Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez was in the thick of things again for Argentina as they stunned Egypt 3-2 in Atlanta in their World Cup last 16 clash
What a difference four days makes. After Argentina had overcome a scare against Cape Verde to advance to the World Cup round of 16, MEN Sport rightly sung the praises of Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez. While his nation may have looked to Lionel Messi for inspiration, it was Martinez at both ends of the pitch who delivered the victory.
Fast forward to Tuesday evening and it was Martinez in the spotlight but this time, for all the wrong reasons. He was easily beaten in the air for Yasser Ibrahim’s opener before losing sight of Mostafa Ziko to put Egypt on the brink of qualification.
Martinez’s defensive partner Cristian Romero reduced the arrears with 11 minutes of normal time remaining and while Argentina eventually managed to scrape through, it did not save the defensive duo from Gary Neville’s cutting criticism.
“You watch Romero and Martinez, and they’re the best ‘worst centre-halves’ in the world,” he told ITV Sport post-match.
“You watch them, they give goals away constantly. But they don’t care about giving goals away because they’ll score goals at the other end. They have massive personalities and they keep going. Look, at that point in the game, you think Argentina are hanging on for dear life.
“They’re fighting for their lives and Romero is part of that comeback, you know what I mean? Why is he there? You always ask the questions: ‘Why is Martinez scoring in the last game? Why is Romero scoring there?’ Because they don’t give in and they fight, and they fight, and they fight.”
Some of those traits that Martinez has showcased at the World Cup, are what have made him an Old Trafford fan favourite. You can tell the passion he feels, every minute he is on the pitch.
And when it is channelled in the right way, you see magical performances like against Cape Verde or when he proved the critics wrong against Manchester City last season. However, this gung-ho approach has a time and a place, and that is not during a marathon, 38-game, Premier League season.
The issue for Argentina is that Martinez and Romero are cut from the same cloth. They both wear their hearts on their sleeve and neither man is afraid of jumping feet first into a tackle to spark a reaction.
But realistically, you cannot go a full season with two centre-backs like that. You leave yourself too prone to attacks and you simply cannot win every match 3-2.
That doesn’t necessarily mean there is no longer a place for Martinez in United’s defence. We saw last season that he can do well partnered with Harry Maguire who is perhaps the ‘yin’ to the Argentine’s ‘yang’.
The worry is that beyond next season Martinez, were he to stay at Old Trafford, would become the experienced head in that defence. Matthijs de Ligt could take on that responsibility but as we all know, there are questions as to whether he will return to the same standard he reached before his back injury.
Having a player like Martinez in your squad can be valuable, as he has shown in this tournament with some impressive defensive displays. But knowing when to be calm and provide a clear head at the back in order to keep a valuable clean sheet is equally as important, if not more so.
That’s the Martinez United need next season and if he can find that balance, which he managed against Cape Verde, the Reds will benefit.
























You must be logged in to post a comment Login