Cambridge City Council approved the Market Square plans but details of the gates must still be provided before they are installed
Plans to reimagine Cambridge’s Market Square could include nine-foot tall security gates branded “fundamentally tragic” by traders. Cambridge City Council approved the refurbishment at a planning meeting on Wednesday (September 2), but further details of the gates must be submitted before they are approved.
A design and access statement by Cartwright Pickard said the gates were part of plans to tackle antisocial behaviour alongside better lighting, CCTV, and an extension of market opening hours. Plans submitted in November 2025 show the proposed four gates, which would be locked every evening, with a height of 2.751m or around nine feet.
Council planning officers told the meeting they weren’t convinced the gates would be in the right place, as they block the north-south main route. They proposed the condition that no gates will be installed until further details are submitted and approved.
Zoe Harding, a market trader, called the gating of civic spaces “fundamentally tragic” and expressed concerns the current design could “destroy” the market. She sent councillors an alternative plan which would create and maintain “desire lines” and remove “the need for the gates”.
Councillor Tim Bick said he supported the wider scheme as a compromise, but would prefer all the stalls be removable to create open space in the market at night.
The Lib Dem councillor said: “Partly because of the effect of empty stalls in the evenings when the market is closed, the square is then prone to much antisocial behaviour by the provision of multiple concealed areas.
“I have instead assurances on antisocial behaviour that additional deterrence will come from better lighting, more natural surveillance through the design through better CCTV, from the gating of new fixed stalls and regular security visits.
“We can’t simply address those uncertainties and concerns by never adapting the market square or refurbishing it while the infrastructure falls further behind modern standards and the growth in the footfall that we see. Especially when we have the chance of significant investment that many city centres would look on with envy.”
The plans include a number of removable stalls at the Guildhall side to allow for events to be held but there will be a number of fixed stalls, including where the gates are proposed.
Cllr Dave Baigent raised concerns the plans could harm the heritage of the city’s market. The Your Party councillor said: “It will no longer be a street market, there will be sheds all over – that is a real matter of heritage. People will look back I’m sure in 20 years time and go, ‘where’s the market gone?’ because this is the beginning of an erosion of our city’s heritage.”
Cllr Robert Dryden said: “Our policy is it should be public open space and not obstructed by anything – if it’s got locked gates it’s not open public space any more.” The Labour councillor said he would not be voting to approve the plans because of the reasons for refusal given by officers.
The council approved the refurbishment plans but under the condition that no security gates are to be installed until details about their location, design, and colour have been submitted and approved.







You must be logged in to post a comment Login