Connect with us

NewsBeat

Iranian school hit early in the war is now a memorial to children

Published

on

Iranian school hit early in the war is now a memorial to children

MINAB, Iran (AP) — This will never be a school again.

Its bright blue gate is still painted with the symbols that once welcomed children: Iran’s map, oversized pencils and portraits of legends in science and literature.

But now, the walkway beyond it guides visitors past rows of photographs. They show children busy living, at birthday parties and more. Then come the same small faces on black banners of mourning.

This is the emerging memorial to the schoolchildren killed in the attack in the earliest moments of the war that the United States and Israel began across Iran on Feb. 28. Strikes hit the Shajareh Tayyebeh school in Minab.

Advertisement

Iranian officials said more than 100 students were killed. Months later, the Trump administration still has not directly accepted responsibility for the strike or released the Pentagon’s findings, even as an Associated Press investigation found evidence that at least one U.S. missile hit the school.

Attention turned to Minab again in the past week when a new round of U.S. strikes along Iran’s southern coast struck a wedding and other areas, sending some of the injured to a hospital in the community.

The AP visited the badly damaged two-story building whose classrooms remain frozen mid-lesson, with desks half buried and ceilings collapsed.

There have been calls to preserve the ruins as a historical record. Hormozgan Gov. Mohammad Ashouri Taziani has said the building would be turned into a war museum and memorial.

Advertisement

Nearby, a section of Minab’s cemetery has been dedicated to those killed. Families and others move quietly across the grave-marked artificial grass.

Residents said three bodies still have not been found.

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

NewsBeat

Aldi vs Lidl: The latest development in the budget supermarket wars

Published

on

Aldi vs Lidl: The latest development in the budget supermarket wars
The two budget retailers are battling it out to open a new store (Picture: Getty Images)

When it comes to supermarket rivalries, there’s none quite so interesting (and fierce) as the one raging between Aldi and Lidl. 

The German budget retailers go head-to-head each month in a bid to be crowned the UK’s cheapest supermarket, and more often than not it’s Aldi that’s victorious.

But in their latest battle, it’s looking like it might be Lidl that’ll come out on top.

The big brands are both keen to open a new store in one of the UK’s poshest towns, and a verdict as to which one will be able to do so is imminent.

Advertisement
People enjoying the sunshine outside a cafe in the old market town of Holt in Norfolk, England. The buildings housing Byfords cafe and shop are thought to be among the oldest in the town.
Holt was recently ranked the 7th poshest town in Britain (Picture: Getty Images)

Aldi and Lidl have both submitted planning applications to build new stores in Holt in Norfolk, with Lidl wanting to open off Nightjar Road and Aldi off Old Station Way.

The market town, which is the epitome of a ‘chocolate box town’, is made up of quaint flint and red brick buildings, cute cobbled courtyards, and independent businesses, art galleries and boutiques.

It’s also home to Gresham’s Private School, which has had some notable alumni over the years, including Olivia Coleman, Sir James Dyson, and W.H. Auden.

For those unfamiliar with the area, Holt previously came in 7th place in The Telegraph’s ranking of Britain’s 15 poshest towns.

The frontage and brand logo of a branch of German discount retailer Aldi, taken in a local retail park on Wirral, UK on a sunny afternoon
Aldi wants to open off Old Station Way (Picture: Getty Images)

As such, some locals don’t think the budget brands are suitable for their ‘beautiful Georgian’ town; but others welcome the idea, as the current grocery options aren’t the most affordable.

Ask Metro


Advertisement

Use AI to go deeper into the stories you care about – powered by Metro and trusted publications.

There’s a Budgens store at Kerridge Way, a Morrisons Daily inside a BP petrol station, and a food hall inside Bakers & Larners, the town’s very own luxury independent department store.

Taking to Facebook, Hayden Cunningham said: ‘We desperately need an Aldi; not only is it going to be a cheaper alternative to Budgens, but it will bring a lot more job opportunities to a lot of us out here. Besides that, I can’t see why anybody would say no to this; if you don’t wanna shop at Aldi then just don’t. Simple as.’

Advertisement

Similarly, Shane Webster commented: ‘As much as I would love to afford to do my weekly shop in Bakers & Larners, reality has to kick in, so yes please Aldi we welcome you.’

As Alan Raymond Palmer shared: ‘A new supermarket is vital.’

Nicola Smith wasn’t so keen though, sharing: ‘Just a lot of tat in Aldi and Lidl. Would be lovely to get a decent supermarket.’

And Mandy Mops asked: ‘Why oh why do we need two budget supermarkets in this beautiful Georgian town and so close to each other?’

Advertisement
Lidl supermarket store exterior, with woman shopper outside the entrance.;
Planners think Lidl should be given the green light for a Holt store (Picture: Shutterstock / Paul Maguire)

To answer Mandy’s question, Holt doesn’t need two supermarkets. In fact, North Norfolk District Council has been warned that allowing both to open could have ‘significantly adverse’ consequences for the town.

As reported by the Eastern Daily Press (EDP), independent retail consultants at Nexus told the council the town centre ‘cannot survive’ both stores opening. They said trade at Budgens could fall by as much as 30 per cent, with the wider town centre ‘facing a hit of up to 22.6 per cent’.

It was decided that one store would not cause such harm to Holt, and it’s therefore been recommended that only one of the planning applications be approved.

But which one will they pick?

Capture of two big German discounter supermarkets; at left side is Lidl, at right side is Aldi S??d. View and shot from center of street between supermarkets. In street is some traffic. Ruhrgebiet.
Who will win the budget retailer war? (Picture: Getty Images)

Aldi’s site is said to be the better of the two in planning terms, as the land at Old Station Way is closer to the town centre, and has been identified as suitable for a food store in the Holt Neighbourhood Plan.

Lidl’s plot, on the other hand, is further out on the edge of town and was never intended for retail use.

Advertisement

Despite this, it isn’t looking good for Aldi, as part of their planning proposal includes access to the busy A148 bypass, which has been deemed ‘unacceptable in the interests of road safety’ by Norfolk County Council’s highways department.

As such, planners have recommended Lidl be given the green light at a North Norfolk District Council development committee meeting set to take place on Thursday, September 10.

And Lidl is confident they’ll be the right choice.

Do you shop at Aldi or Lidl?

Andrew Hodgkinson, regional head of property at Lidl GB, recently told the EDP: ‘Holt residents have been clear that they want a Lidl store in the town and we are ready to deliver one.

‘With capacity for only one discounter in Holt, Lidl is the only realistic and deliverable option, and we are ready to get spades in the ground should planning permission be granted on Thursday.’

Advertisement

However, Lidl shouldn’t celebrate just yet, as committee members don’t have to follow the recommendations from planners, so Aldi could still get the votes.

And Aldi has been actively encouraging the people of Holt to show support and let the council know how much they want the retailer to open there, with an online form.

So, the war wages on and we’ll have to wait and see what happens next…

Do you have a story you’d like to share? Get in touch by emailing MetroLifestyleTeam@metro.co.uk

Advertisement
Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Dramatic police chase in Fife as cops deploy spike strips before arrest

Published

on

Daily Record

Police were first alerted to reports that a Vauxhall Mokka had collided with a lamp post and fence on Bruce Road in Glenrothes at around 7.45am on Sunday.

A man has been arrested and is in hospital after officers were forced to use spike strips following a police chase in Fife.

Advertisement

Cops were first alerted to reports that a Vauxhall Mokka had collided with a lamp post and fence on Bruce Road in Glenrothes at around 7.45am on Sunday, September 6. As officers approached, the vehicle made off, sparking a dramatic pursuit throughout the town.

Footage shared with the Record showed police throwing down spike strips outside the Lidl store on Leslie Road as the car was eventually brought to a halt. Cops could then be seen grabbing the driver and pulling him out of the vehicle before he was arrested.

The man was also taken to hospital, where he currently remains. His condition is not yet known.

Advertisement

Dozens of police could be seen in attendance and the black Vauxhall Mokka was spotted with a large dent at the front as it was later recovered. Detectives say their enquires into establishing the full circumstances of the incident remain ongoing.

A Police Scotland spokesperson said: “Around 7.45am on Sunday, September 6, 2206, a Vauxhall Mokka collided with a lamp post and fence on Bruce Road, Glenrothes.

“As officers approached, the vehicle made off and a pursuit took place until the car was brought to a stop by officers in Leslie Road and the driver, a 45-year-old man, was arrested. The 45-year-old was taken to hospital where he remains. Enquiries are ongoing.”

Advertisement

Get more Daily Record exclusives by signing up for free to Google’s preferred sources. Click HERE.

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Wales breaking news plus weather and traffic updates (Sunday, September 6)

Published

on

Wales Online

A lifeboat was launched after a person fell overboard from a dinghy near the Menai Bridge.

At 3.06pm on Thursday, September 3, HM Coastguard volunteers at Beaumaris received a page relating to a report of a person having fallen into the water.

The Beaumaris Atlantic 85 inshore lifeboat and the Mobile Coastguard Rescue team from Bangor attended the scene and discovered the casualty and his craft had been recovered to the shore by a passing vessel.

Advertisement

The casualty refused medical treatment but was advised to be alert for secondary drowning symptoms.

The lifeboat was then stood down by the Coastguard.

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Plan for 18 new Scarborough homes at previously rejected site

Published

on

Plan for 18 new Scarborough homes at previously rejected site

​A planning application has been submitted to North Yorkshire Council for the development of 18 homes on land at Carr House, Snainton, near Scarborough.

The proposal, put forward by Mulgrave Developments Ltd, outlines plans to construct 16 new houses and convert an existing dwelling into two homes.

​The site, which is located off Green Lane, about 13km southwest of Scarborough, includes an agricultural barn, which would be demolished under the new plans.

​The application also includes associated access and drainage works, with a focus on improving the existing conditions of Green Lane.

Advertisement

​This application follows a previous proposal for 19 homes on the same site, which was refused by the council in 2024.

Proposed Elevations Plot Two. Housing Plan For Land Off Carr House, North Of Green Lane And East Of Station Road In Snainton, Scarborough. Courtesy Of Applicant

​The refusal was based on concerns about insufficient information regarding the impact on protected species and biodiversity, inadequate highway safety measures, and failure to provide affordable housing. An appeal against the decision was also later dismissed.

​According to submitted plans, the new application includes a revised layout to improve safety and the character of Green Lane, a reduction in the density of housing, and an increase in soft landscaping and public open space.

The housing mix has also been adjusted, with the new proposal consisting of eleven two-bed properties, four three-bed properties, and three four-bed dwellings.

Advertisement

​Each plot would come with parking for two vehicles and “the majority of plots” would benefit from access to a garage.

​“To reflect the local vernacular, the dwellings would be constructed of artificial stone with concrete double pantile roofs in either rustic or cayenne red, thereby reinforcing the more modern development theme present on either side of Station Road and reflecting the palette of materials used with the settlement,” the submitted plans state.

​North Yorkshire Council has not set a date for deciding on the plans, which are open to representations from members of the public.

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Arsenal vs Chelsea – Premier League LIVE: Kai Havertz levels for Gunners in thrilling first half

Published

on

Arsenal vs Chelsea - Premier League LIVE: Kai Havertz levels for Gunners in thrilling first half

Advertisement

Follow Daily Mail Sport’s coverage of Arsenal’s game against Chelsea in the Premier League from the Emirates.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Kit in agony on Coronation Street as he clutches his chest – and violence follows | Soaps

Published

on

Kit in agony on Coronation Street as he clutches his chest - and violence follows | Soaps

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web
browser that
supports HTML5
video

A life-changing diagnosis is causing Kit Green (Jacob Roberts) to rapidly unravel on Coronation Street… and he wasn’t particularly known for his restraint to begin with.

Advertisement

The Cobbles copper Kit Green was blown away when his sister Gemma Winter-Brown (Dolly-Rose Campbell) learned that due to a death of their estranged aunt from cancer, the BRCA gene runs in their family.

Both she and their mother Bernie Winter (Jane Hazlegrove) decided to get tested, while Kit started to wonder if the gene could be linked to some of his current health concerns. This, of course, could also mean that Brody (Ryan Mulvey), Kit’s biological son, could be at risk too.

Kit was totally blindsided to realise that his family carried the BRACA gene. (Picture: ITV)

The Winter family have been devastated after consulting with Dr Gaddas, which caused Kit to spiral further. Bitterly reflecting on his life before Bernie made contact with him in 2024, Kit unfairly branded his mum the source of all his drama and branded his heartbroken mum ‘a curse’.

Although Kit has got tested offscreen, so far he has made the decision to keep his family in the dark about his diagnosis.

Advertisement

However, he ends up confiding in the most unlikely person imaginableTodd Grimshaw (Gareth Pierce).

In this video, we see Kit at his lowest when Todd finds him in the backyard brooding. Drawing on his own experience suffering Theo’s abuse in silence,Todd wrongly assumes that Kit is still not over Sarah Platt (Tina O’Briensplitting up with him from prison and encourages him to unburden. However, Todd gets the shock of his life when Kit reveals that he has cancer.

In a recent interview, actor Jacob Roberts, who portrays Kit, shared some insight into Kit’s decision to share this deeply personal news with Todd.

‘I think that happens in real life as well. You end up telling people who are not actually connected with you,’ Jacob reckoned.

Advertisement

Ask Metro


Use AI to go deeper into the stories you care about – powered by Metro and trusted publications.

‘He feels safe with Todd because I also feel like Todd has his back,’ Jacob said.’ He can tell Todd certain things that won’t go further, as it does on the street. It catches like wildfire. But with Todd, I think he’ll keep his secrets.

Advertisement

‘And it’s just to offload why he’s being a certain way. And maybe Todd gets him in that certain situation.’

Breast cancer in males

Common symptoms can include

  • A painless lump or swelling under the nipple or areola.
  • An inverted or retracted nipple that turns inward.
  • Nipple discharge or bleeding.
  • Skin dimpling, puckering, or scaling on the chest.
  • Sores (ulcers) on the chest or nipple area.

Risk factors include

  • Older age, most frequently diagnosed in men in their 60s.
  • Inherited BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene mutations.
  • High oestrogen levels linked to obesity or liver disease.
  • Genetic conditions such as Klinefelter syndrome.

Statistics

  • Around 400 to 420 men are diagnosed with breast cancer in the UK every year. For comparison, roughly 59,000 women are diagnosed annually.
  • Approximately 1 in 870 men in the UK will be diagnosed with breast cancer during their lifetime.
  • There are around 85 deaths from male breast cancer each year in the UK. Since the early 1970s, male breast cancer mortality rates have decreased by about 47%.
  • While breast cancer diagnoses in UK women have risen by roughly a quarter since the early 1990s, incidence rates in men have remained stable.

Sadly, Kit’s week only gets worse from there. After all the pent-up rage and fear of suffering in silence becomes too much to bear… with violent results.

In next week’s trip to Coronation Street, Kit ends up colliding with Ross Wilkes (Ian Burfield), the sleazy no-good dad of  Tyrone Dobbs (Alan Halsall)

Advertisement

When Kit accidentally bumps into Ross in the pub, it causes him to spill his drinks. Suddenly Kit doubles over clutching his chest in pain, prompting Ross to accuse him of making a mountain out of a molehill.

Finally snapping, Kit completely loses his rag at Ross. I won’t spoil exactly what he does… but it ain’t pretty.

Has Kit just put his job as a police officer at risk?

Advertisement

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Cameras on school streets ‘a sensible move’ whilst others say they ‘don’t get it’

Published

on

Cambridgeshire Live

Cambridgeshire County Council is considering using ANPR cameras to enforce school streets, which restrict car movements at drop-off and pick-up times to reduce pollution and encourage walking and other active travel methods

CambridgeshireLive readers have heard that Cambridgeshire County Council is considering using cameras to enforce school street restrictions, which limit vehicle access during school drop off and pick up times. The measures are designed to reduce traffic and pollution around schools while encouraging walking and other forms of active travel.

The council’s highways and transport committee has been asked to approve a report setting out plans to use cameras to enforce traffic restrictions. Officers said “initial planning work” had already begun on installing Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) cameras to enforce turning restrictions on roads including Downing Street.

Advertisement

They are also exploring whether the same technology could be used to enforce school streets, although further assessment would be needed before any decision is made.

Cllr Darren Green, who represents Romsey, said he was “very, very happy” that the council was considering the move. He said: “We know already that school streets can be very fragile and rely on a lot of volunteer work, and best practice would be to back this all up with a camera system. “I hope going forward, once this is in place, that we can prioritise using cameras on school streets.”

However, Cllr Alex Beckett, chair of the committee, stressed that volunteers would continue to play an important role even if cameras were introduced. He said seeing members of the community volunteering to protect their local school can have a greater impact than relying solely on cameras operated by the council. He added that volunteers at some school streets had faced harassment, meaning cameras could ultimately prove a better option in those locations.

Commenter Poppythecat thinks: “This is a very sensible move, ANPR cameras should also be monitoring cycle lanes and fining any drivers driving in or parking on them. They should be sent a copy of the highway code with every fine handed out.”

Advertisement

Dragon33 disagrees: “I don’t get it. There is a swing gate in Norfolk st near St Matthew’s that stops cars going through anyway during school drop off isn’t there? So why have ANPR cameras? Seems like another Vinery Rd LTN in the making.”

Cotonboy48 adds: “In principle this is a good thing, but it will need greater resources to administrate any enforcements and will they be mandatory? Where is the financing coming from? The County Council seems to have little money for urgent road matters, let alone for another scheme. Perhaps have offenders’ cars impounded?”

Click2018 says: “So can you get in touch with my employers and tell them I won’t be in work till 10am and that all front line calls need to be on hold?! Ever think parents have to work and schools have strict drop off times? No, OK I’ll claim housing benefit from the council when I’m jobless!”

Lycralad90 suggests: “Why not get them to walk to school? If they need dropping off in a car you live too far from the school and your kids are in the wrong catchment area.”

Advertisement

Throatwobblermangrove thinks: “Another foregone decision masquerading as safety improvements. Monitoring school drop-off and pick-up times is one thing. But how long before the cameras and restrictions are quietly imposed 24/7, to feed the council’s mindless crusade against convenient transport?”

Tartan53 agrees: “Are the council up to their usual smoking mirror routine? Surely this is the first step in getting the hardware installed for a future congestion charge?”

Marty S adds: “Won’t be long before you’re having to pay just to pick your kids up from school in your car.”

Dominic G asks: “What is the legal basis for ‘school streets?’ I believe there isn’t one? So how can restrictions be enforced if they are not legal?”

Advertisement

Emma W replies: “Schools can apply to the council to close the street for a short while for drop off and pick up time. Usually monitored by either school staff or volunteer parents. Obviously the streets are not through roads. My previous school applied and as they were towards the beginning of a cul-de-sac, it was approved. Residents were able to go in and out, but tended to avoid the closed times just to make it easier for everyone.”

Cambridgeshire Live readers, what do you think? Should cameras be used to enforce school streets, or is this just another way of penalising parents who need to drive their children to school? Have your say in our comments section.

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Liam Gallagher’s incredible life advice for young Oasis fans in new film

Published

on

Daily Mirror

EXCLUSIVE We go inside the mind of Liam Gallagher as he gives thoughts on a range of subjects in Disney+ documentary Don’t Look Back In Anger

The new Oasis film gives fans a real insight in Liam Gallagher ’s mind in a way they have never seen before – giving his verdict on dancing, drinking and even going to bed early. The 53-year-old is always highly entertaining on social media platform ‘X’ but his opinions are often laced in humour.

In Don’t Look Back In Anger sat alongside his brother Noel, the singer gives his views on a range of issues. Giving some life rules to younger Oasis fans, Liam says: “You ain’t gonna get through this f**king life, by not making mistakes. Because you are not f**king robots, d’you know what I mean?

“So go out and have fun, get up in the morning, do your day’s graft and don’t be a c***. And if you are going to be a c*** be a funny one. Live your life and have a good f**king time. Try not to listen to those the doom gloomers, like the politicians and that. Some people can’t be helped. That is what life is about.

Advertisement

“If there is any of that to come from it[the tour] I’m all for it. But the main thing is put the phones down, that’s a start. Sing your hearts out and have a good time. Get drunk and fall over and p**s your pants. Who gives a s**t.

“There is always tomorrow to clean that mess up. Y’know what I mean?”

However, despite telling younger people to party hard, Liam’s days of drinking to those levels of excess seem to be mainly beyond him. He gave up cigarettes for the 2025 tour.

Advertisement

When Noel says he can no longer drink Guinness until 4am, Liam says: “The thing is you get sick of the same s*** that comes out of your mouth. Years ago everything that came out of your mouth was mega. Or come out your mate’s mouth was mega.

“After a while a bit you just go ‘Im full of s***, he’s full of s***. He knows I’m full of s*** and I know he’s full of s***. It’s just like ‘I’m going to bed’. I’ve heard these conversations a million times. But when you’re 20 its the gospel.”

Turning to his stage persona and offering his thoughts on another iconic frontman, Rolling Stones singer Mick Jagger, Liam says: “Another little bit of magic is someone goes stand still.

“Because you are gonna be doing this when you’re f**king 60 and you’re gonna have two double hip operations.

Advertisement

“You don’t wanna be doing that Mick Jagger s***. Mick Jagger must sit there and go ‘I can’t be f**king arsed with this Jumping Jack Flash nonsense. I just wanna stand there and of my thing. But he has gotta go out there and do kung fu kicks and splits and all that. He must sit there and go ‘I can’t be arsed tonight’. All I have gotta do is just stand there. It is genius.”

This comment makes his brother crack up laughing, as will some of the cinema audiences no doubt. The pair were also seen laughing and joking again at the weekend in Venice. Noel compares Liam’s life to the opening line of Oasis song Supersonic ‘I need to be myself, I can’t be no one else’. Noel says: “That’s what he lives his life by, he is who he is and that’s the end of that, and he’s not going to change. I forgot how funny he was.”

He later adds: “There’s two Liams, the one that turns up at rehearsals and there’s the guy on stage who bounces a tambourine on his head. And makes it look cool. You know if I did that I’d look like a utter c****. But somehow he does it and it’s the greatest thing I’ve ever seen. I’d forgotten what he means to people.”

Liam also shows a more mature side in the film when he discusses the death of close friend Gary ‘Mani’ Mounfield in November. This loss weighs heavily on both Gallagher brothers but it has even made Liam reassess things. He says: “Very sad man, very sad. Makes you realise life is precious. The penny dropped, no more bulls*** anymore.”

Advertisement

Welcome to the Liam Gallagher of 2026. In bed early, protecting his vocal chords between gigs and still as hilarious as ever. Fans – and his brother Noel – will hope things continue and he doesn’t let things slide away again.

* Oasis: Don’t Look Back In Anger opens in IMAX and UK Cinema on September 9.

Like this story? For more of the latest showbiz news and gossip, follow Mirror Celebs on TikTok, Snapchat, Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and Threads.

Advertisement

Source link

Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Arsenal FC vs Chelsea LIVE: Premier League match stream, latest team news, lineups, TV, prediction

Published

on

Arsenal FC vs Chelsea LIVE: Premier League match stream, latest team news, lineups, TV, prediction

The biggest game of the new Premier League so far sees the two London rivals face off in a game which promises early clues to this campaign’s title race. The champions host Xabi Alonso’s new-look side as both put their 100 per cent starts to the season on the line. The Gunners, arguably, have more to lose, but have not tasted defeat against the Blues in five years.

Source link

Continue Reading

NewsBeat

Harriet Taylor Mill, the radical feminist philosopher who lived in the shadow of her husband

Published

on

Harriet Taylor Mill, the radical feminist philosopher who lived in the shadow of her husband

I first heard about Harriet Taylor Mill when reading about her much more famous collaborator and future husband, the British philosopher and politician John Stuart Mill.

Appropriately for someone who remains in the margins of history despite her enormous contribution – including to her husband’s status – Taylor Mill was deeply angered by injustice. Throughout her life, she railed against the way society made it impossible for women to freely develop their individuality, arguing this was important for everybody – not just men.

In Enfranchisement of Women (1851), Taylor Mill’s only solo-authored essay published during her lifetime, she asked why women were still regarded as “mere appendages” to men without interests of their own. Her answer was characteristically blunt: “The only reason which can be given is that men like it.”

More than 20 years before her husband’s best-known work, On Liberty (1859) was published without any credit for her contribution, she had outlined what would become famous in that book as the “harm principle”: “Every human being has the right to all personal freedom which does not interfere with the happiness of some other.”

Advertisement

Miniature oil portrait of Harriet Taylor Mill (nee Hardy), 1807-58.
LSE Library via Wikimedia, CC BY-SA

Her arguments were always on the side of independence, her sympathies with the powerless and oppressed. She astutely diagnosed the key political and economic question posed by the industrial revolution as being whether “the lot of the poor should be regulated for them, or by them”.

Taylor Mill was also a ferocious defender of “the pleasure of self-dependence” and the right to free speech. Her views were summarised in a programme of reform she outlined in the late 1840s that would be radical if instituted today, never mind two centuries ago.

She called for the establishment of secular educational schools and universities, complete freedom of speech, all occupations to be equally open to men and women, radical limits to the amount people could inherit – and for marriage “to be like any other partnership: dissoluble at pleasure”.

Advertisement

With words that were often witty and pithy, Taylor Mill cut to the heart of issues in political thought such as patriarchy, socio-economic justice and freedom. In my view, she is long overdue a more significant place in the canon of western social philosophy.

Vulnerable to abuse and exploitation

In the 1830s, while tending to three young children from her first marriage, Taylor Mill wrote for the Westminster Review on a variety of political and philosophical subjects, from colonialism in Australia to Plato via political biographies. Her critiques were always pro-democratic and anti-aristocratic.

Portrait of John Stuart Mill

Portrait of John Stuart Mill by George Frederic Watts (1892).
Wikimedia Commons

She also wrote many unpublished articles on the social, political and economic structures which rendered women vulnerable to abuse and exploitation by their spouses – and on the ethics of love, marriage and divorce. Her invocation of the principle that “the higher the kind of enjoyment, the greater the degree” foreshadowed Mill’s distinction between higher and lower pleasures in his book Utilitarianism, three decades later.

In the 1840s and ’50s, the Mills co-authored a series of excoriating newspaper articles on violence, especially domestic abuse. They railed at the unwillingness of the judicial system and police to tackle this issue, and the power inequalities which rendered people – especially women and those in subordinate positions – so vulnerable to brutality. Many of these arguments still resonate today.

Advertisement

Perfect equality was Taylor Mill’s ideal – in politics, the workplace and the home. But by this she did not mean equality of outcome. In their writings, the Mills endorsed a merit-based system of reward based on people’s efforts and talents, rather than what they had inherited.

They called for a “higher standard of justice” which would enable everyone to “work according to their capacity, and receive according to their wants”.

Ignored and even denied

Despite her lifelong commitment to fighting injustice and inequality, Taylor Mill’s immense contribution to her own husband’s work has largely been ignored – and even denied.

To be fair, Mill often sought to give authorial credit where it was due. But his earliest attempts were stymied by Harriet’s first husband, who felt it would draw too much attention to the Mills’ unconventional relationship.

Advertisement

When they eventually married in 1851, Mill tried to divest himself of the “power and control” over his wife which their marriage would legally grant him. He wrote: “I put on record a formal protest against the existing law of marriage … [and] repudiate all pretension to have acquired any rights whatever by virtue of [it].”

Later, Mill carefully catalogued in his autobiography how many of the works published as “his” were, in fact, his efforts as “a mediator” between Taylor Mill and the public. He highlighted his “interpretations” of her ideas – often combined with inputs from the many fields in which he was a scholar.

Extract from Enfanchisement of Women by Harriet Taylor Mill. Video: History Hub.

Mill also re-published the celebrated essay Enfranchisement of Women, which had originally been published anonymously, under Taylor Mill’s name – and set correspondents straight about its authorship when they wrote to congratulate him, thinking it was his work.

Advertisement

But curiously, Mill’s desire to sing her praises for her work was used as an excuse to ignore her. According to one 1874 essay, published shortly after Mill’s death: “Men have been blinded by affection and bewitched by womankind … [but] John Stuart Mill out-Herods them all.”

In the view of this and many other critics, Mill’s love for his friend and eventual wife completely clouded his judgment of her intellectual capacities, about which he had been entirely deceived – or, at the very least, been “myopic”.

A hundred years after this “Harriet Taylor Mill myth” emerged, it was given a Freudian twist. Mill was said to have chosen her as a partner because she had the same first name as his mother, but the personality of his father.

This view was echoed as recently as 2022 when a biography argued that Mill – brought up in a “totalitarian micro-state” by his father – needed someone else from whom to take “orders” after his death. Other academics such as Jo Ellen Jacobs have refuted such perspectives as misogynistic.

Advertisement

Taylor Mill may well have expected such shoddy treatment in the years after her death in Avignon, France in 1858. But in the 21st century, it is high time she were recognised as an incisive, influential thinker in her own right.

Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending

Copyright © 2025