‘I don’t think it is possible for such a shallow squad to make a run through the All-Ireland series’
Last Saturday saw one of the great Ulster Championship games unfold.
This would have turned into a non-event under the new rules after Derry built up a 10-point lead at half-time. They would have sat with 14 men behind the ball, picking off Monaghan on the counter.
Monaghan, who ironically were the lowest two-point scorers in the League, racked up eight two-pointers to Derry’s one.
This is the way amateur sport should be – skill and risk-taking should be incentivised over systems and efficiency.
I referenced Rory Beggan a few weeks back saying he is an outlier in the game. He may have had his definitive career performance. His three two-pointers and assist for Micheál Bannigan’s goal brought the Farney back from the dead.
Numerous Derry fans were already heading for the exits as soon as the foul was awarded at the end of extra-time. A 50-yard free in wet conditions should not have such an inevitable outcome except when Rory Beggan is standing over it.
Opponents have now been forewarned.
Beggan was not on his own on the two-point front and it was clear from the body language of the Monaghan players in the last 10 minutes that they were ready to roll the dice and they didn’t need any encouragement to shoot from distance.
Derry, in contrast, passing on taking chances outside the arc and favoured playing the ball through the hands and trying to work high-percentage point scorers or goal-scoring opportunities.
The rain at half-time made the ball and the surface greasier and Derry’s approach harder to execute.
They had already been turned over as a result of bouncing the ball three or four times before Patrick McGurk’s fatal bounce allowed Monaghan back up the field for the last minute of normal time.
As I suggested last week, Derry’s starting line-up can compete with most, if not all and would be superior to Monaghan.
There’s questions that will now be asked of this Derry team, but, in truth, their management gave the answers on Saturday.
In the second half, a number of Derry’s core players were either playing below their level or fatigued, which inevitably happens in a fast-paced inter-county game.
To bring on three subs in 70 minutes and to then reintroduce Conor Doherty and Niall Loughlin for two of the subs is a definitive statement by the manager on what he thinks of his panel.
I see many of the same names on the Derry bench over the last number of years but I rarely see them on the pitch.
Had Derry closed out the last few seconds of normal time or extra-time, I feel they would have the ability to overturn Armagh.
Now, I don’t think it is possible for such a shallow squad to make a run through the All-Ireland series. As fate would have it, they’ll now face the Orchard County in round one!
All-Ireland contenders aren’t hoping their key men can last it out or keep under-performers on for the last 20 minutes. They run the bench at every opportunity.
This isn’t a slight on the current Derry management. Their strengths and weaknesses personnel wise are largely what they were in 2022 when they were Ulster champions.
Derry have had a number of successful or heavily-hyped minor and U20 teams in the last three or four years – it seems they haven’t yet had a significant impact at senior level.
In the last two seasons, they’ve faced Tyrone at U20 level and I’d been told, on both occasions, that this Derry team were chasing an All-Ireland and would be too strong for the Red Hands.
Both times Tyrone came out on top.
These short-coming for Derry at U20s and the lack of depth in the senior panel should give the county set-up cause for reflection. There’s either unrealistic expectations or something that needs rectified.
On that note, a word for my own county winning a third U20 title on the trot and five in the last seven.
Another game that evidenced the transformation of the sport, as we racked up 4-19, with not a single score coming from a dead-ball.
That’s the type of statistic that will be trotted out on many a high barstool for the next few decades by those who were playing, coaching and supporting the team last Wednesday night.
Of-course winning U20 titles is no guarantee of future glory at senior level, but it’s a good indicator that you have talent and there are indications that the talent can translate to senior football.
There is so much that can change with regards to a players’ fortunes from under-17 to senior, but under 20 level gives a more accurate look on a player’s physical potential and mentality, which of course will go a long way to determine whether they can make a mark at senior county level.
Want to see more of the stories you love from Belfast Live? Making us your preferred source on Google means you’ll get more of our exclusives, top stories and must-read content straight away. To add Belfast Live as a preferred source, simply click here .



.png)


You must be logged in to post a comment Login