NHS Fife bosses confirmed Dr Beth Upton had ‘left the organisation’ after Sandie won a legal action over her suspension amid a row changing room row with the transidentified male doctor.
The trans medic at the centre of the Sandie Peggie employment tribunal has left the NHS.
NHS Fife bosses today confirmed Dr Beth Upton had “left the organisation” after Sandie won a legal action against the health board over her suspension amid a changing room row with the transidentified male doctor.
Sandie, 56, has vowed to fight on after she launched an appeal against the judgement in her case, which was issued in December.
A spokesperson for NHS Fife confirmed 30-year-old Upton’s departure.
A statement said: “NHS Fife can confirm that Dr Beth Upton left the organisation at the end of 2025.
“As this is a personal employment matter, we will be making no further comment.”
Sandie complained about sharing a female changing room with the doctor, who was born male but now identifies as a woman.
She launched the legal action against her employers in 2024 after she was suspended following the row over the use of a female changing room at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy.
The legal process cost the taxpayer £400,000 and a long-awaited judgement found Sandie, from Glenrothes, had been unlawfully harassed by health bosses over the matter.
But it dismissed her other claims, including victimisation and discrimination under the Equality Act 2010.
The judgement was mired in controversy after it was found to have “misquoted” earlier rulings.
Announcing her decision to appeal against the ruling, mum-of-two Sandie said: “I’m not a campaigner – and I had never heard of the phrase ‘gender critical’ when I raised complaints over two years ago about the decision to allow men into female-only changing rooms.
“I just knew instinctively that it wasn’t right that women were expected to undress in front of men in private spaces, and I still believe this to be the case.
“While I am delighted the tribunal was critical of Fife Health Board, and found they had harassed me, their judgement, I believe, falls short and that is why I certainly won’t be giving up this legal fight anytime soon.”
Margaret Gribbon, Sandie’s solicitor, claimed some of the findings in the employment tribunal’s judgement are “problematic”.
The Employment Tribunal service was forced to issue an amended version of its 300-page judgement, amid claims it had included a “made-up quote”.
The document included a reference to a line supposedly from a leading gender campaigner’s separate tribunal from 2021.
Judge Kemp, who earns £167,167 a year, was facing questions over how the false quote was included in the final judgement.
Maya Forstater, who leads the sex-based rights organisation Sex Matters, said: “There is a partial quote from the Supreme Court’s judgement in the For Women Scotland case that has been edited so that its meaning is completely reversed. Mistakes like this severely undermine people’s confidence in the legal process.”
When John Swinney was asked whether he still had faith in the tribunal’s judgement, The First Minister said: “The conduct of an employment tribunal is a completely independent process to government.”
NHS Fife said it was “aware that the tribunal has now updated the judgement”.
Michael Foran, an associate professor of law at Oxford University, claimed Sandie’s legal team could overturn the tribunal’s interpretation of the Supreme Court ruling.
While Harry Potter author JK Rowling tweeted about the error, saying: “Judge Kemp and the Judicial Office need to explain exactly how this bogus quote made its way into the ruling.
“Misrepresentations of the Forstater ruling are commonplace in the trans activist community but for this to turn up in a court ruling is shocking.”
Lats month, NHS Fife was accused of secrecy over the scandal after it blocked dozens of freedom of information requests.
The board refused to proactively release information about the case – including how much it cost taxpayers to fight it.
NHS Fife blocked 43 FoI requests as of November last year. A probe by the Scottish Information Commissioner remains ongoing.
Tory MSP Murdo Fraser claimed NHS Fife had an “addiction to secrecy”.
Get more Daily Record exclusives by signing up for free to Google’s preferred sources. Click HERE

