Entertainment
HBO’s ‘Band of Brothers’ Has One Episode That’s Almost Impossible To Rewatch 24 Years Later
HBO’s Band of Brothers remains one of television’s most powerful war dramas, but one episode has only become harder to watch with time. Coming off Saving Private Ryan, Tom Hanks and Steven Spielberg reunited for a deeper, more intentional look at the men who fought across the Western Front during World War II. But out of all 10 episodes, the toughest to stomach isn’t an hour built around high-stakes battle sequences or personal turmoil. It’s the penultimate chapter, “Why We Fight,” a harrowing episode that confronts the ugliness of war, the horrors of the Holocaust, and the danger of looking away.
‘Band of Brothers’ “Why We Fight” Confronts a Horrible Truth
While every episode of Band of Brothers has its tough moments, the ninth episode arguably takes the cake as the most sobering chapter in the entire drama. Much of the episode follows the burnt-out Captain Lewis Nixon (Ron Livingston) as he wanders around occupied Nazi Germany looking for his favorite whiskey and reeling from the news that his wife is divorcing him. As the men struggle with the silence, they force themselves to keep up morale with a powerful rendition of “Blood on the Risers,” but that all changes when “Why We Fight” takes a dark turn over halfway through as the Allied soldiers discover the darkest truth of the war. When an Easy Company patrol stumbles upon the Kaufering concentration camp, the response is a melancholy mixture of shock, anger, and a brokenheartedness that had been building up since many of these men watched their buddies die in battle. It’s a brutal, senseless, and historically accurate display that reveals the true nature of the Nazis’ attempts to rule the world, showcasing the unspeakable horrors of the Holocaust.
Watching Easy Company tackle the war machine that was the Third Reich in the eight episodes leading up to this offered a bloody, violent, and seemingly senseless picture of 20th-century warfare that is quite difficult to watch on its own. And throughout the ninth chapter, many of the men have grown disillusioned with the war itself, with those who had been on the Western Front for years silencing the younger newcomers who are itching to see some action. In many respects, men like Nixon are wondering what this was all for, and we see this clearly when Private David Webster (Eion Bailey) yells at the surrendered (yet still proud) German forces as they march on by. “Dragging our asses halfway around the world, interrupting our lives. For what?!” he laments. The men of Easy Company are given more downtime to think than they had been offered throughout the entire war, and the weight of what they’ve done, what they’ve seen, begins to crush them in the process. But before they can fully despair, Webster’s question of why they had to fight is answered — and no one would be the same.
Upon arriving at the Kaufering concentration camp, Easy Company is met by walking human shells. Men who have been beaten, abused, tortured, and starved and are in dire need of medical attention have been left behind the locked gates of Kaufering IV, one of the many camps in the larger complex. Writer John Orloff and director David Frankel did their homework here, having reportedly recreated the vile conditions of the camp through historical photos and personal testimony of the men who liberated Nazi Germany in the first place. It’s in the last 20 minutes of the episode that Band of Brothers reminds the audience why everything Easy Company and the Allies did had to take place, shedding a powerful light on not just the actions of the Nazis themselves, but on the German people who deliberately chose to ignore what was going on just outside their own town. The citizens, who continually profess not to be Nazis, are forced to aid in the cleaning up of the camp, burying the bodies of the men they pretended didn’t exist. The episode ends with a title card that notes that, between 1942 and 1945, the Nazis killed over 6 million Jews and 5 million ethnic minorities — and that’s not including those put in the camps because they dissented by aiding those in dire need.
‘Band of Brothers’ Episode 9 Is Difficult To Get Through
With an incredible eye for detail and historical accuracy that only adds to the disturbing nature of Easy Company’s discovery, “Why We Fight” is an aptly titled hour that speaks to the very soul of the viewer. It’s certainly an episode that’s difficult to forget and even harder to make it through once the patrol makes it to the Kaufering camp. Later, Major Dick Winters (Damian Lewis) reveals that other Allied forces discovered other camps throughout Nazi Germany, many of which were far worse than what Easy Company (and the audience) experience here, complete with execution chambers and ovens meant to burn the bodies. “You’ve never seen anything like this, it’s complete shock that just stumps every feeling of emotion that you have,” the real-life Winters once explained in an interview decades later. “The horror of it, you could never imagine something like this before.”
‘Band of Brothers’ Fans Need This 4-Part War Drama Now That It’s Finally Streaming
Get ready for a different kind of war.
But it’s not just the visuals of “Why We Fight” that make it such a profound and pivotal chapter in not just Band of Brothers, but the war as a whole. It’s the way that the men respond to what they’ve encountered that truly breaks our hearts. Private Roy Cobb (Craig Heaney) is abruptly embraced by an elderly prisoner who just weeps in the soldier’s arms, and Winters is clearly at a loss for words the moment he walks in. But it’s Private Joseph Liebgott (Ross McCall) who is especially of note here, as he is called in to translate the moment Easy Company breaks into the death camp. McCall proves himself an expert at his craft here, forcing Liebgott to bury his own feelings about what he is hearing from the survivors in order to relay the truth to his superiors. As he does so, we can feel the aching in his voice as he stumbles through the explanation, hardly able to come to terms with what he’s seeing, let alone hearing.
In an interview with HBO Max’s official Band of Brothers podcast, McCall reveals that there was actually more footage cut out of the final episode. “In fact, there was a longer cut of this episode with about five more minutes in it, and it was all concentration camp stuff where they saw even more horrible things,” the actor recalled. “This was one of the very few times when [HBO] said, ‘You know, we love this episode, but it’s just one step too heavy.’”
The HBO Miniseries ‘Band of Brothers’ Remains at the Top of World War II Storytelling
There are few television productions that are as masterful as Band of Brothers. Although “Why We Fight” meditates on the very worst of humanity in the Nazi war machine and the German people who refused to stand against it, the miniseries also offers a challenging (if not at times conflicted) picture of the very best. “The Greatest Generation” overcame some of the most egregious horrors of their day, in all of modern history, and fought back against the forces that would have enslaved the whole world. Mixing in actual interviews with the very Easy Company men who served during World War II with dramatic interpretations of their exploits across war-torn Europe, Band of Brothers is a triumph of filmmaking that goes the extra mile far beyond what Saving Private Ryan could ever do — and that’s even including the D-Day sequence. It’s no wonder that Spielberg and Hanks were not finished with this period in not just American, but world history.
Armed with a powerful cast that shines masterfully in each episode, Band of Brothers is the war drama to end all war dramas. It’s a historical epic worth regularly revisiting so that we are reminded of what these brave men fought and died for. “Why We Fight” is a harrowing reminder that pure evil does exist in our world, and that standing against it may cost us everything. But it is far more honorable (and right) than standing idly by, remaining purposefully ignorant of the truth. It’s been two decades since Band of Brothers — still one of the greatest miniseries ever made — hit HBO viewers like a truck on the front lines of battle, and it still leaves a powerful dent.
Band of Brothers is available for streaming on HBO Max.
- Release Date
-
2001 – 2001
- Network
-
HBO
- Directors
-
David Frankel, David Nutter, Mikael Salomon, Phil Alden Robinson, Richard Loncraine, Tom Hanks
- Writers
-
Bruce C. McKenna, Graham Yost, John Orloff
-
-
Donnie Wahlberg
C. Carwood Lipton
Entertainment
Inside the “Next Gen NYC” premiere brunch ahead of 'chaotic' season 2
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/next-gen-nyc-1-061626-346e0278facd4d31894b95fc4e22255b.jpg)
“I call this my crash-out season.”
Entertainment
25 times “The Simpsons” predicted the future
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/The-Simpsons-061226-5-7af0d611d21446768aff554c6bfa2eb9.jpg)
The animated series has long had its finger on the pulse.
Entertainment
Rihanna Supports Summer House’s Ciara Amid West, Amanda Drama
Bravo superfan Rihanna is firmly on Team Ciara Miller.
The “Diamonds” singer, 38, shared a message of support for the Summer House star recently, encouraging Ciara to keep shining amid ex West Wilson’s controversial relationship with her former BFF, Amanda Batula.
Ciara, 30, was interviewed on the red carpet at the 2026 Las Culturistas Culture Awards in May by Bravo’s roving reporter, Chanel Ayan of The Real Housewives of Dubai fame, and Chanel, 48, surprised her by reading out a text message she received from Rihanna.
“She said, ‘Just let her know, stay vibrating in her beautiful frequency,’” Chanel read from her phone in a video shared by Bravo on Wednesday, June 17. “She said, ‘And give god thanks that he’s relieved her of people who don’t deserve an inch of her now chapter. It’s a reward season, baby girl.’”
“Oh, my god. I’m dead!” Ciara reacted to seeing Rihanna’s text message.
Ciara then continued to read out Rihanna’s inspiring words to her.
“Up and on. Now the petty bitch in me wants to say way more, but we’ll do that when I see her,” Rihanna said in the text message.
An excited Ciara told Chanel, “I’m obsessed with her. I listen to her. I mean, I was listening to her before I got ready for this.”
“I feel like we have so much to talk about, and I can’t wait to catch up with her,” Ciara continued, noting that she was hoping to “kiki” and “throw shots back” with Rihanna, Chanel and Summer House costar Mia Calabrese in the near future.
The Las Culturistas Culture Awards took place on May 30 in Los Angeles and aired on Bravo on Wednesday.
Ciara picked up the Allison Williams Cool Girl Award at the awards ceremony and alluded to the drama with West and Amanda in her acceptance speech.
“Thank you so much. If by ‘cool,’ you mean utterly disappointed in everyone around me, yes, I am so f***ing cool,” the former nurse said.
She added, “Obviously, this year has been a little rough, but you know what they say: the best revenge is winning the Allison Williams Cool Girl Award. And booking Love Island USA. And being in Shaboozey’s music video. And also being a registered nurse. And a model. So I’m gonna put this in the bathroom at my new house.”
In April, Ciara’s friend, Mia, 34, revealed on Watch What Happens Live With Andy Cohen that Rihanna quizzed her about the Summer House scandal during a night out in New York City.
“I love her. I love RiRi. And she loves me. I think she loves Ciara as well,” Mia said at the time. “Rihanna wanted all the tea. As soon as she saw me, she beelined for me, took her glasses off, and said, ‘We need to talk.’ I said, ‘Anything for you.’”
Entertainment
Jodie Comer Is Hollywood’s Ultimate Wild Card
A digital poster flips through upcoming titles, revealing a serious, meditative Jodie Comer in a blue, flowing, 17th-century style outfit in The Death of Robin Hood. The film, set to release June 19, is not your average folklore retelling, but instead follows the outlaw (played by Hugh Jackman) at the end of his life, coming to terms with his behavior and misguided deeds. Robin Hood is the draw of the film, but the secret weapon? The enigmatic healer named Sister Brigid, who is brilliantly brought to life by Comer.
Hallway chatter breaks the stillness, with an undeniable Scouse accent and laughter filling the air, ushering in a new energy to the sleek Manhattan lobby. “Hi, I’m Jodie!” the star beams as she puts her hand out for a shake. Though she has the unmistakable glow of an A-lister, the Emmy, Tony, and BAFTA winner is as genuine and down-to-earth as they come. She’s dialed into her environment, and she exudes gratitude for all the many moving parts and people that go into making her press day run as smoothly as possible. Her smile, authenticity, and calm confidence are contagious. Comer is the definition of class, and everyone should take notes.
‘The Death of Robin Hood’ Sparked Jodie Comer’s Contagious Curiosity
Comer and I sit at the end of a long table in the A24 library, where she excitedly offers me some of the muffin she was given at Live with Kelly and Mark, her first bit of press for The Death of Robin Hood. Her playful energy makes the conversation feel like we are two school friends picking up where we left off rather than meeting for the first time. “I got here yesterday, and it’s my first on-camera interview for the film, so it always feels like the first one is [where] you’re trying to figure out what your words are. They’re like, ‘Sum up the film,’ and you have two sentences to do so. How do you do that?”
The actress, who’s best known and beloved for her exceptional work as the charming assassin Villanelle in the critically-acclaimed series Killing Eve, is excited to talk about the film and her career. Written and directed by Michael Sarnoski, the movie is the definition of bleak, brutal, and bloody. The film, also starring Murray Bartlett, Noah Jupe, and Bill Skarsgård, more than earns its R rating, as it’s unafraid to lean into the literal and metaphorical darkness of Robin Hood’s world, and all the brutality that comes with it. With all of this in mind, it makes Comer’s response to my first question about her references for the film that much more unexpected. “I love Shrek, so my reference to Robin Hood is the Robin Hood song in there,” she says with a laugh, before adding, “Of course, growing up, there’s the ‘steals from the rich, gives to the needy’ loose framework or idea that you have of him. And I didn’t know much more, to be honest. So when I got Michael’s script, I just delved into that. I loved it because it felt like a much more human and tangible exploration.”
Comer perfectly captures the essence of the story with that brief description. Jackman’s take on the outlaw is not what you’d expect; his long-flowing white hair and eerily calm, Dirty Harry-like disposition put the audience both at ease and on the edge of their seat. “He was a man who’s lived and has lived in a very particular way and is having to reconcile with that life, which feels like you may not be able to relate to him on many, many levels, but also on a very base level. I think that’s something we all experience within our lives. So for me, I felt like I was really able to connect to him and the story.”
As the title implies, Robin Hood is at the end of his life, and that’s where Come comes in. The folkloric figureheads to a remote island — rather reluctantly — where he is to meet with Comer’s Sister Brigid, a woman with a mysterious and complicated backstory, as well as alleged “healing powers” that could aid the ailing outlaw. Comer’s a master of restraint and subtlety in her performances, which makes her the perfect choice for the part. “I loved her poise. She was an incredible observer and listener. I felt there’s a lot that she’s having to withhold. She’s holding a lot for everybody else, so she’s not always able to express her true feelings. I was fascinated… she references a lot of philosophy and mythology, and I was like, ‘Where does that come from?’”
There was something very unself-aware, and a real lack of vanity and a bluntness and a weirdness.
There’s a beautiful, childlike wonder to nearly every word that falls from Comer’s mouth. She gets lost — in the best way — in her answers, as if she’s processing her experiences and relationship to her character and the film in real time, for the first time. As Comer’s gears continue to turn in her head, she explains why she was so drawn to this character. “What I loved about it was that everyone on the island is presenting as something else, or they’re hiding something,” adding, “[Brigid] was taken in by a prioress. She couldn’t read or write. These are things that she’s learned through story, and then this role is bestowed upon her. So even that is her own contradiction, and there’s little glimpses where you’re able to see that within the film.”
So many of Comer’s characters across stage and screen tell stories that are deeply rooted in perspective, which she agrees is “so true,” and her work in The Death of Robin Hood is no exception. Right when you think you know the extent of Sister Brigid and Robin Hood’s relationship, the rug is pulled out, and the entire movie feels different. “I also love that there’s quite a big revelation in the film of who Robin is and actually the connection that he has to her own past, and how she’s able to transmute her own pain. She doesn’t meet violence with violence. She’s also at a point where she’s connected with this man on a different level. Then she finds out that news. So there’s just a lot that she has to deal with in that moment, and I feel like she had a tremendous amount of grace. Which made me question, ‘God, would I be able to find that within myself?’”
Given our relaxed vibe, I joke that her character also has a “great haircut,” something that is… not true. Brigid has a choppy, temple-length bowl cut. Comer, without hesitating, leans in to the bit. “I mean, that’s the real reason,” she laughs, as we continue to dissect the character. “I think Michael was like, ‘Should we shave your hair?’ And I was like, ‘Absolutely not, Michael!’ she says with a massive laugh. “We wanted it to feel like she’d [cut her hair] herself. There was something very unself-aware, and a real lack of vanity and a bluntness and a weirdness. There’s something childlike but also quite masculine, as opposed to a lot of depictions of that time. So it just felt off. There’s a lot about that island and the energy of it that is mysterious and weird.”
Comer’s fascination with this character didn’t end with the film, as she just recently took an herbalism course, something Brigid would certainly approve of. But when preparing for the role — which doubled as a way to connect with nature, something she was trying to do more of anyway — Comer did what she does with every project: walked into a bookstore. “When I start a job, I like to go into a bookstore and see what jumps out at me.” One of these books was Why Women Grow: Stories of Soil, Sisterhood and Survival by Alice Vincent, as well as Melissa Febos‘ The Dry Season: A Memoir of Pleasure in a Year Without Sex. “I thought, well, that’s quite interesting because that’ll definitely be something that [Brigid] is practicing. What does that activate within your life? When you’re not having that connection to sex or a distraction per se, what else in your life becomes more vivid and apparent?”
For Comer, reading about medieval healthcare was the anchor of her preparation. “At that time, the mind, body, and soul were still very much connected, and each of those components was just as integral as the next, and that made a lot of sense to me. She’s always telling him stories. She’s actually never really telling him what to do. She’s encouraging him through her sharing of what she knows. It’s like breadcrumbs, trying to bring Robin back to himself.”
Stephen Graham Saw Something in Jodie Comer Many Years Ago
Comer doesn’t come from a Hollywood family. Her mother worked for Merseyrail, and her father is a sports physiotherapist. “I was pretty fearless,” she says, thinking back on her childhood. “I was very vivacious. Always playing in the garden, picking up the frogs and the slugs,” the actress remembers fondly. “All my baby videos are me just constantly trying to be front and center. I watch them back, and I’m like, ‘Oh, this makes sense that I would want to do acting.’” Comer knows that she’s always been very sensitive, something that she now views as a “superpower” given her profession. “You’re constantly trying to put yourself in someone else’s shoes. You’re often reflecting on your own experiences and how they may mirror or how they differ.”
It was one of the earliest experiences on her acting journey that proved to be the most meaningful, even today. Back in 2012, Comer had a small role in the BBC One police procedural Good Cop. She didn’t necessarily think much of it, but her scene partner Stephen Graham — who’s most recently known for co-creating, writing, and starring in the Netflix phenomenon Adolescence — certainly did. Her few scenes in the episode were with him, and he was so taken by the innate talent that he gave her his contact info and encouraged her to reach out to him. Despite being a child who loved attention, Comer was quite hesitant to take him up on his offer. Thankfully, her father nudged her to reach out, and the young performer mustered up the courage to send him a text.
Her fears came true, albeit very briefly, when she didn’t hear back. “I just thought, ‘Okay, that was that,’” until everything changed in the blink of an eye, weeks later, when she needed it most. “I was on a train to London doing an audition for a pilot where I had to sing, I’d chosen an Adele song. Jesus Christ, talk about setting yourself up for a fail. I really didn’t want to go. I just was quite disheartened.” Then, as cliché as it sounds, one phone call changed everything. “I got a call from the Good Cop production company.” Graham, a man of his word, reached out and asked them if he could have her number. “He called me straight away, and he was like, ‘Where are ya?’ ‘I’m on the train to Liverpool, got this audition, don’t want to go.’” His exact words? “‘Fuck your audition off.’” Comer, who’s undoubtedly retold this story dozens of times by now, tells it with as much passion and thrill as though it were a secret she has been dying to tell someone. “‘Don’t go to your audition. You want to go meet my agent?’” It all feels almost too good to be true. “Divine intervention,” I say. Her eyes widen as she leans forward, agreeing. “Literally.”
Graham and Comer’s bond has only strengthened since then, with the pair teaming up for the 2021 film Help about the COVID pandemic and its impact on Sarah (Comer), a healthcare worker in Liverpool caring for Tony (Graham), who has early-onset Alzheimer’s. As if winning a BAFTA for her performance wasn’t enough, it was also the first project Comer executive-produced. “It was amazing to be a part of adapting the script and thinking about the cast, and just seeing how a piece like that forms and what goes into it.”
Comer’s been the star of several big-budget, high-profile films in the last few years, including a small role playing Rey’s mother in Star Wars: Episode I – The Rise of Skywalker. She then followed that up with Ridley Scott‘s The Last Duel with Ben Affleck and Matt Damon, in which she played 14th-century woman Marguerite, who accuses her husband’s friend of raping her. In the crime drama The Bikeriders, she transforms into Kathy, the uninhibited wife of brooding biker Benny (Austin Butler), and effortlessly pulls off a thick Chicago accent. Add to that the survival thriller The End We Start From and the post-apocalyptic horror 28 Years Later to the list, and her movie career has mostly featured emotionally heavy, extremely serious subject matter (except for the Ryan Reynolds sci-fi comedy Free Guy).
But this is all a sharp contrast to how Comer carries herself. Comer is thoughtful, introspective, and inquisitive, and that is rounded off by a relaxed, up-for-anything attitude. She’ll gleefully get into the minutia of a performance and the dedication of her craft, but she just as easily comes across as severely unfussy, someone you’d be happy to get a pint with at the pub while you spend the afternoon talking about astrology.
‘Prima Facie’ and the Power of Perspective
Every facet of Comer’s career is rather impressive and fearless, with her immense range evident in shows such as the E4 teen dramedy My Mad Fat Diary, where she plays Chloe, the pretty, popular best friend of main character with exceptional line delivery, Thirteen, a dark drama about a kidnap victim that proved Comer can easily lead a project, and Doctor Foster, the psychological thriller that sees her as “the other woman” in Gemma’s (Suranne Jones) marriage. But it’s her exceptional work in the play Prima Facie that is unsurpassed. Directed by Justin Martin (who most recently co-directed Stranger Things: The First Shadow) and written by Suzie Miller, the one-woman play follows Tessa (Comer), a bold barrister who defends men accused of sexual assault, only to have her entire perspective shift when she, herself, is sexually assaulted. Prima Facie, which was Comer’s explosive West End debut in 2022, was a critical success, earning Comer an Olivier Award and brightening the light on her extraordinary talents.
When it was announced that Prima Facie — which means “at first sight” in Latin — would be heading to Broadway, I was determined to secure tickets. At that time, Comer was riding the wave of the Killing Eve series finale (more on that later), and for many, it was hard to imagine her as anyone but Villanelle. It’s easy for actors to get typecast in a role, especially one tied to such a devoted fanbase, but when I saw Comer take the Golden Theatre stage, the assassin that a massive fandom had fallen in love with for four years was nowhere to be found. As Tessa, Comer speaks nonstop for an hour and 40 minutes with no intermission, and goes through a searing set of emotions, from unbridled confidence and dancing on a table to utter fear and hopelessness as her tears flow on the stage.
My director on the play said that film is a director’s medium, TV is a writer’s medium, and theatre is an actor’s medium.
After such a successful period on the West End, Comer could have easily ended her run on that high note, but when I ask her if she had any hesitations about going to Broadway, her pure love of the craft shines through. “Weirdly, no, because it was so personally rewarding. It’s exhausting, but it’s also invigorating, and you learn so much doing theatre. It demands a lot of you. You really need your full commitment, as does every job, but there is a complacency that can happen within TV and film because you know you’ve got another chance. It’s very sporadic; you’re jumping from the end of a story to the beginning to the middle, it’s very quick. With theatre, you get the luxury to live out a whole story every night, and you get the opportunity to do it again the next day. I just loved it.”
As a dauntless and intrepidly daring performer, Prima Facie was the perfect project for her. “I think there’s also part of me that chases that feeling of exhaustion. I do want to feel like I’ve explored something deeply or that I’ve had to work hard and challenge myself, and there’s also just the beauty of the immediacy of being in a theatre and feeling that connection with people and holding that space.”
Earlier in our conversation, when Comer mentioned executive-producing Help, we discussed how, as an actor, you can feel almost helpless — to an extent, depending on the project — when it comes to the final product. “You might play a scene that’s at the end of the film that emotionally is right for that moment, and then you can see something screened and they put it at the start. It can be jigsawed, it can change so drastically that you’re absolutely at the mercy of.”
This makes her time as Tessa that much more precious. “Justin Martin, my director on the play, said that film is a director’s medium, TV is a writer’s medium, and theatre is an actor’s medium. You can rehearse, come up with all the ways you feel like it’s right. The director also leaves after opening night, it’s crazy. At first, I was like, ‘What?!’ but then you get used to it. But once you go out on stage, it’s yours, and things happen that aren’t meant to happen, or you find something new that invigorates the latter part of the play, and you’re like, ‘Wow, that’s never happened before,’ but you’re more in control of that.” Comer, unsurprisingly, won the Tony for Prima Facie, before taking the production to Ireland and back to the UK, where she, in a very full-circle moment, ended her run in Liverpool, where she was born and raised, this past March.
Comer Says ‘Killing Eve’ Was a “Brilliant” Experience Built on Teamwork
The project Comer is perhaps best known for is Killing Eve, the BBC America spy thriller that follows Eve Polastri (Sandra Oh), an MI5 agent stuck in a bit of a rut, who becomes fixated on the assassin Villanelle (Comer) and is quickly consumed by her. No one knows much of anything about the elusive killer, but Eve is determined to learn everything, even risking her life and the lives of the ones she loves to do so. The fanbase for the series, which is based on Luke Jennings‘ Codename Villanelle novellas, grew (and grew intensely) following its premiere in 2018, with fan accounts featuring edits of Villanelle’s best outfits, guises, kills, witty quips, and, of course, flawless accent gymnastics.
Killing Eve‘s entire cast is sharp. Oh nails Eve’s unpredictability, dedication, and snarky attitude with ease, Fiona Shaw embodies the pretension, smarts, and mystery of Carolyn, and Kim Bodnia, who plays Villanelle’s handler (though such a position is quite impossible), might have a tough exterior. Still, he cares deeply for his wildly unpredictable work companion. However, the series would not have worked had it not found its Villanelle. From the very first moment we lay eyes on the mischievous assassin — who sets the tone for her character when she purposely knocks ice cream onto a child’s lap and smirks — it is crystal clear that Comer is the only one who could pull off this juicy role. Comer won an Emmy and BAFTA in 2019 for Season 1, the same year Oh won a Golden Globe.
Tension mounts in every episode of the stylish series, not just because of the inherent white-knuckle-grip energy that comes with an espionage thriller and high-stakes government missions, but because of the growing sexual tension between Eve and Villanelle. Killing Eve is billed as a cat-and-mouse game between the two complex women, with Eve erring on the side of caution — initially. But Episode 5 of Season 1, “I Have a Thing About Bathrooms,” is where we get the first real taste of the intense sexual chemistry between the two leads, with Villanelle breaking into Eve’s home, much to Eve’s terror, with the sole objective of sharing a meal. Villanelle shouting, “I just want to have dinner with you!” to a petrified Eve is one of the many quotable lines uttered by the assassin, and unofficially kicks off their will-they-won’t-they dynamic for four seasons.
Phoebe Waller-Bridge, of Fleabag fame, is credited with bringing Killing Eve to life, serving as showrunner and head writer for Season 1. Though the love for and dedication to these characters would only build, the series as a whole didn’t have a flawless reception, with some arguing that the tone and overarching narrative felt fractured in the latter half of the series. One of the possible explanations for this could be that each season had a new showrunner, meaning a new captain steering the ship. Season 2 was run by Emerald Fennell, Season 3 by Suzanne Heathcote, and Laura Neal for its final — and most divided — season. “I think it can innately be tricky,” Comer says when I ask her about the frequent changes in showrunner. “Each person has their own impression, their own viewpoint of the characters, and so it’s always going to be flowing, and it’s always going to have a different imprint on it, you know? You want to make sure that that is grounded by an innate sense of truth and loyalty to the characters, but it’s inevitable that it’s going to shift because we’re all so different and we all have different experiences to different things, depending on our own life experiences.”
I always wonder, when a series wraps, if the cast and crew keep in touch. “Not for a while, actually,” Comer says with an air of melancholy. It’s hard to imagine these people, who seem joined at the hip for such a long time, suddenly not speaking anymore. But the reality is that, well, it’s a job. “But I’ve just seen that Sandra is doing a play in London, I think! I have to go see her,” she says excitedly. “You’re thrust into these very intense situations for, like, eight weeks, and then you feel like, ‘This is my life!’ and then you’re gone. You have to be adaptable, and that doesn’t take away from anything that you have experienced with someone,” continuing, “You can support someone, but it doesn’t mean that you’re in each other’s pockets.”
When I suggest that it must be like an intense summer camp, Comer added, “It really, really is. It’s kind of crazy, but it’s brilliant. It’s brilliant because everyone is so open, which you have to be. We’ve got this amount of time, we’ve got this much to achieve, we’ve got to go, the only way you can do it is with teamwork.”
Comer Was Prepared for the Backlash to ‘Killing Eve’s Ending
When talking about Killing Eve, there’s an obvious elephant in the room: the series finale. For most fans, the obvious preferred ending was to have Eve and Villanelle run off, hand in hand, happily ever after, having declared their love for each other. The series finale — spoiler alert — does feature Villanelle and Eve finally giving in to their temptations, sharing a passionate kiss, and even going on a cute date that feels like a scene pulled directly from an ’80s John Hughes movie. However, in the literal last few seconds of the episode, Villanelle is shockingly shot dead after having saved the day and jumping to safety in the water with Eve. The last thing you hear before the credits roll is a piercing shriek of anguish from Eve, which, for many fans, left a toxic taste in their mouth. When I mentioned the series earlier in the conversation, she lit up when I noted how passionate the Killing Eve fanbase remains to this day. I delicately ask Comer if she anticipated the reaction to be that intense, and she didn’t miss a beat, “I think so. Yeah. On some level, absolutely.”
People immediately pointed to the unfortunate “bury your gays” trope seen in media, which is when queer characters’ storylines ends in death disproportionally compared to straight characters. Perhaps there was a feeling that, if the show stayed under the tutelage of Waller-Bridge, Villanelle’s arc wouldn’t have ended the way it did. Even Jennings, the author of books for which the series is based, refused to be silent, penning a detailed, scathing critique of how the series wraps up for The Guardian. “The Season 4 ending was a bowing to convention,” he stated, “A truly subversive storyline would have defied the trope.” Jennings elaborated further, arguing, “How much more darkly satisfying, and true to Killing Eve’s original spirit, for the couple to walk off into the sunset together? Spoiler alert, but that’s how it seemed to me when writing the books.”
It’s hard if you feel like people feel disappointed by something. I had the most amazing time on that show.
If you’ve studied the show since day one, Villanelle’s arc and growth as a person is immeasurable, especially evident in the Season 3 bottle episode, “Are You From Pinner?” — which Comer hilariously recounts to me as being “mental” — in which she goes home to Russia, and we pull back the layers to her wounded upbringing. “I remember when Shannon Murphy came through as a director [for that episode]. It was just this injection of life and clarity. She was like a cannonball. I felt like, ‘Oh, yes, I needed this.’” By the final season, Villanelle’s objectives and priorities have shifted, which makes the final scene all the more devastating. So devastating, in fact, that Jennings was compelled to erase it from everyone’s memory, writing another novel, Killing Eve: Resurrection, which picks up where the finale left off, revealing that Villanelle faked her death and that Eve and Villanelle’s relationship continues.
“When people are spending so much time with these characters, you know there is going to be an expectation. Each individual person will have their own relationship to what they see is right or just, so that is always going to be out of your control,” adding, “It’s hard though, because, once you’re in it, you have to focus on what you’re doing and the material that you have. I will say that everyone who worked on it wanted it to be the best that it could be in that moment. It’s hard if you feel like people feel disappointed by something. I had the most amazing time on that show. I learned so much. I had so much fun.”
Jodie Comer Is Ready To Return to Television
As the conversation winds down, Comer unintentionally brings it back to the beginning, as she mentions reuniting with The Death of Robin Hood‘s Sarnoski for The Chain. The show is based on the novel of the same name by Adrian McKinty, which follows a suburban mom who will go to unspeakable lengths to get her daughter back when she is kidnapped. Comer begins filming on the 8-episode HBO limited series thriller later this year with Damon Lindelof at the helm and Sarnoski directing the pilot and executive-producing the series.
“You spend a couple of episodes with a director, and someone else will come in, and the energy shifts because they work in a different way, and you have to move with it,” she notes when describing the chaotic, yet rewarding process of making television. “I haven’t done TV for a while, and I was like, ‘Oh boy, I forgot about this.’”
I haven’t done TV for a while, and I was like, ‘Oh boy, I forgot about this.’
Our conversation ends, and Comer continues with her packed press schedule. She admits that she’s a bit relieved to be doing press in the coming days with her castmates. Comer easily has enough star power to promote the film on her own, but is humble enough not to want to take up all the spotlight. We return to where our day started — the A24 lobby — which is now filled with people preparing for her photoshoot. Comer’s enthusiasm for the day hasn’t waned at all, as she chats with her team, takes the Polaroid photo that all celebrities take when it’s their first time at the office, and gets her makeup touched up ahead of the shoot.
“It’s so quiet,” she says with a smile, breaking up the nonexistent tension and allowing everyone to veer, ever so slightly, from their focus on their individual tasks. “Now’s your chance to sing Adele,” I cheekily suggest, to which Comer responds with a that’ll-be-the-day laugh. If our conversation proved anything, though, it’s that Comer is unafraid to face any obstacle that comes her way, and if anyone is going to pull off the impossible, it’s her.
Photography: Celeste Sloman | Hair: Christian Wood | Makeup: Emily Cheng | Styling: Emma Jade Morrison | Dress: The Row
The Death of Robin Hood
- Release Date
-
June 19, 2026
- Runtime
-
123 Minutes
- Director
-
Michael Sarnoski
- Writers
-
Michael Sarnoski
Entertainment
Scrapped Star Wars Series Would Have Explored Emperor Palpatine’s Rise to Power : Coastal House Media
Before Disney+ transformed Star Wars into a television powerhouse, George Lucas had plans for an ambitious live-action series that would have explored one of the franchise’s darkest stories: the rise of Emperor Palpatine.
During a recent appearance at Spacecon 2026, Ian McDiarmid, who portrayed Palpatine throughout the saga, revealed surprising new details about the long-canceled project. According to the actor, Lucas envisioned a series centered on the Emperor’s political ascent and the methods he used to seize control of the galaxy.
“[George Lucas] was talking about, I think I can tell you now, a television series,” McDiarmid said. “At the time we didn’t think about Star Wars in terms of television series. Very speculative. We had lunch one day, and he said I’ve got this idea, and I hope you might want to be involved. We could sort of follow the Emperor’s progress, like Hitler’s, some of that. There might be an assassination attempt, and of course it wouldn’t succeed. It sounded really exciting. And he also said that maybe you could direct one, and then I fainted. But sadly, that didn’t come to pass.”
While McDiarmid did not specifically name the series, many fans believe he was referring to Star Wars: Underworld, Lucas’ long-gestating live-action project that was set between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope. The series reportedly spent years in development, with more than 50 scripts written before its enormous production costs ultimately led to its cancellation.
Ian McDiarmid, Sheev Palpatine
Star Wars: Underworld was intended to explore the criminal and political underworld of Coruscant during the early days of the Empire. Producer Rick McCallum previously described the show as a darker, grittier take on the franchise, focusing on the power struggles occurring as the Empire tightened its grip on the galaxy.
What’s especially intriguing about McDiarmid’s comments is the suggestion that Palpatine would have played a much larger role than fans previously believed. Earlier reports indicated the Emperor would remain mostly in the background, but Lucas apparently envisioned a deeper examination of his rise to power and the political maneuvering that allowed him to transform the Galactic Republic into an authoritarian regime.
The comparison to historical dictators isn’t entirely new. Lucas has previously spoken about Palpatine’s rise as a cautionary tale about how democracies can slowly become dictatorships, drawing inspiration from several real-world historical figures and political movements.
Although Star Wars: Underworld never made it to screens, its influence can still be felt throughout modern Star Warsprojects. Many of the ideas and technologies developed for the series eventually helped pave the way for shows like The Mandalorian, ensuring that Lucas’ ambitious vision wasn’t entirely lost to history.
Entertainment
Amanda Seyfried Says Dog Finn Is Her ‘Soulmate’
Amanda Seyfried has opened up about the special relationship she shares with her pets, calling her longtime dog, Finn, her “soulmate.”
In a previous remark about Finn, the “Mean Girls” actress explained that he changed her life in a major way, making her realize that a part of her needed him and the joy he brought.
Seyfried also recently reflected on the backlash she faced over a controversial comment about Charlie Kirk, admitting that she feared for her safety and ended up with a bodyguard.
Amanda Seyfried has doubled down on how deeply connected she feels to her pet dog, Finn.
In an interview with British GQ that has been making the rounds online, the “Mamma Mia!” actress revealed that her beloved Australian Shepherd is undeniably her “soulmate” and opened up about her love for animals.
“I think I have about 50 animals at this point,” she began, adding that she recently lost an old horse but was not sad because the animal lived a “good, grateful life.”
“My soulmate is my dog, Finn,” she continued. “He’s 16½ years old. He was my first dog. I fell so hard in love with life when I met him.”
Seyfried went on to say that aside from Finn, her “favorite animal” is her horse, Herman, whom she noted used to be “an NYPD officer.”
She added that they have a “connection” and that she cannot imagine “not being able to have access to all kinds of animals.”
Social Media Weighs In On Seyfried’s ‘Soulmate’ Comment

Several social media users extended grace to “The Dropout” actress and shared encouraging words following the loss of her pet. Others took to the comment section to gush about her years-long relationship with Finn.
A Reddit user said, “Her relationship with Finn is iconic. Their photos are always so cute. I feel the same way about my dog. My partner and family basically accepts my true soulmate is my dog. We get each other.”
“I’m so glad Finn is still around. I think he’s the celeb pet I’d legit be sad about passing lol,” another user wrote.
Others were puzzled that Seyfried would refer to the animal as her “soulmate,” even though she is married.
“As I was watching it, I wondered what her husband thinks about her dog being her soul mate LOL, hopefully he’s accepting, too,” one user joked.
How Finn Helped Amanda Seyfried Through Anxiety
For fans who follow Seyfried closely, her declaration of love for Finn comes as no surprise.
The furry pet has been a constant fixture by her side for well over a decade and has also appeared with her on late-night talk shows, in magazine shoots, and across her social media account.
In a previous chat with PEOPLE, she disclosed that she used to battle panic attacks and anxiety until she met “the one” on the set of the HBO show “Big Love,” which ran from 2006 to 2011.
“As soon as he was mine, like 24 hours after I got him, I realized something about me needed him,” Seyfried said. “He completely changed my life and helped me find my solitude and my independence. When you have a lifestyle like I did when I was in my early twenties, there were no constants.”
“It was just hard to know where I was going to be the next month because of my career,” she continued. “That’s why I got him.”
Seyfried Tries To Bring Finn To Set

Seyfried added that Finn was instrumental in helping her get her anxiety under control. Since then, she has made sure to negotiate it into her film contracts so Finn can be by her side on set as much as possible.
“My anti-depressant has been a lifesaver,” she said.
“I just can’t picture being anywhere without him,” she says. “Except England. Every time I do a movie over there, I have to leave him. I wouldn’t put him through that plane ride unless I was there for long enough to make sense because he has such a good life when he’s being babysat by my agent.”
Amanda Seyfried Feared For Her Safety After Charlie Kirk Backlash

Seyfried caught some flak last year when she replied to an Instagram Reel compilation of Charlie Kirk, calling him “hateful.”
The comment triggered backlash from Kirk’s supporters, who accused her of implying that his shooting death was justified.
She later shared an Instagram statement saying, “I can get angry about misogyny and racist rhetoric and ALSO very much agree that Charlie Kirk’s murder was absolutely disturbing and deplorable in every way imaginable.”
During her recent interview with British GQ, she admitted that she feared for her own safety after the barrage of backlash, revealing that she even had to hire a bodyguard.
“A, I’m allowed to f-cking voice my feelings, and B, do it in a way that’s not unkind necessarily,” she noted, adding that there is “an outsized fear and hatred and impulse to bash and to tear down,” and she did experience it a little.
“I want my kids to be able to feel safe to voice their opinions as long as they’re not harmful,” Seyfried continued. “So, I’m like, ‘What do I do? What do I say?’ And then all of a sudden I find myself with a f-cking bodyguard at the airport, and I’m like, ‘This is crazy.’”
Entertainment
Harlan Coben’s New Netflix Thriller Is Officially His Most Divisive Series in Years
Harlan Coben‘s stories are unmistakable: they’re emotional, fast-paced, and twisty. The mystery author has produced over a dozen stories for various streaming platforms, most of which are available on Netflix. Over ten of his shows are available to stream right now. The latest entrant is another crime thriller that follows a father on a mission to uncover the truth about his son’s disappearance. Many of Coben’s shows are hits with viewers, consistently appearing in the top ten in the period after their release. But the shows tend to divide critics, and this latest one has proven so.
Titled I Will Find You, the series follows David, played by Avatar‘s Sam Worthington. David has been serving a prison sentence after being convicted of the murder of his son. However, he has someone in his corner in the form of his sister-in-law Rachel (Britt Lower), who never believed David was guilty of the crime. While David has been imprisoned, Rachel, an investigative journalist, has unearthed evidence that her nephew Matthew is still alive. She brings the evidence to David, who decides to break out of prison and find his son. He must outsmart shadowy organizations and law enforcement in his quest to bring Matthew home.
Is ‘I Will Find You’ Worth Watching?
After ten or so shows, the story sounds like typical Harlan Coben, and that’s the exact problem critics found with the show. I Will Find You has debuted with a 71% score on Rotten Tomatoes, signaling a divisive story. This is not Coben’s worst-rated show, but with hits like Run Away, it’s his lowest-rated show this year. Most critics weren’t impressed, and others were downright disappointed by the story’s mediocrity. Collider’s Taylor Gates noted that a missing-person story is not new on TV, but I Will Find You‘s biggest problem is its characters, who make viewers feel like they’ve seen them before in a dozen other shows. “There is ultimately a genericness [in the characters] that permeates, leaning into tropes and archetypes — the persistent reporter, the shady benefactor, the rogue cop, etc. — instead of creating more well-rounded, fleshed-out individuals,” she wrote in her review of I Will Find You Season 1.
Other critics shared similar sentiments, noting that even with flaws such as weak characters and pacing issues, I Will Find You delivers an engaging story. ScreenRant‘s Cher Thompson said the show “makes a concerted effort to ensure that its mystery makes sense and comes to a satisfying conclusion.” Meanwhile, Nick Schager of The Daily Beast compared the show to junk food that “makes viewers crave additional servings (no matter how bad they feel afterward).”
All episodes of I Will Find You are available to stream on Netflix. Stay tuned to Collider for more updates.
- Release Date
-
June 18, 2026
- Network
-
Netflix
- Showrunner
-
Robert Hull
- Directors
-
Adam Davidson, Maggie Kiley, Maja Vrvilo, Brad Anderson
- Writers
-
Robert Hull, Harlan Coben
Entertainment
“Smile” tackles sports, “A Quiet Place” hits the Florida Keys, and more IDW Dark comic expansions (exclusive)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/IDW-dark-any-given-smile-a-quiet-place-rising-tides-061226-d99d529dba464f95b115bd1d7f152046.jpg)
Exclusive looks at the new IDW Dark comic expansions, including a new “Twilight Zone.”
Entertainment
Jamie Lynn Spears Recalls Daughter Maddie’s Near Death Fight
Jamie Lynn Spears is opening up about the terrifying day she thought she had lost her daughter forever.
Nearly a decade after Maddie Aldridge’s near-fatal ATV accident, the actress and her now-18-year-old daughter are reflecting on the ordeal that left their family fearing the worst.
From desperate prayers to what Spears describes as a miracle recovery, the mother-daughter duo is sharing how the life-changing experience strengthened their faith and forever changed the course of their family’s story.

In a new interview with PEOPLE, Jamie Lynn Spears looked back on the 2017 accident that nearly claimed Maddie’s life.
“That was the day I thought I’d lost my daughter. Against all odds, this baby girl fought to be here,” the actress revealed.
Maddie was only eight years old when she was riding an ATV on the family’s property in Fluker, Louisiana. According to Spears, the frightening incident happened in an instant.
“We were watching her, and we still don’t quite know if she was dodging a dog or what it was,” she shared, adding, “She went in the water and me, my father-in-law and my husband [Jamie Watson] ran as fast as we could to go jump in to get her out, but she was stuck under the ATV.”
As family members rushed to help, Spears’s mother-in-law called 911. Emergency responders arrived within minutes to assist in rescuing Maddie from beneath the vehicle.
Spears Thought Her Daughter Was Gone
The situation became even more devastating once Maddie was pulled from the pond.
“When Maddie was pulled out of the water, it was really not a sight anybody wants to see,” Jamie Lynn Spears recalled. “At that point, she was not breathing. We thought that she had passed.”
Then came a moment the doting mom says she will never forget. A firefighter suddenly announced they had found a pulse.
Maddie was immediately airlifted to a hospital, where doctors placed her in intensive care. She remained in a coma for two days as loved ones waited and prayed for signs of improvement.
The family’s fear grew so severe that a priest was called to administer her last rites. For Spears, the experience was almost impossible to process as she watched her daughter fight for survival.
Jamie Lynn Spears Believes A Miracle Happened In The Hospital

While Maddie remained unconscious, Spears shared that an extraordinary moment unfolded in her hospital room.
“He comes in, and she physically sits up in all her restraints and tubes,” the 35-year-old said while recalling the priest’s visit. “I’m screaming for the doctors, like ‘Come in here now!’”
The experience left everyone stunned. “Even the priest was like, ‘I’ve never seen anything like what’s happening,’” Spears explained.
For the “All That” actress, that moment strengthened her belief that her daughter could hear the prayers surrounding her.
“I knew she was in there and felt all of us praying. We were given a miracle, and I don’t take it for granted,” she said
Although Maddie has no memory of the accident itself, she believes the ordeal had a lasting impact on the family’s faith.
According to Spears, “I feel like our faith got a lot stronger. In the end, I think such a negative experience affected us positively.”
Spears Says Maddie’s Recovery Led To A Special Promise
Before the accident, Maddie had often talked about wanting a younger sibling. According to Jamie Lynn Spears, those conversations took on new meaning while her daughter remained in a coma.
“I was bargaining with God, like, ‘Take my arm, take my leg. I don’t care. Just give me my baby back,’” she recalled, adding, “I was like, ‘I’ll have a baby. I’ll have whatever you want.’”
When Maddie finally regained consciousness, Spears immediately remembered one thing. “You going to give me that baby?” she asked her mother.
Spears laughed while remembering her response. “I was like, ‘Oh, He’s already calling in,’” she shared. Only a few months later, the singer became pregnant with her second daughter, Ivey, who was born in 2018.
Jamie Lynn Spears Celebrates Maddie’s Bright Future
Despite the grim predictions that followed the accident, Maddie made a full recovery and is now preparing for an exciting new chapter.
“Seeing everybody rally around me, it made me realize how blessed I am. It really made me so grateful for every day,” Maddie said during the interview.
The teenager is set to attend the University of Southern Mississippi this August, where she plans to study health sciences while continuing her softball career.
Watching her daughter thrive remains something Spears says she never takes for granted. “I just was so happy to have her, but how in the world did God give her back?” she said.
The actress reflected on everything Maddie has accomplished since that frightening day, saying, “And then He gave her back in a way that she’s succeeding, she’s beautiful, she’s kind, she’s smart…”
Entertainment
Where is the “Gilmore Girls” cast today? See what Lauren Graham, Alexis Bledel, and the rest of the stars are doing now
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/GILMORE-GIRLS-040726-c73667e251534316b307eafeb0438f9b.jpg)
The residents of Stars Hollow are busier than ever.
-
Business4 days agoNo Jackpot Winner as $257 Million Prize Rolls Over to $269 Million Monday Draw
-
Fashion6 days agoWeekend Open Thread: Tuckernuck – Corporette.com
-
Crypto World7 days agoMarkets Rally as SpaceX IPO Looms Amid Iran Tensions and Inflation Surge
-
Crypto World4 days agoZimbabwe Requires Crypto Businesses to Register Annually Under New FIU Regulations
-
Crypto World5 days agoBitget enters Argentina’s regulated crypto market through PSAV registration
-
Tech6 days agoNanoClaw integrates JFrog registries to secure AI agent downloads
-
Tech6 days agoThis Week In Security: Microsoft On Microsoft, Register Your Domains, Linux On ARM, And FreeBSD Joins The File Cache Club
-
NewsBeat7 days agoEl Nino has formed in the Pacific and could set records, forecasters say
-
Entertainment7 days agoDonnie Wahlberg & More Heat Up Las Vegas at Circa’s Barry’s Downtown Prime
-
Tech7 days agoOpendoor Ends India Operations, Fueling a Bigger Conversation About AI and Outsourcing
-
NewsBeat6 days agoFBI searches office of Ohio voter registration group
-
Tech7 days agoAnthropic is spending $150M to embed 1,000 AI fellows inside nonprofits. No degree required.
-
Entertainment7 days ago‘The Pitt’s Fan-Favorite Doctor Confirms Noah Wyle Gave His Blessing to Return [Exclusive]
-
Crypto World7 days agoRipple and Bitso Bring MXNB Stablecoin to XRP Ledger
-
Fashion7 days agoCoffee Break: Scarf Waist Belt
-
Tech7 days agoFormer AWS CEO Adam Selipsky to lead new $10B AI data center venture
-
Entertainment4 days agoMatt Damon’s Viral Sci-Fi Thriller Has Taken Over HBO Max
-
Business4 days agoAnthropic staff to meet White House officials next week, Axios reports
-
Tech4 days agoAs AI companies race to go public, who else is along for the ride?
-
Business7 days agoJustin Bieber Prepares for 2026 Tour Return with New Music and Promoter Talks




You must be logged in to post a comment Login