The Other Bennet Sister fans have fallen in love with the BBC period drama and are now looking for their next Jane Austen fix – this could be it
The Other Bennet Sister has resonated deeply with period drama fans, but as they complete the first and only season, they’re desperately seeking another Jane Austen tale.
Within the same universe Austen crafted, viewers can discover Death Comes to Pemberley, a narrative that continues directly from where Pride and Prejudice ended.
Much like the 2026 production, The Other Bennet Sister, this 2013 standalone series also extends Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, penned by a different author. It draws from P.D. James’s 2011 novel, which employs the same characters and literary style as the original 1813 work.
Spanning three episodes, it pursues a murder mystery storyline, featuring the beloved characters Austen devotees recognise but placed in a somewhat altered setting.
The Guardian described its execution was “respectful” towards Austen’s iconic masterpiece while still managing to “stand out” as its own “very different” creation.
It also shares similarities with the Pride and Prejudice adaptation, as Chatsworth House in Derbyshire served as Pemberley’s exterior backdrop. This identical location featured as the estate in the 2005 film.
One viewer posted their thoughts on IMDB, saying: “If you are like me and enjoy your Pride and Prejudice and a good murder plot, then you would love this series!”
They added: “Elisabeth in particular is just like I would have imagined; she is the same spirited, outspoken person we know and love, while Darcy is more brooding, quiet and responsible (while I may have chosen other actors in terms of appearance, I think they portray the characters very well as reactions).”
A PopMatters reviewer wrote: “Death Comes to Pemberley, a sequel to Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice by P.D. James, is a worthy addition to Austen’s original, and the BBC adaptation makes that case wonderfully.”
Taking place in 1803, the programme opens six years following the union of Mr Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet, when a disappearance occurs which rocks the whole community. Following a dispute, Wickham and Denny leave in a horse-drawn carriage, and moments later, two gunshots ring out.
Upon learning of the incident and the men’s disappearance, Darcy dispatches a search team. They find Wickham in a state of hysteria, clutching Denny’s lifeless body, and the narrative unfolds revealing how this devastating death came to pass.
Naturally, venturing into Austen’s universe carries significant risk, as the cherished writer’s work holds almost sacred status amongst devoted readers.
Consequently, the adaptation has attracted its share of detractors regarding its depiction of certain Austen characters that have been reimagined by subsequent authors.
One viewer says on IMDB: “When you use well-known and loved characters from something as famous as Pride and Prejudice, they should at least stay faithful to their original characters. Which it does, mostly, but the portrayal of Elizabeth Bennett was just really off.”
Elizabeth is portrayed by Anna Maxwell Martin, alongside Matthew Rhys as Fitzwilliam Darcy, Jenna Coleman as Lydia Wickham and Matthew Goode as George Wickham.
For those seeking their next Austen-inspired drama, this makes an excellent starting point with its easily bingeable three-episode run; Death Comes to Pemberley can be streamed now on BBC iPlayer.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login