Former Manchester United star Paul Scholes has a history of taking aim at Manchester United managers
Paul Scholes’ recent scathing criticism of Manchester United interim boss Michael Carrick is nothing new for the Old Trafford icon. Scholes slammed his former team-mate following United’s 2-1 defeat away to Newcastle on Wednesday evening.
Carrick has been imperious since replacing Ruben Amorim at the beginning of the year. Defeat in the north east was his first since becoming United caretaker boss for the second time in his career.
While Scholes reserved some choice words for the 44-year-old, Carrick is not the only United manager who’s been on the receiving end of a rollicking from the ex-England star.
FOLLOW OUR MAN UNITED FB PAGE! Latest news and analysis via the MEN’s Manchester United Facebook page
The TNT Sports pundit has unloaded on coaches from Jose Mourinho to Ruben Amorim. Here, we take a look at what Scholes has had to say on several former United bosses.
Michael Carrick
Following the disappointing result against the Magpies, an irritated Scholes took aim at Carrick via social media. On his Instagram story, he posted: “Michael has definitely got something special about him…cos Utd have been c**p last four games…night.”
In their previous four games, United had earned 10 points from 12, having beaten Crystal Palace at home and Everton away. They also drew with West Ham away and beat Tottenham Hotspur at Old Trafford.
Scholes then displayed his appreciation for Newcastle’s midfielder Sandro Tonali, inscribing the Italian’s surname next to a love heart emoji.
Ruben Amorim
In December 2025, just weeks from Amorim’s sacking, Scholes unleashed on the Portuguese manager. Speaking on his podcast with former team-mate Nicky Butt and Paddy McGuinness, The Good, the Bad and the Football, Scholes laid into Amorim and his footballing philosophy.
Scholes said: “I don’t think the manager gets the club, full stop. I just don’t think he’s the right man. Man United is about risk and entertainment, more than anything.
“Having fans on the edge of their seat f*****g ready to go. If you go to Sporting Lisbon and watch, they played three at the back. Right away, that’s a no.
“Man United never do that. They can’t do that. They just can’t, it’s been proven over years and years and years. I just don’t think he gets it.”
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Solskjaer was relieved of his United managerial duties in November 2021. While Scholes didn’t lambast his ex-team-mate, he did concede that Solskjaer didn’t have what it takes to lift United to the heights of winning the game’s biggest trophies.
“He probably couldn’t take us to that next level,” Scholes said after the Norwegian was sacked. “He got us to second in the Premier League, which isn’t bad. Numerous semi-finals.
“A final as well last year, but he just couldn’t make that final step. I have to say it’s difficult. You think of Liverpool, Manchester City, and Chelsea, there’s a lot of quality in this Premier League. Whoever comes now, it’s not going to be easy to get Manchester United to where they want to be.”
Erik ten Hag
Back in September 2024, after United were soundly beaten by Spurs, Scholes dug out the Dutchman for a series of disjointed performances. Ten Hag was sacked by United in October 2024.
“You don’t know how they’re going to play,” Scholes said on SuperSport. “You don’t know how they’re going to approach games, whether they are going to play on the counter-attack or sit deep or whether they’re going to try to have all the possession in the game.
“We’ve no idea. They look like an uncoached football team. The players looked dead today, they looked flat and they looked like they were thinking ‘I don’t know what to do’. There’s no enthusiasm for the game of football and that can only come from the training pitch.”
Ralf Rangnick
Rangnick succeeded Solskjaer at the end of November 2021. Following this period as boss, it was agreed that the German would continue in a consultancy role for another two years.
Ultimately, Rangnick departed United for good at the end of that season after leading them to sixth place in the Premier League. Scholes was quick to judge the former RB Leipzig manager’s time in charge at Old Trafford, saying he didn’t resemble a top-level coach.
“They’re either not taking the instructions on, or they don’t want to,” Scholes said on United’s players under Rangnick.
“It’s been a bad six or seven months, the season’s not been good enough. The sack for Ole was coming, we all knew that, we all felt that but where was the plan? You think there has to be a plan, they must be bringing in an elite top coach into the football club to revive the season.
“Man Utd, they should have the best of everything. And to not have a plan and bring, what is technically, a sporting director. I think he’s coached a team two years out of the last 10 years.
“Don’t get me wrong, I like the man, I think he comes across really well. His team, it just looks like he lacks experience in the last five or six years. His team, they’re a team of individuals.”
Jose Mourinho
The Portuguese legend took over at United in 2016 after winning several major trophies in his career. Despite winning the Europa League and League Cup in 2017, United were labouring under the ex-Chelsea boss just a year on.
He was eventually sacked after a sobering defeat to Liverpool in December 2018, with Scholes claiming the former Real Madrid manager was “embarrassing” the club.
“The team is very low on confidence,” Scholes said in October 2018, with United struggling in the Champions League and Premier League.
“We talk about them being dull, and we talk about the first 10 games of the season, but you’re going into last season as well.
“The last year has been dull to watch. I don’t know how many times we’ve sat in this studio watching games and we end up watching the other screens, looking at the other games, trying to find some goals.
“He’s coming out in press conferences, he’s constantly having a go at players, he’s having a go at people above him because he’s not getting what he wants and I think his mouth is probably out of control and I think he’s embarrassing the club.”
