Hannah Spencer’s parliamentary story – as the new Green MP for Gorton and Denton – has just begun.

Nevertheless, the life story that she presented in her victory speech was that of a plumber, not a politician. She identified herself – in present tense – by that trade; she had not grown up wanting to be a politician. She also celebrated qualifying as a plasterer during the “chaos” and “pressure” of the election campaign. She described campaigning jovially as “all this”, as if it were just a challenge in the broader adventure, not the adventure itself.

Despite, or perhaps because of, accusations that the Greens used “sectarian politics” to secure victory, the speech was one of solidarity, of aligning herself with the struggles and achievements of “the community that I am from”. Spencer said that she had lived there in one of the hardest times of her life, and presented the strength of the community “at holding things together” as an inspiration.

She aligned herself and her personal characteristics with those of the constituency, stressing that “I am no different to every single person here in this constituency. I work hard. That is what we do.”

Alongside all the talk of “we”, of common interests and lack of difference, Spencer singled out several audiences for her story. One such audience? Her now-plumberless “customers”, to whom she duly apologised: “I’m sorry, but I think I might have to cancel the work that you had booked in, because I’m heading to parliament”.

Spencer also addressed those who voted for her, and those who didn’t. She spoke of “my Muslim friends and neighbours”, who “are just like me: human”. She discussed the “left-behind” (“I see you, and I will fight for you”), and people doing jobs like hers: “We will finally get a seat at the table”. And she addressed “our white working class communities, the background that I have become so glad to be from”.

A personal and political journey

My research focuses on political narratives and storytelling as a means of communication: the stories that parliaments contain and project, the stories we tell about the places we’re in and the stories that politicians use to communicate themselves to voters. Spencer’s speech is an attempt to portray a compelling story to her new constituency.

She spoke about how moving away from the constituency to nearby Trafford made the qualities of Gorton and Denton’s community “even clearer”. Only realising your love for a place and the people in it when you’ve moved away is a familiar narrative device. As Joni Mitchell once sang, “You don’t know what you’ve got ‘til it’s gone”.

In Spencer’s speech, this tactic carried a sharper political edge. This is a constituency that people move away from to get the “nice life” that Spencer described: “good schools, a thriving high street and clean air”.

This part of the story carried a rebuke to an audience that Spencer was addressing, but not by name: the Labour Party, for whom this was a traditionally safe seat. Spencer observed that “working hard used to get you something”.

I would argue that “you”, in this context, is a reference to traditional Labour voters. The implication here is that it is voting Labour that “used to get you something”.

Being a politician now isn’t an aspect of Spencer’s story that she’s keen to claim. She may now sit at Westminster, but she appears to frame this as an extension of who she already is — a worker, a neighbour, a constituent — in a new arena.

In doing so, she attempts to recast political representation itself as continuity of identity. The challenge, of course, will be whether she can sustain that claim. It is easier to say “I am no different” on a victory stage following a byelection win than from the House of Commons. The durability of her narrative – and perhaps her political appeal – will rest on whether she can remain recognisably “from” the constituency while operating within the institution of parliament.

Far from embracing and being dependent upon technology, many people are pushing against it and ditching smart home devices.

They are turning their backs on lights that turn on automatically, robot vacuum cleaners and ovens you can turn on from your office 30 miles away.

They are living in what are being called ‘dumb homes’, where lights are turned on by proper switches, the oven needs to be manually operated with knobs, and the fridge doesn’t send photos to your phone when you’re short of milk.

Our house is and always will be a dumb house. My husband and I each have a smartphone, and we have an internet router, but other than that our house and its contents are bordering Neolithic.

When people arrive at our house they don’t get filmed by a doorbell as they dither about on the doorstep; they simply knock on the door. I know ring doorbells are supposed to be good for security, but society has managed for centuries with a door knock, and that is what we’re sticking with.

We don’t have lights that turn on automatically with the morning alarm or blinds that open themselves.

We don’t have a fridge that sends an alert to us if we accidentally leave the door open. If this happens we just curse a little and take it on the chin. And we wouldn’t dream of getting one of those high-tech fridges fitted with cameras that take pictures – ‘shelfies’ – of their contents and send them to your phone so you know what to stick on your shopping list. Basically, we have a small, no-mod-cons fridge, one step up from an old-fashioned larder.

Our oven isn’t very smart either. In fact, until I started writing this column I didn’t know there was such a thing as a smart oven – one that allows users to monitor and control cooking from their phones. They can include automated cooking programs, recipe suggestions sent directly to the oven, voice control, and built-in cameras to check on food remotely. I couldn’t think of anything worse. I find it hard enough to successfully cook a meal while standing in front of my oven never mind from several miles away. Were I to try remote cooking I’d need the fire service on standby.

This growing shift towards dumb homes – highlighted by estate agents and often referred to in newspaper property supplements – features reliable, no-fuss appliances over automated systems. Many homeowners are opting for simple buttons, switches, and knobs over voice-activated or app-controlled systems.

Our TV isn’t smart, our radio isn’t smart, our vacuum cleaner isn’t robotic and our toilet hasn’t got Bluetooth: don’t you just hate those loos that flush when they feel like it – usually when you’re still on it?

Our home is well and truly dumb, and I’m glad of that.

We also have – brace yourself – a landline, which I have to say I use more than my mobile to make calls. Speaking on it doesn’t make my tinnitus worse, which mobiles tend to do, especially after more than ten minutes.

I recently read about ‘dumb phones’ – basic models offering a digital detox from smartphone distractions. They are gaining popularity for their simplicity, long battery life, and affordability, often featuring physical keypads, small screens, and limited, or no internet connectivity.

I don’t want a fully-integrated smart home. I want a comfortable house that, if anything, harks back to the good old days when people flipped light switches, drew curtains and flushed the toilet themselves. Dependable and reliable, and far better than all this so-called smart nonsense.

Attorney General Pam Bondi announced federal charges Friday against 30 more people who are accused of civil rights violations in a January protest inside a Minnesota church where a pastor works for Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Bondi said on social media that 25 people were in custody and more arrests would follow. The new indictment comes a month after independent journalists Don Lemon and Georgia Fort and prominent local activist Nekima Levy Armstrong were charged for their alleged roles in a protest at Cities Church in St. Paul.

Bondi accused the group of attacking a house of worship.

“If you do so, you cannot hide from us — we will find you, arrest you, and prosecute you,” she wrote on social media.

A livestreamed video posted on Facebook shows people interrupting services at Cities Church on Jan. 18 by chanting “ICE out” and “Justice for Renee Good,” a reference to the woman who was fatally shot by an ICE officer in Minneapolis on Jan. 7.

Protesters targeted church over its pastor

Protesters descended on Cities Church after learning that one of the church’s pastors also serves as an ICE official. The protest drew swift condemnation from Trump administration officials and conservative leaders for disrupting a Sunday service.

In total, 39 people now face charges of conspiracy against religious freedom and interfering with the right of religious freedom. The new defendants had initial court appearances and were released.

Lemon and Fort said they were at the church as journalists covering news. Levy Armstrong was the subject of a doctored photo posted by the White House showing her crying during her arrest. The three have pleaded not guilty.

The indictment says the “agitators” entered the church in a “coordinated takeover-style attack” and engaged in acts of intimidation and obstruction.

“Young children were left to wonder, as one child put it, if their parents were going to die,” the indictment says.

Church welcomes more arrests

A lawyer for the church praised the Justice Department for charging more people.

“The First Amendment does not give anyone — regardless of profession, prominence, or politics — license to storm a church and intimidate, threaten, and terrorize families and children worshipping inside,” Doug Wardlow said in a statement.

The revised indictment adds new allegations when compared to the original filed in January.

It says two people “conducted reconnaissance” outside the church a day before the protest and recorded their visit on video, with one saying, “My thoughts are to be able to close up this whole alleyway right here.”

The court filing quotes one protester as chanting in the church, “This ain’t God’s house. This is the house of the devil.”

Trahern Crews, who was charged in January and is lead organizer of Black Lives Matter Minnesota, said the latest arrests were a “waste of time.”

“It’s a shame that the people who have killed Alex Pretti and Renee Good or Keith Porter have not been arrested but peaceful protesters have,” Crews said. Porter was fatally shot in Los Angeles by an off-duty ICE officer.

Minnesota was hotbed for immigration blitz

Levy Armstrong defended the protest shortly after it occurred. She said critics needed to “check their hearts” if they were more concerned about a disruption than the “atrocities that we are experiencing in our community.”

The protest came at a tense time in Minnesota, where the Trump administration sent thousands of federal officers for Operation Metro Surge after a series of public fraud cases where the majority of defendants had Somali roots. Officers frequently deployed tear gas for crowd control in neighborhood clashes with residents, often detaining them along with immigrants.

Good, 37, was shot in Minneapolis. In another fatal shooting a week after the church protest, a federal officer killed Pretti, a 37-year-old nurse, in the same city.

Nationwide demonstrations erupted in response, followed by a change in Operation Metro Surge’s leadership and the eventual wind-down of the immigration enforcement operation. Roughly 400 ICE officers and Homeland Security agents were expected to remain in Minneapolis by early March, down from roughly 3,000 at the peak, according to a court filing.

Since then, the Twin Cities have grappled with the impact to communities and the local economy. Minneapolis said it suffered an impact of $203 million due to the operation, with tens of thousands of residents in need of urgent relief assistance.

Separately, a woman who was at the church service has filed a lawsuit against some people who were charged, alleging emotional trauma and an inability to exercise her religion that day.

___

Associated Press writer Ed White in Detroit contributed to this report.

Hello and welcome to coverage from the Premier League of Wolves vs Aston Villa.

The two sides will start the match with very different objectives, one desperately trying to pick up points to avoid the inevitable, while the other attempts to keep the league’s big beasts behind them in the race for Champions League football next season.

Wolves welcome Villa to Molineux – the first of three home games in the space of a week. Liverpool are visitors on Tuesday, and again in the FA Cup next Friday.

And manager Rob Edwards says it is time for his players to lift themselves for the fight. Edwards said: “We’re here to fight and show how good we are. The players have always got something to fight for, these next three games in particular, and they shouldn’t be difficult to get up for at all.

“We understand the scale of the task and we know we’re not going to be favourite in any of the games, but we’ve got to make sure that we bring our best.”

In contrast, Villa boss Unai Emery sounded downbeat, claiming it is going to be “very, very difficult” for Aston Villa to maintain their top-three position in the table after picking up only five points from four league games.

Emery said: “I know it’s going to be very, very difficult to keep our position. Why? Because we have three teams behind us: United, Chelsea and Liverpool. Our position for them is their objective, their priority and their challenge, and they have the power to get us.

“Of course, our challenge is to try to keep the advantage we have now, and try to play looking forward, and tomorrow, three points, no more. We are going to fight, day by day, next week, next month, very exciting moments. Everything can happen, but exciting moments.”

Stand by for lineups and team news…

A vehicle fire has led to a major road closure

The M2 has been closed near Ballymena following a vehicle fire.

The affected area has seen the major road closed from the junction of the Raceveiw Rd in the direction of the Larne roundabout.

Authorities have been contacted for more information.

Drivers are advised to avoid the area if possible and should seek an alternative route at this time.

Want to see more of the stories you love from Belfast Live? Making us your preferred source on Google means you’ll get more of our exclusives, top stories and must-read content straight away. To add Belfast Live as a preferred source, simply click here

Wolves delivered a significant blow to Aston Villa’s Champions League aspirations with a 2-0 victory at Molineux, a result that also saw them surpass Derby County’s record-low Premier League points tally.

Second-half goals from Joao Gomes and Rodrigo Gomes secured only Wolves’ second win in 29 games, taking their season total to 13 points and moving them beyond the meagre 11 points posted by the Rams in the 2007-08 season, thus avoiding the notoriety of being the worst-ever Premier League team.

The defeat was particularly galling for Unai Emery’s side, coming against local rivals and extending their poor record at Molineux.

Villa’s woeful display saw their top-four hopes take another hit.

open image in gallery

Having been in the title race as recently as January, their form has dramatically declined, with just one win from their last five games, leaving them now looking over their shoulder at the chasing pack rather than challenging at the top.

Villa had not won at Molineux since 2020, so, despite their respective positions in the table, the visitors knew this was not going to be an easy game.

The weather did not help, with rain lashing down and affecting both sides’ ability to move the ball around.

Still, it was Villa that looked the most likely initially and they fashioned several good chances in the first half.

The first came after six minutes when Morgan Rogers played a brilliant ball for Ollie Watkins to race on to, but the striker took too long to get his shot away and it was blocked by Yerson Mosquera.

From the resulting corner, Pau Torres found himself in yards of space near the penalty spot but could not make a clean connection with his header.

open image in gallery

Advertisement

Jose Sa was tested for the first time in the 17th minute as Douglas Luiz produced a rasping volley from Matty Cash’s cross, but it was straight at the goalkeeper.

Villa could not find that early goal and the level of their performance slipped alarmingly as the match went on.

They were punished just after the hour as Wolves scored with their first shot on target.

They won the ball in midfield, Jackson Tchatchoua was given too much space to send in his cross, which Adam Armstrong laid off for Gomes to power the ball into the roof of the net.

It was the only real moment of quality in a poor game.

Villa tried to get something out of it in the final 30 minutes, but the closest they came was when Ian Maatsen thrashed an effort straight at Sa.

Their best chance came in the seventh minute of stoppage time when a loose ball fell to Amadou Onana, but Sa got enough on the ball to allow Mosquera to clear off the line.

Then, with the game in the final throes, Wolves sealed the three points with a breakaway goal, Rodrigo Gomes converting from 12 yards.

This result will not change the outcome of Wolves’ season but there were wild scenes of celebration at the end while Emery stormed down the tunnel in disgust.

Neil Sedaka, the legendary songwriter behind hits including “(Is This the Way to) Amarillo”, “Breaking Up Is Hard to Do” and “Love Will Keep Us Together,” has died. He was 86.

The New York-born songwriter was reportedly rushed to hospital in Los Angeles this morning.

In a statement to Variety, Sedaka’s relatives said: “Our family is devastated by the sudden passing of our beloved husband, father and grandfather, Neil Sedaka.

“A true rock and roll legend, an inspiration to millions, but most importantly, at least to those of us who were lucky enough to know him, an incredible human being who will be deeply missed.”

More to follow…

With spring just around the corner, many people are wondering when is the best time to start cutting their lawns again.

Now we are coming to the end of February, many Brits are looking forward to longer days and hopefully some warmer and brighter weather. With quite a few regions of the UK experiencing days without sunshine, many of us are desperate for spring to begin.

However, as the weather does start to get better, many homeowners will now need to pay more attention to their gardens. While the winter months have allowed Brits to forget about their outdoor maintenance, the warmer seasons will soon have our lawns resembling a jungle if it isn’t looked after properly.

With many avid gardeners quite happy to start tackling the job, many of us are unsure of when is the best time to get the lawnmower out. In fact, many experts warn cutting the grass too early could actually be extremely harmful to your lawn and could ruin it for the year.

This is because mowing the lawn during the colder months can cause lasting damage to the grass as it struggles to thrive in freezing temperatures, reports Devon Live. Therefore, as we move into early spring, our grass will be concentrating its energy on developing a stronger root system so it can flourish throughout the warmer seasons.

By cutting your grass too early, you will be damaging this process which will result in a lackluster garden for the rest of the year. So when is the best time to start mowing the lawn in 2026 to achieve a luscious green garden?

Overall, experts generally agree the temperature will have sufficiently increased enough to make mowing safe by March 15.

Urging gardeners to not start cutting their grass too early, Gardeners’ World presenter Monty Don previously explained the issue on his blog.

He wrote: “Cutting too early during the colder months can damage your lawn, as grass doesn’t thrive in low temperatures. By mid-March, the weather in most parts of the UK has warmed enough to make mowing beneficial.”

However, the gardening expert does warn Brits not to put their lawnmower on the lowest setting on this first cut. Don explained: “The grass will need mowing in March but do not cut it too short. Just give it a light trim for the rest of this month.

Get more Daily Record exclusives by signing up for free to Google’s preferred sources. Click HERE

“This will encourage good root growth and as a result the grass will be a lot healthier and better able to resist summer drought.”

For those wanting to get their best results out of their garden in 2026, Don also shared some handy tips and tricks for households to follow.

He said: “To get a ‘good’ lawn you have to think positively. Put your efforts into healthy grass rather than fighting perceived ‘problems’ like daisies, moss, ants, worm-casts, moles, plantains, dandelions and fairy rings. Nine times out of ten if the grass is healthy then everything else will look after itself.

“The best grass likes very well drained soil. Moss, for example, is always a symptom of poor drainage, made worse by shade. Unfortunately even the best prepared soil becomes compacted by matted roots, rain and, especially, normal family use.

“The answer is to work on it at least once a year by sticking a fork in the ground and wiggling it about and repeating the process every 6 inches or so.”

Following the fork method, Don recommends creating a mixture equal parts sieved topsoil, sharp sand and sieved leaf mould or compost.

He added: “If you do not have these things to hand then just sharp or silver sand will do the job. Spread it across the area you have pricked and brush it in with a stiff broom, filling the holes with the mixture. This will help drainage and feed the grass.

“It is also worth giving the lawn a good scratch with a wire rake. This will get at all the overwintering thatch and moss, and let light and water get to the soil and to the roots of the grass. Put the debris on the compost and then mow. It will look a little bald for a week or so but will grow back thicker than ever.”

You drive into Efrat, and you feel like you’re in small-town USA. There’s a supermarket, coffee shops, tidy roads and American families pushing buggies. 

The two main differences? Firstly, the flags are Israeli. Secondly, we’re in the occupied West Bank, a half-hour drive from Jerusalem.

Efrat is a settlement, set up on Palestinian land more than four decades ago. According to international law, its very existence is illegal – a ruling that Israel has long rejected and ignored.

We’re here because Efrat has been the pilot for a new project that, like so much in Israel, has delighted some and enraged others.

Officials from the American Embassy have come here for one day to create a “pop-up” consulate to serve the thousands of US citizens who live here.

It’s a move that’s never been done before.

Around 4,000 people in Efrat – that’s about a third of its population – are US citizens. And as we watched, a decent chunk of that number came to a community centre, clutching passports, documents, small Stars and Stripes flags and paperwork.

For those residents, it’s a very welcome new initiative – applications that used to involve a day spent in Jerusalem were now being sorted in one visit. But for others, this is another step along the road towards settlements being legitimised and the West Bank being annexed.

Read more from Sky News:
Man who left his partner paralysed in a brutal attack jailed
Pakistan says it is in ‘open war’ with Afghanistan

‘It’s a game-changer’

We meet Yonatan Marcus, the municipality’s chief of staff. He’s originally from New York state, and says he’s hugely proud that Efrat has been picked to be the trailblazer for this. He offers credit to both President Donald Trump and to Mike Huckabee, America’s ambassador in Israel.

“I think it’s a game-changer – a real change. It comes from a real love. It’s unbelievable. Ambassador Huckabee’s love for this country and caring for this country, for the people here, and his love for America,” he says.

“He knows that if America and Israel are together, it makes both countries stronger. Doing these acts and providing these services comes from understanding our history and our instinct for survival,” he beams.

‘We don’t see Arabs as our enemies’

The Weinbergers are here with their documents. Michael and Roxanne, along with three children. He’s originally from New Jersey, she from Oregon, and both still have deep affection for their homeland. But they love their lives here, on a settlement set on a West Bank ridge.

“I can probably name more congressmen than Knesset members,” says Michael. “I feel love for both places. Biblically, Israel has a strong meaning for us, but when the US beat Canada at the Winter Olympics I was very excited.”

Roxanne is more emphatic. I ask which country has her heart, and she has no doubt. “My heart is here but I am still very much an American. As an American Jew there is no good answer because both places feel like home.”

They see Efrat as a town that unites more than it divides. “People from outside think ‘oh, every Arab and Jew hates each other’, but that’s not the case,” Michael says.

“We don’t see Arabs as our enemies. We want to have some future together. We could have some future together. In this region we have coexistence groups, and there is a desire for that.”

West Bank compared to the Falkland Islands

Inside, we talk to the town’s mayor, Dovi Shefner – more forthright, more anxious. Proud that the American officials are here, but also nervous about the future.

“We want peace, but all the years, and especially after October 7, we know many of them want to kill us and throw us from our land. We want to live in peace, but when someone tries to kill you, you don’t wait for them to kill you. You fight.”

The West Bank, he tells me, belongs to Israel, as written in the Bible, and he draws a parallel between this territory and the 1982 war to regain the Falkland Islands. “No British citizen knew where it was, but it was the centre of their lives. You had to fight for it.”

Efrat is calm, neat and tranquil. But settlements like this are desperately controversial and divisive. We leave and drive to Bethlehem, just down the road.

‘The situation has deteriorated further’

Ahmad al Nawawreh is cooking falafel (warm and delicious) when we meet him. He smiles easily, talks willingly, and worries when we ask him about the effect of American support for the nearby settlements.

“The situation has deteriorated further,” he says. “Nothing has improved. On the contrary, their behavior has become even more aggressive. The settlers claim that Trump supports them, which seems to embolden their actions. It feels as though both we and our land are being taken from us.

“They are continuously violating our rights. Not long ago, they stole livestock belonging to local residents, and have also vandalised public property. There is no sense of brotherhood or goodwill here. Everything feels strained and unjust.”

One year after he was Tasered, beaten and arrested by police in Buffalo, New York, a 56-year-old refugee from Myanmar was picked up by Border Patrol agents from a local jail and dropped off outside a Tim Horton’s coffee shop before he was found dead on the street one week later.

Video surveillance footage shows a white van dropping Nurul Amin Shah Alam in a shopping center parking lot more than an hour after the shop had already closed. He wasn’t wearing shoes, only the orange booties that were issued by the jail.

Cameras never showed him entering the shop, and he wasn’t seen again until five days later, when a woman called 911 to report his body on the street more than five miles away.

The case of Shah Alam, who was nearly blind and spoke only little English, has shocked Buffalo’s Rohingya community and outraged residents and advocates who have raised alarms for months about the Trump administration’s treatment of vulnerable immigrants, refugees and their families.

A timeline of events before his death on the streets of Buffalo before punishing winter weather are now raising critical questions about local law enforcement’s handling of his case and their cooperation with federal immigration authorities who failed to notify his family that he was no longer in custody.

open image in gallery

New York Attorney General Letitia James says her office is reviewing legal options. Members of Congress are also demanding investigations.

February 15, 2025

Shah Alam, a member of Myanmar’s persecuted Rohingya minority, arrived in the United States as a refugee in December 2024 with his wife and two sons.

Two months later, on the morning of February 15, 2025, he had wandered into a person’s backyard in the Riverside neighborhood.

After buying a curtain rod, he mistakenly entered the person’s property, according to the Legal Aid Bureau of Buffalo, which represented Shah Alam.

According to body-worn camera footage of the incident, officers can be heard shouting out “what are you doing” and repeatedly ordering him to drop the rod in his hands. “Put it down or you’re going to get Tased,” one officer shouts.

open image in gallery

open image in gallery

He then sticks the rod into the snow and stands beside it while officers continue to order him to place it on the ground. He then places his hand out in front of the officers while they threaten to fire their Tasers, which they point at him throughout the incident.

Shah Alam, who is speaking Ruáingga throughout the incident, then appears to raise the rod to defend himself, and the officers fire.

Once on the ground, one officer calls Shah Alam a “f****** a******” and punches him in the head.

An officer later says Shah Alam bit the officers..

“He’s gonna be injured. I don’t know how bad,” an officer says. “He got hit by all four [Tasers] and still came at us with the f****** poles. He almost got shot.”

The next day, he was arraigned in Buffalo City Court and held on bail set at $25,000. A federal immigration detainer alerting federal authorities he was in custody was issued after his arrest, according to the Erie County District Attorney’s Office.

May 2025

Shah Alam remained in the local jail, and a grand jury indictment followed four months later.

He was indicted for felony assault, burglary and criminal mischief charges.

open image in gallery

Advertisement

His bail was lowered to $5,000, but Shah Alam’s family decided to keep him in the jail where they could visit him, fearing that Immigration and Customs Enforcement would pick him up and send him to a detention center outside of Buffalo, or deport him.

Earlier this month, Shah Alam agreed to plead guilty to reduced charges of criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree and one count of criminal trespass in the third degree, according to District Attorney Michael J. Keane.

His sentencing was scheduled for March 24.

“My decision was the result of a comprehensive evaluation of his conduct, criminal history, acceptance of responsibility, medical condition, time served in pre-trial custody, and the proposed resolution,” Keane said in a statement shared with The Independent. “I also considered the significant collateral consequences that would result from a felony conviction — including mandatory deportation.”

open image in gallery

February 19

Shah Alam’s guilty plea did not make eligible for ICE detention or removal from the country, according to his attorneys.

At 5:25 p.m. February 19, sheriff’s deputies at the Erie County Holding Center handed him over to Customs and Border Protection officers, according to a timeline from the Buffalo Police Department.

Keane, the district attorney, was not aware of his release into immigration custody until the day he died, he said.

When Border Patrol agents picked him up, they shortly realized he wasn’t supposed to be deported. Officers instead offered him “courtesy ride” to a Tim Horton’s coffee shop, which was “determined to be a warm, safe location near his last known address,” according to a statement from the agency.

open image in gallery

He showed no signs of distress, mobility issues, or disabilities requiring special assistance, the agency said in a statement.

His family was not contacted.

Video surveillance footage obtained by The Washington Post and Buffalo’s Investigative Post shows Shah Alam exiting a white van in a shopping plaza after 8 p.m., more than an hour after Tim Horton’s had closed for the night.

The van leaves one minute after dropping him off.

He walks slowly past the coffee shop’s drive-through window, which was open, and pulls the black hood of his jacket over his head, according to the video. Footage does not show him trying to enter.

Six minutes after leaving the van, the man walks away through a parking lot then disappears from view. He never made it home.

February 22-24

Shah Alam’s Legal Aid Bureau attorney Benjamin Macaluso filed a missing persons report on Sunday with the Buffalo Police Department, according to police.

Macaluso said he was “unable to confirm his client’s current location despite contacting federal authorities,” police said.

The next day, police launched an investigation and mistakenly determined that Shah Alam was in federal custody — and then closed the case. The detective handling the case corrected the error four hours later.

open image in gallery

On Tuesday, police issued a missing person poster on social media.

That night, police began canvassing the area, including previous known addresses as well as local hospitals and shelters.

Between his arrest and release, Shah Alam’s family had moved across town, roughly five miles away from where he was dropped off.

February 25

According to police, a woman called 911 at 8:29 p.m. Tuesday to report an “unresponsive male wearing a dark parka and khaki pants who appeared not to be breathing, with his hands described as gray in color.”

She said the man was moving three hours earlier but, when she passed by the same area that night, he was still on the ground “and no longer moving, at which time 911 was contacted,” according to police.

Buffalo Fire Department personnel arrived on the scene and initiated chest compressions. Buffalo Police officers also administered Narcan. Emergency responders pronounced him dead.

Shah Alam was more than five miles south of where Borders Patrol officers left him.

open image in gallery

open image in gallery

Advertisement

February 26

According to police, Shah Alam’s family was notified of his death by the Erie County Medical Examiner’s Office shortly after 10 a.m. Wednesday.

His death was determined to be “health related in nature,” according to a spokesperson for the city. The medical examiner has not yet determined a cause or manner of death.