Max Dowman Ban Stands: 16-Year-Old Misses Three Arsenal Games, Including Liverpool, After Appeal Fails

The Max Dowman ban will stand after an independent commission rejected Arsenal’s appeal against the 16-year-old’s red card in their Carabao Cup defeat at Fleetwood Town. The Football Association confirmed on Thursday that the commission had dismissed claims of both wrongful dismissal and excessive punishment, leaving the teenager suspended for three matches.

He will miss Sunday’s trip to Liverpool, then the games against Hull and Newcastle. Sources differ slightly on how to describe those fixtures, but one report says he will not be available for a top-flight match until 29 November, when Arsenal host Manchester City. The FA said the commission’s written reasons will be published “in due course”, so the logic behind the verdict is not yet public.

What happened at Fleetwood

Referee Michael Salisbury sent Dowman off in the 85th minute on Tuesday. The winger had reacted to a heavy challenge from behind by Fleetwood’s Harrison Neal, and he was shown a red card for violent conduct after kicking out. The match finished 1-1. League Two Fleetwood then beat the Premier League champions 5-3 on penalties. Viktor Gyökeres had levelled after Aaron Loupalo-Bi put the hosts ahead.

The decision split opinion. One report says Dowman did not fully kick out, though his foot did make contact. Arsenal felt the referee had been harsh and argued that Dowman himself could have been seriously hurt by the tackle. The laws of the game define violent conduct as using or attempting to use excessive force or brutality against an opponent when not challenging for the ball, “regardless of whether contact is made”. That wording means the absence of a full kick does not settle the matter. The commission has not yet said how it read the rule.

Arteta’s reaction and a troubling pattern

Mikel Arteta was seen glaring at Dowman as he left the pitch and appeared to say something to him. Afterwards the manager said he had not spoken to the teenager about the incident. He added that the team had been “very clear on the things to respect, the things that emotionally we have to dominate” in their preparation. He also said he would watch the incident back before assessing it.

Paul Merson publicly criticised Arteta’s treatment of the player, saying “He’s a kid”. Ray Parlour called Dowman “a little bit unlucky” and said he must learn from the mistake. There is also a harder fact for the player. This was his second red card this month, after a dismissal playing for England’s Under-19s. That makes the argument that this was a one-off reaction harder to sustain, although the commission’s reasoning on that point remains unknown.

Consistency in how kicking-out incidents are punished is also part of the debate. One report notes that Phil Foden was sent off for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes in the Manchester derby this season, while Cole Palmer escaped a red card after crashing into Matheus Fernandes in Chelsea’s defeat to Tottenham.

A stretched Arsenal wing

The timing is awkward for Arsenal. Bukayo Saka, Christos Tzolis and Noni Madueke are all injured, and Dowman was making only his second start of the season at Fleetwood. Arteta made nine changes for that game, and Ødegaard came on at half-time as Arsenal struggled to find rhythm.

The Max Dowman ban therefore removes another wide option just as Arsenal head to Anfield. It also keeps a teenager who has had limited game time out of league action for close to a month. Fleetwood, meanwhile, go into the first quarter-final in their history, at home to Everton or Newcastle. Arsenal’s focus is now on how they cover the flank, and on whether the commission’s written reasons shed any light on a decision that has divided supporters and pundits.

Explore more on this topic with Vexel Search.