Gilfoyle spent 17 years in prison following the death of his wife
A new true crime documentary will explore the story of Eddie Gilfoyle, who was jailed for killing his pregnant wife Paula.
Gilfoyle’s story features in the third episode of the new Channel 4 series The Accused: Beyond Reasonable Doubt. It will air on Thursday night (July 2) at 10pm.
The new series tells the stories of people fighting convictions that they believe are a miscarriage of justice. After years in prison they attempt to overturn their guilty verdict. Episode one examined Jason Moore, who was sent to prison in 2013 for the murder of his ‘close friend’ Robert Darby.
Click here to get the biggest stories straight to your inbox in our Daily Newsletter
Last week’s second episode was centred around Stacey Hyde, who was jailed for killing her best friend’s boyfriend when she was a teenager. The series has been praised for how it examines the impact on those who maintain their innocence.
Eddie and Paula Gilfoyle appeared the perfect couple, having recently tied the knot and were expecting their first child together in June 1992. Appearing as a happy couple, tragedy soon struck.
Paula, who was eight and a half months pregnant, was found hanged in the garage of their home in Upton, Wirral. She was just 32 years old at the time of her death.
While all the evidence pointed towards a tragic act of suicide, Gilfoyle was arrested just four days later. He was soon charged with his wife’s murder.
Police had found a handwritten note at the scene, pointing to Paula’s death being deliberate on her part. However, prosecutors said at former Army medic Gilfoyle’s trial that he had forced his wife to write the suicide note. The jury was also told that he convinced her to put a noose around her neck and climb a ladder.
Despite protesting his innocence and denying the allegations, Gilfoyle was found guilty of murder and handed a life sentence. He spent 17 years behind bars.
The Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), which investigates possible miscarriages of justice, inherited an application for review of the conviction after an expert prosecution witness changed their view about the likely cause of death. While the CCRC referred the conviction to the Court of Appeal in March 1999, the court upheld the case in December of the following year.
With Gilfoyle and his legal team making repeated efforts for the case to be examined, the CCRC declined to refer his case back to the Court of Appeal. Complaints issued by Gilfoyle about the case include claims that investigating officers walked through the crime scene, the destruction of evidence and a lack of proper investigation.
While he was eventually released on license 17 years after his wife’s death, Gilfoyle is still fighting to clear his name. The new episode of The Accused will see him talking about his version of what happened and why he kept fighting for nearly two decades in prison.
Also appearing in the documentary are legal experts and psychologists, who will examine whether Gilfoyle has any other way to clear his name. Gilfoyle’s case has previously been explored in a BBC Panorama special.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login