EXCLUSIVE: Linda Clarke, a member of Scottish Labour’s governing body, has hit out at Sarwar and his deputy Jackie Baillie.
A Scottish Labour official has accused Anas Sarwar of admitting “zero” mistakes after a “dire” Holyrood election result.
Linda Clarke also questioned if the party leadership is capable of any “insightful analysis or change” after the crushing defeat.
Her criticisms come as Scottish Labour agreed a review of their defeat to John Swinney’s SNP.
Labour went down to their worst ever Holyrood election result on May 7th, falling to 17 MSPs.
Senior party figures blame Prime Minister Keir Starmer for the defeat, but they also admit failings with the Scottish Labour campaign.
Insiders feel Sarwar tried to win too many constituencies and produced a manifesto lacking in ambition.
READ MORE: Scottish Labour official blasts “toxic” and “authoritarian” party after election humbling
A frank exchange of views took place at Labour’s governing Scottish Executive Committee (SEC) on Saturday.
In a message to an internal Scottish Labour Facebook forum, leaked to the Record, SEC member Linda Clarke hit out at Sarwar and his deputy Jackie Baillie.
She wrote: [The] meeting did not vote to support the SLP top leadership – or give it any seal of approval.
“Nor did it vote to censure or replace it. However there was a very very frank discussion.
“Unfortunately IMO, the top leadership is committed to ZERO change and admitted to ZERO mistakes in policy or strategy.
“I don’t see any evidence that Sarwar or Bailie are capable of any insightful analysis or change.
“There is clearly still a lot of work to be done within the SLP to learn and act from these dire results.”
Clarke represents the Scottish Labour Women’s Committee on the SEC.
A party source rejected Clarke’s claims and said she held a “minority view” on the governing body, adding that Sarwar was willing to take responsibility for the campaign.
The insider also said the SEC agreed a review that would involve interviews with members, staff and candidates.
They also said there is a general acceptance that the Scottish Labour hierarchy could have motivated party members better in relation to the campaign.
Clarke’s criticisms came after another SEC member, Alison Ann-Dowling, also blasted the state of the party.
In a message posted in a feminist WhatsApp group, also leaked to the Record, she wrote:
“I’m afraid I don’t share the view that categorising any challenge to the scottish labour leadership about their performance and the outcome of the election is in fighting or disruptive.
“The way the Scottish Party has been run has been problematic for years, long before Starmer and Reform.”
She claimed the party is too centralised around Sarwar and his deputy Jackie Baillie, and criticised the Holyrood campaign:
“I also think it’s wrong and counter productive to give individuals in positions of leadership full control over the Party, but decouple that from any personal accountability for their actions.
“We had no list strategy. The 38 constituency strategy was wildly optimistic and failed to read the public mood. We failed to communicate a coherent manifesto election offer that we could sell as an elevator pitch on the doorsteps.
“The entire party has been centralised to a toxic level of control held by a small group of people, to an extent I’ve never seen before. I could go on.”
Sarwar has promised to stay on as leader to provide opposition to the SNP Government.
Fellow Labour MSPs Michael Marra and Paul Sweeney have been tipped as potential successors if he stands down.
Scottish Labour has been contacted.



You must be logged in to post a comment Login