Michael Carrick still has an impressive record as Man Utd head coach this season but it is becoming increasingly difficult for teams to stand out.
Paul Scholes didn’t phrase it particularly well and he missed the bigger issue, but he had a point. Manchester United haven’t been great in the last four games.
But they certainly haven’t been as bad as Scholes made out and seven points from a possible 12 in a run that includes away games at West Ham, Everton and Newcastle isn’t exactly disastrous.
The former United midfielder also picked the wrong target for his criticism. He put the blame on Carrick for United’s struggles, and the problem for Carrick is that others might be reaching for the simplistic conclusion as well.
But that is an issue that goes well beyond the current United head coach. So his side hasn’t been great in the last four games. Which Premier League team has?
Get MEN Premium now for just £1 HERE – or get involved in our United WhatsApp group by clicking HERE. You can also join our United Facebook page by clicking HERE and don’t miss out on our brilliant selection of newsletters HERE.
City and Arsenal have managed 10 points from the last four games, but for City that includes a home draw against Nottingham Forest and scrappy, battling wins against Leeds and Newcastle United. Arsenal drew with Wolves four games ago, won a set-piece bore against Chelsea and have just been criticised for their approach in edging past Brighton.
Liverpool have won three of the last four, but have just lost to Wolves and stole three points from the City Ground against Forest. In short, nobody is playing particularly well this season.
Ruud Gullit said this week he had stopped watching football because he no longer enjoys it and it’s no surprise it was a Premier League game that tipped him over the edge – Arsenal’s win against Chelsea.
The farcical battle for set-piece supremacy this season has dominated headlines recently, but that is only one chapter of a wider story. Every Premier League game has become a battle of duels, with man-to-man marking turning games into 10 individual battles. Win six of them and your chances of winning the game will be stronger.
That makes it difficult for any team to stand out in the Premier League. That only two of the 20 teams are outperforming their xG this season suggests chance creation has been low, and working openings and space from open play has been difficult. United aren’t alone in finding that difficult.
Too many matches are either being decided by set-pieces or are a war of attrition for 75 to 80 minutes, before players get tired and fresh substitutes influence the game, with space eventually opening up.
United’s recent lack of width is a fair criticism, but the games at West Ham, Everton and Newcastle were notable for a lack of space. United scored when they were throwing men forward at the London Stadium, from a rare counter-attack at the Hill Dickinson and from a set-piece at St James’ Park.
This isn’t an issue solely related to them and to Carrick. There is an argument that they deserve more credit than they got for winning an ugly game at Everton. They had one chance to show their quality, and they delivered with a brilliant move for Benjamin Sesko’s goal.
There are questions Carrick has to answer and he will be under pressure to find some answers against Aston Villa, but it takes a partner to dance, and not many teams in the Premier League this season are keen to tango.
Instead, games are becoming a mess of bodies and battles, of stoppages and set-pieces. It feels a bit unfair to be too critical of United, when no team in the league is looking like a slick footballing machine this season.
But this is the reality of Carrick’s situation. He has a limited timeframe in which to impress enough to get the job long-term. Even after defeat to Newcastle, he is still in plenty of credit, and if he can win enough games to finish third, that should be enough.
Some will want to look for someone who might deliver a more inspiring style, such as Luis Enrique or Julian Nagelsmann. But they are benefitting from not having to coach in the Premier League this season. Carrick is, and even if his team wins scrappy games, he should probably get more credit for that.

;)




