North Yorkshire BESS schemes branded ‘zombie’ projects

Both the Mowbray scheme, proposed for land near East Rounton, between Northallerton and Yarm, and the Bellmoor project, planned on farmland at South Kilvington, near Thirsk, have been given ‘gate one’ status by the National Energy System Operator (NESO).

The listing means the projects no longer have a firm date for connection to the national grid.

Campaigners say the change in status is further reason why the schemes should be rejected.

NESO has reformed its register of planned energy projects to prioritise schemes which are ready for connection.

Schemes which are ready to proceed have been given ‘gate two’ status.

Experts say there are too many BESS projects in the pipeline with more than 200GW of storage planned, which is far more than the UK will need in the coming decades.

Hundreds of people have submitted objections to the planning applications for the BESS schemes, which are currently being assessed by North Yorkshire Council.

Andrew Sheldon-Thomson, from online group Stop Battery Storage – Northallerton & Yarm, which was formed to oppose the Mowbray development, described the scheme as a “zombie project”, adding: “It’s alive on paper but not actually going anywhere in reality.”

Mt Sheldon-Thomson said the gate one listing meant the project was “not demonstrably deliverable”.

He added: “Under the NESO connections reform process, the project has been classified as gate one and removed from the active connections queue.

“As a result, all connection parameters—including the connection date, point of connection, and required network works—are indicative only, and no deliverable connection solution has been identified.”

He said the classification meant the scheme would not fulfil the requirement of being sustainable development and therefore should be refused.

South Kilvington resident Philip Martin is one of the founders of the Thirsk Against Battery Storage (TABS) group.

He said the update from NESO was “good news”, but the group would continue to maintain its opposition.

“We’re really delighted that this project is now undeliverable in this location, but until NatPower withdraws the application we’re going to continue to fight.”

Mr Martin said the developer had been told by the council to prepare an environmental impact assessment and members were waiting for further consultation exercises which would take place if the report was published.

The Local Democracy Reporting Service has contacted NatPower for comment.

BESS plants store electricity from the grid at times of lower demand and release it back to the grid when it is needed most.

NatPower says the facilities make an essential contribution to ensuring reliable, secure and affordable electricity for the country.

A spokesperson said previously that the company was committed to engaging with the local community in the evolution of plans for its Bellmoor and Mowbray energy storage schemes.