force” behind her and remembered sliding down the grass embankment.

The jury was shown an e-fit image published back in July 2003 of a man based on the description the woman had given.

Mr Price said the now 51-year-old Quinn would have been 29 years old at the time of the attack and showed the jury a series of photographs taken of him between 1994 and 2006.

He said Quinn “strenuously” denied being the rapist when he was finally arrested and interviewed by the police in December 2022, and said he did not know the woman.

Mr Price said it was agreed by both the victim and defendant that “she was a stranger to him, and he was a stranger to her”.

But the prosecutor told the jury that back in 2003, Mr Malkinson, then a security guard at the Ellesmere Shopping Centre in Walkden, was the man arrested in connection with the crime.  

This was after two police officers, who had seen Mr Malkinson earlier that summer, felt he matched a description of the attacker given to them by Detective Inspector Joanne Rawlinson.

Mr Malkinson was then 37 years old and was “white with very noticeable tan, olive skin”.

But the victim had previously told police she had managed to scratch the right side of her attacker’s face and believed he should have a mark showing this.

Despite Mr Malkinson appearing to “strikingly” match the description the victim gave when police officers spoke to him at the shopping centre, he had no such scratch mark.

At the time, Mr Malkinson had recently started staying at a flat with a fellow worker on Aspinall Grove, Little Hulton, not far from where the attack had happened.

Mr Price told the jury that all the indications showed the woman had been assaulted by a “local man, who knew the area”.

Mr Malkinson was found at a Salvation Army hostel in Grimsby after having told his flatmate he had “had enough” with troubles with people he used to live with and was moving to the Netherlands.

The jury heard how this “sudden departure” only added to the suspicion around him, and he was arrested and taken to Crescent Police Station in Salford.

Mr Price said both the victim herself and another witness provided very detailed descriptions of the attacker and the “conspicuous” way he was dressed with an open white shirt.

He said that the location where the victim was “swept down the embankment” just before she crossed over to Farnworth showed he was “not only a local man”.

Mr Price said: “He was also one who knew of this obscure location, a man with prior knowledge of its existence and accessibility, someone who, as he followed her, knew she was soon going to reach it and so timed his attack to coincide with her passing close to somewhere he knew he might easily, forcibly and swiftly take her out of sight and away from the road.”

The prosecutor told the jury how both the victim and two witnesses each picked out images of Mr Malkinson and identified him as the attacker when shown by the police.

Mr Malkinson was tried for rape at Manchester Crown Court in 2004, found guilty and ultimately spent more than 17 years in prison before his release in December 2020.

Mr Price said the identification of him made by the witnesses was “honestly made” but was mistaken.

He said the further evidence, including DNA evidence, “proves” that Quinn and not Mr Malkinson was the real rapist.

Mr Price said there was also further evidence to show how the attacker’s appearance more closely matched that of Quinn’s.

He told the jury that this evidence included “none of the intrinsic weaknesses which existed in the evidence used, wrongly, to convict the innocent Andrew Malkinson”.

Mr Price said the Quinn’s defence would invite the jury to consider whether Mr Malkinson was in fact the real rapist and that it was up to the prosecution to prove it was Quinn.

Quinn, of Whipton Barton Road, Exeter, denies two counts of rape, one count of attempt to strangle, and one count of assault, intending to cause grievous bodily harm.

The trial, before Mr Justice Robert Bright, continues.

Regime change isn’t what it used to be. Donald Trump himself had talked it up as a reason for attacking Iran.

In a White House briefing, press secretary Karoline Leavitt talked it all the way back down.

It took until day five of the military action for the White House to lay out its objectives: destroy Iran’s navy; destroy its ballistic missile capacity; ensure its proxies in the region can no longer harm Americans; and ensure it can never obtain a nuclear weapon.

Follow the latest updates on the conflict with Iran

“Regime change” and what comes next for the Iranian people were conspicuous by their absence.

There was no statement of intent to support a popular uprising in Iran, nor was there any sign that a US mechanism was under consideration to make it happen.

“We hope that freedom rests in their hands,” said Leavitt, referring to the Iranian people without any hint of how “freedom” could be achieved.

She didn’t rule out the use of ground troops but said they weren’t part of the plan.

Asked about reports the Trump administration was considering Kurdish forces in the hope of inspiring a popular uprising in Iran, she responded that such a suggestion was “completely false and should not be written”.

When she talked “victory”, she talked US interests.

“Victory will be determined by the commander in chief,” she said, “once the goals and the objectives that we have repeatedly laid out are fully realised”.

She didn’t put a timeframe on the military action but said the focus was on a “quick and effective” success.

Read more:
Trump’s solutions leave insurance sector unimpressed
Spain’s PM not mincing his words over Trump’s war on Iran

Between Wednesday’s military and political briefings, it’s clear the Americans are content with their level of success.

Secretary of state Marco Rubio had said on Monday that the US military action was triggered by Israel’s plan to attack Iran.

It had promoted suggestions that President Trump was bounced into a pre-emptive strike by Israel’s intent.

On Trump’s motivation to launch strikes, Leavitt said he acted on a “good feeling” that Iran was going to strike US assets and personnel in the region.

The countdown continues for Sunderland’s biggest music event of the year – Radio 1’s Big Weekend.

Parts of the venue have already been fenced off and works are underway to bring the event to life, which is set to see some of the biggest names in music descend on our region.

This week, the BBC have confirmed how you can buy tickets for the weekend.

Here’s everything you need to know.

When is BBC Radio 1’s Big Weekend?

Radio 1’s Big Weekend will take place over three days – May 22, 23 and 24.

Where is it being held?

The Big Weekend is being held at Herrington Park, in Sunderland this year. If you aren’t familiar of where that is, the park can be found opposite iconic landmark Penshaw Monument.

The last time it was held in the region was in 2019, in Middlesbrough, and it was held in Herrington Park in 2005.

Headliners back then included the Foo Fighters and The Black Eyed Peas.

How much are tickets?

Ticket prices have this week been confirmed – here’s how much you’ll need to pay to get in.

Friday

General admission – £34.50

VIP admission – £86.00

Saturday

General admission – £44.50

VIP admission – £106.00

Sunday

General admission – £44.50

VIP admission – £106.00

Where can I buy tickets?

The tickets will be available to buy via Ticketmaster, and you can find the ticket link by going on the BBC website.

When do they go on sale?

The ticket sale dates are staggered.

Tickets for Friday, 22 May will go on sale at 9am on Friday (March 6).

Tickets for Saturday and Sunday (May 23 and 24) will go on sale on March 11.

Are tickets allocated by region?

Yes – the BBC say they have been put into three ‘pots’.

The first pot, which is 30% of tickets, are allocated to Sunderland residents.

A further 60% are for the wider North East including County Durham, Newcastle, Gateshead and Northumberland.

Then, the final 10% will be available to the rest of the UK.

Can I go to all three days?

No. It has been confirmed that you can’t buy tickets for all three days.

You can buy a maximum of two tickets per person per day.

You are allowed to go on Friday and either Saturday or Sunday, but not both.

Are there age restrictions?

Yes, there are age restrictions.

You can only attend on Friday if you are 18 or over.

No restrictions are placed on Saturday or Sunday, but anyone aged 15 or under must be accompanied by an adult at all times.

What is the line-up?

Unfortunately, a full line up for the three day event has not yet been revealed.

Previous headliners have included the likes of Sam Fender, The 1975, Harry Styles and Billie Eilish.

Dr Zakariya Waqar-Uddin, known as Dr Zak, was tragically found at the bottom of Huntcliff in Saltburn-by-the-Sea, North Yorkshire, on May 21, nine days after he went missing from his home in Lancashire.

The 44-year-old, who grew up in Euxton and was a GP in Chorley, was due to visit the dentist and travelled to Teesside, where a flat he had was up for sale. 

He also worked as a GP at Buckshaw Village Medical Group and Standish Medical Practice.

However, Dr Zakariya’s family did not hear from him, and he was reported missing. On May 21, coastguard teams sadly discovered his body. 

An inquest at Teesside Coroners’ Court, sitting at Middlesbrough Town Hall, heard how Dr Zakariya died from multiple traumatic injuries due to a fall from a height. 

His mother, Patricia Waqar-Uddin, who attended the inquest alongside other family members, described her son as “charming, helpful, and very compassionate to all whom he met”. 

She said he had “no airs and graces” despite his successful career and was the “best son any parents could ever hope for in life”. 

The inquest, held on Tuesday (March 3) heard how Dr Zakariya had previously suffered from some stress following the breakdown of his marriage and the dissolution of his GP partnership. 

However, two months before his death, there was no mention of any mental health concerns when he spoke with a dermatologist. 

The inquest heard how his mother had tried to ring him on the day he left his home, but that his phone was switched off, and she could not confirm whether he had been to the dentist. 

After he was reported missing, a search was launched across Teesside after his dark purple Volkswagen Touran was found, before his body was found on May 21.

Dr Zakariya was identified through his dental records, and there were no significant toxicology findings, a report confirmed.

Daughter Jasmine ‘will make Zakariya extremely proud’

Dr Zakariya’s former partner, Laura Jane Dunning, fought back the tears as she paid tribute to him during the inquest, saying he was “charismatic, had a warm smile, and a very good sense of humour”. 

Ms Dunning said Zak, whom she married in October 2016 and shares daughter Jasmine, now eight, with, said she took comfort in the fact Dr Zakariya knew she was “well and happy”. 

She said: “I am distraught and I am very sad that Jasmine has lost her father.

“She will continue to be loved and cherished, and I know she will make him extremely proud. 

Dr Zak (Image: SARAH CALDECOTT)

“I hope Zak found his peace, and I thank him for the many happy times we had together.”

During the inquest, Coroner Bailey had to consider whether Dr Zakariya had intended to take his own life, but this was ruled out.

Ms Waqar-Uddin told Coroner Bailey that her son was not agitated when he left his home and did not believe he intended to take his own life. 

She said there was no communication about intent left at his home and that he was also applying for jobs: “He had too many plans for the future.” 

Coroner Bailey recorded a narrative conclusion, saying: “Dr Zakariya was found dead at the bottom of Huntcliff in Saltburn on May 21. 

“It is not known how or when he exited the top of Huntcliff.”

‘We will miss him deeply’

In a statement, Ms Waqar-Uddin said Dr Zakariya was more than his profession and treated his patients with the “same care and respect he gave to his family”.

She said: “On social media, there were more than a thousand tributes to him when his death was announced.

“He often spoke of the joy and satisfaction being a GP brought to him.

“To us, he was the best son any parents could ever hope for in life, and we will miss him deeply for the rest of our lives.

“He was grateful to his youngest brother, Yusuf, for the love and support he extended to him despite living and working 6,000 miles away.

“To Yusuf, on Zakariya’s and our behalf, we say thank you, son. We are so proud of you. Proud that you were there and supported Zakariya, and was a kind and loving brother to him.

“He cared and loved his daughter Jasmine, but missed her greatly, so much so that the pain of not seeing her became unbearable for him.

“Some in the medical profession need to have a more compassionate and caring approach. 

“As one doctor said to Zakariya, ‘the trouble with you Zak, is that you actually care for the patients, whereas I just care about the money’.

“One patient wrote: ‘Dr Zak was a brilliant GP. The medical profession and humanity are the poorer for his passing.’

“In conclusion, Zakariya deserved a long and fulfilling life. He gave so much to us, his parents and to his patients, and we will miss him deeply.”

The display is a 13-inch panel that Apple calls Liquid Retina. It’s the same technology as the MacBook Air, though it lacks Apple’s ‘True Tone’, which adapts the display colours to your environment to help with eye strain. It is also fractionally smaller than the 13.6-inch MacBook Air and the 14-inch base model of the MacBook Pro, but that gives it an advantage in portability, weighing the same as the MacBook Air at 1.2kg.

Battery life is said to be up to 11 hours for browsing the web or 16 hours for streaming video, while connectivity includes Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 6. The MacBook Neo runs macOS 26 Tahoe, which is the latest software version, matching the more expensive MacBooks.

Why does it matter?

I’ve reviewed Apple MacBooks for the last decade, and I used them for the decade before that. The announcement of the MacBook Neo is huge, not only because it makes Apple’s laptops accessible to a wider range of people, but also because it will reinvigorate the budget end of the laptop market in terms of competition.

I’ll be honest, I never thought Apple would hit the £600 price bracket for a laptop, which is actually £500 when you take into account the education discount available to students and teachers. The company has always positioned its MacBooks as premium products compared to Windows laptops, with fancy designs, better performance for creatives, and longer battery life.

Manchester City weren’t good enough against Nottingham Forest as they fell seven points behind Arsenal with a game in hand after a 2-2 draw

With 30 minutes left of Manchester City’s game with Nottingham Forest, Pep Guardiola was ready to twist. Impatient after Nottingham Forest’s equaliser and an average showing from his starters, the coach had Nathan Ake and Jeremy Doku ready to come on.

Then City did what they do worse than nearly every team in the league and scored from a corner. To make it even sourer for Arsenal, it was their old nemesis Rodri who got on the end of Rayan Ait-Nouri’s corner and powered his header into the net.

City’s Ballon d’Or winner absolutely loved it, pumping his fists repeatedly in front of the family stand to celebrate the goal. It was his first in the Premier League since the final day of the 2023/24 season when it helped to crown the team champions, and without this goal they would have stood less chance of chasing Arsenal down this year.

Get MEN Premium now for just £1 HERE – or get involved in our City WhatsApp group by clicking HERE. You can also join our City Facebook page by clicking HERE and don’t miss out on our brilliant selection of newsletters HERE.

The goal, and the celebration, lifted the noise at the Etihad after an evening where the team had toiled. They hadn’t been at their best despite Antoine Semenyo neatly giving them a first-half lead with a clever finish for his 12th goal of the season.

It was niggly rather than nice as City were unusually wayward on the ball and slow in attack. If they were going to survive, they needed a watertight defence.

That ended when Morgan Gibbs-White backheeled through the legs of Ruben Dias and past a stunned Gigio Donnarumma early in the second half, leading to Guardiola feeling the need to twist. Rodri’s goal was the vindication of sticking with the same players that have pulled City back into this title race after results at United and Tottenham left them feeling low.

Even that wasn’t enough though. City were punished again for sloppy play as Elliot Anderson smashed one in from outside the box, curling it around Marc Guehi and past Donnarumma to once again silence the crowd. This time Guardiola twisted, with Abdukodir Khusanov and Doku coming on, but the damage had been done.

Haaland and Rodri had penalty claims, Sels did brilliantly to tip over a Semenyo free-kick and Savinho’s shot was cleared off the line with the last kick of the game. A messy end for a messy night, and not the performance or the result City needed to kick off a critical month for their season.

City know they can play much better than this, whoever is on the pitch. They are going to need to if they are to have any hope of catching Arsenal in their final nine matches.

Buy Carabao Cup Final VIP tickets

This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more

From £1,399

Seat Unique

Advertisement

Buy tickets here

The Carabao Cup Final will see Arsenal v Manchester City at London’s Wembley Stadium this March.

A 61-year-old man has been charged in connection with the death of a 54-year-old man in Haddington.

A second man has been charged in connection with the death of a man in East Lothian. Emergency services were called to Carlyle Gardens in Haddington on Tuesday, February 10.

A 54-year-old man was found injured in a property and was taken to hospital. Sadly, he died on Wednesday, February 18.

Officers from Police Scotland have now arrested and charged a 61-year-old man in connection with the death. He is due to appear at Edinburgh Sheriff Court on Thursday, March 5.

It comes after Mark Ingle was arrested and charged by police last week. The 41-year-old appeared at Edinburgh Sheriff Court on Wednesday, February 25, charged with murder.

He made no plea and was remanded in custody to appear again at the court within eight days.

Senior Investigating Officer Detective Inspector Ross Duthie, of the Major Investigation Team, previously said: “My thoughts are with the man’s family and friends at this difficult time. We have a dedicated team of officers carrying out extensive enquiries and a police presence remains in Haddington as part of this.”

A Police Scotland spokesperson added: “A second man has been arrested and charged in connection with the death of a man. Officers attended a property in Carlyle Gardens in Haddington around 12.40pm on Tuesday, 10 February, 2026.

“A 54-year-old man was taken to hospital, where he later died on Wednesday, 18 February. The 61-year-old man is due to appear at Edinburgh Sheriff Court on Thursday, 5 March.

“A 41-year-old man has previously been arrested and charged in connection with his death. He appeared in court on Wednesday, 25 February.”

Get more Daily Record exclusives by signing up for free to Google’s preferred sources. Click HERE.

Aesthetica and York St John University are bringing back The Creative Business Skills Academy this Spring, offering 12 fully funded places to creative founders and business owners.

After a successful launch in 2024, the free 12-week in-person programme will run from May 6 to July 29, taking place on Wednesdays from 6-9pm.

The programme aims to equip entrepreneurs with the practical tools, strategic frameworks and industry networks required to build sustainable ventures.

RECOMMENDED READING:

The Academy supports creatives at the crucial early stages of starting, growing and scaling their businesses.

York is one of just 27 cities worldwide to hold a UNESCO City of Media Arts designation and the Academy aims to use this global recognition to help people get into the creative sector.

Cherie Federico, Director of Aesthetica, said: “York’s UNESCO City of Media Arts designation is not simply a title – it is a call to action. The Creative Business Skills Academy is about turning creative potential into sustainable businesses.

“By investing directly in founders and small enterprises, we are building the infrastructure that allows creativity to thrive, generate employment and shape the future of our city. Supporting entrepreneurial talent at grassroots level is how we secure long-term cultural and economic impact.”

The Academy is free to attend and tailored specifically for start-ups and early-stage founders working across architecture, film, fine art, gaming, XR, textiles, fashion and related disciplines.

Each weekly session includes a 1.5-hour practical workshop, a one-hour masterclass led by industry experts, and dedicated time for structured networking and peer exchange.

Key topics include branding, marketing, project management, developing income streams, accountancy, legal frameworks, HR, sales, negotiation, strategy, scaling and growth — core skills that underpin resilient creative enterprises.

Confirmed speakers include: Alison Grade, founder of Mission Accomplished; Farah Hussain, founder of Farah Networking; Kit Monkman, co-founder of Viridian FX; and Cherie Federico of Aesthetica, amongst others. Their collective expertise spans enterprise, publishing, immersive technology, networking and global brand building.

Professor Brendan Paddison, Dean of York Business School at York St John University, said: “As a university rooted in York, we recognise the transformative role creative enterprise plays in regional prosperity.

“Our partnership in the Creative Business Skills Academy reflects our commitment to equipping founders with the strategic insight, commercial awareness and leadership capability needed to scale successfully.

“By connecting academic expertise with industry practice, we are strengthening the creative ecosystem and ensuring that innovation translates into meaningful economic growth.”

For more details and to apply for any of the 12 free places, go to: https://creativeskillsacademy.org