Trump was asked about Harry’s comments after the Duke of Sussex made a surprise visit to Kyiv
Mikey Smith , Christopher Mallett and Ambarish Awale Trainee Trends, Showbiz and Lifestyle Writer
23:09, 23 Apr 2026
Donald Trump has responded after Prince Harry urged world leaders to do more to end the war in Ukraine, saying the Duke of Sussex does not speak for Britain.
The former US President was asked about Harry’s remarks after the royal made a surprise visit to Kyiv, where he praised Ukraine’s resistance to Russia and appealed for stronger international action.
Speaking to reporters, Trump first joked about the Duke and Duchess of Sussex before dismissing Harry’s political influence, Mirror reported.
Advertisement
He said: “How’s he doing? How’s his wife? Please give her my regards, OK?”
Trump then added: “I don’t know. I know one thing, Prince Harry is not speaking for the UK, that’s for sure. I think I’m speaking for the UK more than Prince Harry, that’s for sure. But thank him for his advice.”
Harry travelled to the Ukrainian capital this week in an unannounced visit, arriving by overnight train from Poland and reaching Kyiv’s central station at around 8am.
Advertisement
During an address in the city, the Duke spoke directly about the conflict and called for renewed efforts to bring it to an end. He praised the country’s resilience and described Ukraine’s defence as brave in the face of continued aggression.
Addressing Russian President Vladimir Putin, Harry said: “Years into this war, with immense losses and limited gains, it is increasingly clear that this path offers no victor only more loss.”
He continued: “President Putin, no nation benefits from the continued loss of life we are witnessing.”
Although he did not mention Trump by name, Harry also directed comments at the United States, referring to the responsibility of American leaders.
Advertisement
He said the US, now his adopted country, has a “singular role” in the conflict because America had pledged to support Ukraine’s sovereignty and borders when the country gave up its nuclear weapons.
He told the Trump administration: “This is a moment for American leadership – a moment for America to show that it can honour its international treaty obligations – not out of charity, but out of its enduring role in global security and strategic stability.”
The visit marked Harry’s third trip to Ukraine since Russia launched its full scale invasion in February 2022.
His arrival came shortly after reports of a Russian drone strike on a railway yard in the Zaporizhzhia region. According to Ukraine’s Deputy Prime Minister Oleksii Kuleba, a train driver was killed in the attack.
Advertisement
Harry was welcomed in Kyiv by Ramina Arseniy Yatsenyuk, executive director of the Open Ukraine Foundation, which organised the Kyiv Security Forum.
After stepping off the train, he spoke briefly to reporters and explained why he had returned.
He said: “It’s good to be back in Ukraine,” adding he wanted to remind people around the world what Ukraine is up against, and to support the those doing extraordinary work every hour of every day in incredibly tough conditions.
It is do or die for Tottenham in their battle to stay in the Premier League, and they have another must-win game on their hands this weekend when they take on Wolves.
Roberto De Zerbi still has not won a game since taking over from Igor Tudor in north London, and the Italian sees his side occupy the final place in the relegation zone with five matches to play.
Burnley were the second side to have their relegation confirmed after their midweek defeat by Manchester City, which saw Pep Guardiola’s side leapfrog Arsenal into top spot.
Rob Edwards’ Wolves were condemned to the drop after West Ham drew 0-0 with Crystal Palace last week.
Advertisement
Now, the Black Country club could help drag Spurs into the second tier with them, with the north Londoners two points adrift of safety.
Date, kick-off time and venue
Wolves vs Tottenhan is scheduled for a 3pm BST kick-off on Saturday, April 25 2026.
The match will take place at Molineux.
Advertisement
Where to watch Wolves vs Tottenham
TV channel: In the UK, the game will not be televised live as it lands during the 3pm Saturday blackout.
Free highlights: The Sky Sports app and YouTube channel will show highlights from 5.15pm with Match of the Day broadcasting on BBC One at 10.30pm BST.
Wolves vs Tottenham team news
Advertisement
Wolves have seven men out for this game.
Sam Johnstone, who had established himself as first-choice goalkeeper, is likely out for the season with a shoulder injury, while Jose Sa is also struggling with a shoulder problem of his own.
Should both be ruled out, it could mean that third-choice shot-stopper Daniel Bentley keeps his place after starting in the 3-0 loss at Leeds.
Matt Doherty could return after he missed the last two matches with a niggle, while midfielder Angel Gomes is touch and go with a toe injury.
Advertisement
Ladislav Krejci suffered whiplash at Leeds, and Enso Gonzalez is out for the remainder of the campaign with a knee problem.
Yerson Mosquera is suspended.
For Spurs, it is a case of same old, same old.
Cristian Romero is the biggest casualty, ruled out for the season with a knee injury that he suffered against Sunderland.
Advertisement
Goalkeeper Guglielmo Vicario remains sidelined with a hernia problem, while Wilson Odobert, Dejan Kulusevski, Mohammed Kudus and Ben Davies are all longer-term absentees.
James Maddison, who has recovered from an ACL injury that he suffered during pre-season, was on the substitutes’ bench for the 2-2 draw with Brighton, but he didn’t make it onto the pitch to complete his comeback.
Wolves vs Tottenham prediction
Spurs simply must win this game. There is no two ways about it.
Advertisement
They have not won in the Premier League since December, but they have to snap that rotten record if they are serious about staying in the top flight.
Wolves are wounded after their own relegation was confirmed, and they could be motivated knowing that Spurs could provide them with a huge away day in the second tier next term.
Wojciech Jankowski, a spokesman for the Lesko Forest District where the attack occurred, told Onet: “At this time of year, bears that have awakened from their winter sleep come to places like this, close to human homes, in search of food. This was an unexpected encounter for both the bear and the human.”
Officials requested Mandelson’s vetting details days after Independent revealed he failed
Cat Little, the most senior official in the Cabinet Office, told MPs on Thursday that detailswere requested on 15 September.
You can read the full story below:
Nicole Wootton-Cane24 April 2026 01:00
Advertisement
Comment: As his cabinet cracks, how does Keir Starmer carry on regardless?
At PMQs on Wednesday, Keir Starmer looked more assured than he has for some time – but there is something almost delusional in his upbeat demeanour, says John Rentoul.
Nicole Wootton-Cane24 April 2026 00:00
Advertisement
McSweeney says he ‘doesn’t recognise’ himself in pressure claims
Morgan McSweeney has denied claims he pressured civil servants into appointing Lord Peter Mandelson as US ambassador.
Sir Keir Starmer’s former chief of staff, widely regarded as a protege of Lord Mandelson, resigned in February over his part in the peer getting the coveted job.
Ahead of his appearance at the Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday, the political strategist reportedly told a security forum in Kyiv: “I find it strange reading about a character with the same name as mine sometimes.
“I don’t recognise that character,” he said, as first reported by The Times.
Advertisement
It comes after former Foreign Office chief Sir Olly Robbins said there was an “atmosphere of pressure” and “constant chasing” from within the private office about Lord Mandelson’s vetting.
Downing Street has already denied that civil servants were bullied or cajoled by Mr McSweeney.
Nicole Wootton-Cane24 April 2026 00:00
Advertisement
Labour risk being ‘stonked’ in London elections over Mandelson scandal, Sadiq Khan warns
In a stark warning to Sir Keir Starmer, the London mayor admitted Labour are having a tough time in the capital with Westminster scandal threatening the party’s foothold in London’s councils.
Describing the Mandelson crisis as “an omnishambles from start to finish”, Sir Sadiq said he was “really frustrated” that the scandal was making it harder to engage voters in the party’s local achievements.
Nicole Wootton-Cane23 April 2026 23:15
Advertisement
Morgan McSweeney denies pressuring civil servants
The prime minister’s former chief of staff has denied claims he pressured civil servants into appointing Lord Peter Mandelson as US ambassador.
Morgan McSweeney, who resigned in February over his role in appointing Lord Mandelson, is alleged to have told Sir Philip Barton, then permanent secretary at the Foreign Office, to “just f***ing approve” Mandelson’s appointment.
Speaking at a conference, The Times reports he said: “I find it strange reading about a character with the same name as mine sometimes. I don’t recognise that character.”
He said he resigned because he “took responsibility” for recommending Lord Mandelson for the role of ambassador.
Advertisement
Mr McSweeney will appear in front of the Foreign Affairs Committee next week.
Nicole Wootton-Cane23 April 2026 22:58
Watch: Starmer looks less like prime minister and more like lawyer desperately defending himself
Starmer looks less like prime minister and more like lawyer desperately defending himself
Nicole Wootton-Cane23 April 2026 22:00
Advertisement
Starmer made ‘biggest mistake of his life’ appointing Mandelson – Red Wall chair
Sir Keir Starmer made the “biggest mistake of his life” by appointing Lord Peter Mandelson as British ambassador to the US, the leader of a prominent group of backbenchers has said.
Jo White, who chairs the Red Wall group of Labour MPs, said the government must “cleanse” itself of the problems that have emerged from the vetting scandal.
Amid reports of a split in his cabinet, the prime minister has accused his opponents of making politically motivated allegations.
Advertisement
Asked if she agreed with calls for Sir Keir to quit, Ms White told GB News: “Obviously I’ve heard these conversations at the side lines.
“I’ve been out and about in my constituency, speaking to local residents, and nobody has said to me they think it’s time for Keir Starmer to go.
“They obviously expressed concerns about exactly what’s happened and the way where we are now.
“But people have said to me, there’s a big job of work to be done, and their focus is on sorting out the cost-of-living crisis, and I met with the Red Wall group with Sir Keir yesterday, and our discussion wasn’t about Peter Mandelson.
Advertisement
“Our focus was on re-building industry and growth in our constituencies.”
She added: “He’s made the biggest mistake of his life.
“He’s admitted that, and I think that the biggest thing he has to do is re-iterate his commitment to clean up our politics, because we can only re-build trust if we cleanse ourselves of the problems.”
Nicole Wootton-Cane23 April 2026 21:42
Advertisement
‘He’ll be toast by August’: Readers on Starmer’s precarious position after Mandelson scandal
Our community sees Keir Starmer’s position as increasingly fragile, with many arguing he is clinging on to power amid mounting doubts over his leadership, authority and electoral prospects.
You can explore our community’s thoughts below:
Nicole Wootton-Cane23 April 2026 21:00
Advertisement
Recap: Starmer could face sleaze inquiry, The Independent understands
The prime minister could face a parliamentary inquiry over the Lord Peter Mandelson scandal, it has been reported.
The Independent understands Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch is urging the Speaker of the Commons to refer Sir Keir Starmer to the privileges committee over concerns he misled MPs over the vetting process.
Any move would be subject to a vote by all MPs.
Advertisement
Nicole Wootton-Cane23 April 2026 20:30
Ex-Labour MP calls PM’s decision to sack Robbins the ‘biggest act of political self-harm’
A former Labour MP has blasted the sacking of Sir Olly Robbins as the “biggest act of political self-harm anyone ever saw” as he joined calls for the prime minister to face the privileges committee over the Mandelson vetting scandal.
Karl Turner, who had the Labour whip removed last month, told Sky News he is “not suggesting the prime minister has deliberately misled parliament” but added “integrity is important”.
Advertisement
He said he doesn’t want the PM to resign, but instead “improve and get a grip of things”.
Karl Turner is the MP for Kingston upon Hull East (Chris McAndrew/UK Parliament/PA) (PA Media)
Northumbrian Water said this follows one of the driest years on record and comes thanks to its “careful management” in 2025.
Despite prolonged dry weather, the region avoided the water restrictions and drought measures that affected other parts of the UK.
Kieran Ingram, water director at Northumbrian Water, said: “Given the challenges we faced last year, and how hard our operational teams have worked to recover, we’re in a strong position now we’re in spring.
Advertisement
“We’re fortunate to have fantastic teams made up of industry experts, doing everything they can throughout the year to carefully manage our supplies.
“And while we do everything that we can, we need our customers to help us by doing the same.”
Reservoir recovery has been aided by winter rainfall, which naturally replenishes stocks through run-off and river abstraction.
However, the volume of water that can be drawn from rivers is limited to protect wildlife and maintain environmental quality.
Advertisement
Northumbrian Water continues to urge customers to use water wisely, highlighting that demand significantly influences reservoir levels.
The highest demand day in March saw 716 million litres used across the North East.
Mr Ingram said: “From finding and fixing leaks quickly to prioritising essential work on our networks, we’re doing everything to maximise how much we can refill the reservoirs.
“But we all have a part to play.
Advertisement
“Small changes, like turning off the tap while brushing your teeth, can make a real difference to the levels of demand on our water network and keeps water in the environment where it belongs.”
The company has already repaired 2,711 leaks in the first three months of 2025 and is investing £50 million in network improvements between 2025 and 2030.
Northumbrian Water also reminds the public that domestic leaks can have a significant impact – one leaky toilet can waste 78,500 litres per year, equivalent to 52,300 kettle boils.
Other advice includes spending one minute less in the shower, which can save up to 40 glasses of water each time.
Advertisement
To keep customers informed, the company has launched a monthly infographic on its website showing rainfall, reservoir levels, leakage rates and demand figures.
Additional water-saving tips and details about current reservoir storage are also available online.
Now looking ahead to 2026, the teams are preparing for a similar test of their skills and are not going to rest.
The company also encourages customers to report visible leaks to help reduce water wastage further.
The burnt Basque cheesecake has become a global phenomenon, but this homemade cheesecake is surprisingly easy to make with a simple recipe that takes less than 15 minutes to prep
Whenever my family and I are on our travels, amongst the initial spots we seek out is a quality neighbourhood bakery or patisserie. It’s an excellent method to familiarise ourselves with the locale, and my husband invariably chooses a San Sebastian or Burnt Basque cheesecake.
Advertisement
This velvety, decadent cheesecake has swiftly established itself as a fixture in cake establishments throughout the UK, and indeed globally, despite its modest beginnings in a small bar in Spain. The delectable dessert originated in the 1980s in San Sebastian, a coastal city in the Basque region of Spain, and from that point, its fame has expanded, particularly with the emergence of social media during the 2010s.
Today, you can anticipate finding this luxurious sweet on restaurant menus everywhere, yet it wasn’t until recently that I prepared it at home and discovered just how straightforward it was to produce a spectacular creation that would wow the entire household.
I initially prepared this dessert for Easter as it’s frequently accompanied by chocolate sauce, and it proved immensely popular, with numerous people returning for additional helpings, notwithstanding its richness.
However, I prepared it once more not long ago, to earn favour with my husband. All that’s required is combining all the components in a bowl and blending, then after it’s placed in a cake tin with baking parchment, it’s prepared for cooking, reports the Mirror.
The most challenging aspect is determining the right moment to remove it from the oven and subsequently allowing it to firm up for no less than six hours, ideally through the night. Yet it’s absolutely worth the patience.
To achieve as much authenticity as possible, I followed the straightforward recipe on Spanish Sabores, a website dedicated to making numerous Spanish classics simple and accessible to recreate at home.
How to make a perfect Burnt Basque Cheesecake
Ingredients:
Advertisement
1kg of soft cheese
Seven eggs
400g of sugar
One tbsp of flour
200ml of double cream
Method:
Preheat your oven to 210°C or Gas Mark 7.
After measuring out your ingredients, combine them in a bowl and mix until smooth.
Line a cake tin with baking paper, then pour in the mixture and place on the middle shelf of the oven.
Advertisement
Baking time can reach up to 45 minutes, but begin checking after 30 minutes have elapsed, then every five minutes thereafter. The key is to “burn” the top of the cheesecake while maintaining a slight “wobble” in the centre.
Once you’ve browned the top to your liking, remove it from the oven and allow to cool before refrigerating to set for a minimum of six hours, though overnight is preferable.
When set, slice and serve. This style of cheesecake is often accompanied by a chocolate sauce, though you can equally savour the rich, creamy flavours on their own.
Europa Oil & Gas’ proposal to install a 125ft (38m) rig in the village of Burniston, close to the North York Moors National Park, has been recommended for approval by North Yorkshire Council despite more than 1,600 local objections.
Residents will organise a lobby ahead of the planning meeting outside Scarborough Town Hall at midday on Friday, more than a year after full plans were submitted and months after a previously scheduled meeting was postponed.
The proposed wellsite, which is located 350 metres to the east of the village of Burniston, 700 metres southwest of the coastline, and 800 metres south of the North York Moors National Park boundary, were first announced in 2024.
Advertisement
Europa’s plans would employ a proppant squeeze method to extract the gas – a technique which has been likened to “small scale fracking” and which is allowed under current legislation.
The planning application has attracted more than 1,600 objections from local residents, local MP Alison Hume, parish councils including Burniston, Cloughton, Newby & Scalby and Scarborough Town Councils, and Friends of the Earth, among others.
Professor Chris Garforth, of Frack Free Coastal Communities, said: “Councillors have a clear choice: reject this reckless scheme – or ignore the voices of the more than 1,600 objectors who refuse to let our community become a testing ground for the serious risks to health, homes, environment and climate that fracking brings.”
He added: “We’ve had to formally complain about systemic failures in how the council has handled this application. Their response has been inadequate, so we’re now escalating to stage two of the council’s complaints procedure. A ‘yes’ vote based on a fundamentally flawed process would be unsafe and indefensible. This only strengthens our call for councillors to reject this application.”
Advertisement
A spokesperson for Europa said: “The proposed development in terms of planning is very straightforward. The development is temporary in nature and is for a single appraisal well to test a gas accumulation, something which has been delivered safely and in an environmentally sound manner many times historically in the UK.
“The planning application has been put forward for approval by the council’s officers following a thorough analysis of the application by specialist officers to ensure that it fully complies with the strict regulations that govern these activities in the UK.”
Speaking to the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS), the spokesperson also claimed that Frack Free Coastal Communities continues to “mislead councillors when raising concerns with respect to elements of the operational procedures associated with the project, such as the proposed proppant squeeze, which is highly regulated but falls outside of the planning process and will be dealt with under national regulations and authorities”.
Earlier this month, Friends of the Earth published new research from leading geologist Professor Stuart Haszeldine of the University of Edinburgh, which warned that the evidence from analysis of the seismic activity triggered by Cuadrilla’s fracking at Preston New Road in Lancashire in 2019 and from Preese Hall in 2011, “shows that earthquakes from high-volume fracking and low-volume fracking are ‘equally large and equally unpredictable’”.
Advertisement
Friends of the Earth campaigner, Tony Bosworth said: “The government has rightly committed to banning fracking for good. It blights our countryside, won’t lower UK energy bills, and is deeply unpopular.
“With significant parts of England already covered by oil and gas licences, the UK government must reassure communities by banning all forms of hydraulic fracturing for fossil fuels.”
Europa has previously said the scheme would be positive for the local economy and “no-one is going to notice” its presence.
Hope Day is in Year 8 at The Mount School in Dalton Terrace, which counts Oscar winning actress Dame Judi Dench among its former pupils.
And she is helping the charity Made By Dyslexia launch a new campaign that aims to transform what millions of children and parents find when they search “What is dyslexia?” online.
At the heart of the campaign is a new star-studded animation called What is Dyslexia? designed to bring a more balanced, strengths-based understanding of dyslexia to the top of search results.
Recommended reading:
Advertisement
13-year-old Hope, who recently she took on the role of Annie in York Light Opera’s rendition of the musical voices the main character, Lola, in the film which also features the voices of Jeremy Irons, Liv Tyler and Jaalen Best.
Hope Day took on the title role in York Light Opera’s rendition of Annie Image: Matthew Kitchen
Hope discovered she is dyslexic when she was seven years old – following this she discovered Made By Dyslexia and learnt that her dyslexia means she is really creative, this then fuelled her passion for acting.
She said she wanted to be part of this film to help other children see that being dyslexic gives you brilliant strengths.
“There is so much online that makes dyslexic children and young people feel like there is something wrong with them. When I was younger, I discovered Made By Dyslexia and it helped me find what I am really good at,” said Hope.
Advertisement
“I realised my creativity and passion for singing and dancing is thanks to my Dyslexic Thinking. I wanted to be part of this film to help other children see that being dyslexic gives you brilliant strengths.”
Hope during the recording (Image: Supplied)
Hollywood actor Jeremy Irons, the voice of the wise inventor said: “Coming from a family of creative dyslexics, I know just how important it is that we ensure all dyslexic children understand their extraordinary strengths. Throughout history, dyslexics have played a role in many of the world’s most significant innovations, from the light bulb to the motor car.
“I am so proud to be involved in this wonderful project and hope that everyone will support us in watching, sharing and reviewing the film, so that each year, millions of children and parents will find it at the top of their searches.”
Jeremy Irons (Image: Mike Fordham)
Kate Griggs, executive producer of the film and founder of Made By Dyslexia, said: “Every year millions of children search online to understand what dyslexia means for their future, but what they find is often framed around difficulty. When that is the first story a young person hears about their mind, it can damage confidence before they understand their strengths.
Advertisement
“This campaign is about changing that first impression. As a dyslexic, parent of dyslexic children, and the founder of Made By Dyslexia, I know how vital this is. By bringing a more balanced and empowering understanding of dyslexia to the top of search, we can help young people see confidence, capability and their bright futures.”
Hope with charity founder, Kate Griggs (Image: Supplied)
The film and campaign launches today (Friday, April24) followed by a premiere at the UK’s biggest cinema screen the BFI IMAX in London on Saturday, April 25.
You can now watch the film at www.whatisdyslexia.org. Every comment, share and review helps towards ensuring the film reaches the top of search right across the world.
Hope is a pupil at The Mount School in York (Image: Supplied)
Ryan King, 31, carried out sexual offences against the children in Glasgow and Renfrewshire between October and November, 2025
King pled guilty and was sentenced to three years and nine months in prison at Paisley Sheriff Court today, Thursday, April 23, for carrying out sexual offences against children in Renfrewshire and Glasgow.
Detective Inspector David Hardie blasted the ‘depraved’ pervert.
He said: “King gave no thought to his victims, just using them for his sexual gratification. “Our thoughts remain with his victims and I hope this sentencing brings them some comfort as he faces the consequences of his depraved actions. “Police Scotland will fully investigate all reports of sexual crimes and abuse. I’d encourage anyone with concerns about this type of criminality to contact officers so we can carry out an investigation.”
Advertisement
Get more Daily Record exclusives by signing up for free to Google’s preferred sources. Click HERE.
The Baton Rouge Louisiana mall incident erupted after two groups argued at a food court, police said. At least one suspect is still being sought
Lauran O’Toole, Peter Hennessy UK & World News Editor and Alice Scarsi
00:20, 24 Apr 2026
One person has been killed and at least five others wounded following a horrific shooting at a Louisiana shopping centre on Thursday. The incident is thought to have started after two groups became involved in an argument at a food court, according to police.
Police Chief TJ Morse said five people were in custody and there was no ongoing threat to the public.
Advertisement
The incident occurred at approximately 1.22pm local time, city police said. Earlier reports indicated at least 10 people were left injured, with two thought to be in a critical condition. Baton Rouge Police Chief Thomas Morse Jr said surveillance footage suggested “two groups of people got into an argument inside the food court and started shooting at each other”.
“Unfortunately, there were some innocent people that were in the area that might have also caught some rounds”, he added.
The shooting does not appear to be a random act of violence, “but a very targeted kind of disagreement between two groups of people,” Morse said.
The gunfire sent terrified shoppers fleeing and diving for cover in shops and changing rooms at Louisiana’s largest mall as people warned others to “take cover” and “get down,” witnesses say.
Advertisement
The FBI and Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives attended the scene alongside police officers. Photographs circulated online revealed a significant police presence at the shopping centre. One man stated that he and his wife were thankful for the swift response from the emergency services.
“I am aware of the active shooter scene at the Mall of Louisiana,” said Gov. Jeff Landry. “I am in coordination with law enforcement and we will update as we know more. Please avoid the area.”
Officers confirmed that some of the victims are undergoing surgery, according to the Emergency Medical Services (EMS).
Advertisement
Sid Edwards, Mayor-President of East Baton Rouge Parish, said: “I’m on scene at the mall. We have set up a command post. There has been a shooting with multiple victims. All civilians have been safely escorted out of the mall. Please keep the victims and their families in your prayers.”
Five individuals were arrested in connection with the shooting, police confirmed in the hours following the incident.
Ministers have been urged to do more to protect the public after data from 500,000 people who volunteered their health information to the UK Biobank was breached and offered for sale online in China.
Information of all half a million members had been listed for sale on the website Alibaba, said science minister Ian Murray, as he called the incident an “unacceptable abuse” of data.
Mr Muarry told the Commons on Thursday that the charity had informed the government about the data breach on Monday, and said the information did not include names, addresses or contact details.
But Dame Chi Onwurah, the Labour chair of the science, innovation and technology committee, said it was “another blow to public confidence”, adding that it showed “little progress had been made” in protecting public data after she said she was given assurance by Mr Murray in February that standards of public sector information security and data hygiene would improve.
Advertisement
She said: “[The] statement, however, demonstrates just how little progress has been made. It raises serious questions about whether lessons have been learned from repeated data breaches and leaks, and whether robust data management practices are being enforced at publicly funded bodies.
“Public trust in the handling of sensitive data is handled is key to the government’s digital transformation ambitions. This is another blow to public confidence.”
The Biobank is the world’s most comprehensive dataset of biological, health and lifestyle information. It has been used to achieve improvements in the detection and treatment of dementia, cancers and Parkinson’s.
The data was offered for sale on Alibaba’s ecommerce platforms (AFP/Getty)
Mr Murray told MPs: “Biobank told us that three listings that appear to sell … Biobank participation data had been identified. At least one of these three datasets appeared to contain data from all 500,000 UK Biobank volunteers.
“Additional listings offer support for applying for legitimate access to UK Biobank or analytical support for researchers who already have access to the data.”
Advertisement
“The government has spoken to the vendor today, and they did not believe that there were any purchases from the three listings before they were taken down,” Mr Murray added.
The UK Biobank was established to advance medical research and scientists from across the world can use its data – with the personal information removed – for studies that are deemed in the public interest.
All of the participants were aged between 40 and 69 years old when they joined the study between 2006 and 2010. Their data is used to track their long-term health and help researchers to understand, prevent and treat serious illnesses.
UK Biobank has referred itself to the Information Commissioner’s Office following the breach, said Mr Murray, who said the data involved in the breach could include gender, age, month and year of birth, socioeconomic status, lifestyle habits, and measures from biological samples.
Advertisement
He said he could not give a complete guarantee that nobody could be identified, but said it would likely only be done so through a “very advanced way”.
Blood samples taken from volunteers, ready to be stored in the UK Biobank (Getty)
In a statement, he told the Commons: “Once the government was made aware of the situation, we took immediate action to protect participants’ data. Firstly, we worked with Biobank, the Chinese government and the vendor, to ensure that those three listings – that UK Biobank informed us (of), including participant data – had been removed.
“I want to thank the Chinese government for the seriousness with which they work with us to help remove these listings.
“Secondly, we ensured that the Biobank charity revoked access to three research institutions identified as the source of that information.
“And thirdly, we have asked that the Biobank charity pause further access to its data until they put in place a technical solution to prevent data from its current platform from being downloaded in this way again. I can confirm to the House that this pause is now in place.”
Advertisement
In a statement published on Thursday, Professor Sir Rory Collins, chief executive and principal investigator of UK Biobank, told those in the study: “We would like to inform you about an incident involving UK Biobank data.
“We apologise to our participants for the concern this will cause, and we hope to provide reassurance by outlining the serious actions we are taking in response.
“Your personally identifying information in UK Biobank is safe and secure.
“Listings offering access to UK Biobank data (which did not contain any personally identifying information) were found on a Chinese consumer website. These listings were swiftly removed before any purchases were made.
Advertisement
“We are putting in place additional security measures to prevent this happening again. We will conduct a comprehensive investigation into this incident.
“Since UK Biobank started to make your de-identified data available for research in 2012, it has led to thousands of discoveries that are already leading to improvements in the prevention and treatment of many different diseases.”
Professor Elena Simperl, Department of Informatics at King’s College London, said: “The recent UK Biobank data exposure is not a moment to point fingers, but to take seriously what it tells us about national data infrastructure. Initiatives like UK Biobank are absolutely essential to driving innovation across the health and life sciences ecosystem.
“With longitudinal data on half a million volunteers and more than 18,000 peer-reviewed papers to its name, the UK is world-leading in this space, and rightly proud of it.
Advertisement
“What happened here was an infrastructure problem, not the result of a complex cyber attack. Too often, the costs of maintaining infrastructure for flagship data stewardship projects like this are treated as an afterthought. The UK has built something remarkable, but we need to keep investing in keeping it safe.”
You must be logged in to post a comment Login