For many UK growing businesses, using spreadsheets is such an integral part of running a company is like using that noisy kettle that still works.
It’s what we always did, so why change? They are trusted, inexpensive (in the short term), and simple. You can fit everything onto one doc, with employee info on one tab, sick leave on another, expenses in a third, and their hours and salary on tabs beginning after “Sheet 1” (usually only fully understandable by one super user).
For a while, it seems like a perfect system. Then the business hires 10 more employees. One employee works from another location. A boss forgets to fill in a vacation planner. Unbeknownst to everyone, the once thought-up efficient plan is slowly doubling, as well as tripling, to add to time, money, and irritation.
The issue is not the spreadsheet, per se. The problem is that the company grows so big, spreadsheets are just too small on their own to contain it.
The Productivity Drain Nobody Notices
Manual HR doesn’t really fall over. It just slowly pours away your company’s margin every day.
Managers hunting down signed documents, updating the 5 locations where they keep employee records, and checking whether the “latest” version of a spreadsheet is actually the latest. HR admins are doing the same weekly manual tasks: copying data, approving leave requests from chain emails, and calculating absence values in a spreadsheet.
On their own, these little tasks don’t seem like much. Added up, they’re a tidy sum.
A growing company might be burning through dozens of hours every month on tasks like maintaining manual processes that should long since have been automated. All that time could be spent by managers on developing their staff, operational improvements, growth, or really anything other than knowing how to track down that contract the vendor sent a while ago that is almost definitely in the Generally Important Stuff 2019_Q3 folder titled “FINAL_v2_UPDATED” on the general drive.
But, most notably, as companies scale, inefficient manual processes compound. When a team is eight, maintaining a process may work fine, but by the time a company gets to 50 employees, it’s a frustrating mess.
Human Error Becomes a Business Risk
Spreadsheets are labour-intensive and are therefore prone to human error.
An out-of-date phone number may not seem serious until you need an emergency contact. A double entry in the payroll may provide uncomfortable conversations and headaches for the accountants. An incorrect holiday day entered in a spreadsheet can damage employee trust much faster than you may think.
The biggest problem is that unconnected systems introduce inconsistencies. A spreadsheet says an employee has completed the required training. Another sheet says they haven’t. One manager updates a record while the other keeps using the file they saved to their desktop three weeks ago.
This isn’t due to carelessness. This is what happens when there’s too much room for error.
Compliance Problems Can Escalate Quickly
Problems can grow quickly from bad to worse
Storing a few contracts in a shared drive just isn’t good enough.
You also need to keep on top of your employee files, manage right-to-work checks, make sure you’re tracking absence procedures, and keep sensitive data safe. If this information is spread out over a few spreadsheets, emails, and a couple of random systems, maintaining good compliance practices is going to be confusing at best.
Where documents are missing or records aren’t being generated, businesses open themselves up to unnecessary legal and financial risks. Even the smallest oversight can expand to cause real issues during audits, claims or disputes.
It’s another reason why businesses reach a point when manual processes quickly get out of hand, and they decide to look for dedicated UK HR software to manage.
That solution allows firms to centralise their records, automate reminders, and ensure that important documents aren’t getting buried in the depths of a filing cabinet.
Employees Notice More Than Businesses Think
Old, paper-based HR systems have a bigger impact on the employee experience than many leaders believe.
They see that their leave request has taken two days to approve because the right spreadsheet was buried three tabs down. They see when others’ induction processes are ad-hoc. They see themselves waiting three days for a response from HR. They see managers asking for information they already supplied for the second time.
These may sound like minor complaints, but they reflect the way employees perceive their employers. A company that isn’t buttoned up in its operational processes will have a hard time projecting external credibility.
In markets with healthy competition for talent, the operational efficiency of an organisation plays a significant role in effective employer branding. Workers now have an expectation that things will operate smoothly in a workplace, especially as many workplaces tout themselves as forward-thinking, corporate-minded or on a very aggressive growth trajectory.
Technology Creates Room for Growth
HR software is seen as a grudge purchase that businesses can get by without for now, but it’s an outlay that pays off in terms of efficiency and future growth.
Modern platforms cut out the busywork, reduce human error, ensure compliance with automatically enforced policies and shared digital records, and remove time-consuming HR headaches when you scale.
Spreadsheets have value, but relying on them entirely for HR often leads to creeping costs that go unnoticed for far too long.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login