JJ Gabriel should have become Man Utd’s youngest-ever player this week, but instead, he might be approaching the end of his Old Trafford career.
This should have been the week when JJ Gabriel etched his name into the Manchester United history books. A debut against Brighton on Wednesday would have made him the first 15-year-old to ever play for the club.
Instead, it is the week when his future at Old Trafford appears to have reached the point of no return, no matter how much United insist they still believe the situation can be rectified. The question should be how badly they actually want to fix it.
United sources are bemused by what has prompted Gabriel to issue a formal notification that he wants to leave the club. It is a big enough issue to cause him to refuse to train with the first team this week, effectively ruling himself out of that Brighton game.
Amateur sleuths can probably suss out what is going on here. Gabriel scored a hat-trick on his UEFA Youth League debut against Sabah on Thursday, but then promptly deleted a raft of posts on Instagram and removed all mention of United from his social media channels.
A few hours after that game at Leigh Sports Village, Michael Carrick handed Champions League debuts to 19-year-olds Harry Amass and Shea Lacey. Another 19-year-old, Tyler Fletcher, was on the bench.
Gabriel was ineligible for that fixture because he wasn’t on United’s ‘A’ list when they submitted their squad to UEFA and because he isn’t yet 16, he couldn’t be added to the ‘B’ list.
He will be old enough to be on the B list when United head to Madrid to face Atletico next month, and a Champions League debut was always more likely once the legwork had been done in securing qualification to the next round.
It now looks pretty clear that wasn’t enough for Gabriel, or for his father Joe O’Cearuill, a voiceforous supporter of his son on social media and a major influence on his career. The former Republic of Ireland international has never shied away from trumpeting just how good he believes his son can be.
He has regularly posted videos of his goals on X and clips from behind-closed-doors training sessions and games and industry sources claim he can be difficult to deal with. He has previously denied talking to other clubs about a move for his son.
Rather than taking a debut in the Carabao Cup, Gabriel is ready to toss it all away at United, just as he considered doing barely a year ago when he came close to joining Manchester City. He has also accepted invites to Barcelona and has met first-team players at the Nou Camp. His commitment to United can certainly be questioned.
Could United have done more? Director of football Jason Wilcox intervened in 2025 to keep Gabriel at the club, and he has regularly trained with the first team since then. He met Ruben Amorim, has been backed by Michael Carrick, given regular exposure to the seniors at Carrington and told the pathway is there.
It’s interesting to look back at Gabriel’s hat-trick at Leigh Sports Village last Thursday now. He celebrates enthusiastically, thanks teammates for assists and doesn’t look like a player who has thrown his toys out of the pram because he isn’t involved in the first-team.
That fits with the view of many around Carrington, who talk of him as a polite individual and someone who has fitted in well with the senior squad. The sight of Benjamin Sesko giving him a headlock on the way out to training recently was evidence of that.
You could argue United should have found room on their 12-man bench for Gabriel against Sabah last week, but depending on how the game went, there was never any guarantee he would get on. It’s easier to make the case that 90 minutes against different opposition in the UEFA Youth League was a good tune-up for a debut against Brighton, especially as the Under-21s didn’t have a game at the weekend.
The comparisons with Max Dowman are also relevant. He was 15 when he made his Champions League debut for Arsenal, and comparisons between the two players’ progress aren’t unwarranted, given that both are generational talents. Gabriel might believe that if Dowman was ready, then so was he.
If United have erred with Gabriel, then perhaps it came in pre-season. There was an expectation he would make a mark this summer, but he played just eight minutes against Atletico Madrid in Stockholm. That lack of exposure was a surprise.
But this was always likely to be the season when the prodigiously talented teen made his first-team debut, and that was on the cards this week. You wonder whether Gabriel will one day regret the fact that the opportunity might well pass him by.
Maybe United will find a way to soothe relations with the Gabriel family before the season ends. Perhaps he could yet play for the first team this season. He is clearly good enough to leave his mark.
But the history of Gabriel at United would suggest that even if that happens, another drama could be lurking around the corner.
FOLLOW OUR MAN UNITED FB PAGE! Latest news and analysis via the MEN’s Manchester United Facebook page
You must be logged in to post a comment Login