Harrogate Spring Water and its parent company Danone have been denied permission to increase the size of their plant in Harlow Moor Road, Harrogate.
Ahead of the meeting, Dame Judi Dench and Dame Joanna Lumley had urged councillors to reject the application.
The decision was taken by members of North Yorkshire Council’s Harrogate and Knaresborough area planning committee following objections from residents, campaign groups and local politicians over the loss of around 500 trees in Rotary Wood, an area of community woodland in the Pinewoods area of the town.
Impassioned pleas not to grant the planning application were made at the meeting today (FRIDAY) at Harrogate Civic Centre.
Sarah Gibbs, from the Save Rotary Woods campaign group, told councillors: “Pinewoods are the lungs of Harrogate, Rotary Wood its beating heart.
“Please do not underestimate the value of our woodland. Rotary Wood was planted for a more sustainable future. It is hope, community, belonging, connection, peace and prosperity of body and mind.”
She added: “This has gone on for so long that you may have pressure on you to push this through.
“But I implore you to do what is right, not what is easy, to recognise a failing, undemocratic planning system and make a stand against it.”
Harrogate town councillor Josie Caven also spoke out against the plan.
Rotary Wood. Photo: Caught Light Photography (Image: Caught Light Photography)
She said: “We believe that the application should be rejected on the grounds of the arguments presented, the volume of public opposition, the irreversible loss of valuable green space and a failure to achieve sustainable development in line with national and local planning policy.”
The committee voted unanimously against the reserved matters application despite a recommendation from officers to approve the plans.
Members were also instructed that the principle of development had already been established by an earlier outline planning application and issues such as the loss of trees should not be considered.
RECOMMENDED READING:
‘It is a living growing woodland’ – Dame Judi speaks against Harrogate Water plans
Plan for 129 new homes in Yorkshire town get go ahead
Committee member Councillor Peter Lacey proposed that the application be rejected.
He said: “I think there are several things that make me uneasy about this development.
“First, we’ve talked about the ecological argument. I was concerned to read that the ecological survey was undertaken in August rather than springtime, for example.
“The second area is scale. There is still, for me, something about a doubling in size of an industrial unit within a sensitive area that makes me feel uneasy.”
Cllr Lacey said he was concerned that the water supply could run out, which fed the factory.
Councillor Hannah Goslow said: “The policies require us to protect and enhance landscape heritage and green space, and I don’t believe this scheme does either.
“The design simply isn’t good enough for Harrogate or for our climate commitments.”
After the meeting, Richard Hall, managing director of Harrogate Spring Water, said the company was disappointed by the committee’s decision and was considering its next step.
“Our plans have been recommended for approval by the council and we have addressed the two reasons given for deferring this decision at the previous meeting.
“Throughout this process, we have worked constructively with officers and the local community to strike the right balance between sustainable development and economic growth.
“We feel our proposal represents a significant investment in Harrogate – creating over 50 new jobs, delivering an annual £2.3 million boost to the local economy, and a commitment to protecting the local environment. “
Critics of the scheme, however, welcomed the outcome.
Councillor Mike Schofield, Green Party member for the Harlow and St George’s division, said: “This was never about opposing development in principle—it was about ensuring that the details of this proposal were properly evidenced and acceptable for our community.
“Residents raised clear and legitimate concerns around landscaping, drainage, access, and the overall scale of the scheme. Crucially, too many of those issues remained unresolved.”
Ms Gibbs, who spoke during the meeting, afterwards said she was “thrilled and overjoyed”.
“Our beautiful asset of community value woodland, Rotary Wood, is safe again for now, though this will likely go to appeal.
“We need to keep up the pressure. We have so much celebrity support and hope that those amazing people will stand with us and keep the pressure on.”
Harrogate MP Tom Gordon said: “Common sense has finally prevailed. Swapping a cherished woodland for a plastic water bottling plant should never have been on the table.
“We still need to be wary of future attempts to destroy our cherished woodland, today’s decision represents a welcome but temporary reprieve.”
The MP had previously asked the government to intervene on the scheme, but ministers refused.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login