Denice Finnigan asked a judge to jail her saying it was the ‘best place’ for her
A mum asked a judge to be jailed after she tore clumps of a woman’s hair out at a taxi rank. Denice Finnigan was also part of a gang who launched bricks at a shopkeeper after he retrieved a stolen bottle of wine from her and emptied it down the drain.
However, rather than pleading to be released from Styal prison, she “believes it is the best place for her” whilst she attempts to address her drug addiction and “become a better mother”. And a judge granted her wish, telling her that he “hopes she can make a fresh start” when she’s eventually released.
Liverpool Crown Court heard yesterday, Monday, that police attended Bath Street in Southport on August 5, 2024, after receiving reports of fighting, which erupted after Finnigan stole a £6.99 bottle of pinot grigio from nearby Coronation News. Shop owner Jamie Lodge was said to have attended the area following the theft and taken the alcohol from the 37-year-old, of Manchester Road in the town, before emptying it down the drain.
Click here to prioritise Manchester news in Google from the MEN
But Zara Kayani, prosecuting, described how Finnigan responded by threatening to “smash his head in”. A group of up to seven people in her company then began threatening Mr Lodge and a second man, Anthony Baird, with bricks before the latter was shoved to the floor by several women and kicked by a man, leaving him “covered in blood” as a result of injuries to his head and face.
Both subsequently had bricks hurled towards them before they managed to retreat to their van. However, their attackers prevented them from leaving, with the windscreen being smashed as a result of a further brick being thrown at the vehicle, reports the Liverpool Echo.
Then, on April 18 last year, Rachel Rose and her partner had been on a night out in Southport and were walking to a taxi rank on Lord Street when Finnigan’s boyfriend began whistling at them. When the victim’s boyfriend took exception to this, the man was said to have told him: “Go back to where you’ve come from.”
The male then added to Ms Rose that his girlfriend was “going to kill her and do her in” and began “getting in her face, goading her”. It was at this stage that the defendant ran down the road and grabbed the other woman by her hair, dragging her to the floor.
While the couple were able to escape into a taxi, both Finnigan and her partner began kicking at the vehicle, causing a dent to a rear door. Ms Rose was thereafter dragged from the car and kicked to the back of her head, causing a lump.
The complainant detailed in a statement, which was read out to the court on her behalf, that clumps of her hair were also pulled out during the assault while she further had her fingernails ripped out. She added: “This was the most distressing experience I’ve ever been through. I felt completely helpless and terrified.
“After being discharged from hospital, the children witnessed my return home in an injured and distressed state. Seeing their reaction to my injuries was deeply upsetting. Since the incident, I avoid going out and feel extremely anxious in public spaces. Situations that once felt normal now cause me fear and pain. I want the court to understand that this was a serious and violent assault.”
Finnigan has 19 previous convictions for 38 offences, including assaults on emergency services personnel and 21 related to matters of theft. Olivia Belle, defending, told the court: “Unusually, Ms Finnigan wants to remain in custody. This was a defendant living a very chaotic lifestyle, addicted to crack cocaine and heroin and heavily misusing alcohol.
“She has been diagnosed with bipolar and post-traumatic stress disorder and suffers from depression and anxiety. She has only been medicated since coming into custody. She wishes to remain in custody to get the help that she desires. I understand that she is completing a hairdressing course and a catering course in custody.
“I am instructed to ask for a custodial sentence in this case, as it is Ms Finnigan’s view or personal feeling that, if she were to be released into the community at this time, although she would receive help, her drug use is very extreme. She believes that the best place for her to remain abstinent is in custody.
“She tells me that, for the last five weeks that she has spent on remand, she has taken to staff and other inmates very well. She sees herself starting these courses so that, when she is released, she has a brighter future for herself and her daughter. She is 12 years old. Given her drug and alcohol use, she is only allowed phone contact at present. She wishes to become a better mother and become clean of class A drugs. She believes that the best place for her, at present, is in custody.”
Finnigan admitted assault occasioning actual bodily harm, assault, criminal damage, theft and failing to surrender to custody in relation to a date in October last year where she did not attend court. Appearing via video link to HMP Styal wearing a black and grey Under Armour tracksuit top and sporting long brown hair, she was jailed for 10 months.
Sentencing, Recorder Mark Ainsworth said: “You have a poor record, both with regards to dishonesty and offences of violence. I say that to place these events into context.
“You stole a bottle of wine from a shop. When you were confronted by an owner and somebody else, there was an altercation. The victim was pushed to the ground by you. Others joined in. There were kicks and punches. There were references to bricks being used. It is clear that the complainant sustained injury as a result of what happened.”
Turning to the April 2025 assault, Recorder Ainsworth added: “Rachel Rose had been out with her partner. There was a discussion with them which was taken to be banter, but it seemed to provoke some sort of altercation. It is clear that, during the course of that altercation, Ms Rose was seriously assaulted. She was grabbed by the hair, she was pulled to floor, she was kicked.
“Plainly, these are serious matters. I am told something of your background in mitigation. It is said that you have a chaotic lifestyle, which I readily accept. I am told that you have a 12-year-old daughter, who is currently living with her father. I am told, in the past, that you have had difficulties with drugs, including crack cocaine. I am also told that you have mental health difficulties.”
The judge then said of the “progress made while being held at Styal prison”: “That is a significant factor and something that is commendable. It seems that you are free from drugs, you are receiving assistance for your mental health issues and you are undertaking courses in respect of hairdressing and catering.
“In the circumstances, given the progress that you are making at Styal, I am going to accede to that request. What I am hoping is, however we have got to this point, we have reached a point where you can draw a line and, on your release, make a fresh start, hopefully in a much better position and, hopefully, having gained the skills that you have identified Styal prison. Quite what happens on your release will be a matter for you.”
