Prime Video’s ‘Neagley’ Is a ‘Reacher’-Lite Spin-Off That’s Officially Worth Your Time

Reacher is one of Prime Video’s best and most popular shows, currently wrapping up its brutal fourth season and already confirmed to return for a fifth. The flagship series reintroduced audiences to Jack Reacher, played by Alan Ritchson, a self-described nomad who wanders around the U.S. solving crimes and collecting allies. One of Reacher’s few close friends is Frances Neagley (Maria Sten), a corporate security professional and PI who became an instant breakout character, stealing every scene she was in, and it didn’t take long for Prime Video to give her a show of her own.

Spin-offs are tough to crack. They need to walk a fine line between feeling like they belong in the same continuity as their predecessor and carving out a unique identity. The best — Better Call Saul, Maude, Frasier — make it look easy, but it’s actually damn hard. Neagley isn’t a carbon copy of Reacher, but it also doesn’t do nearly enough to distinguish itself from its parent series. Whether that’s a strength or a weakness depends on the viewer, but Neagley successfully delivers a compelling, intimate mystery that will satisfy those who are already Reacher-pilled.

What Is ‘Neagley’ About?

As its title suggests, Neagley centers on Frances Neagley (Sten), back in her hometown of Chicago and working as a private investigator. Solitary, independent, and damn good at her job, Neagley is also living with haphephobia, an intense aversion to physical touch that limits the relationships she can maintain. When her childhood friend, Tommy Crane (Jhaleil Swaby), dies by apparent suicide, Neagley discovers a connection to a mysterious farm named Echo Canyon that recruits people seeking a fresh start to overcome trauma. Suspecting foul play in Tommy’s death, Neagley joins forces with Detective Hudson Riley (Greyston Holt) to look into Echo Canyon, which is led by the disturbing Lawrence Cole (Damon Herriman).

Neagley‘s cast also includes Adeline Rudolph as Renee Birdwhistle, an assistant working at Neagley’s PI firm who becomes a close ally; Jasper Jones as Keno, a young homeless man whose savvy instincts aid the investigation; and Matthew Del Negro as Pierce Woodrow, the CEO of a pharmaceutical company developing a revolutionary drug. Also, as has already been confirmed, Alan Ritchson reprises his role as Reacher, so you can expect to see him pop in. Neagley hails from Reacher creator Nick Santora and Emmy-winning TV veteran Nicholas Wootton. Unlike Reacher, the protagonist of numerous books by author Lee Child, Neagley has no novel of her own (yet), meaning Season 1 is a completely original story.

‘Reacher’s Spin-Off ‘Neagley’ Benefits From Likable Characters

Like its parent series, Neagley gets a lot of mileage from a strong ensemble that does great work with thinly drawn characters, of which the show’s lead herself is by far the most compelling. Sten is very comfortable in the role, and she makes the most of the chance to explore the character’s haphephobia and its root. Her chemistry with everyone is on point, and the subtle, slow-building dynamic she has with Holt’s Hudson is particularly enjoyable. Her few scenes with Reacher are also very sweet, though don’t expect to see Ritchson a lot this season. He is effectively used, but this show is a proper showcase for Neagley and doesn’t feel the need to rely on Reacher too much.

Holt does a fine job with a very one-note character. Riley is a good cop: by the book, committed, and desperate to break ties with his criminal family by scoring a big win for the department. There’s nothing particularly impressive about him, but he is a solid ally for Neagley, and their emotional bond builds effectively throughout the season. Rudolph and Jones are good supporting players who actually contribute meaningfully to the investigation. Neagley builds a strong team for herself, and she’s also a capable leader, if a tad more indifferent than one would wish. (There’s also a cameo midway through the season that will probably make your 40-year-old uncle very happy.)

Reacher has never been a show that focuses on building layered antagonists; in fact, it often opts for evil in the most literal sense, with irredeemable villains absent of any humanity or relatable trait. Neagley is the same. Del Negro plays a scumbag entrepreneur, Gordon Gekko by way of Albert Wesker, while Herriman, for his part, delivers exactly what you’d expect from an actor who’s already played Charles Manson twice. He’s a cult leader to a T — silly dances, self-aggrandizing speeches, and emotional manipulation — all while giving off enough creepy vibes to fill an entire season of Mindhunter. Cole and Woodrow both work within the context of the show; they’re not memorable or particularly interesting, but they’re effective, and in a show like Neagley, that’s all that matters.

‘Neagley’ Needs to Form a Stronger Identity for Itself

Image via Prime Video

Advertisement

The biggest issue with Neagley is that it’s a very safe expansion of the Reacher formula. It has the same structure, follows the same narrative beats, has the same visual language, and uses the same archetypes. It works, but Neagley is such an interesting character, and so different from Reacher, that her show should have been less afraid to try other things stylistically, narratively, and emotionally. So little of her personality is woven into the show’s fabric, and future seasons would greatly benefit from having more of Neagley in their DNA.

The one place where Neagley truly carves an identity of its own is in the action. Neagley isn’t a 6’3” juggernaut; she can’t just punch her way through every situation and is instead forced to rely on a more restrained approach. Her fights feel slower and more hard-hitting; every time she takes a punch, you can see it taking a toll on her. The choreography isn’t as visceral as in Reacher, nor is it as acrobatic as the average Marvel movie: here, the fights feel dirty, desperate even, one punch at a time for everyone involved. Similarly, her team is a lot less battle-hardened. Hudson is actually kind of bad in a one-on-one, which is appreciated; cops are so often depicted as all-around fighters in shows like these, so this bit of reality is a welcome change.

Visually, the direction is straightforward, not exactly flashy but far from mediocre. Blocking is rarely an issue in Reacher, and it’s not in Neagley either, largely because the small cast means there are usually no more than three people in the same shot. The editing is rather rough at times, though, with some particularly clumsy cuts during the fight scenes. The sets and staging are also uninspired, to the point where Neagley’s PI office, Hudson’s police station, and the bank the characters visit midway through the season look identical.

At the end of the day, Neagley gets the job done. It’s a show that delivers exactly what it promises, with a simple but well-executed mystery led by an incredibly intriguing lead and greatly elevated by a likable cast. There’s a lot of room for the series to grow in character work, visual identity, and narrative ambition. However, unlike Reacher, Neagley won’t be changing locations or cast, and Season 1 does a good job laying the foundation for a stronger, more confident sophomore outing.

Neagley premieres September 16 with all episodes on Prime Video.