Residents packed out Townley Memorial Hall to voice their opposition to the proposed East West Rail train cleaning centre near Fulbourn, as many said the whole project “needs cancelling”
Cambridgeshire Live readers have expressed robust opinions about proposals for a Cambridge Eastern Train Care Centre near Fulbourn, with many questioning the scheme, its positioning and its timing.
Local residents filled their village hall to voice their opposition to a proposed train cleaning facility. East West Rail (EWR) has identified a site near Fulbourn “as the most likely location” for the new centre, which has faced widespread resistance in the village.
A public meeting took place on Sunday (May 31) where residents filled Townley Memorial Hall to discuss the proposals and strategies to challenge them. James Colyer, one of the organisers, said the turnout was “beyond expectations” and the mood among residents was very clear.
The 46-year-old said: “This was literally just sprung upon us – potential site or not – and in a town of this many people we only have a limited amount of space.
“The feeling across the whole village, across Wilbraham, Teversham and all the surrounding villages is all the same. This is just utterly preposterous, utterly – utterly preposterous and will bring about the destruction of the area.”
One of our readers, Garyblowpants comments: “The whole thing needs cancelling. It will turn out to be a complete disaster like HS2. Way over budget, delivered decades late and completely out of date if it is ever finished. Cancel it now!”
Timturb0 adds: “Local complaints about disruption and ‘limited space’ in Fulbourn come across as classic petty NIMBY resistance — short-sighted and stubbornly unwilling to accept shared national responsibility. Residents packed the hall to label the plans ‘utterly preposterous’ and ‘devastating’ after they were supposedly ‘sprung upon us,’ yet this ignores the facts.
“The proposed Cambridge Eastern Train Care Centre sits right on the edge of Fulbourn on pre-existing fields along Wilbraham Road. With thoughtful design, it will cause limited long-term interruption to village life while delivering essential infrastructure. Britain is growing rapidly, almost entirely due to high net migration, adding millions more people who need housing, jobs, and reliable transport — especially in the Oxford-Cambridge arc. East West Rail and this depot are vital to provide frequent, dependable services, cut wasted empty mileage, ease road congestion, and support economic growth. Blocking it harms everyone.
“Suggesting ‘put it somewhere else’ is the same weak excuse that stalls infrastructure nationwide. A growing, diverse Britain demands openness to change and practical trade-offs. No village can freeze in time while the country absorbs large-scale immigration and expands.
“The way forward: insist on strong mitigation like noise barriers and screening, plus local benefits such as jobs and better services — but drop the stubborn delay tactics. Britain needs to build. Embracing necessary edge-of-village sites like this is the responsible, forward-looking response to our demographic reality.”
Calumen Nomen says: “East-West Rail is anything but vital. There is no viable business case for it (that’s why EWR won’t publish one), the environmental degradation is on a colossal scale and goes through much BMV (Grade 1) agricultural land.
“And the Infrastructure and Projects Authority said that ‘successful delivery of the project appears to be unachievable. There are major issues with project definition, schedule, budget, quality and/or benefits delivery, which at this stage do not appear to be manageable or resolvable. The project may need re-scoping and/or its overall viability reassessed.’ And then, of course, there’s the perverse decision to build ‘Britain’s biggest New Town’ and then by-pass it completely by this new rail-track. Oh -and we have a falling birth-rate. This is not a ‘growing Britain’.”
Camssurvivor thinks: “With British Rail being nationalised again, I expect a drop in passenger numbers. Private competition increased business by 50 per cent. Indifference in the public sector is highly likely to lead to negative outcomes.”
Rhodabike says: “Quite right, the residents are objecting. A project of this scale is not appropriate for a residential area. There’s no reason whatsoever why it has to be built next to houses.”
Would you welcome the proposed train cleaning centre? Comment below or HERE to have your say.





.jpeg?quality=75&auto=webp&width=960)




You must be logged in to post a comment Login