Dublin star Jack McCaffrey has defended suspended manager Ger Brennan, saying his 12-week ban was ‘overly harsh’
Jack McCaffrey believes former Dublin teammate Ger Brennan only spoke publicly about his 12-week suspension due to ‘a particularly verbose member of the GAA hierarchy’.
Dublin boss Brennan will be permitted to return to his touchline role at Kingspan Breffni on Sunday when the 2023 All-Ireland winners face Cavan in a crucial Round 2B encounter.
Last week, Brennan released a statement via his legal representative addressing various comments made by GAA President Jarlath Burns during media appearances on Tuesday.
Brennan took issue with what he described as ‘insulting’ remarks from Burns regarding the disciplinary process, stating the entire episode had made him feel ‘disenfranchised, undervalued’ and experiencing ‘a lack of belonging to the association’.
At Monday afternoon’s announcement of PTSB’s new sponsorship of the PTSB Dublin club leagues and championships, former Footballer of the Year McCaffrey suggested Brennan conducted himself ‘really admirably’ throughout the ‘overly harsh’ suspension and maintained his silence until he felt forced to respond, reports the Irish Mirror.
“I think Ger has acknowledged and apologised and held his hands up early doors,” McCaffrey observed. “And probably felt that his punishment was overly harsh and pursued his appeals, as far as I could see, quietly. And was unsuccessful in them. And then didn’t say a peep really – until he did. Which I think was prompted by a particularly verbose member of the GAA hierarchy talking about it.
“And I think Ger has every right (to feel aggrieved). He was punished, he accepted his punishment. Why do people still need to keep having a pop off him in the media over it? Sorry, that might be a mischaracterisation of what happened but I do have a huge amount of sympathy for Ger in feeling that he was overly, harshly punished.”
McCaffrey stated he didn’t believe the severe sanction imposed on Brennan, in contrast to the lack of action taken against Donegal manager Jim McGuinness for a relatively similar incident in the Kerry game, represented ‘an anti-Dublin thing’.
“I don’t think it means that everybody should get a 12-week ban, two wrongs don’t make a right in that instance,” McCaffrey remarked, while recalling the 12-week ban handed to his former Dublin teammate Diarmuid Connolly after an incident involving a linesman in 2017.
“I am reminded of an episode when I was playing, when one of our teammates got a 12-week suspension for touching an official, and it just became clear that a lot of people touch officials over the course of a season, from watching games, and yet don’t get 12-week bans.
“So I think that’s a case-by-case thing, it’s not an anti-Dublin thing at all. I’m a firm believer that anyone involved in the GAA at any level is doing it with the best intentions and doesn’t go out to treat anyone unfairly. I’d give everyone the benefit of the doubt there. But I can completely sympathise with Ger feeling very disappointed.”
Dublin are desperately seeking to revive their Championship campaign following consecutive defeats to Leinster rivals Westmeath and Louth. Brennan has been absent from Dublin’s last four matches in total due to a suspension stemming from an incident during their National League clash with Galway on March 22.
“It’s just such a pity really,” said medical doctor McCaffrey, a six-time All-Ireland winner. “And I think Ger has behaved really admirably around the whole thing, in terms of just keeping the head down in so far as he could. And they got on with it as a group.
“I think particularly in a first season when you’re trying to find an identity as a gang with new players and everything like that, I just felt sorry for them having to deal with that. And I think Dean (Rock) in fairness has done a remarkable job. I’m sure he didn’t see himself in that role six months ago, 12 weeks ago even.
“I think they’ll have some regrets over it because it’ll have affected the year, and they’ll just need to kind of look back on it and obviously make sure it doesn’t happen again.”
Sign up to our free sports newsletter to get the latest headlines to your inbox

You must be logged in to post a comment Login