Maya Hawke Becomes First Star Cast in Magic: The Gathering Film After Three Failed Attempts

Maya Hawke has become the first actor attached to Legendary Entertainment’s live-action Magic: The Gathering film, a project that has already outlasted several studios and more than a decade of false starts. The news, first reported by Deadline and later confirmed by other trade outlets, gives the long-troubled adaptation its first piece of casting.

What we know about Maya Hawke’s role

The details are thin. Variety says Hawke “will star” in the film, and, citing Deadline, expects her to anchor an ensemble that has yet to be cast. IGN, relaying the same Deadline report, says sources describe her part as a “key” one and that producers wanted her to get the first offer. The Hollywood Reporter says there is no word on what character she will play, and Variety likewise says her role and the plot remain under wraps.

So while some headlines frame it as a lead role, the reporting supports a narrower reading: Hawke is the first name on a film that is meant to feel like an ensemble piece. Her exact billing and character are unconfirmed.

Hawke is best known for Stranger Things. Her film credits include Once Upon a Time in Hollywood, Asteroid City, Do Revenge and Maestro, and she voiced Anxiety in Pixar’s Inside Out 2. She is also set to appear in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, among other upcoming projects.

A director who actually plays the game

Matt Johnson, the Canadian filmmaker behind BlackBerry and Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie, is directing and co-writing with Noah Gardner and Aidan Fitzgerald. Variety reports that Johnson is a longtime fan of the game. He shared a story about entering a major tournament in Detroit while half-seriously planning to drop out of film school and go pro. By his telling, a brutal losing streak ended that plan within hours.

That background could matter for a franchise where fans are famously protective of the lore. IGN suggests that Johnson’s comedy credentials and the ensemble framing point toward something in the spirit of Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves. That is the outlet’s inference, not anything the studio has said about tone.

Why this adaptation keeps stalling

The casting news lands against a rough history. According to IGN, Hasbro struck a deal with Universal in 2008 to turn several of its brands, including Magic, into films, but that effort was canceled by 2012. Fox picked up the rights in 2014, attached Simon Kinberg as a supervisor and brought in a Game of Thrones writer. It still went nowhere, and the game’s lead designer, Mark Rosewater, confirmed the project was dead in 2022. Netflix also explored a live-action film and an animated series in the early 2020s, with no result.

The current effort is structured differently. Legendary and Hasbro Entertainment announced their partnership in 2025, and Vulture reported Johnson’s involvement in July 2026. IGN also notes that crew members from the Dune films, including storyboard artists, costume designers and location scouts, are reportedly contributing. The film is intended as the start of a broader film and TV universe.

Hasbro and Legendary’s bigger bet

The game launched in 1993 and has grown into a sprawling business spanning digital games, publishing, live events and consumer products. It has also produced crossover card sets tied to Final Fantasy, Marvel, Star Trek, Dungeons & Dragons and The Lord of the Rings. The Hollywood Reporter notes that this brand recognition is part of what Hasbro hopes to turn into a screen franchise.

Legendary brings a track record with game and book adaptations, including A Minecraft Movie and the Dune series. Hasbro is also pursuing a Clue reimagining with Sony and a Monopoly film with LuckyChap and Lionsgate. A release date and the rest of the cast have not been announced.

For now, the signing of Maya Hawke is the clearest sign that this version of Magic: The Gathering is moving from announcement to production. Whether it can succeed where three earlier attempts failed will depend on who joins her and what the film turns out to be.

Explore more on this topic with Vexel Search.

File photo: Maya Hawke @ Sid The Cat Auditorium.jpg by Justin Higuchi, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.