Screenshots from such videos were offered Tuesday as evidence in the murder case against Tyler Robinson, the man charged in Kirk’s killing. But the full videos were not shown in court, after defense attorneys objected out of concern that the footage would undermine Robinson’s right to a fair trial.
Legal experts say the defense team’s worries are real: Media coverage in high-profile cases like Robinson’s can have a direct “biasing effect” on potential jurors, said Cornell Law School Professor Valerie Hans.
“There were videos about the killing, and pictures and analysis (and) the entire saga of how this particular defendant came to turn himself in,” said Hans, a leading expert on the jury system. “When jurors come to a trial with this kind of background information from the media, it shapes how they see the evidence that is presented in the courtroom.”
Advertisement
Defense attorneys also want to oust TV and still cameras from the courtroom, arguing that “highly biased” news outlets risk tainting the case.
Prosecutors, attorneys for news organizations, and Kirk’s widow urged state District Judge Tony Graf to keep the proceedings open.
“In the absence of transparency, speculation, misinformation, and conspiracy theories are likely to proliferate, eroding public confidence in the judicial process,” Erika Kirk’s attorney wrote in a court filing.
Prosecutors intend to seek the death penalty for Robinson, 22, who is charged with aggravated murder in the Sept. 10 shooting of Kirk on the Utah Valley University campus in Orem. He has not yet entered a plea.
Advertisement
An estimated 3,000 people attended the outdoor rally to hear Kirk, a co-founder of Turning Point USA, who helped mobilize young people to vote for President Donald Trump.
To secure a death sentence in Utah, prosecutors must demonstrate aggravating circumstances, such as that the crime was especially heinous or atrocious. That’s where the graphic videos could come into play.
Watching those videos might make people think, “‘Yeah, this was especially heinous, atrocious or cruel,’” Hans said.
Utah County Attorney Jeffrey Gray testified Tuesday that he thought about seeking the death penalty before an arrest had been made. He could not recall exactly when he told the governor and federal officials about his plan. Asked why he announced so early his intent to seek the death penalty, Gray said the case was already drawing enormous public attention.
Advertisement
“The more delay, then it just creates all this unnecessary public speculation,” he said, adding that he didn’t want Erika Kirk to have to sit with the uncertainty.
Defense attorneys are seeking to disqualify local prosecutors because the adult daughter of Chad Grunander, a deputy county attorney helping prosecute the case, attended the rally where Kirk was shot. The defense alleges the relationship represents a conflict of interest.
Grunander’s daughter testified Tuesday that she did not video the shooting or the aftermath. She said she was looking at the crowd when she heard a loud pop and a man sitting nearby shouted, “He’s been shot.” She never turned to look back at Kirk and did not know he was the person shot until after she ran to safety, she said.
Judge Graf said he would issue his ruling on whether to disqualify prosecutors on Feb. 24.
Advertisement
Utah State Bureau of Investigation agent David Hull testified Tuesday that DNA on a firearm found wrapped in a black towel in a wooded area just off campus matched Robinson’s. Robinson also reportedly texted his romantic partner that he targeted Kirk because he “had enough of his hatred.”
Robinson’s attorneys have ramped up claims of bias as the case has advanced, even accusing news outlets of using lip readers to deduce what the defendant is whispering to his attorneys during hearings.
“Rather than being a beacon for truth and openness, the News Media have simply become a financial investor in this case,” defense attorneys wrote in a request for the court to seal some of their accusations of media bias.
Further complicating efforts to ensure a fair trial is the rhetoric swirling around Kirk’s death because of his political prominence. Even before Robinson was charged, people jumped to conclusions about who the shooter could be and what kind of politics he espoused.
Advertisement
“People are just projecting a lot of their own sense of what they think was going on, and that really creates concerns about whether they can be open to hearing the actual evidence that’s presented,” said University of Utah law professor Teneille Brown.
Donny van de Beek has been supported by several of his ex-Manchester United teammates after announcing a huge life update on social media
A number of Manchester United players have shown their support for Donny van de Beek after the former Reds midfielder got engaged to long-term girlfriend Estelle Bergkamp.
Advertisement
Van de Beek, who made 62 appearances during a four-year spell at Old Trafford, started dating Bergkamp, the daughter of Arsenal legend Dennis Bergkamp, back in 2019 when he was playing for Ajax.
The loved-up couple welcomed their first child, a daughter, in April 2022 before their second child, a son, was born in February 2024. Now, Van de Beek and Bergkamp are set to tie the knot after their engagement was announced in a wholesome Instagram post on Monday evening.
In a joint-post – alongside several images of Van de Beek, 28, proposing – Bergkamp, 30, said: “The easiest YES ever [ring emoji and white love heart emoji].”
Dennis Bergkamp commented with two love heart emojis, while ex-Everton midfielder Davy Klassen wrote: “Congratulations [two love heart emojis].”
Van de Beek’s former United team-mates Bruno Fernandes, Matthijs de Ligt, Christian Eriksen and Willy Kambwala liked the post, while Reds legend Edwin van der Sar also dropped a like.
After leaving United in July 2024, Van de Beek has spent the last 18 months at La Liga side Girona. He played 35 appearances and scored three times in his debut season at the Spanish outfit.
However, he has been restricted to just two appearances this campaign. This is because Van de Beek ruptured his Achilles tendon during a 1-1 draw against Athletic Club in September.
Advertisement
Content cannot be displayed without consent
During his time at United, Van de Beek helped the Reds reach the Europa League final in the 2020/21 season before being part of the squad that lifted the Carabao Cup in February 2023.
Upon his departure from the Reds, Van de Beek released an emotional statement on social media. “Dear Manchester United family. Today is a memorable day as my adventure at the club comes to an end,” he said on Instagram.
“I want to thank you all for your support throughout the years. From the moment we arrived at Manchester United, we felt extremely welcome and we are grateful for that.
“Thank you to everyone at the club for making us feel at home. A special thanks to all the fans that made these years unforgettable. Besides the football, the birth of our two children here ensures that Manchester will always have a special place in our hearts.
Advertisement
“Good luck to everybody, we’ll meet again [Japanese Ogre emoji and red love heart emoji].”
Sky has slashed the price of its Essential TV and Sky Sports bundle for the 2025/26 season, saving members £336 and offering more than 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more.
Sky will show at least 215 live Premier League games this season, an increase of up to 100 more.
Dogs often opt to follow their owners to the toilet; however, little you may know, there’s a pretty adorable story behind this and it will totally melt your heart
10:26, 04 Feb 2026Updated 10:26, 04 Feb 2026
It’s fair to say that many people love their dogs, with the animals often being described as man’s best friend but, little you may know, they are actually sending you messages via their actions. We may think we know everything about our beloved pets, but it may not be the case, as animals tell us things by using adorable signs.
This was recently brought to people’s attention on TikTok when unhide opened up about a super cute idea, and the clip has since gone viral. When it comes to dogs, they are a lot more sensitive than people realise, and you can often see how loving yours is by the way it acts and follows you around.
In the video, is was explained: “Here’s a fact about your dog you probably didn’t know. Does your dog ever follow you around and nose its way into whatever you’re doing, or just stands at the door whenever you’re at the bathroom, and waits for you?
“Well, it’s actually them trying to mimic wildlife to protect you while you’re vulnerable and going to the bathroom. They stand guard to make sure no one attacks you. I guess dogs really are too good for us.”
Content cannot be displayed without consent
The video has been viewed over 400,000 times since it was shared, and thousands of people have commented too. Many thought the cute story was totally “adorable”.
One person replied, saying: “Yes! She’s always at my bathroom door waiting for me whenever I use it.”
Advertisement
Another added: “My dog comes into the bathroom and lies on the floor until I’m done. If I close the door, he pushes it open.”
A third said: “Or it’s just the fact the dog suffers separation anxiety and misses you because you’re gone, even if it’s just to go to the bathroom?”
Meanwhile, a fourth commented: “My dog does that all the time.” One more also chimed in with: “Aww, cute babies.”
Why do dogs really do this?
Little you may know, it’s long been believed that dogs often follow their owners into the bathroom to protect them. It’s thought to act on a primal instinct to guard pack members during vulnerable, confined moments.
Advertisement
However, this behaviour can also be triggered by strong social bonding, intense curiosity and a genuine desire to be near their favourite person. Even though some have believed the guarding theory for years, not all animal behaviourists agree with it, but it’s still pretty adorable nonetheless.
According to RSPCA Pet Insurance, there could be a number of reasons why your pet does this. The website explains: “Many dogs like to follow their owners everywhere, including the bathroom, with some going as far as to scratch at the door while we’re using the toilet.
“In general, dogs follow us because they are social animals and enjoy human company. As their owner, you are the one who meets most of their needs, including for affection, so following is a sign of this attachment.
“They may also be waiting for routines they enjoy such as a walk or dinner time. Providing your dog has plenty of exercise, enrichment activities and mental stimulation, following behaviour is not a problem. If it becomes annoying, it’s important not to reward your dog through attention or treats.
Advertisement
“If your dog suddenly follows you more, this may be a sign they are feeling insecure due to some change (including ageing), afraid (such as of a thunderstorm) or unwell. Your veterinarian can help you with all these situations.”
Arsenal midfielder Declan Rice made a big Mikel Arteta admission when asked about the maturity shown to defeat Chelsea and reach the Carabao Cup final
Declan Rice has revealed that Mikel Arteta ‘controls everything’ at Arsenal in a clear verdict after the Carabao Cup semi-final triumph over Chelsea. The Gunners beat their London rivals 4-2 on aggregate, with the only goal of a cagey second leg at Emirates Stadium coming in the final minutes through Kai Havertz.
Advertisement
Last month at Stamford Bridge, Arsenal won a thrilling first leg 3-2, which put the tie firmly in their hands. A clean sheet for the hosts would have sealed a spot in the final at Wembley, with Arteta’s side seemingly less expansive in their attacking play on the night.
Chelsea were also reluctant to push for goals in the early stages, despite being behind, with Liam Rosenior opting for a back five formation. With the Blues not conceding until several bodies were sent forward during the final stages in search of a winner, the game plan somewhat worked.
However, Arteta has methodically set up a defensive unit incapable of being penetrated regularly. The Spaniard has improved Arsenal significantly over the last few years with Rice making a clear admission on him after the victory.
Advertisement
He told CBS Sports: “Our manager has total control of everything, from top to bottom of the football club! Everyone listens to him, we all believe in his work. Gabi Heinze has come in, defensive coach, he’s been unbelievable!”
Earlier in the interview, When asked how he was feeling, Rice replied: “Shattered, the schedule has been ridiculous and when you’re playing Chelsea, who have got so many good players that are constantly making you work [it’s not easy].
“Credit to them it could have gone either way tonight and in the first leg but I think everything we’ve been building towards over the last few years has come together this season. We’re into our first final in a very long time so we need to enjoy the moment.”
Advertisement
The enjoyment of their achievement is expected to be short-lived however, with attention swiftly turning to their next Premier League clash this Saturday which is at home to Sunderland.
A trip to Brentford arrives the following Thursday with the Gunners then hosting Wigan Athletic in the FA Cup that weekend.
Arteta’s side then have the chance to get the jump on some of their rivals with a fixture against Wolves from March brought forward to later this month. That change has been made because Arsenal are now heading to Wembley on the weekend they were scheduled to face the Premier League’s bottom side at Molineux.
Advertisement
That rearrangement gives Arsenal less time to prepare for the North London Derby away at Tottenham. However, it is unlikely Arteta is too concerned, considering the reason with Arsenal in a major final for the first time in nearly six years.
After the victory, he said: “We are so happy. I think overall, over the last two games, I think we deserved to be through. It was a long match, we expected that.
“We wrapped it up at the end in a beautiful way, with Kai scoring the goal in the match that he did and the reaction from the crowd.
“The starters, the finishers, the staff, it just was magical. So I’m really happy because it was a really tough match against a great opponent and we are in Wembley.”
Since this year’s awards show aired, executive producer Ben Winston has been lifting the lid on how some of its stand-out moments, including The Biebs’ performance, came to be.
During an interview with Rolling Stone, he explained that each act was given an hour and a half of rehearsal time on the Grammys stage to make sure they had every detail nailed down before the ceremony – but the Canadian star only used a fraction of it.
“He came to the stage, he did it once,” Ben recalled. “It was brilliant. We are seven minutes into his hour-and-a-half rehearsal. And he goes, ‘How’d it look to you? You happy with it?’ And I was like, ‘Oh, my God. It looked beautiful. I loved it.’ And he went, ‘OK, fantastic. See you Sunday!’”
Justin Bieber’s performance at the 2026 Grammys was a stand-out
John Salangsang/Shutterstock
Advertisement
In the end, Ben cajoled the As Long As You Love Me singer into running through it one extra time before he headed backstage after just 15 minutes.
What’s more, he also claimed that Justin’s decision to perform in boxers and socks wasn’t something he had planned from the get-go.
“I don’t think he decided what the outfit would be until he walked onstage,” Ben added, which perhaps explains why he decided to wear… well… next to nothing.
Elsewhere in the interview, Ben revealed that Lady Gaga had only landed in LA from Japan the day before the event, and it was touch and go whether she’d be able to perform at all.
Advertisement
“There was one point a few weeks before the show that we thought we might have to lose her from the show, ’cause she just was like, ‘I just don’t see how I can’,” he explained, pointing to the fact that Gaga was performing a string of shows in Japan just days before the Grammys.
“So it was amazing that not only did she do it, but I think she brought one of the most iconic performances.”
Snooker legend and BBC commentator John Virgo has died aged 79.
Virgo enjoyed an 18-year professional career, winning the 1979 UK Championship among four non-ranking titles, and reaching the semi-finals of the World Championship in 1979.
He is perhaps best known for his post-playing career, presenting snooker TV programme Big Break alongside comedian Jim Davidson from 1991 to 2002.
Following his retirement from playing in 1994, Virgo became a BBC commentator.
Advertisement
His last commentary for the BBC came 17 days ago when Kyren Wilson beat John Higgins in the Masters final.
Last year’s winners, Les Bleus, are the hosts for the opener this time as they welcome the country that had clinched the previous two instalments of this staple tournament in northern hemisphere rugby union’s annual calendar.
World No5-ranked France come into Thursday’s match having won their last two internationals following a four-Test losing streak against South Africa and New Zealand last year.
Head coach Fabien Galthie has made a few eye-catching selection calls ahead of this potentially must-win game in the quest to retain their Six Nations title, but there will be unanimous French joy when it comes to one particular returning star in influential captain Antoine Dupont.
Ireland, currently ranked fourth in the world standings, have won five of their seven games since being beaten by France early last year, with the only two defeats for Andy Farrell’s squad coming against the Springboks and the All Blacks. Of more concern, however, is the list of injury absentees facing the Irish boss.
Advertisement
Here’s everything you need to know about the opening match of this year’s Six Nations.
France vs Ireland date, kick-off time and venue
France vs Ireland takes place on Thursday March 5, 2025 at the Stade de France in Paris.
Kick-off is scheduled for 8:10pm GMT, which is 9:10pm CET in France.
Advertisement
This year’s Six Nations is starting on a Thursday for the first time to avoid a clash with the opening ceremony of the 2026 Winter Olympic Games, which takes place in Milan on Friday evening.
How to watch France vs Ireland
TV channel: In the UK, France vs Ireland is being shown live and free to air on ITV1, with coverage beginning at 7:20pm GMT.
Live stream: Live coverage of the game will also be available for online streaming via the ITVX website and app, which is free with a registration.
Advertisement
Live blog: Meanwhile, you can follow the action as it happens in Paris on Thursday right here with us, in Standard Sport’s dedicated live blog.
France vs Ireland team news
So stacked with talent is the French set-up that Galthie has left all-time record try-scorer Damian Penaud, last year’s Six Nations-winning skipper Gregory Alldritt and veteran centre Gael Fickou out of his 42-player tournament squad entirely.
Experienced prop Uini Atonio will play no part, having retired on health grounds following a cardiac event last month, while fly-half Romain Ntamack is out injured.
Advertisement
In come Anthony Jelonch and Theo Attissogbe, starting this first Test at No8 and on the wing, respectively, while star scrum-half Dupont returns to captain his country following a lengthy lay-off that saw him miss much of 2025 with a knee injury picked up against Ireland last year.
Dupont is partnered by fly-half Matthieu Jalibert, who starts amid a strong club campaign for Bordeaux, while last season’s leading try-scorer Louis Bielle-Biarrey joins Attissogbe on the wings. Nicolas Depoortere and Yoram Moefana are named in the centre spots and Thomas Ramos is given the nod at 15 to complete a formidable backline.
France’s starting pack against Ireland consists of Francois Cros and Oscar Jegou either side of No8 Jelonch, with locks Charles Ollivon and Mickael Guillard behind front-rowers Jean-Baptiste Gros, Julien Marchand and Dorian Aldegheri.
On the bench, meanwhile, Galthie has opted for a forward-heavy 6-2 split.
Advertisement
He’s back: Dupont missed most of 2025 with a serious knee injury suffered against Ireland in the Six Nations
Getty Images
As for Ireland, a combination of injuries, form and disciplinary issues have left returning head coach Andy Farrell – who missed last year’s competition due to British and Irish Lions commitments – with fewer decisions to make than he may have liked.
Bundee Aki is suspended for Ireland’s first three Six Nations matches after being issued a four-game ban for “verbal abuse and disrespect” towards match officials during Connacht’s recent loss to Leinster in the United Rugby Championship (URC).
Advertisement
Joining him among Ireland’s absentees are the likes of Mack Hansen, Tadhg Furlong, Hugo Keenan – who fractured his hand in training last week – and Andrew Porter, who are all injured, while out-of-form wing James Lowe is left out of the matchday 23 entirely.
Jamie Osborne is fit to start at full-back against France, with Jacob Stockdale and Tommy O’Brien on the wings, Garry Ringrose and Stuart McCloskey in the centres and a half-back team of Sam Prendergast and Jamison Gibson-Park.
Cian Prendergast has been called into the back row alongside captain Caelan Doris and Josh van der Flier, the second row features Tadhg Beirne and Joe McCarthy, and up front it’s star hooker Dan Sheehan plus props Jeremy Loughman – making his first Ireland appearance in two years, with first-choice looseheads Porter, Paddy McCarthy and Jack Boyle all sidelined through injury – and Thomas Clarkson, who deputises for Furlong.
Farrell matches Galthie with a 6-2 bench split. In the full 37-man squad there was room for in-form uncapped pair Edwin Edogbo and Nathan Doak, but neither make the matchday squad on this occasion.
France vs Ireland head to head (h2h) history and results
It is France who remain the overall head-to-head winners in this match-up, having extended their lead with a 60th competitive victory over the Irish in 2025.
Ireland had narrowed the gap in recent years, beating France in their two previous showdowns between 2023 and 2024, while each nation has won five of the last 10 Tests.
Advertisement
France still hold the advantage in Six Nations history, though, having won 13 times to Ireland’s 11. The other two meetings in this tournament have ended as draws.
France vs Ireland prediction
The French rallied to overcome the early loss of star skipper Dupont to injury that day, and his availability for a first France cap since then is a huge boost to Galthie’s group.
Tough test: Ireland head coach Andy Farrell is without several key players due to injury and suspension
Niall Carson/PA Wire
Advertisement
This is the only Six Nations fixture which has, on average, been decided by fewer than 10 points (8.8), and it has also seen the highest percentage of games won by seven or fewer points (58 per cent).
It is therefore always difficult to pick a winner between these two rugby colossuses, but we’re giving the edge to France due to home advantage as well as Ireland’s worrisome injury list, which includes several absences in key positions.
The legendary snooker commentator from Salford and former UK Championship winner has died at the age of 79
Legendary snooker commentator John Virgo has died aged 79. Virgo was regarded as the voice of the sport, making his final appearance on the BBC for last month’s Masters tournament.
Advertisement
As a player, the Salford-born star enjoyed a successful career and claimed the UK Championship in 1979. Virgo died in Spain, where he lived, on Wednesday.
World Seniors Snooker chairman Jason Francis confirmed the news by posting on social media platform X: “Heartbreaking to share the news that we’ve lost the great ‘JV’ John Virgo this morning, he passed away in Spain.
“Rosie (his wife) and Brooke-Leah would like everyone to know. Our hearts go out to them both, Gary and the grandchildren. JV was doing what he loved to do right up until the end, entertaining everyone.”
Advertisement
“Such an important person in my life but in our sport in general. An amazingly loyal friend to me, and someone you felt was sat with you at the match when he was commentating on TV. Hard to take this one…one great person who touched so many lives and loved the game. We will never forget you bud. RIP JV.”
The World Snooker Tour also said: “Everyone at World Snooker Tour is deeply saddened to learn of the passing of legendary snooker player and broadcaster John Virgo, aged 79. Our thoughts are with his family and loved ones. Rest in peace, JV.”
After retiring in 1994, Virgo went on to become the sport’s most legendary commentator. He was inducted in the World Snooker Tour Hall of Fame three years ago, reports the Mirror.
Advertisement
His famous catchphrase: “Where’s the cue ball going?” added to his legendary status. Virgo was also known for his flamboyant waistcoats.
Throughout his playing career, Virgo climbed to No. 10 in the world rankings.
He fronted the BBC’s snooker programme, Big Break, which aired from 1991 to 2002, alongside Jim Davidson.
Looking back on the show’s success, he told the Express: “I always remember, Jim had a bit of a reputation in the business for being hard work.
Advertisement
“A few people asked me, ‘How are you getting on working with Jim Davidson?’ I said, ‘He doesn’t bother me, I worked with [Alex] Higgins for 20 years’! I wasn’t daunted by working with Jim.
“It’s a funny thing about life. He’s your crafty Conservative comedian and I’m your dour northern socialist. How do you come up with that? But obviously the chemistry worked.
“Although Jim didn’t know much about snooker, what a funny man and a very generous man to work with. We really got on well. Besides, when you’re in those positions, the most important thing is that the show works.”
Advertisement
In 2020, he and wife Rosie relocated to Spain. The pair moved to the Costa del Sol and hoped that the milder climate would help alleviate Virgo’s discomfort from a long-term neck injury.
Plans to turn a flat on Castlemilk Road into a short term holiday let have been approved by councillors on the planning committee today (January 27) despite a wave of objections from neighbours.
A short-term let has been approved in Rutherglen despite neighbour objections.
Advertisement
Plans to turn a flat on Castlemilk Road into a short term holiday let have been approved by councillors on the planning committee today (January 27) despite a wave of objections from neighbours.
The application relates to an upper-floor cottage flat within a four-in-a-block building, and the plans sought permission to change the use of the property from a permanent home to a short-term visitor accommodation.
The decision was taken to the planning committee after seven formal objections were raised.
Residents lodged concerns about potential noise and disruption, increased footfall, loss of privacy and pressure on on-street parking.
Advertisement
Planning officers decided that the change of use would not result in significant harm to residential amenity. A key factor was that the flat has its own private entrance, reducing interaction with neighbouring households in the shared building.
Permission has been granted on a temporary basis until January 2036, after which the property must revert to residential use unless further consent is approved. Conditions also require the submission of landscaping details to protect neighbouring privacy along with an agreed scheme for waste and storage collection.
*Don’t miss the latest headlines from around Lanarkshire. Sign up to our newsletters here.
And did you know Lanarkshire Live had its own app? Download yours for free here.
Weeks of heavy snowfall in Japan has killed at least 35 people, government officials have said.
And there are fears the worst is yet to come – with more heavy snowfall expected this weekend.
Nearly 400 more have been injured, 126 people seriously, primarily around the northern and central regions of the country – and more than a dozen properties damaged.
As of Wednesday, 15 prefectures were affected, with snow in some areas estimated to have reached up to 2m (6.5ft).
Advertisement
Task forces have been set up and deployed to some of the worst-hit regions.
Image: Pic: Kyodo via Reuters
Most of the fatalities and injuries reported across the country were caused by falls as people tried to clear the snow from around their homes.
There have also been reports of people suffering sudden heart attacks.
In the northern city of Uonuma in Niigata prefecture, a rice-growing region, a man in his 50s was found collapsed on the roof of his home.
Advertisement
In Nagaoka city, a man in his 70s is believed to have died after falling from the roof of his house.
Image: Pic: AP
The weather is getting warmer, but officials have warned melting snow could cause landslides.
“Please do pay close attention to your safety, wearing a helmet or using a lifeline rope, especially when working on clearing snow,” chief cabinet secretary Minoru Kihara told reporters.
The report comes almost 10 years after an investigation into baby deaths at the hospital, with the Scottish Government ordering a review.
09:08, 04 Feb 2026Updated 09:08, 04 Feb 2026
A Scots maternity ward has fallen short of standards in 16 different areas in a recent inspection, including potential gaps in incident reporting.
Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) carried out an unannounced inspection of Ayrshire Maternity Unit at NHS Ayrshire & Arran’s University Hospital Crosshouse on October 8-9 last year, and later carried out another on October 27 the same year.
The report comes almost 10 years after an investigation into baby deaths at the hospital, with the Scottish Government ordering a review. Between 2008 and March 31 2016, there were four significant adverse event reviews concerning stillbirth deaths at the unit at Crosshouse Hospital, Kilmarnock, East Ayrshire.
Advertisement
A BBC investigation at that time found there had been six so-called “unnecessary” deaths of babies at the hospital since 2008. In a report released on Wednesday, HIS said it had found 16 requirements, two recommendations, and 10 areas of good practice.
Requirements included better fire safety, incident reporting, ensuring women can receive timely access to midwifery telephone assessments, better governance and oversight of the maternity ward, and the right care at the right time. It also called for ongoing engagement among staff to ensure a transparent workplace, and to ensure timescales of significant adverse events reviews are achieved to support and improve the quality and safety of care.
It also found the hospital must take more steps to ensure patient equipment is clean and ready for use. The inspection also noted a number of areas where the ward is excelling – including support for families with newborns, a dedicated area for bereaved families, and that families were given the opportunity to stay in the hospital during births.
Advertisement
Speaking of the report, Donna Maclean, chief inspector, HIS, said: “During this inspection we observed cohesive team working in all areas inspected. Maternity staff we spoke with described positive working relations between midwifery, obstetric, anaesthetic and the health care support team. Staff described feeling supported to escalate staffing issues and concerns to their senior charge midwife.
“Women within the unit told us they felt listened to and supported in making decisions about their care – women described positive experiences of communication and compassionate interactions with staff. Women and their families also told us they would be happy to recommend NHS Ayrshire & Arran maternity services to their family and friends.”
She added: “However, we raised concerns regarding potential delays to care for women accessing maternity triage and potential gaps in incident reporting, which may impact on the learning from adverse events and reducing opportunities to improve safety. We also raised concerns regarding fire safety. Other areas for improvement identified include flushing of infrequently used water outlets and some improvements required in the cleanliness of patient equipment.”
Advertisement
This inspection resulted in 10 areas of good practice, two recommendations and 16 requirements. Jennifer Wilson, nurse director of Ayrshire Maternity Unit, said she acknowledges the findings in the report, and says NHS Ayrshire & Arran is committed to making the necessary improvements.
She said: “NHS Ayrshire & Arran is committed to the provision of high standards to ensure our patients receive safe and dignified care at all times. Our teams have a strong focus on ensuring that improvements are made to deliver the best possible care across health and social care services.
“As a learning organisation, NHS Ayrshire & Arran values scrutiny and inspection of our services. We acknowledge the recent Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s (HIS) report following their visit to Ayrshire Maternity Unit. The report highlighted cohesive multidisciplinary team working and positive working relationships and demonstrated that our teams provide a good standard of care for families, supporting patients to make decisions about their care.”
She added: “We acknowledge that there are areas where we need to make further improvements, and these have been addressed within our action plan. I would like to take this opportunity to thank our teams for their hard work in caring for the women, babies and families who use our services.”
Advertisement
Health Secretary Neil Gray was asked about the report in an interview on BBC Radio Scotland’s Breakfast programme. He was asked why issues around the reporting of adverse events have been raised almost a decade after a review ordered by the Scottish Government.
Mr Gray said: “I welcome Healthcare Improvement Scotland’s report, it demonstrates that our inspection regime is working to ensure that localised issues are being addressed, and I expect Ayrshire and Arran to respond timeously, to ensure that all of the recommendations, all 16 recommendations, are delivered as fast as possible.
“This is the fifth inspection that Healthcare Improvement Scotland has carried out at our acute maternity services across Scotland, when we consider that NHS Tayside has now implemented all of the recommendations in its report into the maternity services at Ninewells.
“I expect a similarly timeous response from Ayrshire and Arran in Crosshouse to ensure that the safety of patients is absolutely paramount, and that we can ensure that our maternity services are safe for women and their families.”
Advertisement
Asked whether they are safe today he said: “Yes I believe they are.”