John Swinney has refused to commit to stopping violent thugs who attack women being given bail or getting released early from jail.
The First Minister failed to back calls for immediate action despite pledging ‘personal leadership’ to protect women from violence and saying recent cases in Scotland have been ‘appalling’.
It came as he was confronted by opponents following the recent deaths of 35-year-old Stacy Hunter and Samantha Lee, 54, who were both killed by their partners or exes.
Ms Hunter was killed by her estranged husband Jim Mair, 43, in Houston, Renfrewshire, three weeks after he was released on bail after being accused in court of strangling her. He then took his own life.
Ms Lee was killed by her partner Joseph Greer, 40, with a claw hammer in Aberdeen while he was banned from approaching her. He was jailed for a minimum of 22 earlier this year.
The Tories, Labour and the Liberal Democrats all raised concerns about violence against women in the opening First Minister’s Questions of the new Holyrood term, just days after Mr Swinney pledged a new Misogyny Bill in his programme for government.
Stacy Hunter was killed by her estranged husband
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay highlighted the murder of both Ms Hunter and Ms Lee by ‘dangerous scumbags who were freed to kill’.
He demanded that a statutory presumption against bail for those accused of violent, sexual or domestic abuse offences in solemn case is reinstated following its repeal in 2023, and also called for him not to proceed with automatic early release of men who commit violence against women after two-thirds of their sentence.
Mr Findlay said: ‘His consultation document even admits that this “could have an impact” for victims of violence against women and girls. This cannot be allowed to happen.
‘I’ve written to the First Minister this morning setting out a range of constructive proposals to protect women and girls.
‘Will he stop violent thugs who attack women from being given bail, and stop them from being freed early?’
Mr Swinney said he would be happy to meet to discuss issues with Mr Findlay and victims of ‘heinous crimes’.
He said: ‘What I will do is apply the leadership that I’ve set out to parliament to make sure that we have in place a combination of different measures.
‘There are of course criminal justice aspects of this whole issue that have got to be set out. But there is also the principled leadership to communicate to men and boys in our society through every aspect of the work of the State the unacceptability of violence against women and girls, and I will lead that effort within Government.
‘And if there are constructive contributions to be made in parliament then I will of course welcome them but I ensure Parliament of the determined leadership that I am going to give to address this issue.’
Earlier, Mr Swinney pledged ‘personal leadership’ on tackling violence against women and girls and admitted that ‘the experience over the summer has been appalling in Scotland and it has to be remedied’.
Scottish Labour acting leader Dame Jackie Baillie highlighted soaring numbers of sexual crimes, rape and domestic abuse, as well as delays between reporting incidents and convictions.
Citing the murder of 28-year-old Claire Inglis in 2021 when her boyfriend Christopher McGowan was bailed to her address as well as the call of Ms Hunter’s for GPS tracking of violent offenders on bail, she demanded a clear timetable of when ‘life-saving changes’ will be enacted.
Mr Swinney said the cases ‘give us all cause for concern about the fact those individuals were on bail and were able to perpetrate the heinous crimes that they were able to perpetrate’ and highlighted that pilot work is underway on GPS tracking and he wanted progress as quickly as possible.
But Ms Baillie said: ‘Actions speak louder than words and so I want to press him on that timetable for GPS tracking because women’s lives are being lost whilst it is not in place.
‘The epidemic of violence against women and girls in Scotland demands immediate action and we cannot afford any more delay.’
John Swinney pledged ‘personal leadership’ on tackling violence against women and girls
Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Alex Cole-Hamilton also raised the murder of Vikki Soloman, 44, by her ex-partner Lee Greenan in Edinburgh after police didn’t attend a call asking for help. He later died in custody.
Mr Hamilton said: ‘There is a pattern here of women being let down by the system, horrifically let down, and with fatal consequences.’
He added: ‘For Vikki, for Stacy, for all of those currently facing abuse, will this government act with urgency before more women die at the hands of men?’
Mr Swinney said: ‘Yes, we will.’
Following the exchanges, the First Minister’s official spokesman said he ‘wants to work constructively with others’ on the issue.
But when asked if any commitment can be given that domestic abusers and sex offenders won’t be given early release, he said the consultation on the issue has recently closed and ‘that process will have to play out’.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login