Lifetime TV Thriller On Netflix Is One Of Many That Will Make You Question Everything, Including Your Existence

By Robert Scucci
| Published 16 seconds ago

After watching The Paradise Murders on Netflix, I noticed a startling pattern: there are suddenly a lot of Lifetime TV thrillers available on the streaming giant. They’re all 87 minutes long, mostly feature a female protagonist who’s being manipulated, lean into every psychological thriller trope known to man, and are such “light” fare that I’d hardly even consider them movies. But for some reason, I feel compelled to slowly work through all of them for the love of the game, which brings me to 2025’s The Body in the Locker.

Guess what this one’s about? Spoiler alert: the title tells you everything you need to know. A quick look through the Netflix catalog after searching “Lifetime” reveals similarly hilarious and on-the-nose titles to suffer through, like Held Hostage in My House, Stolen Baby, Abducted on Prom Night, and my personal favorite, a title I’ve yet to even consider watching but probably will, Gaslit by My Husband.

I love a good thriller, and what I’ve learned after watching The Paradise Murders, and now The Body in the Locker, is that I apparently also really, really love terrible ones. While The Body in the Locker is a step up from The Paradise Murders, it’s still a punisher that I need to talk about.

We Found Her Inside The Armoire … Of Despair! 

Okay, here we go. The Body in the Locker first introduces us to Amy Robertson (Kirsten Comerford), the new CEO of her father’s (John Koensgen) charity program after his untimely passing. She’s married to James (Chris Hong), who’s interviewing to become partner at the same charity but constantly butts heads with Peter (Robert Notman), the other guy aggressively gunning for the same position. Amy’s mother, Clare (Jayne Heitmeyer), is painted as a perfectionist through dialogue about her when she’s not around, establishing a domineering dynamic that will most certainly come into play later.

One day, while looking for documents, Amy has a run-in with Lisa (Briauna James), the woman working the front desk at the storage facility, who clearly knows about her late father’s foundation because she mentions what a crappy program it is. While rummaging through the storage locker, Amy is horrified to find a dead body hidden in the armoire, which makes me wonder why the movie isn’t called The Body in the Armoire, but I digress.

Naturally, the authorities need to get involved, which introduces us to Detective Clark (Dale Samms), a guy who seems generally unfazed by how a dead woman’s body somehow managed to make its way into an exceedingly wealthy, philanthropic CEO’s storage unit. Of course there’s no camera footage, and of course some key players are present when the unit burns down, making everybody a suspect. To make matters worse, Amy is accosted in her house when somebody tries to steal a mysterious flash drive that nobody knows the password to, thinking nobody was home, resulting in one of the most hilarious moments in the film: Amy picking up the most pathetic-looking fireplace poker and yelling, “I’m armed!”

The Body in the Locker goes on like this, making sure to lean into every thriller trope you can think of, from our protagonist winding down with a bath before something terrible happens to every suspect showing up at the wrong place and time, making them all look super suspicious even though it’s heavily implied that whoever killed the woman in the locker was acting alone. James gets grilled by the press at work and refuses to divulge information that could soil his late father-in-law’s reputation, while Clare tries to keep the whole thing hush-hush so her family’s legacy remains free of any dark spots.

Stop Interfering With Active Crime Scenes! 

The Body in the Locker is only the second Lifetime movie I’ve watched on Netflix, but a clear pattern is starting to emerge that I’ll be keeping tabs on. Everybody in these movies loves interfering with active crime scene investigations. The Paradise Murders shows guests at a luxury resort, some of whom are suspected of first-degree murder, coming and going as they please. Some of these people are caught rummaging through the victim’s personal belongings, and the most they get is, “Hey, buddy. Don’t do that!”

The same exact thing happens in The Body in the Locker. A storage unit is incinerated, and nobody, not even Lisa, whose entire job is to keep an eye on the business during the late-night hours, is ever questioned or told to stop coming to work until everything is sorted out. On one hand, it makes for a great mystery because everybody is so catastrophically stupid that maybe they accidentally Mr. Magoo’d a woman to death, panicked, and dragged her body into a nearby storage unit. I mean, the murder HAD to have happened there, right? Certainly somebody would have noticed a dead human body being dragged into this place before it got stuffed into an armoire, right?

I’m just a guy asking questions. You may also be asking questions like, “Why on Earth would I ever watch something like The Body in the Locker?” and I don’t have a clear answer for you other than I found it really, really funny. There are movies like The Room and Birdemic: Shock and Terror that get by on their low-budget cult-movie charm, but this one is entirely in a league of its own. At least for me, I’ve been really enjoying yelling at these Lifetime movies on Netflix while getting my cardio in on the exercise bike. I think the extra boost to my heart rate is enough to keep me coming back for more.

As of this writing, The Body in the Locker is streaming on Netflix. The real mystery, though, is whether you can handle it.

THE BODY IN THE LOCKER SCORE