EXCLUSIVE: Fulton MacGregor said he did not know why the SNP failed to include a commitment for kindergarten in their manifesto.
An SNP candidate has broken ranks by criticising his party’s manifesto on education.
Fulton MacGregor said he was “disappointed” the SNP did not back the introduction of kindergarten, which would raise the age a child starts school.
He also called for the abolition of primary one tests introduced by John Swinney when was Cabinet Secretary for Education.
SNP members backed a kindergarten-stage for younger children at their party conference in 2022.
However, no mention was made of kindergarten when the SNP unveiled their Holyrood manifesto this month.
READ MORE: Top charity blasts Holyrood parties over manifesto promises on child povertyREAD MORE: Malcolm Offord accused of ‘buying his way’ to Reform Scotland top job after admitting donation
MacGregor, an SNP MSP for ten years who is standing for re-election, said at a hustings organised by the Upstart charity:
“Perhaps before I come to what’s in in the SNP manifesto, I will address the issue of kindergarten, of course, which is the main issue that Upstart exists to promote and put on record, which I don’t mind doing, my disappointment that the SNP manifesto does not include a commitment to kindergarten in this parliamentary term.”
He added: “This is despite my own personal best efforts to try and get it there, and I know actually the cabinet Secretary for Education and the outgoing minister Natalie Don both also were supportive of that as well.
“I think it should be recognised, though, that a kindergarten stage is SNP party policy, which I’m very pleased about and just because it isn’t in the manifesto does not mean that it isn’t something that can be taken up in the next parliamentary session.”
Journalist Lesley Riddoch, who chaired the hustings, told MacGregor his criticism was “astonishingly honest” and asked what the SNP’s problem was with the policy.
He replied: “The honest answer is I don’t know.”
MacGregor, who is standing in Coatbridge and Chryston, also said: “I think perhaps it’s maybe not seen as being as of an urgent concern as other areas.”
On primary school testing, a policy defended by Swinney, he said: “I’ve been an outspoken critic of testing at P1.”
He continued: “I just don’t think that they should exist at all. I don’t think that it’s one of these things that you can make better, you can make less intensive.
He also said: “But they just really shouldn’t be happening. And I don’t mind saying that. That could be seen as quite strong, but I do think that we should take the opportunity early in this next parliamentary session, hopefully under an SNP government again, to get rid of them rather than trying to dilute them. They should just go.”
MacGregor also said he is “not a fan” of homework at a primary school level.
In 2018, Swinney as Education Secretary rejected calls to axe P1 tests:
“Frankly many of the criticisms from opposition politicians have ranged from ill-informed to hypocritical.
“Some opposition politicians are now proposing to scrap P1 assessments.
“To do this would be deeply irresponsible, and parents would quite rightly never forgive any politician who puts party politics ahead of the educational interests of their children.”






You must be logged in to post a comment Login