The match referee had no option but to issue a red card following the ugly incident
Welsh starlet Stefan Emanuel was left writhing in pain after being dropped on his head in a horror tackle that saw a player sent off and made the crowd and match commentators groan.
The Wales U20s co-captain – who is regarded by many as a future senior international star – was in action for Cardiff RFC in their Super Rygbi Cymru clash with Llandovery on Saturday when the incident occurred with less than quarter of an hour of the match played.
After taking the lead through Osian Darwin-Lewis, Cardiff were pushing for a second try as Emanuel received the ball just inside his own half and looked to offload to lock Ethan Phillips outside him.
JOIN OUR WALES RUGBY FACEBOOK PAGE! Latest news, analysis and much more
While he got the pass away, however, the centre was smashed into by Llandovery scrum-half George Macdonald, who lifted Emanuel into the air and tipped him beyond the horizontal, before dropping him hard on the back of his head.
The challenge immediately drew groans from those in attendance and the S4C commentary team, with the referee immediately bringing the game to a halt.
Former Wales international Josh Turnbull, on co-commentary duties for S4C, winced as Emanuel was slammed into the turf, with commentator Phil Steele saying: “That looked really nasty, Steff Emanuel it was. It was a really nasty clout.”
Having hit the 4G surface hard, Emanuel was left holding the back of his head and neck in pain as a medic immediately ran to his aid and supported the player’s head.
Further medical staff from Llandovery also ran over, as referee Rhys Jones consulted with his assistants and confirmed that he was issuing a red card to Macdonald.
Llandovery captain Joe Powell was taken aback by the decision, as Jones explained: “Red nine, lifts him and drops him on his neck, clearly. It’s nothing else but a red card.”
An incredulous Macdonald also questioned the colour of card, with the referee telling him: “You have lifted the player and twisted and driven him by his neck into the ground, so it’s a red card.”
As the scrum-half trudged off, Steele said: “There we are. If it’s a tip tackle, intent doesn’t come into it, it’s outcome,” while Turnbull added: “I’m not sure why the Llandovery boys are arguing with the ref.
“If he lifts him off the floor, you’ve got to bring him back down, haven’t you?”
After being checked over by the medics, Emanuel was deemed OK to carry on and played all but 10 minutes of the clash, which Cardiff won 45-14.
Follow all of our channels to ensure you stay up to date with the latest Welsh rugby news. Sign up to our free daily newsletter here and our WhatsApp channel here for all the breaking news.


You must be logged in to post a comment Login