No one knows whether Andy Burnham will deliver the dramatic national change he promised on the steps of Downing Street. But he has already cleared the first hurdle.
The man who launched his premiership standing in a homeless shelter in Victoria in his trademark dark blue T-shirt and jacket looked and sounded dramatically different from any of his peers.
Most new Prime Ministers opt to frame their accession to the most senior office in the land by releasing an official portrait of them shaking hands with the monarch. Burnham chose to start his opening day as the King’s First Minister chopping mushrooms for a group of rough sleepers.
The change in narrative was further in evidence when he delivered his first address to the nation outside No 10 without the ornate podium favoured by Keir Starmer.
Speaking confidently, and without notes, he somberly intoned: ‘It requires my generation of politicians to raise our game and rise to the new challenge. Britain needs to show the world that we can regain our stability once again, and that is our challenge, to make politics work, to make it work better.’
A poll conducted last week revealed that 40 per cent of those questioned don’t know who Andy Burnham is. And I suspect those who have just been introduced to him for the first time will have liked what they saw.
He appeared sincere, relaxed, and managed to speak directly to the country, avoiding the awful technocratic buzzwords favoured by his immediate predecessors.
As one ally said to me: ‘We’ve got one job in the first few weeks, that’s to show that Andy Burnham does not represent business as usual. They’re sick of the Westminster circus.
No one knows whether Andy Burnham will deliver the dramatic national change he promised on the steps of Downing Street. But he has already cleared the first hurdle, writes Dan Hodges
‘And they want someone in Downing Street who looks like them, sounds like them and understands their hopes and fears.’
If that was indeed the objective yesterday, it was a case of job done. But if the first hurdle was cleared, there were also numerous reminders of the obstacles that still loom over him.
Over the past few days, he and his advisers have been keen to stress that despite the speed of the transition, Burnham has a clear plan for government. But yesterday he was forced to finally admit that is not the case.
‘Later this year, I will bring forward a new plan for Britain, a ten-year plan, laying out a path from where we are now to where I believe we all want Britain to be,’ he declared. So we will all have to wait weeks, or maybe months, before we know what Burnhamism actually looks like.
Then there was his headline pledge to end rough sleeping.
‘I will soon go through that door behind me and issue my first instruction: To end rough sleeping in our country,’ he announced with a characteristically dramatic flourish.
That was a foolish commitment, and one that over the years ahead will come back to haunt him.
No prime minister has the power to completely eradicate the scourge of rough sleeping. And every figure huddled in a doorway this winter will be held up by his political opponents as an example of his hubris and naivety.
Further problems are presaged by the appointment of his top team. The dramatic announcement of John Healey as Chancellor represents his first major collision with political reality.
He had intended to hand the post to key ally Ed Miliband. But a backlash from an unlikely alliance of the markets and the trade unions meant he had to embark on the first U-turn of his premiership. The selection of his wider Cabinet has also stored up trouble for the future.
The cull of Starmerite loyalists – Darren Jones, Steve Reed, David Lammy, Peter Kyle, Liz Kendall, Nick Thomas-Symonds and Lord Hermer – was surprisingly brutal. And while it communicated strength and underlined his change-focused agenda, those who have been discarded will already be plotting their revenge.
Rachel Reeves also has her allies across the party. As one Starmer supporter said: ‘What happened to the end of factionalism?’
The appointment of Miliband to Foreign Secretary also means three of the four great offices of state are now held by men. While this may represent a welcome repudiation of Labour’s hypocritical fixation with diversity by the party’s latest male leader, it will also store up resentment among Burnham’s female backbenchers.
So on the first day of the Burnham premiership, we learnt two important things.
First, we finally have a Prime Minister who is comfortable in his own skin. Keir Starmer only looked happy when he was out of the country he was elected to govern, glad-handing dignitaries on his foreign adventures.
Rishi Sunak appeared to the working people of Britain as if he had landed from Mars. Liz Truss spent her brief tenure of office looking like a rabbit in the headlights, which is what she basically was.
Andy Burnham likes being in the spotlight. Not, as some of his critics charge, because he has an inflated ego, but because he is good with people. His default stance is they are his allies on his great political adventure, not his enemies.
But we have also seen that while Andy Burnham is secure in his own skin, he is not yet fully at ease with his national leadership role. His decision to make rough sleeping his first major announcement, while worthy, represented a retreat into his mayoral comfort zone.
We are promised a further policy announcement on the cost of living tomorrow. But as we have seen, that will be rushed out in isolation, not as part of a wider, comprehensive, fully-costed economic strategy.
Although the diplomatic niceties were observed, and Donald Trump topped his list of calls to foreign dignitaries, there is an ongoing and concerted effort by his aides to shift the focus away from foreign affairs to domestic issues.
Yet in a sense, all of this was inevitable. As I observed yesterday, Burnham and his team had hoped they would have until the end of September to plan the transition of power. And Keir Starmer’s understandable – but nonetheless self-serving – refusal to hold the fort for his successor means Andy Burnham is not yet ready to take a firm grip on the reins of power.
So for now it will simply be a case of him taking each day at a time. And to be fair, our new Prime Minister’s first day in office has gone well. Much, much tougher days lie ahead.



You must be logged in to post a comment Login