Manchester City were the better team against Arsenal but still had to work to make that count on the scoresheet

18:44, 19 Apr 2026

Arsenal are desperately trying to end the Manchester City era of dominance in the Premier League. In the biggest game of the season, even an error wasn’t enough for them.

Gianluigi Donnarumma’s clanger had the potential to be the defining moment in a title race that has become more gripping than anybody imagined a few weeks ago. Moments after David Raya called for calm heads in the wake of Arsenal going a goal down at the Etihad inside 16 minutes, City’s No.1 lost his and his clearance was charged down by Kai Havertz straight into the City net.

There was an irony given all the conversation around Kepa Arrizabalaga and goalkeeping No.2s after the Carabao Cup final, but also a pattern for City’s season. All the forward steps they have taken towards the top of the Premier League table have not been enough for them to actually reach the summit before they have suffered another setback: nearly but not quite.

Click here to find out the latest Manchester City news in our daily newsletter

When Rayan Cherki danced his way through the Arsenal defence to score the opening goal of the game, it looked like City were once again the unstoppable force in April that barge all title contenders to one side. Then the Donnarumma error came seconds later and the whole stadium went into shock, Guardiola running back towards his seat in the dugout with his hands on his head to get a second look at the horror that had unfolded.

Arsenal, whose inclusion of Martin Odegaard in the XI was a surprise boost for them, were more aggressive and more attacking than their performances in recent weeks have been. In a first half littered with errors, City had the better of it but Arsenal were hardly spectators.

Then, as the game opened up and stretched in the second half, the visitors sensed their opportunity. Donnarumma saved well from Havertz, then moments later Eberechi Eze’s shot hit the inside of the left-hand post and spun past the other one and away from danger.

As the game ticked past an hour enter Donnarumma again, this time starting an attack with a positive throw forward for Nico O’Reilly. City’s matchwinner from the cup final sprung forward, exchanged passed with Jeremy Doku and then put the ball across the box where Erling Haaland held off Gabriel and lashed it into the bottom corner.

The Norwegian should have scored before then, but he was also putting in a monstrous shift against Gabriel and the Arsenal backline that referee Anthony Taylor was happy to let go unchecked. It wasn’t the worst strategy, although how Gabriel escaped a red card for throwing his head forward to Haaland’s was beyond anyone in the stadium with sense.

Haaland, like O’Reilly and Donnarumma, had his moment and made it count and a terrific rearguard effort kept out Arsenal for the rest of the game and seven long added minutes. Bernardo Silva and Rodri are unrivalled in these big games and Silva was straight to Donnarumma at full-time before celebrating with the South Stand in his first game since announcing he is leaving.

This afternoon was the high point for this new team as they overcame the pressure and the setbacks in the game, building on their Carabao Cup win to produce an even bigger victory. And in claiming a huge three points, they give more hope to the idea that their climax this season may come with more silverware.