THE case of a Co Antrim man accused of the murder of Chloe Mitchell almost three years ago took a dramatic twist today (Thursday) when his legal team withdrew from it citing “professional compromise”.Brandon John Rainey (29), formerly of James Street, Ballymena, was due to be re-arraigned at Belfast Crown Court on a charge of murdering the 21-year-old and preventing the lawful burial of her remains on June 3, 2023.His senior counsel, Neil Connor KC, told the court two weeks ago that he had fresh instructions from Rainey, who would now plead not guilty to murder but guilty to “manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility”.Rainey was produced today (Thursday) from Maghaberry Prison to court for his scheduled re-arraignment hearing with the public gallery packed with the victim’s family, relatives and friends.Uniformed police officers were in attendance in the courtroom along with civilian security guards.As Rainey appeared in the dock escorted by a number of prison officers, Ms Mitchell’s distressed mum Georgina ran out of the court.Mr Connor said that at this moment in time he represents the defendant Brandon Rainey.“Unfortunately, I have an application to make to the court this morning and that application is to withdraw from the case,” he told Madam Justice McBride.He said not only was he withdrawing from the case, but so was his junior Neil Moore and their instructing solicitors James Ballentine & Sons.“There are two aspects to this: one is that we are professionally compromised and secondly the accused, during consultation at court this morning, indicated that he no longer wished us to represent him,” explained Mr Connor.“To that extent, the client lawyer relationship has broken down irretrievably in this case.“I appreciate it is disappointing at this late stage but I have to make this application on those two grounds. I don’t make this application lightly,” he added.Madam Justice McBride enquired of Mr Connor if the defendant had indicated that he had spoken to any other legal team.Mr Connor replied: “Yes, he has, My Lady. He has spoken to a firm of solicitors, and I can indicate that they have, within the past few minutes, been in contact with my learned junior Mr Moore.
“They have indicated they are not intending to take instructions in this case if the defendant approached them. Ultimately, that is a matter for the accused.“Mr Rainey had been in quite substantial contact with them over the last couple of days, which we were not aware of. So this has obviously been brewing for some period of time.“So it is on the basis of a breakdown, a complete breakdown, of the client lawyer relationship, and also there is an aspect of professional compromise in this case.”Said Madam Justice McBride: “This is a very unfortunate turn of events, but in light of what you have outlined to the court, because you are professionally embarrassed and the breakdown of the client-lawyer relationship, I will accede to your application.”The senior judge said the case had been expected to proceed and it was one of the cases that was granted an exemption due to the withdrawal of services by the Criminal Bar Association in Northern Ireland.Madam Justice McBride said she would list the matter for Monday, March 16, 2026, to allow the defendant time to secure a fresh legal team to represent him.“To assist in you in that, I am going to ensure and ask that the solicitors have all of the papers in a state of readiness to give it to any new solicitor that maybe instructed.”Mr Connor said his instructing solicitors had indicated that the papers will be boxed up and ready to go today (Thursday).Senior prosecutor David Russell KC said he understood the professional compromise by the defence and said Rainey should be produced in person in court next Monday along with any new legal team he has securedMadam Justice McBride told the defendant that he would be produced next Monday in person and she expected an update on his legal representation and if in the meantime he speaks to a new firm of solicitors who are willing to represent him they should also attend court on Monday on his behalf.As Rainey was being led out of court in handcuffs by prison officers, some members in the public gallery shouted at him “scum”, “scum b******d”, ”rat” and “cowardly b******d” before they were ushered out of court by police and civilian security guards.Chloe Mitchell’s remains were found days after she went missing.She was last seen alive on CCTV in Ballymena town centre in the early hours of June 3, 2023 and an extensive search operation was launched by the PSNI.Detectives investigating her disappearance later launched a murder inquiry after human remains were discovered in the Co Antrim town.This led officers to attend a flat in the James Street area of the town which prompted Rainey’s arrest.
For all the latest news, visit the Belfast Live homepage here and sign up to our daily newsletter here.

