The judge said: “I don’t think it is safe to release him under any conditions at the moment.”
A man charged with the manslaughter of children’s nurse Karen Cummings in December 2024 was today denied compassionate bail to attend a specialist for ongoing back problems.
Kevin McGuigan, 44, whose address was given as c/o Maghaberry Prison, is currently awaiting trial in December this year for the gross negligence killing of the mother-of-two.
The 40-year-old was found unconscious with a serious head injury in a house at Laurel Heights, Banbridge, Co Down, on December 14, 2024.
Emergency services attended the scene and Ms Cummings, who worked at Newry’s Daisy Hill Hospital, was pronounced dead a short time later.
Last month, McGuigan was arraigned at Belfast Crown Court and formally pleaded not guilty to her manslaughter and also denied three firearm offences.
In addition, he pleaded not guilty to handling stolen goods, namely a double-barrelled shotgun on December 14, 2024.
Co-accused Glenn Robert King, 44, c/o Magilligan Prison, is also charged with manslaughter and possessing a firearm in suspicious circumstances.
He was not arraigned with McGuigan and a legal application on his behalf is due to be heard next month.
During a contested compassionate bail application on Thursday, prosecution barrister James Johnston said police objected to McGuigan being released from custody.
“Police say that this does not qualify as a compassionate bail application as the defendant wishes for private medical treatment rather than use the prison health facilities,” said Mr Johnston.
“Police have looked into this gentleman who advertises himself online as a mind and body wellbeing specialist and also advertises himself as willing to go and see patients.
“The other objections are the risk of interference with witnesses, most notably a risk of further offending and there is a concern that he will not abide by bail conditions and may abscond.”
Mr Johnston said McGuigan is facing separate charges on a second bill of indictment of common assault, burglary of the Ramada Hotel in Belfast, wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm and possessing three kitchen knives in a public place.
The prosecutor told Judge Richard Greene KC: “On November 24, 2024, the defendant was in a nightclub and was captured on CCTV assaulting someone on the dance floor.
“He is later captured on video entering the Ramada Hotel and going into the kitchen and was seen on camera putting three knives into his pockets.
“He goes out of the hotel and punches a man and then slashes him with one of the knives. He was detained by police and the three knives were recovered. He was put on bail for that offence.
“Then two weeks later a more serious offence occurs whereby very tragically a nurse and a mother lost her life when the defendant and his co-accused who were in her home as guests and had with them a sawn-off shotgun.
“The two of them were struggling with the loaded firearm when it went off which tragically killed this woman with a fatal head shot wound.”
The court heard painter and decorator McGuigan left the scene and gave no assistance to Ms Cummings. Following his arrest, he told police that he took the firearm to her house.
“He frankly told police: ‘I am under threat and l am in fear. I take this firearm with me everywhere I go’. He was on bail and was walking around with a loaded firearm which led to very tragic circumstances.”
The court was told McGuigan had relevant convictions on his criminal record. In 2020, he was jailed for 18 months for having a loaded gun and ammunition in the Chimney Corner Hotel in Co Antrim the previous year.
“Police say there is a history of this man being involved in very serious offences, such as pointing a gun at people in a hotel and attacking a man on the street with a knife,” said Mr Johnston.
Defence barrister Caitriona Keenan said McGuigan had been in custody since his arrest two weeks after the killing of Ms Cummings.
“This is his first application for bail and he has been entirely compliant and cooperative (in prison),” said Ms Keenan.
“Mr McGuigan has been experiencing severe back pain since December 2025. His mother and sister are in court with a cash surety and they will pick him up from the prison, see the specialist and take him back to the prison.
“This specialist deals in spinal manipulation and osteo therapies so it will be physical, hands-on treatment. This is a man who has been struggling with back pain for the past seven months.”
Judge Greene said he was not satisfied that it was a proper compassionate bail application and refused it.
“It is not a case that I think it is appropriate for bail given the seriousness of the offences for which he is in custody for,” outlined Judge Greene
“His behaviour while on bail for the Section 18 (wounding) offence which was an egregious event where he armed himself with three kitchen knives and attacked a member of the public who sustained hand injuries.
“Two weeks later he became involved in an incident whereby a lady lost her life when a firearm was discharged and he was charged with gross negligence manslaughter.
“I don’t think it is safe to release him under any conditions at the moment,” added Judge Greene.
For all the latest news, visit the Belfast Live homepage here and sign up to our daily newsletter here.






You must be logged in to post a comment Login