Organised by Vogue, the Met Gala this year was based around the theme of “costume art”. An accompanying exhibition of the same name opens at New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art on May 10, with a focus on the dressed body.

Responses to the Met Gala – the US fashion event of the year – and its related Costume Art exhibition have been sharply divided. On the one hand, critics have applauded the exhibition’s use of an inclusive range of mannequins, representing a wide group of bodies that go far beyond the normal “model physique”.

On the other, this apparent celebration of diversity has been contrasted with the overwhelming thinness of the red carpet at the Gala, as well as the involvement of its honorary chairs, Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and his wife Lauren Sánchez Bezos. The couple were said to have sponsored the event to the tune of $10m (£7.4m), sparking calls for a boycott.

As the influential fashion commentators Diet Prada noted, this year’s Met Gala was more poorly received than ever before, with speculation rife about why some celebrities were missing the event.

As artwashing is now an established media tactic, the positive elements of the exhibition could be viewed as a distraction from the negative capitalistic associations of its sponsors.

However, in an age dominated by Ozempic and other GLP-1 drugs, an exhibition celebrating bodies of all shapes and sizes does far more than pay politically expedient lip service to the idea of diversity.

Diversity fights back

The exhibition – masterminded by Andrew Bolton, the British-born curator of the Costume Institute at the Met – pairs garments and artworks “organised into a series of thematic body types that reflect their pervasiveness and endurance through time and cultures”.

The choice of these thematic body types – which divide into sections including the Naked Body, the Classical Body, the Ageing Body and the Disabled Body – had been the subject of media coverage long before column inches were filled with the usual discussions of celebrity outfit choices.

Over the past month, a series of articles and related social media posts have trailed that the show would feature a physically diverse array of mannequins. This would support the exhibition’s stated aim of exploring distinct bodies across time and space. On April 21, sculptor Frank Benson – most famous for his figurative works – posted on social media that it had been the “honour of a lifetime” to create a group of mannequins for the Met’s show.

These newly commissioned mannequins allow the show to present its garments on an array of bodies – variously abled, fat and thin, and in different states of pregnancy and undress. These are not one-off pieces. As Benson confirmed, the mannequins will be transferred afterwards into the Costume Institute’s permanent collection and used in future exhibitions.

Each of the figures wears a mirrored mask, encouraging viewers’ identification with these more “realistic bodies”. In so doing, the curators utilise a highly literal but effective means of reflecting the norm within clothing and spaces usually reserved for the thinnest of bodies.

Alongside the forms of the mannequins themselves, “the Corpulent Body” (the Met’s somewhat unfortunate wording) is also invoked through specially commissioned photography and fashion design, including work by designers Karoline Vitto and Michaela Stark.

Stark has created some of her highly recognisable undergarments that truss the body in silk organza ties – resulting in pockets of fat and bulging extrusions that encourage speculation on what the beautiful erotic body might look like.

Is there a future for body positivity?

Despite this, recent data from industry insiders suggests a broader backward slide in representation that counters the narrative pushed by the exhibition. The model Felicity Hayward has done pioneering work season after season recording plus-size representation on the runways: the autumn/winter 26 lineup (shown in Europe and US in February) had the lowest numbers of size inclusive models for years.

Of the 3,840 looks shown at New York Fashion Week, only 20 were shown on plus-sized bodies. This was a staggering 50% lower than it had been the previous year.

Vogue Business interviewed a number of casting directors on this notable shift. One, Chloe Rosolek, described this “regression in inclusion” as the literal “erasure of women’s bodies”. The Costume Art exhibition seems to stand firm against this shift.

But as many social media observers have noted, the exhibition’s attempts at representing equality and body positivity feel at odds with a red carpet that was populated by an ever-thinner group of celebrities. With weight-loss easier to achieve than ever thanks to the widespread use of GLP-1 drugs, many figures in the public eye have appeared to lose significant amounts of weight.

The Gala guestlist did include a more diverse crowd, including the disabled transgender model Aariana Rose Philip, whose body one of the mannequins was based upon. But in event roundups dominated by influencers, singers and actors, this bodily diversity makes little impression.

While Instagram feeds suggest the most important and fashionable of red-carpet appearances belong to the thinnest bodies, the exhibition itself does seem to achieve its goals in furthering representation of diverse bodies. And it does so on one of the most influential and public stages.

Fat studies scholar Jeannine A. Gailey argues that people who are fat are simultaneously paid undue attention on account of their “taking up too much space”, and are also ignored due to the perception of fatness as both undesirable and morally questionable.

Conversations around what kind of bodies are valued through forms of representation feel very relevant to the aims of Costume Art, thanks to its prominent portrayal of fat, ageing and disabled bodies.

Despite its problematic associations with Bezos, Costume Art nevertheless provides a highly visible – and thereby meaningful – counter to the world of ever-shrinking thinness that Hollywood appears to cling to, perhaps offering the body positivity movement a much needed life raft. However, now that anyone can access these weight-loss shortcut drugs, one wonders how long body positivity can remain afloat.

A Utah judge has ruled that cameras will be allowed in the courtroom during proceedings for Tyler Robinson, the man accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk, rejecting defense arguments that extensive media coverage could taint a future jury pool.

The ruling made by Judge Tony Graf Jr. on Friday comes as the case continues drawing national attention and as conspiracy theories continue to swirl online about the assassination that shook the country in September.

Judge Graf also moved Robinson’s preliminary hearing to July 6 through July 10, citing the massive volume of evidence still being reviewed in the high-profile death penalty case.

He claimed this move was necessary so that Robinson’s attorneys would have enough time to review discovery materials. He did, however, acknowledge the public’s interest in moving the case forward without unnecessary delays.

Robinson faces multiple charges, including aggravated murder, in the September 10, 2025, killing of Kirk, the founder of Turning Point USA. The charges are eligible for the death penalty.

In the immediate aftermath of Kirk’s killing, conspiracy theories spread rapidly across social media, podcasts and political forums before authorities had publicly identified a suspect or motive.

The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) summarized some of these theories ahead of court proceedings.

Some commentators falsely claimed the shooter was transgender, echoing broader anti-trans narratives pushed by extremist groups. Others alleged the assassination was part of coordinated political violence by the left, despite federal research showing most political violence in the United States is linked to right-wing extremism. And some conspiracy theories promoted antisemitic claims or alleged that Robinson had been radicalized by college professors.

The defense had sought to block cameras and electronic media coverage, arguing the intense publicity surrounding Kirk’s killing could prejudice potential jurors. They also presented experts who testified that livestreamed proceedings and online commentary could reinforce public bias.

Graf ultimately rejected those arguments, finding they did not justify a blanket ban on cameras.

Policies on cameras and livestreaming vary among states, and many, including Utah give judges discretion over whether to allow cameras. Cameras are generally prohibited in federal courts.

Investigators also disputed claims that media coverage had been uniformly biased against the defense.

“I think the tone of it went both ways. I think some of the tone of it was negative toward the prosecution and some of it was negative toward the defense as well,” Utah County Attorney’s Office investigator Cole Christiansen testified in April. “Some of it was negative toward Erika Kirk, and some of it was negative toward Charlie Kirk.”

The judge also noted that most people consume information about the case through commentary and social media rather than watching proceedings live, meaning a camera ban would not necessarily limit exposure to potentially prejudicial coverage.

Graf further pointed to safeguards already in place, including restrictions on camera placement, courtroom decorum rules and limits on what attorneys can publicly say about the case.

Robinson is scheduled to return to court on May 19.

Ian Watkins was attacked and died in HMP Wakefield where he was allegedly slashed with a make-shift knife with Rico Gedel and Samuel Dodsworth on trial for his murder

A nurse started “screeching” at Ian Watkins’ injuries before the singer “gargled” on his own blood after being attacked in jail, a prison officer said. Rico Gedel, 25, also known as Rashid, and Samuel Dodsworth, 43, are both accused of murdering the former Lostprophets frontman at HMP Wakefield on October 11 and are on trial at Leeds Crown Court.

Watkins, 48, was jailed for 29 years in December 2013 with a further six years on licence, after admitting a string of sex offences – including the attempted rape of a fan’s baby, The Mirror reports.

The court heard how prison officers went to the aid of Watkins after he was allegedly attacked with a makeshift knife, and a nurse also attending to him made a “screeching” sound when she saw the extent of the injuries. It was after this that Watkins began “gargling” before going into cardiac arrest and dying.

Jurors sitting on the trial have so far heard how he suffered three injuries caused by a makeshift knife during a 20-second attack. Footage showing a blood-soaked Watkins emerging from his cell has been released by West Yorkshire Police after jurors were shown it by prosecutor Tom Storey KC.

Both Gedel and Dodsworth deny murdering Watkins. Gedel is accused of carrying out the attack, while Dodsworth is accused of keeping watch and disposing of the weapon in a bin in the recess area.

On Friday, two prison officers gave evidence from the witness box, with one noting he first became aware of Watkins’ injuries while on the landing of B wing.

Advertisement

He said: “I don’t remember the time, but I remember seeing something. From what I remember, I remember stood looking down the landing. I kind of had a bit of a view down the landing but not much of one.

“From what I saw, I saw Mr Watkins come out of his cell, wearing a white T-shirt, and I remember seeing blood down the front of his shirt. He didn’t really do anything, he just kind of stood there and looked towards where me and two other officers were stood.

“He went back towards his cell, like he was trying to get back in for whatever reason. I alerted the two staff members I was stood with in case they didn’t see it and all three of us went to his cell.”

The officer said a colleague went to help Watkins, while he and another went to apprehend Gedel, who he saw punch another inmate. After being apprehended, Gedel was taken to his cell, neighbouring Watkins’. Officers were then said to have carried out a strip search before one kept watch.

Peter Moulson KC, for Gedel, asked the officer if he heard any sentences uttered by Watkins such as: “Get away from my cell you s***stain.” Mr Moulson said: ” And then the ‘N’ word is used in this context, Watkins said: ‘This is an – N word – free zone.’

“Did you hear Watkins to the effect of: ‘If you don’t move from the cell now, I’m going to f****** stab you.’ And finally, from Watkins: ‘I’m going to count to three’ and then the words, ‘One, two’.” The officer said he did not hear any of those statements, but was close enough that he would have heard it if it was said.

Another officer was then called into the courtroom to give evidence and told how he had been in charge of unlocking the cells on the left-side of the wing – where Gedel’s and Watkins’ were situated – on October 11 last year. He said he interacted with both inmates.

Of Gedel, he said they spoke and added: “As I opened his door, I saw it was Mr Gedel and basically said to him, ‘What you done this time?’ And we laughed a bit and had a smirk and I went onto unlock the other cells.”

He said the comment was due to his move onto B wing. He said “sometimes it is just a normal move, but other times prisoners will be moved if there’s been an incident or something similar to that,” reported YorkshireLive.

The next cell the officer unlocked was Watkins. He said: “As I opened his door, he was sat on his bed doing a drawing. I asked what he was drawing and he showed me. It was a picture of another prisoner’s partner and we had a chat and that was that. He did a lot of paintings and drawings.”

After he unlocked the cells, the officer said he then began to carry out cell searches to make sure everything, including the locks and windows, were secure. The officer said he did not think Gedel was in his cell when it was searched, but Watkins was in his. He added: “He was still doing his drawing…”

The officer said he then joined other officers on the landing. He told the court: “I made an observation to the left to look down the landing, and there were two workmen and as they got past Watkins’ cell, one made a gesture, to the left-hand side of his neck, as in a slicing motion.

“At that time, that’s when Mr Watkins’ put his head out of his cell. Mr Watkins’ was leaning out of his cell, so his head was present just outside of the cell structure, and at that moment in time, that’s when I noticed a lot of blood coming away from his neck.

“First instinct, I told the two other members of staff, and we made our way down to Mr Watkins’ cell, and [a colleague] held him and helped him into his cell and we made our way down the stairs to apprehend Mr Gedel.” The officer said it was “fair” to assume Gedel had been involved. He said: “Experience, from myself, I know of Mr Gedel from previous wings. He has carried out numerous assaults from other locations.”

Once Gedel was apprehended, the officer said he went back to Watkins’ cell to assist with treating him. He said: “I could see a cut to his right ear, a large laceration to his right cheek, and also a very large laceration from his left cheek to lower neck.”

The officer said Watkins was “sat in his bed” and was “still conscious and spoke to me”. He said: “I asked if he was ok when I first went in and he said that yes he was fine. I was trying to keep him awake and keep him talking.

“As I showed the nurse the injury to his neck, the nurse was quite shocked and made a ‘screeching’ noise and at that point, I think that’s when Mr Watkins realised what had happened and he deteriorated even further. He fell back onto his bed and was gargling.”

The officer said the nurse then expressed the opinion Watkins was going into cardiac arrest and CPR was administered, but Watkins’ died.

The trial continues.

Starting from under £60,000, the BMW iX3 has a very distinctive front end with a new version of the brand’s ‘kidney’ grilles in the centre which are illuminated for visual drama.

In this instalment of Drive Time, John gets behind the wheel of an exciting BMW Electric SUV and finds out that Mazda is using biofuel on the new CX-5 launch.

The UK market is being flooded with electric SUVs and most of the arrivals have lacked the Wow factor.

BMW has changed that with the launch of the new iX3 which delivers on all fronts.

This newcomer can go up to 500 miles on a single charge and it also boasts a superb interior with lots of new tech and striking exterior looks.

Starting from under £60,000, the iX3 has a very distinctive front end with a new version of the brand’s ‘kidney’ grilles in the centre which are illuminated for visual drama.

The car has clean lines and does without ugly plastic cladding and there are nice LED lights front and rear.

The looks may not be appreciated by everyone but it does stand out from the crowd.

And if the exterior does not blow you away, the interior certainly will.

READ MORE: JOHN MURDOCH’S DRIVE TIME: We get behind the wheel of the new Audi Q3 e-hybrid model and preview Kia’s Seltos SUV

The view from the comfortable seats is dramatic. There is no traditional instrument panel as BMW has dropped it to launch ‘Panoramic iDrive’ – a full width display which runs along the total length of the windscreen and provides all the information you could ever need without having to take your eyes far off the road.

Below that you also get a very large 17.9-inch infotainment touchscreen in an unusual shape.

It is fairly easy to operate but there are lots of menus and sadly you no longer get the rotary dial to operate it.

I only had the car a few days so I did not master it completely but owners should be able to programme their own shortcuts to make things easier.

There is bags of space for four adults to travel in comfort and a 520-litre boot makes it practical for family use.

Another 58 litres of space is available under the bonnet and the cabin has numerous storage areas for smaller items.

The car’s real trump card is its fantastic range. BMW claims it can go 500 miles on a single charge but even if you cannot match that in real world motoring, you will still get over 400 miles without much trouble.

That is truly impressive and puts all its rivals in the shade.

A 11kW home charger will take about 11 hours to charge the car fully and if you can find a 400kW unit at a charging station the car can go from 10-80 per cent in just 20 minutes.

The iX3 is ideal for town driving and it is also a very quiet motorway cruiser.

On twisty country roads it is surprisingly agile despite its hefty 2.3 tonnes and there is very little body roll while the steering is very responsive.

It can sprint to 62mph in just 4.9 seconds and can hit a top speed of 130mph.

The steering wheel is a nice shape but the buttons on it are very small and difficult to use.

All the latest safety kit is fitted to the iX3 including adaptive cruise control, blind spot monitoring, driver attention alert and autonomous emergency braking.

READ MORE: JOHN MURDOCH’S DRIVE TIME: We take a look at KGM Musso all-electric pick-up truck and new CUPRA model

Tax-wise, it will cost you just £10 in the first year but £620 for years 2-6.

Company car drivers will enjoy low Benefit In Kind rates as it falls into the lowest bracket of just three per cent.

This car boasts an astonishing electric range, is great to drive and striking to look at and in my opinion is the best electric SUV on sale at the moment.

In further motoring developments, to demonstrate the potential role sustainable fuels can play in reducing greenhouse gas emissions when used as an alternative to fossil fuels, the launch cars on the Mazda UK all-new Mazda CX-5 launch in Scotland will be powered by a 100 per cent second-generation biofuel with no fossil fuel component.

Provided by SUSTAIN Fuel Technologies, the SUSTAIN 100 95 RON E10 second-generation biofuel is created from biomass such as food and agricultural waste and other non-food by-products.

This content utilises the carbon that already exists in our atmosphere, which plants absorb as they grow, recycling it rather than releasing additional CO2 that is currently locked underground in fossil fuels.

The all-new Mazda CX-5 is powered by a 2.5-litre e-Skyactiv G 141ps petrol engine, paired with 24V Mazda M Hybrid technology, replacing the previous 2.0-litre base unit.

Advertisement

This engine delivers confident performance with improved torque for quicker response, seamless acceleration, and better driving comfort.

Producing 141ps and 238 Nm of torque, the front-wheel drive variant accelerates from 0-62mph in 10.5 seconds, while cylinder de-activation enhances efficiency.

Powering this engine with SUSTAIN 100 95 RON E10 fuel requires no modification and delivers no change in performance.

Continued internal combustion engine development blended with electrification is a well-established example of Mazda’s powertrain innovation, enhancing vehicle efficiency as part of Mazda’s Multi-Solution Approach.

This strategy is well-suited to the application of sustainable fuels as a compelling alternative to fossil fuels and a way of reducing greenhouse gas emissions in combination with efficient engines.

*Don’t miss the latest headlines from around Lanarkshire. Sign up to our newsletters here.

And did you know Lanarkshire Live had its own app? Download yours for free here.

Footage circulating on social media has captured the moment giant waterspouts spiralled off the coast of a popular tourist spot ahead of the summer holidays

Footage circulating on social media has captured the moment giant waterspouts spiralled off the coast of a popular tourist spot.

Southern Spain has been hit by flash floods as violent storms moved through the region head of the summer holidays. Torrential rain triggered flooding on the roads parts of Murcia. Cars could be seen floating in deep floodwater as downpours battered the area.

Several marine tornadoes appeared offshore and witnesses reported seeing at least three waterspouts. The vortexes stretched from dark storm clouds down towards the Mediterranean, the Sun reported.

A waterspout is a rotating column of air that forms over water. It can cause destructive wind gusts. Extreme cases can see winds of up to 250km/h.

Spain’s state weather agency AEMET reiterated severe weather warnings across Campo de Cartagena and authorities issued a yellow alert for thunderstorms, warning of possible hail and powerful gusts of wind.

An orange alert remained in place for torrential rain. Forecasters predicted up to 40mm of rainfall within a single hour.

The conditions are part of a wider storm system hitting eastern and southern parts of the country after weeks of warm weather. Meteorologists have warned of downpours, electrical storms and quickly changing conditions across the region.

This intense weather comes weeks after storms hit Spain in March, killing one person.

More than 250 litres of rain per square metre were recorded in some regions and rivers surge to dangerous levels.

Trains were cancelled, schools were closed and mass evacuations were carried out earlier this year after Storm Leonardo dumped more than 15 inches of rain in just 24 hours.

In Portugal, Storm Leonardo also claimed a life and forced thousands more from their homes.

The Liberal Democrats won 43 out of 45 seats in South Cambridgeshire

South Cambridgeshire’s MP has praised the “stonking” majority won by the Liberal Democrats in South Cambridgeshire today (May 8). The Liberal Democrats won 43 out of 45 seats in the South Cambridgeshire District Council elections, with Conservatives winning the remaining two.

This increases the Liberal Democrats overall seats, as they previously had 34 seats. MP Pippa Heylings (Lib Dem) shared her thoughts on the win.

MP Heylings said it was a “stonking” win for her party. She added that Reform had “completely taken over the Conservatives” across Cambridgeshire, but also nationally.

However, she said those who had voted for the Liberal Democrats in South Cambridgeshire had “rejected the more divisive and Trump-like” politics by voting for the party.

Advertisement

She added that the win was “evidence in South Cambridgeshire and across the country that the Liberal Democrats can beat Reform” and people were “choosing” them.

Earlier in the day, Councillor Bridget Smith, leader of the council and Liberal Democrat candidate, retained her seat for the Gamlingay ward. She said she was “delighted” with her win. She added that it was “lovely” that the voters put their “faith” in her.

Before the majority win was announced, Cllr Smith said she “expected the Liberal Democrats to have a really exciting day”.

With the Liberal Democrats winning the majority, it mean the Conservatives lost out on seven seats they previously held. Of the two seats that the Conservatives lost included longstanding councillors Bunty Waters for Bar Hill and Sue Ellington for Swavesey.

However, leader of the opposition Councillor Heather Williams retained her seat for The Mordens ward. On the loss, she said: “It’s not unexpected, nationally it’s quite clear there were going to be losses. We are in a five party situation, all of us have to adapt to that.”

She added that she was “very proud” of the Conservative candidates that won, and also the others that put themselves forward.

She also said: “I’ve had a cursory look and When you look at the votes compared to previous years, that vote has come down.”

However, Heather did offer her congratulations to the Liberal Democrats.

The 14-month-old boy has been fighting for his life after inhaling the common ingredient used to decorate cakes and other desserts while his mum was making a birthday cake

The family of a toddler who was put into an induced coma after inhaling cake decorating power has issued a heart-warming update on his condition.

The 14-month-old boy has been fighting for his life after inhaling the common ingredient used to decorate cakes and other desserts. Katie Robinson, a professional baker in Australia, was making a Bluey-themed birthday cake for a friend’s son when her own child grabbed a container of gold decorating dust.

Little Dustin was rushed into emergency surgery at Brisbane’s Queensland Children’s Hospital in Australia to remove decorative lustre dust that had turned to paste in his lungs.

Katie said has now said that the Gold Coast boy is breathing well on his own as he continues to recover from incident.

“Dusty has had his breathing tube taken out and now has high flow oxygen through nasal prongs,” she wrote in an update to those who have donated to help support the family via GoFundMe.

“His meds have decreased but he is still in a drowsy state. The doctors are happy with his progression, however still unsure about lasting effects on the lungs.”

Over 1000 people have donated to the family via the platform and more than $50,000 has been raised in just four days.

“Thank you so so much for the incredible amount of love and support for Dusty and his family!” the organiser Rochelle Evrard – a long-time client of Katie’s and the person she was making a Bluey cake for at the time of the accident – wrote on Friday.

“We have well and truly exceeded expectations from the community. Not only with monetary donations but our inboxes have been flooded with support and offers of help and accommodation.”

The little boy was being supervised in the studio of his home while his mum put the finishing touches on the cake. It is understood that he pulled down a tube of lustre dust powder before he began choking.

“Within seconds [he] had just pulled it off with his teeth, the cap, and just inhaled it and ingested it at the same time,” Katie told an Australian news site earlier this week.

“He was just choking and getting upset, and you could tell that he was starting to struggle to breathe.”

Dustin’s parent’s Katie and Chris began first aid while calling emergency responders.

“In the time it took for the ambulance to get there, he was not breathing well. He was grunting, really low grunt and then trying to take a quick, sharp breath in,” Katie added.

“His body was flopping around, his eyes were rolling in his head, and he was just getting unresponsive. I was trying to slap his cheeks, call out his name, and he just wasn’t opening his eyes. So [it] got really scary at that point.”

Dustin required surgery to “flush out his lungs” using a saline solution. Medical professionals later determined that the dust contained copper.

Copper can trigger respiratory distress, severe lung damage and even long-term chronic damage when ingested.

“It’s just not a product that you would expect to be anywhere near anything that has to do with food,” Katie said.

“All the doctors have said this is such a rare case … they haven’t really seen this before. So it’s been a difficult one for everyone.”

The dust was labelled for use on removal parts of a cake.

Facing criticism of their handling of the closure of Reeth Medical Centre, senior NHS officials told about 300 people who attended a public meeting at St Andrew’s Church, in Grinton, today (FRIDAY) that they followed the statutory process at all times over the issue.

The officers from NHS Humber and North Yorkshire ICB said distributing the centre’s 1,600 patients to neighbouring practices was the only option they were left with when the only bidder to take over the centre was found to be unsuitable.

The Wensleydale-based Central Dales Practice had stepped in to provide a two-day-a-week branch service in Reeth.

Practice staff were holding talks with the owners of the existing centre owners, Dr Mike Brookes and Marie Brookes, whose retirement has prompted the closure, the audience was told.

But the meeting of North Yorkshire Council’s scrutiny of health committee heard from patients who were still deeply concerned about the ICB’s involvement and the level of service patients could expect in the future.

Mother-of-two Hannah Waggett said: “Timely health interventions are at risk from the current proposal of just two days a week when appointments are available the full five days a week currently.

“If our children aren’t able to be seen in a timely manner, that is unacceptable.”

Patient Deborah Kerrigan asked the ICB what checks had been done to ensure the proposed changes would not put patients at risk and lead to a preventable loss of life.

She said members of the community felt “frightened, scared and still in the dark, adding: “Assigning somebody a GP at a surgery they can’t access because they have no car, there is no public transport, or the only road is both due to weather or roadworks — this really does happen here — has the same impact as not having a GP at all.”

Jill McMullon, chair of Hawes and High Abbotside Parish Council, questioned what the impact of the changes would be on existing Central Dales Practice patients and whether the plans being put in place were sustainable.

She said: “Rural areas deserve the same care as those living in towns and cities.

“The ICB has demonstrated a lack of care and a distinct disregard and lack of understanding for the area they cover.

“Their suggestion that over 1,200 patients could simply be transferred to Hawes was frankly ludicrous.”

In response to the criticism, after being asked why there had been no apology, Lisa Pope, the ICB’s deputy place director for North Yorkshire, said: “If people feel that there is something that we could have done differently within our responsibilities and as an ICB, then I absolutely apologise, if we have made people feel unsafe, unclear or unconsulted with.”

Asked how patients could continue to be kept safe, the senior officer said: “I think the answer is that you will be every bit as safe under the care of the Central Dales Practice as you have been under the care of Mike and Marie Brookes.”

But the ICB officials rejected criticism of the organisation’s communications, saying they had been unable to announce the closure during the process to find a new operator due to statutory requirements.

The meeting was told that the ICB attempted to find a new operator for the medical centre, but although there were a number of enquiries, only one bid was submitted which patients were told was not suitable.

Ms Pope stressed that the ICB had not chosen to close the medical centre, adding: “This is not an ICB decision, this is not a commissioning decision; it’s a decision that’s been made by the partners and the ICB is then duty bound to follow a distinct process that was set out in the statute of law and we’ve done that and we’ve done it at the times that we’ve been able to do that.”

The meeting heard concerns that no succession planning had been undertaken ahead of Dr Brookes’ retirement.

However, Dr Valerie Taylor, who has worked at the medical centre, told the meeting that Dr Brookes had made attempts over a number of years to find a GP to take over the business.

The ICB said they were unaware that the Reeth Medical Centre partners were going to hand back their contract until they gave notice in November last year.

He continued: “My message to Downing Street tonight is very, very clear – they have got a lot of listening to do to the fact that Labour have been hammered here in Scotland and an SNP Government, after 19 years in office, has just been emphatically returned to office, and Scotland needs respect as a consequence of that election outcome.”