Burnley have been awarded in excess of £35million after a landmark legal success against Everton, a bombshell judgment that could ultimately prove to be bad news for Manchester City, if found guilty of alleged charges
Manchester City’s rivals could each demand more than 100million in compensation, it’s claimed, after Burnley’s landmark legal success against Everton.
The Clarets have been awarded in excess of £35million – plus interest – from Everton by an independent Premier League commission as compensation. Everton are appealing the decision, made after the commission concluded that the Merseysiders benefited from a sporting advantage for breaching Profitability and Sustainability Rules.
In the case, the commission awarded £26million for losses due to relegation and £9.1million in interest. According to the commission’s judgment, the Toffees “accepted that its breach of the PSR conferred a sporting advantage but disputes both the extent and effect of that advantage”
Everton provided an expert who stated “that Burnley had suffered no financial loss following relegation”. However, the Clarets’ expert witness claimed they had lost £51.7m before interest. Burnley’s expert witness claimed the club had lost £51.7million before interest.
It’s a landmark case because under Premier League rules its clubs cannot sue each other through the courts – but they can do so through arbitration.
Click here to find out the latest Manchester City news in our daily newsletter
Now, if City are ultimately found guilty of serious charges among their alleged 115 breaches of Premier League rules, it could be a very costly affair.
Four clubs – Arsenal, Manchester United, Liverpool and Spurs – served legal notices on City in 2024, reserving the right to seek compensation if City are found guilty. They served compensation notices after being advised by lawyers of a potential six year statute of limitation period, dating back to November 2018 – when the Football Leaks document were first published by Der Spiegel, the German website.
If that indeed does happen, it opens the door to compensation claims by those clubs, who can argue that the alleged breaches gave City sporting advantages over their rivals over numerous seasons, between 2009 and 2017.
According to The Times, sources involved in the process estimate some of those clubs “had calculated potential losses costing significantly more than £100m” – down to income losses, not least missing out on the Champions League.
If you add interest, as in the Everton case, that figure would rise substantially higher.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login