York Council’s Executive backed trialling Tuesday closures this year to improve accessibility including for disabled people, despite hearing that up to £7.8 million less could be spent in the city centre as a result.
Disabled people told councillors on Tuesday, May 12, the move sent a powerful message they they were an equal part of the local community.
But traders warned the move could put visitors off, pile pressure on the event when it is open and cause further harm to the already struggling hospitality industry.
Cllr Pete Kilbane, the council’s Labour economy spokesperson, said they had to strike a difficult balance but they would not bar people from the city centre during the event.
RECOMMENDED READING:
It follows the introduction of restrictions barring Blue Badge holders and other vehicles from driving into the city centre during the event last year following a North Yorkshire Police request.
The Anti-Terror Traffic Regulation Order (ATTRO) is now available to use year round but is expected to be activated only during future markets and other events on a case-by-case basis, in consultation with the council and other emergency services.
The police said last year the restrictions were needed to deter terror attacks.
Tuesday’s executive meeting heard the national terror threat level had recently been raised to severe, meaning an attack is highly likely.
But disabled people said in the run up to last year’s market the measures would restrict their access to the city centre, resulting in the event’s opening times being pushed back.
The approved plans are set to see the market open from 10.30am to 7pm every day except Tuesday.
York Christmas Market is set to close on Tuesdays this year (Image: Staff)
Blue Badge holders will be able to use the ‘Goodramgate loop’ between Deansgate, King’s Square and Colliergate but Church Street would be closed.
Extra hostile vehicle measures would be put in place as a result, costing an estimated £50,000 in extra running costs.
The council and other bodies would monitor the measures during the event and make any changes deemed necessary.
Council city development lead Garry Taylor said the measures would allow the city centre to run as normal, as well as allowing access to disabled people and Blue Badge holders.
But he added the estimated loss of spending in the city centre could be between £2.6 million and £7.82 million, 1.87 and 5.62 per cent of total spend respectively during the market.
Amanda Cooper, of the York Disability Rights Forum, told councillors disabled people found it very difficult to be in the city centre when the market is on.
Ms Cooper said: “Restricting access to essential services including banks could cause some to go into financial difficulties or debt.
“Those who oppose this may themselves become disabled one day, they should reflect on that.”
But organisations including York’s High Street Forum, Business Improvement District (BID), Made In Yorkshire and others all objected to the plans warning of their impact on the local economy.
Market trader Nick Miller said closing one day a week would mean having to stop production and potentially hire fewer staff for them.
The trader said: “We had 241 applications for jobs on our stall last year, it’s worrying that that many people need a job in York.
“The market’s already busy at peak times, this could put more pressure on the market as a whole.”
Liberal Democrat Deputy Leader Cllr Paula Widdowson said the saga showed the issue of Blue Badge access to the city centre should never have been turned into a political football.
Cllr Widdowson said: “We’re talking about safety in the city centre during one of the busiest periods of the year, this shouldn’t have been left to politicians balancing competiting priorities.”
Economy and Culture Executive Member Cllr Kilbane said a return to a seven-day market was not ruled out in the future as officials continue to work on long term solutions to access issues.
The executive member said: “No city has cracked making events such as the Christmas Market fully accessible but we will turn over every stone to make sure all residents and visitors can access the city centre while it’s on at a bare minimum.”
You must be logged in to post a comment Login