Connect with us
DAPA Banner

Entertainment

Inside Kanye West’s Failed UK Comeback Plan

Published

on

Kim Kardashian and Kanye West leaving kids basketball practice in Calabasas

A high-stakes plan to bring Kanye West back to the UK has collapsed in dramatic fashion, leaving behind financial losses, public backlash, and a canceled festival.

What was meant to be a carefully orchestrated return quickly unraveled, exposing miscalculations, mounting criticism, and a gamble that ultimately failed under intense scrutiny from both officials and the public.

The Ambitious Kanye West Comeback Plan

Behind the scenes, the effort to reintroduce Kanye West to UK audiences was anything but casual.

Industry giant Live Nation reportedly poured time, money, and resources into securing his return, even traveling internationally to court the controversial star.

According to a source who spoke to the Daily Mail, “Live Nation put together a big package of multiple shows across the globe including Wireless.”

Advertisement

The ambition was clear: not just a single performance, but a global comeback narrative centered around one of music’s most polarizing figures.

However, warning signs were already present early in the process.

The same source revealed that concerns had been raised about the optics of hosting the rapper in North London.

“They were advised that it would be mad to put him on stage in Haringey, so close to a large Jewish community in north London, and they didn’t listen,” the source shared.

Advertisement

Despite those warnings, planning continued. Critics were later unimpressed with claims that consultations had been thorough.

The insider said, “They are now saying that they asked ‘stakeholders, ‘ but this is simply ludicrous.”

Kanye West Deal Raises Early Red Flags

Kim Kardashian and Kanye West leaving kids basketball practice in Calabasas
MEGA

Even before the Wireless Festival announcement, securing venues proved difficult.

Attempts to stage performances at major stadiums were unsuccessful.

The insider noted, “Before they signed a deal with Wireless they had asked about putting a show on at the Tottenham Hotspur and West Ham grounds and both turned them down absolutely flat.”

Advertisement

That rejection alone hinted at the controversy surrounding West’s return.

The source said, “That should at least have shown them what a problem there was. Then there was an exploration of asking Twickenham but it was felt to be the wrong crowd for Kanye.”

Still, negotiations pushed forward, culminating in a massive payday.

“He asked for and got $15million to play those three nights at Wireless. At that late point they still hadn’t secured a headline act,” the insider added.

Advertisement

From a business perspective, the gamble was enormous and increasingly fragile.

Kanye West Ban Sparks Immediate Fallout

Kanye West wearing sunglasses
Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency / MEGA

Everything changed when UK officials stepped in. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood blocked Kanye West’s entry, citing concerns that his presence would “not be conducive to the public good.”

The consequences were swift. Within moments of the ban becoming public, the Wireless Festival, set to take place in Finsbury Park, was canceled outright.

Promotional materials vanished almost instantly, leaving only a brief notice stating the “festival has been forced to cancel.”

Fans were promised refunds, but frustration quickly surfaced. Many questioned why organizers failed to prepare alternatives, especially given the risks tied to booking such a controversial headliner.

Advertisement

The fallout extended beyond disappointed ticket holders. Political and advocacy voices also weighed in.

Sir Keir Starmer argued that West “should never have been invited,” while support for the government’s decision came from groups like The Campaign Against Antisemitism.

Karen Pollock, CEO of the Holocaust Educational Trust, strongly criticized those defending the artist.

“No other community would be told to ‘forgive’ or ‘talk’ – the disgusting racism would be recognized for what it is,” she said.

Advertisement

Financial Fallout And Industry Backlash

Kanye West walking
MEGA

The collapse of the event has triggered serious financial concerns. Live Nation now faces the possibility of staggering losses, with some estimates reaching $30 million.

Although contracts may allow the company to recover part of the $15 million fee, doubts remain.

As one source bluntly put it, “Live Nation should be able to get all $15million back as their contracts say that it is the responsibility of the artist to get a visa. Because the decision was made by the Home Secretary they believe that they can get their money back.”

Still, optimism appears limited. “They think it’s not as big a disaster as it could have been but, good luck getting Kanye to pay you back,” the source continued.

The damage goes beyond finances. Industry insiders have described the situation as a major misstep.

Advertisement

Another insider said, “This is one of the biggest mess-ups that they have made since Covid, and I am including the Ticketmaster disaster which has led to them being sued in that.”

Criticism of the company’s judgment has been sharp. The source continued, “This shows how arrogant and out of touch they are. They thought that they would get away with it and that everyone would roll over. That didn’t happen which is why Kanye released a new apology, but it was too little too late.”

The source also questioned the artist’s pattern of behavior, adding, “Kanye has just been cynically doing what he always does which is cause outrageous offence, go away for a year, and then come back with an album and apology. That playbook no longer flies.”

A Comeback That Could Not Be Saved

Kanye West seen arriving a his hotel in NYC
MEGA

Kanye West’s attempted return was already under scrutiny due to his past controversies, including offensive remarks and public backlash. Although he had issued an apology earlier in the year and expressed a desire to demonstrate change, it wasn’t enough to shift public sentiment.

He had even suggested he wanted to show “change through his actions” and engage directly with Jewish communities in London ahead of the planned shows.

Advertisement

However, for many critics, the timing and sincerity of those efforts were questionable. The broader response suggested that reputational damage, combined with political pressure, proved too significant to overcome.

Wireless organizers attempted to defend their decision-making process after the cancellation. In a statement, a spokesperson said, “As with every Wireless Festival, multiple stakeholders were consulted in advance of booking YE and no concerns were highlighted at the time.”

However, by then, the damage was done. The festival’s future now hangs in the balance, with reports suggesting it could “go dark” in 2026 if a new headliner cannot be secured.

What began as a bold attempt to revive Kanye West’s presence in the UK has instead become a cautionary tale, one that highlights the risks of betting big on controversy in an increasingly scrutinized entertainment landscape.

Advertisement

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Entertainment

RFK Jr. book shares new details of 'tense conference call' planning JFK Jr. and Carolyn's funerals

Published

on


JFK Jr., Carolyn Bessette, and her sister Lauren died in a plane crash off Martha’s Vineyard in July 1999.

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

“Survivor” star Monica Culpepper breaks silence on son Rex's death at 28: 'Our worst nightmare won't end'

Published

on


The former Syracuse Orange quarterback died on March 14 following a dirt bike accident. He was 28.

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

Sabrina Carpenter Is Unrecognizable With Brown Hair, Bangs

Published

on

Everything to Know About RHOSLC Alum Jen Shah's Legal Drama

Sabrina Carpenter proved she shines no matter what shade of hair she rocks.

Carpenter, 26, was unrecognizable while posing for Perfect Magazine in a brunette wig on Tuesday, April 7. Her hair, which was much darker from her signature honey blonde mane, was worn down and straightened. Her look was finished with short bangs cut above her eyebrows.

Carpenter complimented her wig with a black manicure and soft makeup, including rosy cheeks, light pink lips and mascara.

Fans went wild over her look via social media. “Omg didn’t even recognize her!! ❤️,” one wrote, while a second added, “ooo the black hair looks good.” A third commented, “Full on shape shifting ❤️.”

Advertisement

While chatting with the publication, Carpenter, who was styled by fashion editor Katie Eleanor Grand, opened up about her dark makeover, sharing, “I love to play dress up. This shoot was really fun for that reason.”

She added, “We got to really try some looks that I’ve never tried before. Lots of wigs, lots of different makeup for me, lots of shapes that maybe I wouldn’t normally wear. I can just play a little bit more with editorial. It was really fun.”

Carpenter also got candid about her upcoming gig headlining Coachella on Friday, April 10, and April 17, which she manifested two years ago while performing on the same stage.

“Now, two years later, we’re back,” she said. “And I think that’s what makes this show feel really, really surreal: getting to celebrate all the songs that have come after it, and just how many lives they’ve lived since they’ve come out.”

Sabrina Carpenter Hits Back at Critics Who Think She s Too Raunchy


Related: Sabrina Carpenter Poses Nude for ‘Rolling Stone’ After Album Cover Backlash

Advertisement

Sabrina Carpenter isn’t afraid to strip down. Carpenter, 26, showed off her birthday suit while posing on the cover of Rolling Stone on Thursday, June 12. The singer went completely naked for the photoshoot, covering her body with extra-long, Rapunzel-like locks. Instead of rocking her signature bouncy curls, Carpenter opted for wavy tresses, which cascaded […]

Photographed by Bryce Anderson, Carpenter continued, “When I’m on stage, there’s a button. I think it’s been this way ever since I was young. And when you’re singing these songs, whether these songs be your personal stories or songs you wrote about other people, in that moment, it really becomes a show.”

Carpenter explained, “I’ve always been able to differentiate when I get off stage. I am a human being. I’m a 26-year-old girl. I’m hormonal. I’m emotional. I’m dealing with a lot of stuff. For me, it really just has been compartmentalising the moments where I feel like the show must go on and then moments where I can really allow myself to be a little all over the place and allow that to be OK.”

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

Trump To Pause Bombing Amid “Workable” Peace Plan

Published

on

Rihanna Seemingly Addresses Baby Rumors, Talks "Little Pouch"

U.S. President Donald Trump said late Tuesday he’s pulling back on his threats to attack Iranian bridges, power plants, and other civilian targets. His decision depends on Iran agreeing to a two-week ceasefire and reopening the Strait of Hormuz. Trump also said Iran has proposed a “workable” 10-point peace plan that could help end the war the U.S. and Israel launched on Feb. 28. Early Tuesday, Trump threatened that “a whole civilization will die tonight,” doubling down on an 8 p.m. EST deadline to reach a deal.

RELATED: Trump Warns “A Whole Civilization Will Die Tonight” As Iran Says 14 Million Are Ready To Defend Nation (UPDATE)

Trump Pulls Back Iran Threat Amid Peace Plan Proposal

In a post on his social media site, Donald Trump said Iran could agree “to the COMPLETE, IMMEDIATE, and SAFE OPENING of the Strait of Hormuz” and said that he’d then “suspend the bombing and attack of Iran for a period of two weeks.” He cited conversations with Pakistani officials as the basis for these negotiations.

The update was shared at 6:32 local Washington D.C. time, about an hour and a half from his deadline. Also, the president said in his post that Iran has presented “a workable basis on which to negotiate.”

“Based on conversations with Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and Field Marshal Asim Munir, of Pakistan, and wherein they requested that I hold off the destructive force being sent tonight to Iran, and subject to the Islamic Republic of Iran agreeing to the COMPLETE, IMMEDIATE, and SAFE OPENING of the Strait of Hormuz, I agree to suspend the bombing and attack of Iran for a period of two weeks. This will be a double sided CEASEFIRE! The reason for doing so is that we have already met and exceeded all Military objectives, and are very far along with a definitive Agreement concerning Longterm PEACE with Iran, and PEACE in the Middle East. We received a 10 point proposal from Iran, and believe it is a workable basis on which to negotiate. Almost all of the various points of past contention have been agreed to between the United States and Iran, but a two week period will allow the Agreement to be finalized and consummated. On behalf of the United States of America, as President, and also representing the Countries of the Middle East, it is an Honor to have this Longterm problem close to resolution. Thank you for your attention to this matter! President DONALD J. TRUMP,” the Truth Social post said.

 

Advertisement

Donald Trump had previously threatened Tuesday that a “whole civilization will die tonight” if Iran fails to meet his latest deadline to strike a deal. His terms include reopening the strait through. During peacetime, a fifth of hte world’s oil is transported through it.

Since the war began, Trump has repeatedly imposed deadlines linked to threats, only to extend them. Tehran previously rejected a 45-day ceasefire proposal by Egyptian, Pakistani and Turkish mediators. The nation sought a permanent end to the war.

Iran Vowed To Reciprocate Trump’s Energy

Tehran’s representative at the U.N., Amir-Saeid Iravani, said the threats “constitute incitement to war crimes and potentially genocide.” Iravani also said Iran would “take immediate and proportionate reciprocal measures” if Trump launches devastating strikes.

For context, the U.S. and Israel have battered Iran with attacks targeting its military capabilities, leadership and nuclear program. Iran has responded with a stream of strikes on Israel and Gulf Arab neighbors, causing regional chaos and outsized economic and political shock.

Advertisement

Early Tuesday, Iran’s president said 14 million people, including himself, have volunteered to fight. The president said his volunteers are ready to sacrifice their lives behind the nation.

Additionally, a general in Iran’s Revolutionary Guard general warned that Iran would “deprive the U.S. and its allies of the region’s oil and gas for years” and expand its attacks across the Gulf region if Trump carries out his threat.

Iran was standing on business, despite Trump saying that U.S. forces could wipe out all bridges in Iran in a matter of hours. Trump also claimed the U.S. could reduce all power plants to smoking rubble in roughly the same time frame.

Advertisement

“Civilization” Death Threat Caught National And International Heat 

Late Tuesday, Pakistan’s prime minister urged Trump to extend his deadline by two weeks to allow diplomacy to advance. In a post on X, Shehbaz Sharif, whose country has been leading negotiations, also asked Iran to open up for two weeks the Strait of Hormuz.

Before the deadline, airstrikes hit two bridges and a train station. Also, the U.S. hit military infrastructure on Kharg Island, a key hub for Iranian oil production. It was not clear if airstrikes against Iran on Tuesday were linked to Trump’s threats to widen the civilian target list. At least two of the targets were connected to Iran’s rail network. Additionally, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Israeli warplanes struck bridges and railways in Iran. Tehran, Iran, fired on Israel and Saudi Arabia, prompting the temporary closure of a major bridge.

Trump’s shocking threats between Easter Sunday and Tuesday did not seem to account for potential harm to civilians. His words prompted Democrats in Congress, some United Nations officials, French officials and even scholars in military law to say such strikes would violate international law.

In Rome, Pope Leo XIV said Tuesday that the threats were “truly unacceptable” and that such attacks would violate international law. Also, French Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot said that attacks targeting civilian and energy infrastructure could constitute a war crime.

Advertisement
RELATED: Make What Great?! Marjorie Taylor Greene & Candace Owens Blast President Trump’s Easter Threat To Iran Ahead Of Ceasefire Rejection

Associated Press reporters Bassem Mroue, Jon Gambrell, Mike Corder, Samy Magdy, Seung Min Kim and Michelle Price contributed to this report via AP Newsroom. International-based writers David Rising, John Leicester, Rod McGuirk, Natalie Melzer also contributed. Additional contributors: Farnoush Amiri at The United Nations; and Konstantin Toropin, Joshua Boak and Will Weissert in Washington. 

What Do You Think Roomies?

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

RFK Jr. book alleges he was 'cruel' to late wife Mary about her weight, told her 'she had squandered her beauty'

Published

on


The new biography used interviews and RFK Jr.’s private diaries to discuss challenges and tragedy with his second wife, Mary Richardson Kennedy.

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

Arsenio Hall recalls saving an elderly couple from a house fire with Jay Leno

Published

on


In spite of their public feuding in the 1990s, Hall considers Leno a “big brother” after he took him under his wing when he came to Hollywood.

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

Lady Gaga Pulls Out Of Concert At Last Minute

Published

on

Lady Gaga at 2026 Grammy Awards

After months on the road and nearing the final stretch of her global “Mayhem Ball Tour,” Lady Gaga was set to deliver another high-energy performance in Montreal. But just hours before showtime, everything changed. Lady Gaga abruptly canceled her Monday night concert, leaving fans stunned as she revealed a sudden health setback had forced her off stage at the last minute.

Lady Gaga Forced To Cancel Concert Amid Health Scare

Lady Gaga at 2026 Grammy Awards
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA

The Grammy-winning star took to Instagram Stories on Monday to break the news, revealing she is currently battling a respiratory infection that has worsened in recent days. “Hi everyone. I’m so sorry to share that I’m unable to perform tonight and have to cancel the show,” she wrote.

Gaga explained that despite trying to push through, her condition ultimately forced her to step back. “I’ve been fighting a respiratory infection for the past few days and doing everything I can to rest and recover, but it’s gotten worse,” she revealed, adding that her doctor “strongly advised” her not to perform.

She also noted she wouldn’t be able to deliver the level of performance fans expect. “My doctor has strongly advised me not to perform today and to be honest I don’t think I could give you the quality of a performance today that you deserve,” Lady Gaga said.

Advertisement

She’s ‘Absolutely Heartbroken’ After Canceling Show

Lady Gaga at 2026 Grammy Awards
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA

The singer made it clear how difficult the decision was, expressing deep regret over canceling the show. “I know how deeply disappointing this is, and I truly could not feel worse about letting you down,” she wrote. “I’m so sorry to everyone who made plans to be there and support me.”

She also reflected on her time in Montreal, calling her previous shows there “magical and deeply meaningful. To everyone who was coming tonight, I’m absolutely heartbroken and so sorry.”

Lady Gaga Cancels Show As ‘Mayhem Ball Tour’ Nears Finale

Lady Gaga
ZUMAPRESS.com / MEGA TheMegaAgency.com

At the time of her announcement, Gaga had not shared details about rescheduling the canceled show or issuing refunds, leaving fans waiting for further updates. The canceled performance was set to be her third show in Montreal, following appearances on Thursday and Friday.

The cancellation comes as Gaga nears the end of her massive “Mayhem Ball Tour,” which kicked off in July 2025. The global tour, supporting her sixth studio album Mayhem, has taken her across the U.S., Europe, Australia, and Asia before returning to North America for its final leg.

Up next, she is scheduled to perform two shows in Saint Paul, Minnesota, before wrapping the tour in New York City.

‘Mayhem Ball Tour’ Expanded After Overwhelming Fan Demand

Lady Gaga at UK Premiere of "Joker Folie à Deux".
Fred Duval/MEGA

Lady Gaga originally hadn’t planned to extend her run of shows, but fan response quickly changed that. When she announced the “Mayhem Ball Tour” back in March of 2025, Gaga revealed that the “incredible response” to her album Mayhem inspired her to keep the momentum going beyond her initial dates in Singapore.

“We chose arenas this time to give me the opportunity to control the details of the show in a way you simply can’t in stadiums, and honestly, I can’t wait,” she wrote on Instagram. “This show is designed to be the kind of theatrical and electrifying experience that brings MAYHEM to life exactly how I envision it. The MAYHEM Ball Tour is officially coming your way. See you soon, monsters.”

Advertisement

The 2026 Grammys Performance Almost Didn’t Happen

Lady Gaga at "Joker: Folie A Deux" Photocall - The 81st Venice International Film Festival
Daniele Cifalà / MEGA

While her ongoing tour continues to make headlines, Lady Gaga’s show-stopping 2026 Grammy Awards performance almost didn’t happen. Despite ultimately taking the stage on February 1 with a rock version of her hit “Abracadabra,” and walking away with two trophies, the pop icon came close to skipping the performance altogether due to scheduling challenges.

“There was one point a few weeks before the show that we thought we might have to lose her from the show because she just was like, ‘I just don’t see how I can,’” Grammys executive producer Ben Winston revealed.

At the time, Gaga had just wrapped a series of shows in Japan as part of her “Mayhem Ball Tour,” leaving little to no time for rehearsal. “Unlike everybody else who had time to rehearse offsite or with their dancers or band or creative team, she couldn’t,” Winston explained. “She was literally on stage.”

Lady Gaga’s Last-Minute Grammys Pivot Pays Off Big

Lady Gaga at Netflix's "Maestro" Los Angeles Photo Call
Jeffrey Mayer/JTMPhotos, Int’l. / MEGA

To make it work, Gaga and her team pivoted creatively, ditching a large-scale production in favor of a more stripped-down, rock-inspired performance centered around her at the piano. “It was so different, so original, so spectacular,” Winston said.

The last-minute adjustment ultimately paid off, delivering one of the night’s most memorable performances despite the behind-the-scenes uncertainty.

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

Entertainment

From Paris, With Glug: The Alcoholic Star Trek Episode That Gave Us Hope

Published

on

From Paris, With Glug: The Alcoholic Star Trek Episode That Gave Us Hope

By Chris Snellgrove
| Published

As a franchise, Star Trek is full of episodes that are hard to understand. Sometimes, this is because of all the weird technobabble. You can only hear someone mention tachyons and deflector dishes so many times before you zone out. More often, though, it’s hard to understand an episode because you don’t understand why a character made a surprising decision. This can make Star Trek feel like a horror movie because you find yourself screaming at the screen, wondering why supposedly smart people are making nothing but dumb decisions from beginning to end.

A prime example of this is “Non-Sequitur,” a Voyager episode where Harry Kim wakes up back on Earth. Instead of being stranded in the Delta Quadrant, he’s engaged to the girl of his dreams and generally living his best life. However, he risks it all to restore the timeline so that his best buddy, Tom Paris, can have meaning in his life again. Kim’s decision to ruin his own life for his friend was baffling to everyone, including the actors. But Kim’s shocking choice perfectly defines what Voyager is all about: standing fast to your ideals, no matter the cost.

The Man Who Had It All

“Non-Sequitur” is an episode where Harry Kim seemingly has it all. After his shuttlecraft starts shaking, he suddenly wakes up in a different timeline where he never joined Voyager’s crew. Instead of enjoying a happily ever after with his old flame (and now fiancée) Libby, however, he becomes obsessed with finding out what happened to him. That obsession reaches a fever pitch when he finds out that Tom Paris never made it to Voyager and has become a drunk, bitter has-been. After getting Paris’ reluctant help, the two restore the timeline and rejoin Voyager on its 70-year mission to get home.

It’s a standout episode of Star Trek: Voyager and arguably the first really great Harry Kim episode. However, it can be hard to suspend your disbelief when watching “Non-Sequitur,” especially if you put yourself in Kim’s shoes. For most people, being separated from all their friends and family for the better part of a century is one of the worst things that could ever happen to them. This is an episode where Harry seemingly got a second chance at living an infinitely happier life, but he ultimately threw it away to return to the bleak status quo of his existence in the Delta Quadrant.

From Paris, With Glug

Interestingly, both Ensign Kim actor Garret Wang and Libby actor Jennifer Gatti had the same questions about why the heck Kim would ever want to return to Voyager. Eventually, producer Jeri Taylor revealed the answer in an old interview with Cinefantastique: “The big thing is finding his friend Tom Paris is dissolute, because of this whole change,” she said. “Kim may be living a lovely life with his girlfriend, but it is at the cost of his friend’s happiness, and it just isn’t right. He is too much a young man of principle and integrity to indulge himself when it is at the expense of others.”

Arguably, this perfectly encapsulates the values of Star Trek: Voyager. As an idealistic and principled Starfleet officer, Harry Kim couldn’t screw over his best friend just to make his own life better. Just like Janeway couldn’t use the Caretaker to take her ship back home because she knew it would doom the Ocampa. Kim’s moral dilemma isn’t all that unique. In the finest Trek tradition, he must choose between happiness and duty, and he doesn’t hesitate to choose duty.

Advertisement

Is that message more than a bit cheesy and impractical? Of course. But let’s face it: we watch Star Trek because these characters are aspirational. They give us hope that, hundreds of years from now, humanity will have evolved beyond petty selfishness in the collective pursuit of bettering ourselves.

Harry Kim did something that none of us would have done in his place, and that’s the point. He’s modeling how to be a better man. In this way, “Non-Sequitur” is more than a solid Voyager episode: it’s also the embodiment of this franchise’s greatest ideals, perfectly defining everything that fans love about Star Trek.


Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Entertainment

Star Trek Is Less Progressive Now Than It Was 30 Years Ago

Published

on

Star Trek Is Less Progressive Now Than It Was 30 Years Ago

By Chris Snellgrove
| Published

Critics and social media pundits have been quick to frame the modern era of Star Trek as the franchise’s most progressive. Often, that’s cited by NuTrek defenders as one of the best reasons to watch each series. Those defenders are wrong. Star Trek has never been less progressive than it is right now.

To find out where the disconnect is, all an objective observer need do is take a look at Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. Before NuTrek started giving itself credit for being open-minded, Deep Space Nine was regarded as the most progressive entry in Star Trek’s canon, and it still is.

Far Beyond Identity Politics

Why is Deep Space Nine Star Trek’s most progressive show? It had the franchise’s first Black captain in a leading role, and the show found clever ways to explore modern issues of race through episodes like “Far Beyond the Stars.”

Compare this to Discovery, which got progressive brownie points for making Michael Burnham the franchise’s first Black, female captain in a leading role. That might sound similar, except Sisko wasn’t treated as a black Captain; he was treated as a great character, being played by a great actor, breathing life into great writing.

That didn’t happen with Michael Burnham. While Sonequa Martin-Green was excellent as Michael Burnham, she was frequently hampered by bad writers who had nothing to say about race or racism but were eager to shout, “Look who we put in the captain’s chair!”

Advertisement
Adira Tal and Michael Burnham on Star Trek: Discovery

Sisko wasn’t the only progressive character in the series. The prominent Trill character Dax effectively served as an allegory for trans people. Sisko originally knew her as a curmudgeonly womanizer, Kurzon Dax, and their friendship remained the same when she became a beautiful young woman.

Over the course of the show, Deep Space Nine offered surprisingly nuanced allegories exploring what it is like to become another person and how that affects how you are treated. Compare this to Discovery, which introduced an explicitly trans Trill (Gray Tal) and did little with his character, instead focusing on the nonbinary character Adira Tal.

They’re Here, They’re (Secretly) Queer

While it was tough to pull off in the Rick Berman era of Star Trek, Deep Space Nine even managed to squeeze in some bisexual characters in the form of Bashir and Garak. When Andrew Robinson read about Garak introducing himself to Bashir, he decided the Cardassian had a sexual interest in the young doctor and acted very flirtatiously. This created a subtext that the characters were gay (or, as Robinson claimed, “omnisexual”), and Lower Decks even showed alternate universe versions of Garak and Bashir ending up together. 

For DS9 fans curious about these characters’ seemingly mutual attraction, their every interaction was filled with a delightful “will they, won’t they” energy. The queer coding of Bashir also added a frisson of tension to his friendship with Chief O’Brien (especially when, in “Extreme Measures,” Bashir suggests O’Brien likes him more than he likes his wife). Compare all of this sexual tension to NuTrek, which presented gay romance as stable-but-boring (like with Stamets and Culber in Discovery) or loudly one-dimensional (like with Jay-Den in Starfleet Academy).

When Kira agreed to have O’Brien and Keiko’s baby, Keiko pushed her husband to spend intimate time with Kira, including giving her massages. Eventually, O’Brien and Kira developed a mutual attraction that they agreed not to pursue because he’s a married man.

In retrospect, it really looks like Keiko wanted the three of them to become a throuple, and the modern fandom enjoys this (admittedly brief) acknowledgment of polyamory and the ways love and sex might be different in the future. Compare this to NuTrek, whose exclusive embrace of monogamy makes shows like Discovery and Starfleet Academy seem downright conservative. 

To Explore Strange New Speeches

These examples from Deep Space Nine underscore why modern Star Trek isn’t nearly as progressive as Alex Kurtzman and his supporters think it is. Remember when Spock said that “logic is the beginning of wisdom, not the end”? Well, the storytelling corollary to that is “diversity is the beginning of progress, not the end.” Just throwing someone other than a white, straight, male into a role doesn’t magically make a show progressive unless you use them to tell interesting stories exploring complex ideas.

Star Trek made waves by casting a Black man and a woman in leading roles decades ago, and those shows used those characters to explore questions of race and femininity while pushing back against negative cultural stereotypes. Discovery cast a Black woman in a lead role and made her alternate between crying and giving inspirational speeches. That’s just bad storytelling, and her combination of race and gender doesn’t retroactively make the storytelling any better.

Advertisement

Tokenism Disguised As Progressivism

Similarly, Discovery and Starfleet Academy prominently featured gay characters but gave them remarkably little to do as a couple. Discovery controversially killed Culber off (don’t worry, he got better after Paramount did the “kill your gays” trope) and focused very little on their relationship. Starfleet Academy focuses even less on Jay-Den’s romantic relationships outside of quick cut shots, instead just putting him in a skirt and calling it a day. It’s tokenism disguised as progressivism, which is offensive on the face of it and infinitely less rewarding than DS9’s more veiled (thanks, Berman) attempts at presenting queer relationships.

All these years later,  Deep Space Nine remains the gold standard of progressive Star Trek storytelling simply because it used its diverse characters to tell exciting stories that challenged the status quo. NuTrek wants credit for being progressive simply because it includes these characters, but these series fail to do anything interesting with them, instead telling bland stories that are mostly Trek in name only. Now that Paramount is moving forward and taking the franchise in a new direction, we can only hope they slingshot into the past and take their storytelling cues from DS9, the decades-old show more progressive than Alex Kurtzman could ever conceive of.


Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Entertainment

Summer House Alums and More

Published

on

Everything to Know About RHOSLC Alum Jen Shah's Legal Drama

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2025