Manchester City cruised into the final of the Carabao Cup to face rivals Arsenal despite another poor second-half performance
Brace yourselves, Pep Guardiola may really be off this time. Any more leaps like the one that accompanied Manchester City’s third goal and the manager’s back is going to decide his future for him.
As it is, the sight of the 55-year-old twirling around his technical area and shaking his fists in joy at his 21-year-old Uzbek centre-back was a welcome reminder of the energy that is still alive and well at the Etihad. If Guardiola isn’t to see out his contract until 2027 – and it remains a big if – he will leave a squad that is good enough to compete for trophies.
City saved their best performance of the season for the first leg of this semi-final, holding their nerve in the north-east and then producing two moments of quality to take a 2-0 advantage. After Sunday’s collapse at Spurs though, there were more nerves than there should have been for the visit of Eddie Howe’s side.
FOLLOW OUR MAN CITY FACEBOOK PAGE! Latest news and analysis via the MEN’s Manchester City Facebook page
Guardiola’s selection left room for more nerves, placing responsibility on Omar Marmoush up front and Phil Foden behind him to get the game won. Marmoush duly obliged inside six minutes, exchanging rapid passes with Tijjani Reijnders before seeing Dan Burn’s attempted clearance loop in off the Egyptian’s shin.
Newcastle looked like they had turned up to do their best impression of the 2024/25 version of City, and their midfield was easily played through every time the home side went forward. Kieran Tripper looked to test with a free-kick, but the Blues countered, and when Trippier could only kick Antoine Semenyo’s cross up into the path of Marmoush as he fell over trying to get back, the striker had an easy second.
That isn’t to say that City had it all their way – James Trafford had to make a number of excellent saves when Newcastle did carve City open. However, they were awful in the middle and when Reijnders slammed home a third before half-time the game and the tie were done.
There was of course the obligatory City wobble as soon as the second half started, with Yoane Wissa shooting horribly wide in the first 30 seconds when put clean through on goal after an error from Abdukodir Khusanov. Warning unheeded, Anthony Elanga waltzed past Tijjani Reijnders, Rayan Ait-Nouri and Nico O’Reilly far too easily to pull a goal back after an hour.
Having been delighted in the first half, Guardiola’s mood changed as he watched another below-par performance coming after the break. His triple substitution with 20 minutes to go to bring on Rayan Cherki, Rodri, and Erling Haaland summed up where this City team are at: they can take Blues from one end of the spectrum to the other in the same match.
That sort of inconsistency needs addressing and ironing out, but it takes a high level to be 90 minutes from one trophy and well in the hunt for three others after six months of the season just as it does to reach five League Cup finals in 10 years. If his team can rise to it, Guardiola still has plenty of celebrations left in him.


