A Jewish man who repeatedly kicked a Catholic nun has been acquitted based on his insanity defence – but has been ordered to be committed to a psychiatric hospital for up to six years.
The violent assault in April on a 48-year-old nun walking in her habit in Jerusalem‘s Old City sent shock waves across Israel and its many Christian communities.
The attacker, who has not been named, shoved the elderly woman causing her to collapse to the floor hard, and began to walk away when he doubled back and repeatedly kicked the nun.
The assault that left severe bruising on the nun occurred in front of the Cenacle, a building on Jerusalem’s Mount Zion considered holy to both Christians and Jews, the latter of whom regard it as the burial place of the biblical figure King David.
A judge at Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court today ruled that there was evidence that a Jewish man from a settlement in the occupied West Bank committed the actions he was charged with.
However, he was entitled to an insanity defence after the district psychiatrist found he was psychotic at the time of the attack.
The director of The French Biblical and Archaeological School of Jerusalem, where the nun is a researcher, said that he hoped the psychiatric hospitalisation would be carried out in full ‘so that public safety can be assured, our colleague can recover psychologically, and people can live in and visit Jerusalem without fear, regardless of their belonging to any community’.
But Friar Olivier Poquillon added he regretted the decision not to impose a criminal penalty.
A Jewish man who repeatedly kicked a Catholic nun has been acquitted based on his insanity defence
The attacker, who has not been named, shoved the elderly lady causing her to collapse to the floor hard, and began to walk away when he doubled back and repeatedly kicked the nun who
The assault occurred in front of the Cenacle, a building on Jerusalem’s Mount Zion considered holy to both Christians and Jews, left the nun with heavy bruises to her face
‘At the moment of the incident, his judgment was nevertheless sufficient for him to deliberately choose a Catholic nun as his victim from among all the people present,’ he said.
Clergy and advocates say verbal abuse and spitting have grown increasingly common in the densely packed historic heart of Jerusalem.
There, Christians, Jews and Muslims cross paths daily, mostly uneventfully, as they visit some of the holiest sites of Christianity, Islam and Judaism.
But the violent beating of the nun was seen as a rare and worrisome escalation in the volatile environment that people of all faiths have been experiencing in nearly three years of war.
Yisca Harani, who founded the organization Religious Freedom Data Center to track harassment of Christians, said even mentally unstable people can be influenced to act by the prevailing discourse around them.
‘He is still someone who is the product of either the ignorance or the incitement that is around him,’ she said.
‘Even if he is mentally unstable, he was fed with all that anti-Christian material that is around us now.’
Harani’s organization has tracked a near-tripling of incidents in Jerusalem from four years ago to the last three months recorded – about one a day now – virtually all by Jewish religious nationalists.
Their hostility to Christians is grounded in the history of persecution of Jews in Christian-majority European countries, in faith practices they see as idol-worshipping, and in seeing their presence as an affront near areas historically sacred to Jews, like the Western Wall, experts say.
In April, an Israeli Defence Force soldier was filmed destroying a statue of Jesus Christ in a southern Lebanon village, an act that drew widespread condemnation
At the time of the attack, Israel’s foreign ministry condemned the ‘shameful act’ in a statement on X, and said Israel remained committed ‘to safeguarding freedom of religion and freedom of worship for all faiths’.
In April, an Israeli Defence Force soldier was filmed destroying a statue of Jesus Christ in a southern Lebanon village, an act that drew widespread condemnation.
The IDF said it viewed the incident with ‘great severity’ and that the conduct of the two soldiers related to the incident was ‘wholly inconsistent with the values expected of its troops’.
Ambassador George Deek, Israel’s new special envoy to the Christian world, said that earlier this month, Israeli police appointed an English-speaking officer to be a first point of contact for Christians in case of incidents, ‘so there will be a rapid response’.
‘We are going to come up with practical solutions to how we can minimise or stop, if possible, the phenomenon,’ Deek said. ‘We take these issues very seriously.’

You must be logged in to post a comment Login