The Cheesecake Guy founded by Matt Kaplan, who is originally from The Big Apple, is situated on the Shambles, and is known for (you guessed it), “authentic” New York cheesecakes that are a “heavenly”.
Visitors said they have “never tasted a cheesecake as good as this” when stopping by the sweet treat paradise.
On The Cheesecake Guy website, Matt reveals: “I moved to York in 2014 from West Palm Beach, Florida.
“My wife grew up in Yorkshire and I loved it when I first visited, so much we decided to live here.
“In less than a year we had packed everything up, and were moving here, dogs and all!
“I was born in New York so living in ‘Olde’ York seems fitting!”
He adds: “Baking is in my blood, my grandfather owned his own bakery, Sherry’s, on 110th and Broadway in New York in the 1960s and 1970s, so it might not be a surprise to my grandmother that this is what I love to do.
“I can always remember him bringing home baker’s boxes at the end of each day!
“All my cheesecakes are baked – in my opinion the only way to make a cheesecake!”
Just some of the current cheesecake flavours available include vanilla, Biscoff, chocolate orange, Galaxy caramel, lemon, Kinder Bueno, peanut butter, banana, and so many more.
The Cheesecake Guy offers ‘a taste of New York in Old York’
On social media, Yorkshire-List praised The Cheesecake Guy for offering “authentic New York treats”.
In a video, the local food and travel expert commented: “Fancy a taste of New York in Old York? You’ll find The Cheesecake Guy on York’s famous Shambles and they’re whipping up authentic New York treats day in, day out.
“The owner was born and bred in New York and his family ran a popular New York bakery in the 60s, so you’re getting a truly authentic experience.
“Their baked cheesecakes are the star of the show with plenty of delicious flavours, from Biscoff to cookies and cream, and strawberry.
“The pistachio had to be our favourite.”
It continued: “As for the décor, it’s giving New York coffee shop and we loved all the quirky little wall stickers.
“If you’re in York, The Cheesecake Guy is definitely worth a visit.”
Matt shares that he loves to make new flavours on request and can make many of the flavours gluten-free, lactose-free or vegan – just email to find out more.
Other customers seem to agree with the Yorkshire-List as over on Tripadvisor, The Cheesecake Guy has a “very good” 4.7/5 rating.
This customer commented: “Met the cheesecake guy himself today Matt.
“Incredibly nice man and the cheesecake was first class best I’ve had.
Have you ever had a New York cheesecake? (Image: Tripadvisor)
“Didn’t even get chance to snap it before I’d eaten half of it. Recommend the pistachio. Will be back.”
Another recent guest posted: “A little taste of heaven! We ordered a selection of the moni cheesecakes and they were the perfect little treat!
“Each one was packed with mouthwatering sweetness and full of flavour bit not too much going on. Perfectly enjoyable.”
Someone else put: “Just the best cheesecake ever in the quirkiest street in York. Amazing flavours, and wonderful staff. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in York.”
Meanwhile, this profile commented: “Had the baklava cheesecake. Never tasted a cheesecake as good as this.
“This place must be visited if you want something exceptional whilst in York.”
Have you been to The Cheesecake Guy in York? Let us know what your favourite cheesecake flavours are.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login