Entertainment
All 12 Stephen King Story Collections, Ranked
You could stick to Stephen King’s novels and get almost everything he has to offer as a writer, sure, but you’d still be missing out if you didn’t also take the time to read some of his short fiction. Those novels are legendary, and some of his very best ones are memorably long (oh hey, IT and The Stand), so it’s worth stressing that King can also do some pretty great stuff when tackling stories of a less paper-intensive nature.
There are, to date, 12 main/official collections of Stephen King short fiction, and they’re all ranked below. Maybe some won’t like the idea of having the novella-heavy collections compared to the collections of King’s that are more made up of short stories, but if something is made up of mostly one, or the other, or there’s a mix of both, then it’s going to be here. With these collections, you do ultimately get some of the author’s best works, and then a few stories that also showcase him at his most flawed, plus everything in between, of course.
12
‘Just After Sunset’ (2008)
If you’re a fan of Stephen King’s, you might be aware that he had a somewhat divisive run of novels throughout the mid-2000s (namely, The Colorado Kid, to Cell, to Lisey’s Story, and then Blaze). Throw in the final Dark Tower book as well, if you want, for its divisive ending, and maybe Duma Key, which does have some fans, but also feels a bit too familiar, even by King’s standards, where repurposed/reused concepts feel, to some extent, forgivable.
In this period, you also have Just After Sunset, which is the least impressive of his short story collections. Things range from forgettable at best to pretty clunky at worst, with the novella N. being perhaps the closest thing to a highlight (and even then, it’s not really amazing or anything).
11
‘Full Dark No Stars’ (2010)
A slightly better collection of novellas than Just After Sunset was a collection of short stories, but not by much, Full Dark, No Stars suffers from some of the same problems, even if all the novellas here have premises that, to some extent, sound promising. “1922,” for instance, starts pretty well, but doesn’t maintain momentum from start to finish the way you might hope a psychological horror/crime novella by Stephen King would.
“Big Driver” is kind of forgettable, but the third (and unfortunately shortest) novella of the bunch, “Fair Extension,” is pretty fun.
At least it sustains things better than “A Good Marriage,” which feels drawn out in the tradition of Gerald’s Game (and has some thematic links), so it’s admirably ambitious, albeit a little disappointing. “Big Driver” is kind of forgettable, but the third (and unfortunately shortest) novella of the bunch, “Fair Extension,” is pretty fun, and feels the closest to vintage King, being kind of nasty and intriguing in all the right ways… it’s just a shame it’s so short, compared to the other stories here.
10
‘The Bazaar of Bad Dreams’ (2015)
Things actually start getting a little better from here, because it’s hard to call The Bazaar of Bad Dreams bad, and so naturally, it’s even harder to call the collections that’ll be mentioned after this bad, too. The biggest “sin” this one commits is being mostly forgettable, as a collection of short stories with a handful of novellas thrown in for good measure.
The closest thing here to a bad selection is probably “Blockade Billy,” though that one could be kind of engaging if you’re a baseball fan (King himself undeniably is, that’s for sure). “Mile 81,” on the other side of things quality-wise, is quite good, and a better story about a weird/spooky car that’s probably not really a car than From a Buick 8, and maybe even Christine, though the latter is iconic, and came from King’s most celebrated period.
9
‘Hearts in Atlantis’ (1999)
The ambition of Hearts in Atlantis goes a fair way in making it a worthwhile read, if you’re a big Stephen King fan, but it’s certainly not a flawlessly done work throughout. That ambition is what keeps it interesting, though, since this almost defies being categorized as a novella or short story collection, seeing as the five stories here play out chronologically, and have some real ties thematically, not to mention featuring a few recurring characters throughout.
Things keep tying back to the Vietnam War, especially after “Low Men in Yellow Coats,” with that first story (and the best in the overall collection) being, overall, a bit more of a coming-of-age sort of thing. There is a sense of diminishing returns from each story there onward, but at least those lesser stories aren’t as long as the highlight here, which is especially a highlight if you’re a fan of King’s Dark Tower series (which makes it frustrating that the movie version of Hearts in Atlantis, which mostly sticks to adapting “Low Men in Yellow Coats,” leaves out most of the Dark Tower references).
8
‘You Like It Darker’ (2024)
The afterword of You Like It Darker kind of cheekily includes the words: “You like it darker? Fine, so do I,” which does imply a real return to horror after a decade or so where Stephen King’s novels often seemed to de-emphasize the elements of that genre, which he used to (well, still is) so well known for. Like, most of the Holly Gibney-related books (there are lots of them) weren’t too horror-focused, and neither was 11/22/63, nor whatever the hell Elevation was.
So, you see him call a book that, in 2024, and you get a bit excited, particularly if you’re a fan of Cujo and hear that one of the stories here is a sequel to that novel (still one of his most frightening works), but then You Like It Darker, in actuality, really isn’t that consistently dark or scary. At least the final three novellas included in the collection are quite good, redeeming things after some largely shaky short stories and the rather baffling “Danny Coughlin’s Bad Dream,” which some people do admittedly seem to like.
7
‘Nightmares & Dreamscapes’ (1993)
Nightmares & Dreamscapes is quite exhausting, seeing as there are 24 short stories here, and the page count – at least for the first edition – was over 800, making it the longest of all the collections here. Unsurprisingly, that also makes it his most chaotic and all-over-the-place in terms of quality. Here, you get the best of King, and the blurst of King.
Like, this might sound like a joke, but there’s a story here called “Head Down,” which is a non-fiction essay about King’s son, Owen, and his Little League baseball team, and it goes on for a surprisingly long time. It’s nice that Stephen King is so invested in it, and also interesting to read after Sleeping Beauties, which the two Kings wrote together, but “Head Down” is still probably something of a slog for anyone else to get through. At least you also get the likes of “Dolan’s Cadillac” and “The Moving Finger” here, plus some experimental stories that work a little better than “Head Down,” like “Sorry, Right Number” (a teleplay) and “The Doctor’s Case” (an instance of King doing a Sherlock Holmes story).
6
‘If It Bleeds’ (2020)
There’s a little horror to be found in If It Bleeds, but it’s also sort of in line with You Like It Darker in de-emphasizing the horror, to some extent, or at least by Stephen King standards. “If It Bleeds” is a Holly Gibney novella that works as a pretty solid thriller, while the final story, “Rat,” is probably the closest to the horror genre overall.
Okay, there is also the first story, “Mr. Harrigan’s Phone,” but that feels pretty heavy on coming-of-age elements, with horror being secondary, and then there’s the rather striking “The Life of Chuck” as the second of the four novellas here, which is more of an existentialist fantasy/drama story over anything else, and stands out thanks to its unique structure. Overall, If It Bleeds is a good collection. None of these stories are absolutely top-tier King, but none of them are bad, so it’s an overall more consistent batch of tales than all the previously mentioned collections.
5
‘Everything’s Eventual’ (2002)
Probably the most underrated collection of Stephen King’s, Everything’s Eventual compiles a bunch of short stories and novellas that King wrote (and originally had published in a variety of places) between 1994 and 2001. The most notable might well be “The Little Sisters of Eluria,” since it’s one of the longer stories here, and it also features Roland of Gilead, who’s the protagonist of The Dark Tower.
That novella’s not essential to understanding The Dark Tower, but it is a worthwhile story within that much broader and more expansive epic. And then the rest of what Everything’s Eventual has to offer is quite fun and surprisingly consistent, especially considering King’s previous short story collection – Nightmares & Dreamscapes – was so out of control in terms of quality/consistency.
4
‘Four Past Midnight’ (1990)
There is one undeniable standout, if you’re looking at King’s novella collections that contain precisely four stories, and that one standout will be gotten to in a bit, but the runner-up is Four Past Midnight. This is Stephen King’s longest novella collection, and is a good deal better than his longest short story collection, Nightmares & Dreamscapes, with at least one story here (“The Langoliers”) being longer than some Stephen King stories that are classified as novels (like Carrie and Rage).
Everything here is good, and some stretches of Four Past Midnight come pretty close to being great, with “The Library Policeman” being a potential highlight, since it really depends on what you’re willing to call a highlight. It’s the most confronting story here, and it comes close to being too much, but you do have to give it props for being equal to some of King’s much longer and more well-known works in terms of sheer horror offered.
3
‘Night Shift’ (1978)
Night Shift is the oldest of the official Stephen King collections, and it’s also notable for having just short stories throughout. It’s not a particularly long book, but there is a large number of individual pieces here… well, specifically, 20 all up. And almost all of them are really good, with a handful that are genuinely great, and anything that’s a bit less-than-amazing doesn’t matter too much, since no story here will really take up a great deal of your time.
It’s a breathless and easy-to-get-through read, and maybe the best book to present to someone if they ever accuse Stephen King of being too long-winded. There are also a surprisingly large number of short stories in Night Shift that were later made into movies, including – quite infamously – the largely unrelated The Lawnmower Man. That’s an interesting rabbit hole to disappear down, if you’ve got the time and want to see what King does when he really doesn’t approve of how a filmmaker handled his work.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login