Sport
Is shooting from outside the box a dying art in football?
Data, tactics and small-screen fame
“I did a quick calculation,” says James Yorke, director of football at StatsBomb, one of the sport’s leading data suppliers and analytics companies.
“After about 25 yards, the expected goal value of a shot is about 0.03, so roughly one in 33 goes in. From 20 yards, that doubles, but is still only 0.06.
“Even from 12 yards – you think, ‘oh, penalty spot, that is a good chance’ – but the likelihood of scoring is still one in six.
“You have to be in the six-yard box before you are even talking about 50:50 coin flips.
“It sounds crazy – your intuition is that goals are more likely than they actually are. For any shot, everyone overestimates the likelihood of it going in.
“But there is a fundamental truth that getting closer in changes something that is highly infrequent into something that is, relatively, much more frequent.
“It doesn’t get exponentially more likely, but the curve is step.”
What Yorke is describing – an expected goals model – is one of the most basic building blocks in football analytics.
But less than a decade ago, using cold numbers to assess shooting opportunities, rather than relying on gut feeling and optimism, was revolutionary.
“Around 2012 up to 2015, expected goals models became prevalent, understood and known more widely,” says Yorke.
“You would be crazy as a coach not to incorporate what those models are telling you into what you are telling players.”
So, did data change tactics? Did coaches see in the spreadsheet that long-range goals carve themselves into our memories, but, over the season, attempting to repeat them dents their chance of victory?
There is a precedent.
In basketball, where successful long-range shots are worth three points rather than two, analytics have conversely fuelled a switch to teams taking on more attempts from distance.
But even the biggest brains in football data aren’t convinced their industry is the cause of the trend.
Speaking at the MIT Sloan Sports Analytics conference in March, Sarah Rudd – who pioneered the use of advanced statistics in football when she was brought in by Arsenal in 2012 – was asked how and why things had changed on the pitch.
“Data is forcing people to be a little more intentional in how they analyse things,” she said.
“So people now ask ‘if I shoot from outside the box what are the consequences?’”
But she also pointed out that long before mathematical models arrived the best teams tended to focus on taking higher-quality shots, closer in.
One of Rudd’s first projects at the Emirates was to assess whether, as per a common criticism of late-era Arsene Wenger, his Arsenal team were attempting to “walk it in”.
“What I found was that they were, but so were all the other good teams in the Premier League,” she said.
The numbers only confirmed the wisdom in what the best were already doing.
Alongside Rudd on the panel was Ian Graham, who, until 2023, held a similar role behind the scenes at Liverpool.
Rather than data affecting tactics, he sees the opposite: a sea-change in tactical approaches affecting the data.
“I think a decrease in shooting distance is a consequence in a change in playing style,” he said.
“Compared to 10 years ago when there was a lot of long-ball football and attempts from outside the area, teams are playing in a much more similar style to that brought in by Pep Guardiola and Jurgen Klopp.
“I think it is just a happy accident that it looks analytics related.”
High-line defences being pressed hard and fast by the opposition mean, when chances do come in today’s game, attackers have either a closer sight of goal or a clear run to it.
No longer are they feeding on knock-downs and snap-shots as deep-lying backlines keep them at arm’s length.
But Taylor’s thought process at Fratton Park in December 2006 wasn’t so complex.
As a loose ball flew up out of a contest between Nwankwo Kanu and Simon Davies, he didn’t think about high-value shots or low defensive blocks, opportunity cost or half spaces.
Instead, Taylor just noticed it sat up lovely.
Now a manager, he thinks today’s generation of players have more on their minds.
“If you sat down players from December 2006 and now, they would be two different groups of people,” he says.
“There has always been pressure internally – from your coach, team-mates and the fans in the stadium – but there is a lot more pressure externally now.
“After a match a player will shower, do their media bits, then turn their phone on and they might have 50,000 messages where they have been tagged on Twitter or Instagram.
“That is where young players – young people in general – get a lot of their information and feedback from. And all humans like praise and dislike stick.
“If you take a shot from 25 yards, it goes over and you get that criticism, the next time that chance arises you are probably going to be thinking in the back of your head, ‘if I miss again, I might get the same response’.
“Does that affect people and shape their decision-making? Of course it does, it has to.”
In November, Sky Sports’ data editor Adam Smith noticed a statistical quirk that might reinforce Taylor’s theory, that what players consume via their screens affects what they produce on the pitch.
The release of Netflix’s docuseries charting David Beckham’s career – the first episode of which zeroed in on his famous long-range goal against Wimbledon in 1996 – coincided with a four-fold increase in shots from 30 yards and beyond in the Premier League.
A few weeks later, attempts from distance seemed to fall back to their previous level.
Social media was barely born in December 2006. Podcast analysis and YouTube watch-alongs didn’t exist. Television showed fewer games and highlights were harder to find.
Social contagion spread in a more personal way.
In today’s Premier League, competing systems and processes grind a way to a result. The players are cogs in the machine.
The noughties though, was a time of alpha ball-strikers. Greatness came more often via a single act from a single actor. A bolt from the blue – or 25 yards plus – formed team’s figureheads.
The top scorers of Premier League goals from outside the box maps the era’s biggest names and rivalries: Frank Lampard of Chelsea, Steven Gerrard of Liverpool, David Beckham of Manchester United, and Thierry Henry of Arsenal.
When the ball dropped to any of them 25 yards out, was their instinct, untamed by multi-outlet criticism, to try and outshine the stars elsewhere?
While most prolific and readily associated with wonderstrikes, those names aren’t the best long-range shooters. Or, at least, not the most efficient.
Since Stats Perform started collecting the data in 2003-04, the most successful player in converting outside-of-the-box shots into goals in the Premier League is Matheus Pereira, the Brazilian who spent two seasons with West Brom between 2019 and 2021 before heading to Saudi Arabia.
Interestingly, Manchester City – known for their highly structured, intricate attack aimed at getting round the back of defences – are well represented among the most efficient long-range artists, with Bernardo Silva, Phil Foden and Sergio Aguero all in the top five.
The whole list skews more recent, suggesting current players are more picky about their chances from distance, shooting less frequently, but more successfully.
There is a silent partner in every screamer of course.
A glut of long-range goals in this summer’s European Championship turned attention on the ball, with suggestions that something about Adidas’ creation – which contained sugar cane and wood pulp – favoured strikers more than goalkeepers.
At the 2010 World Cup an above-average number of long-range goals coincided with goalkeepers claiming Adidas’ Jabulani ball had an unpredictable trajectory.
The 2006-07 and 2007-08 seasons – the two campaigns in Premier League history with the highest share of long-range goals – were both played with the Nike Total 90 Aerow II.
It was the first time that Nike had stopped mentioning the ball being “faster” in their promotional material, believing the quality had to be “inherent”. Perhaps they should have done.
Football
Dave King challenges Rangers to meeting over chairmanship – Scottish gossip
Dave King, Rangers’ largest shareholder, has challenged the current board to call an emergency meeting to let shareholders decide who should succeed John Bennett as chairman after the South Africa-based businessman’s offer to return to the role was given short shrift by fellow directors. (Record), external
Former manager Steven Gerrard did not want to leave Rangers to join Aston Villa when the Premier League club approached him in November 2021, King, has claimed. (Herald – subscription), external
Rangers’ commercial revenue could increase to around £30m next season after agreeing two new deals, an extension with the Kindred Group for the Unibet brand to continue as the club’s front-of-shirt sponsor in addition to Elior becoming their new food and beverage partner. (Football Insider), external
Meanwhile, Rangers’ biggest-ever shirt sponsorship deal, which will enjoy an increase of £1.5m per year to nearly £3m if all targets are met, was more than matched by city rivals Celtic in one game this week in the Champions League. (Record), external
Former Rangers and Scotland Under-21 striker Dapo Mebude will be given the chance to impress in Dunfermline Athletic’s reserve game against Falkirk next week as the 23-year-old continues to train with the Scottish Championship club after leaving Oostende. (Courier – subscription), external
Sport
Rory Gallagher: Former Derry GAA manager intends to return
Former Derry GAA manager Rory Gallagher has said he “fully intends” to return to inter-county management in a statement issued by his solicitors.
Gallagher was “temporarily debarred” from the Gaelic Athletic Association (GAA) in September 2023 after Ulster GAA asked an independent panel to investigate claims of abuse made by Gallagher’s estranged wife Nicola Gallagher.
Gallagher, who stepped back as Derry boss in May 2023, challenged his ban and the Disputes Resolution Authority (DRA), an independent arbitration body, found in Gallagher’s favour following a hearing on 1 February.
“There is no legal impediment to our client undertaking or accepting a role as a GAA Senior Football manager,” a statement from Gallagher’s solicitors Phoenix Law read.
“Our client fully intends to return to inter county management in the near future.
“Two separate investigations have led – rightly – to decisions by the PPS not to prosecute. Mr Gallagher has not been charged with a single offence,” the statement continued.
More to follow
Sport
Sir Alex Ferguson on helping families affected by dementia
Sir Alex Ferguson on helping families affected by dementia
Sport
Women’s Super League predictions: Can anyone stop Chelsea?
The Women’s Super League returns this weekend and Chelsea are aiming to win a sixth title in a row – but can anyone stop them?
New manager Sonia Bompastor is hoping to pick up her first WSL title but Manchester City, who lost out on goal difference last season, will want revenge.
With Crystal Palace joining the top flight and others spending big money in the summer transfer window, it promises to be another rollercoaster campaign.
Some of BBC Sport’s pundits have predicted their top three for the 2024-25 campaign, along with who they think will be relegated, while Emma Sanders tries to predict where each team will finish this season.
Football
FPL tips and team of the week: Erling Haaland not essential this week
Emi Martinez, Aston Villa, keeper, £5m – home to Wolves
Clean sheets have been so hard to predict this season.
Gameweek four saw six of them from the 10 games, which means we’ve had 18 in 40 games – or clean sheets for 18 teams from a potential 80!
There’s no standout keeper this week but Martinez has been a big-game performer in the past and derby games can be tight affairs.
Yukinari Sugawara, Southampton, defender, £4.5m – home to Ipswich
The Japanese full-back has been flying down the right flank in manager Russell Martin’s progressive style of play where he likes to overload areas of the pitch.
Sugawara has put in 16 crosses, double any of his defensive team-mates and second on the team to Will Smallbone.
He’s created three of Southampton’s five big chances and also scored at Brentford.
Ipswich have been goal shy so far, with just two in their four games and, should Saints turn some impressive periods of play into a 90-minute performance, Sugawara has chances of a return at both ends of the pitch.
Trent Alexander-Arnold, Liverpool, defender, £7m – home to Bournemouth
I may sound like a broken record by now but the attacking returns are on the horizon for the most expensive defender in the game.
Alexander-Arnold was close to another clean sheet last week before Nottingham Forest’s smash-and-grab success at Anfield and it’s amazing he has not got an assist yet.
The right-back’s expected assists (xA) stat is an incredible 1.87 from four games. For context, that is an assist higher than any other defender in the game except Villa left-back Digne (0.94). Tottenham’s Pedro Porro and Sugawara are next with just 0.67.
Josko Gvardiol, Manchester City, defender, £6m – home to Arsenal
Defences are likely to be on top when City host Arsenal on Sunday and you’d expect the Gunners to set up like they did last season, to absorb City pressure and hit on the break.
Rodri should return to City’s line-up which should mean Gvardiol playing a more progressive position down the left like he did at the back-end of last season.
He’ll see plenty of the ball, we know he has a goal or assist in him and, if City do keep a clean sheet, the Croatian will be a strong contender for bonus points.
Sport
Sean Dyche: Everton boss working under ‘very difficult’ circumstances
Manager Sean Dyche is working under “very difficult circumstances” amid Everton’s worst start to a league season in 66 years, says the club’s director of football Kevin Thelwell.
The Toffees are bottom of the Premier League without a point having lost all four of their games so far, conceding 13 goals.
They have the poorest record of the 96 teams in Europe’s top five leagues and were knocked out in the third round of the Carabao Cup on penalties by fellow strugglers Southampton on Tuesday.
In an exclusive interview with BBC Radio Merseyside’s Giulia Bould, Thelwell said: “Sean and I work very closely together, our offices are a metre apart so we are talking regularly and consistently about what things we can do, how we can use the resources we have available to try and make things better going forwards.
“Sean has a responsibility for the preparation and performance of the team and fundamentally the results. My responsibility is the support services that sit around that. It is about us talking through some of the performance problems we have got.”
Dyche’s contract expires at the end of the season and, despite the wretched start, club sources have told BBC Sport the 53-year-old’s job is currently safe.
Thelwell added: “I can promise everybody that there is no stone being left unturned in terms of trying to rectify our current situation. He [Dyche] is working under very difficult circumstances.
“We still have ownership and financial situations to resolve so that makes it very difficult for a manager when we want to take that next step.”
Last week, Everton said there is “some work to be done” for American businessman John Textor to complete his takeover of the club following aborted attempts by 777 Partners and the Friedkin Group this year.
The Blues are also scheduled to move to their new stadium on Bramley Moore-Dock for the start of next season.
-
Sport13 hours ago
Joshua vs Dubois: Chris Eubank Jr says ‘AJ’ could beat Tyson Fury and any other heavyweight in the world
-
News2 days ago
You’re a Hypocrite, And So Am I
-
News14 hours ago
Israel strikes Lebanese targets as Hizbollah chief warns of ‘red lines’ crossed
-
Sport13 hours ago
UFC Edmonton fight card revealed, including Brandon Moreno vs. Amir Albazi headliner
-
Technology12 hours ago
iPhone 15 Pro Max Camera Review: Depth and Reach
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
How one theory ties together everything we know about the universe
-
Science & Environment1 day ago
Sunlight-trapping device can generate temperatures over 1000°C
-
News11 hours ago
Brian Tyree Henry on voicing young Megatron, his love for villain roles
-
Science & Environment1 day ago
Quantum time travel: The experiment to ‘send a particle into the past’
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
2 auditors miss $27M Penpie flaw, Pythia’s ‘claim rewards’ bug: Crypto-Sec
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Bitcoin miners steamrolled after electricity thefts, exchange ‘closure’ scam: Asia Express
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Cardano founder to meet Argentina president Javier Milei
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Dorsey’s ‘marketplace of algorithms’ could fix social media… so why hasn’t it?
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Low users, sex predators kill Korean metaverses, 3AC sues Terra: Asia Express
-
Business12 hours ago
How Labour donor’s largesse tarnished government’s squeaky clean image
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
‘Running of the bulls’ festival crowds move like charged particles
-
News13 hours ago
Freed Between the Lines: Banned Books Week
-
MMA13 hours ago
UFC’s Cory Sandhagen says Deiveson Figueiredo turned down fight offer
-
CryptoCurrency12 hours ago
Ethereum is a 'contrarian bet' into 2025, says Bitwise exec
-
Science & Environment19 hours ago
How Peter Higgs revealed the forces that hold the universe together
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
Rethinking space and time could let us do away with dark matter
-
Science & Environment13 hours ago
We may have spotted a parallel universe going backwards in time
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Arthur Hayes’ ‘sub $50K’ Bitcoin call, Mt. Gox CEO’s new exchange, and more: Hodler’s Digest, Sept. 1 – 7
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Treason in Taiwan paid in Tether, East’s crypto exchange resurgence: Asia Express
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Leaked Chainalysis video suggests Monero transactions may be traceable
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Journeys: Robby Yung on Animoca’s Web3 investments, TON and the Mocaverse
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Louisiana takes first crypto payment over Bitcoin Lightning
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Are there ‘too many’ blockchains for gaming? Sui’s randomness feature: Web3 Gamer
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Crypto whales like Humpy are gaming DAO votes — but there are solutions
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Help! My parents are addicted to Pi Network crypto tapper
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
$12.1M fraud suspect with ‘new face’ arrested, crypto scam boiler rooms busted: Asia Express
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
‘Everything feels like it’s going to shit’: Peter McCormack reveals new podcast
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
Why we need to invoke philosophy to judge bizarre concepts in science
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
Future of fusion: How the UK’s JET reactor paved the way for ITER
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
SEC sues ‘fake’ crypto exchanges in first action on pig butchering scams
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Fed rate cut may be politically motivated, will increase inflation: Arthur Hayes
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Decentraland X account hacked, phishing scam targets MANA airdrop
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
CZ and Binance face new lawsuit, RFK Jr suspends campaign, and more: Hodler’s Digest Aug. 18 – 24
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
CertiK Ventures discloses $45M investment plan to boost Web3
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Memecoins not the ‘right move’ for celebs, but DApps might be — Skale Labs CMO
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Telegram bot Banana Gun’s users drained of over $1.9M
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
DZ Bank partners with Boerse Stuttgart for crypto trading
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
RedStone integrates first oracle price feeds on TON blockchain
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Bitcoin bulls target $64K BTC price hurdle as US stocks eye new record
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
SEC asks court for four months to produce documents for Coinbase
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
‘No matter how bad it gets, there’s a lot going on with NFTs’: 24 Hours of Art, NFT Creator
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
Blockdaemon mulls 2026 IPO: Report
-
Business13 hours ago
Thames Water seeks extension on debt terms to avoid renationalisation
-
Politics13 hours ago
The Guardian view on 10 Downing Street: Labour risks losing the plot | Editorial
-
Politics12 hours ago
I’m in control, says Keir Starmer after Sue Gray pay leaks
-
Politics12 hours ago
‘Appalling’ rows over Sue Gray must stop, senior ministers say | Sue Gray
-
Business12 hours ago
UK hospitals with potentially dangerous concrete to be redeveloped
-
Business11 hours ago
Axel Springer top team close to making eight times their money in KKR deal
-
News11 hours ago
“Beast Games” contestants sue MrBeast’s production company over “chronic mistreatment”
-
News11 hours ago
Sean “Diddy” Combs denied bail again in federal sex trafficking case
-
News11 hours ago
Sean “Diddy” Combs denied bail again in federal sex trafficking case in New York
-
News11 hours ago
Brian Tyree Henry on his love for playing villains ahead of “Transformers One” release
-
News11 hours ago
Brian Tyree Henry on voicing young Megatron, his love for villain roles
-
CryptoCurrency11 hours ago
Coinbase’s cbBTC surges to third-largest wrapped BTC token in just one week
-
Technology3 days ago
YouTube restricts teenager access to fitness videos
-
News15 hours ago
Church same-sex split affecting bishop appointments
-
Politics2 days ago
Trump says he will meet with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi next week
-
Politics1 day ago
What is the House of Lords, how does it work and how is it changing?
-
Politics1 day ago
Keir Starmer facing flashpoints with the trade unions
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
Why you should take a cheat day from your diet, and how many calories to eat
-
Technology14 hours ago
Fivetran targets data security by adding Hybrid Deployment
-
Science & Environment1 day ago
Elon Musk’s SpaceX contracted to destroy retired space station
-
Science & Environment20 hours ago
Single atoms captured morphing into quantum waves in startling image
-
Business3 days ago
Guardian in talks to sell world’s oldest Sunday paper
-
Science & Environment20 hours ago
Quantum ‘supersolid’ matter stirred using magnets
-
MMA13 hours ago
Diego Lopes declines Movsar Evloev’s request to step in at UFC 307
-
Football12 hours ago
Niamh Charles: Chelsea defender has successful shoulder surgery
-
Football12 hours ago
Slot's midfield tweak key to Liverpool victory in Milan
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
Hyperelastic gel is one of the stretchiest materials known to science
-
Science & Environment16 hours ago
How to wrap your head around the most mind-bending theories of reality
-
Technology2 days ago
Can technology fix the ‘broken’ concert ticketing system?
-
Fashion Models12 hours ago
Miranda Kerr nude
-
Fashion Models12 hours ago
“Playmate of the Year” magazine covers of Playboy from 1971–1980
-
News3 days ago
Did the Pandemic Break Our Brains?
-
Science & Environment21 hours ago
A new kind of experiment at the Large Hadron Collider could unravel quantum reality
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
11 reasons why you should stop your fizzy drink habit in 2022
-
Politics12 hours ago
Labour MP urges UK government to nationalise Grangemouth refinery
-
Technology2 days ago
What will future aerial dogfights look like?
-
Science & Environment14 hours ago
Odd quantum property may let us chill things closer to absolute zero
-
Science & Environment22 hours ago
Quantum forces used to automatically assemble tiny device
-
Entertainment11 hours ago
“Jimmy Carter 100” concert celebrates former president’s 100th birthday
-
Business3 days ago
Dangers of being a FOMO customer as rates fall
-
CryptoCurrency13 hours ago
SEC settles with Rari Capital over DeFi pools, unregistered broker activity
-
News11 hours ago
Joe Posnanski revisits iconic football moments in new book, “Why We Love Football”
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
How to adopt mindful drinking in 2022
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
What 10 days of a clean eating plan actually does to your body and why to adopt this diet in 2022
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
When Britons need GoFundMe to pay for surgery, it’s clear the NHS backlog is a political time bomb
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
The maps that could hold the secret to curing cancer
-
Business3 days ago
‘I borrowed £44,000 for university and now owe £54,000’
-
News4 days ago
Can the middle powers save multilateral trade?
-
Health & fitness2 days ago
Covid v flu v cold and how to tell the difference between symptoms this winter
-
News3 days ago
As Democrats fold to GOP on border policy, immigrants pay the price
-
Science & Environment1 day ago
Physicists determined the paper most likely to give you a paper cut
-
Politics1 day ago
Will pension increase make up for loss of winter fuel payments?
-
Science & Environment1 day ago
Quantum to cosmos: Why scale is vital to our understanding of reality
You must be logged in to post a comment Login