WARNING DISTRESSING CONTENT: A beloved daughter with a big laugh was just 13 when the worst imaginable thing happened to her, and her mother was left reeling for months then years.
A mother’s worst nightmare came true when her 13-year-old vanished from a car park, while she was waiting for her to finishing her food shop.
On 19 October 1997, Maryann Measles’ disappearance horrified Connecticut. When her broken body was found, her community were devastated to learn she had endure months of abuse from older men culminated in the most horrific ending imaginable.
In July 1998, Maryann’s remains were found at Lake Lillinonah in Bridgewater wrapped in a blanket and weighed down with chains.
Maryann had been raped, tortured, assaulted, and drowned before her body was dumped into the Housatonic Rive. Maryann was not abducted and murdered by a stranger; instead, she was betrayed by those she had considered friends.
Maryann’s parents, Martin and Cindi loved their daughter deeply. Cindi, her mother, often said that holding Maryann for the first time was a feeling she had never known before.
Maryann grew up in New Milford with her three younger sisters, Jennifer, Victoria, and Chelsea. Maryann was known for her big laugh.
By the time she was 13, Maryann was spending a lot of time with a group of older teenagers and young adults.
This group were described as heavy drinking thugs by the owner of a nearby trucker business, according to the New York Times. Some of the girls in this group were dating older boys in their late teens or early 20s.
Cindi, watching her daughter’s new group of friends, grew increasingly worried.
By the start of October 1997, the situation had become serious. Maryann told Cindi that two of the older boys, Alan Walter, 19, and Keith Foster, 21, had been assaulting her, according to Tales From The Underworld.
Cindi went to the New Milford Police Department to file a statutory rape report. The first official complaint was lodged against Walter, and Maryann and her mother intended to return soon to add Foster to the report.
Walter and Foster were angry – but so were the girls in the group – as some of their boyfriends were involved with the 13-year-old. By mid-October, the group had completely ostracised Maryann. Some even threatened her.
On one occasion, Maryann found herself at the New Milford Town Green when three people from her former circle of friends, Maggie Bennett, Alan Walter, and June Segar, confronted her in Bennett’s minivan. As the van circled Maryann, they began to hurl insults and threats.
Maryann found a payphone and rang her mother for a lift. Cindi arrived and collected Maryann. They then headed to the Big Y supermarket in nearby Veterans Plaza to grab some groceries. While Cindi went inside the shop, Maryann stayed in the car.
The car park was bustling with shoppers and parents unloading their shopping. However, while Cindi was inside, one of Maryann’s ex-friends, 24-year-old Ronald Rajcok, parked next to her in his car.
Before Maryann could understand what was happening, he opened the door and grabbed her. Rajcok forced her into his car.
When Cindi returned to the car, she was shocked to find that Maryann was missing. Concerned, Cindi drove home and asked Maryann’s sister if she had seen her return.
Maryann was nowhere to be seen so Cindi went straight to the police station to report Maryann as missing. Initially, officers treated the situation as a runaway case, but Cindi was adamant that Maryann wouldn’t just disappear like that.
After Rajcok forced Maryann into his Pontiac Trans Am, he drove to a lay-by on River Road in New Milford near the Housatonic River. There, the rest of the group was waiting for them. This included Alan Walter, Keith Foster, Dino Dupas, Dorothy Hallas, Maggie Bennett, June Segar, and Jeffrey Boyette.
They raped her and hurled abuse at her. One participant later described how Maryann tried to resist, only to have her arms twisted as she was lifted against her will.
She was repeatedly raped by Walter, Foster, and Dupas, and physically and verbally abused by the girls present. As the attack drew to a close, some of the men moved Maryann closer to the river’s edge and forced her knees down into the shallow water of the Housatonic River, where Walter Alan held her head under for minutes, drowning her.
When Maryann stopped struggling and her body became still, the group then wrapped her body in a blanket and secured it with heavy chains and a padlock.
They attached a cinder block to weigh her down, ensuring her body remained beneath the river’s surface, and discarded her into the Housatonic River.
The search for Maryann Measles continued for nine horrific months. The Measles family posted hundreds of missing-person flyers all over New Milford, on lampposts, shop windows, and notice boards.
Law enforcement dedicated approximately 700 hours to the search, conducting over 80 interviews and following up on around 60 leads in the initial weeks and months.
Police interrogated those who had been close to Maryann, including members of her circle of friends.
Investigators discovered that several of the group had been near the supermarket around the time she vanished.
But getting a straight story was impossible. Some claimed they hadn’t seen her, while others had very vague timelines.
On 15 July 1998, nearly nine months after Maryann disappeared, her remains were found by a boater in Lake Lillinonah in Bridgewater, Connecticut.
Due to the severe deterioration of the remains, Maryann was positively identified through dental records. An autopsy determined the cause of death to be asphyxiation, and the death was declared a homicide by the Litchfield State’s Attorney.
In December 1998, a £50,000 reward was offered for information leading to an arrest. Despite the discovery of Maryann’s remains, the investigation into her murder remained cold, and in July 2001, four years after she had been found, new detectives were assigned to her case.
In light of fresh evidence, in October 2002, officials from the Connecticut State Police declared that arrest warrants had been issued and carried out for eight people linked to the murder of Maryann Measles.
Seven were arrested in Connecticut, while Jeffrey Boynette, living in Texas at the time, was arrested there and extradited to Connecticut to face charges.
Some consented to plea agreements, admitting their involvement and accepting a predetermined sentence, while others opted to go to trial and let a judge and jury determine their fate.
In February 2004, when Alan “A.J.” Walter, seen as one of the group’s leaders, agreed to a plea deal. As part of this agreement, Walter pleaded guilty to felony murder, first-degree kidnapping, conspiracy to commit first-degree kidnapping, conspiracy to commit first-degree sexual assault, and tampering with physical evidence, thereby avoiding the potential of the death penalty.
“I think they should die for what they did,” Cindi told the Associated Press outside the Bantam Court.
Instead, he received a life sentence. Prosecutors stated this deal helped to build the case against the others. Over the next few months more of the group accepted agreements that avoided full trials.
Jeffrey Boyette entered a plea in June 2004. He pleaded no contest to felony murder, first-degree sexual assault, first-degree kidnapping, and risk of injury to a minor.
This meant that he did not admit guilt but accepted that sufficient evidence existed for a conviction, and he was later sentenced to a 50‑year term, with half of that time suspended and a portion of the sentence served on probation afterward.
In September 2004, Dorothy Hallas pleaded guilty to felony murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree kidnapping, and risk of injury to a minor. She was sentenced to 25 years with 5 years of probation.
Maggie Bennett was charged with first-degree kidnapping, conspiracy to commit kidnapping, risk of injury to a minor, tampering with a witness, and tampering with evidence. Because of her cooperation, she was sentenced to 19 years in prison.
In accordance with her plea agreement, June Segar pleaded guilty to felony murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree kidnapping, and tampering with a witness. She was sentenced to 30 years in prison.
Like Alan Walter, Deaneric “Dino” Dupas was also charged with capital murder, and like Walter, Dupas also accepted a plea deal to avoid a possible death sentence. He pleaded guilty to felony murder, conspiracy to commit first-degree kidnapping, and conspiracy to commit first-degree sexual assault. He received a 47-year sentence.
Ronald Rajcok, the man who kidnapped Maryann, was also offered a plea deal in which he admitted to felony murder, first-degree kidnapping, conspiracy to commit first-degree kidnapping, risk of injury to a minor, and tampering with a witness. In return, he received a 36-year prison sentence. However, not everyone accepted a plea.
Keith Foster rejected an offer and instead chose a trial. During his 2006 trial, Foster maintained he had not been present at the time of the murder. After considering the evidence, the jury found him guilty on all charges.
The judge handed him a 110-year prison sentence, by far the most severe punishment in the case. Despite this conviction, Foster continued to deny the court’s rulings, but in August 2009, the Connecticut Supreme Court dismissed his appeal and upheld the conviction.
Decades after Maryann Measles’ death, her family and community members continued to commemorate her.
On 19 October 2023, marking the 26th year since Maryann’s disappearance, her family arranged a candlelight memorial on the Town Green in New Milford to honour her memory.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login