Manchester United need to replace Casemiro this summer but the hunt for an elite midfielder is proving difficult.
Manchester United are not even halfway through the summer transfer window and they have already been dealt two major blows. After the relatively smooth purchase of Ederson from Atalanta, United have hit a wall as they set their sights on an elite Casemiro replacement.
The first name on their radar was Elliot Anderson. Nottingham Forest were keen to stick to their valuation of the midfielder but his £116m transfer fee was not the only problem for United. It was a case of deja vu for the Reds as, like Antoine Semenyo before him, Anderson had his heart set on Manchester City.
Realising a move for Anderson was off the table, the Reds changed tack. Mateus Fernandes was next on the list, with the West Ham midfielder destined to leave following the Hammers’ Premier League relegation. While they were keen on Fernandes, the Reds were deterred by his price tag.
West Ham needed to sell, so his £85m valuation looked open to negotiation. That was until Tottenham swooped in and met the Irons’ asking price. Unlike Bryan Mbeumo the season prior, Fernandes gave no reassurances that he only wanted United.
As such, a move across the capital was agreed and the Reds were back at the drawing board. United’s next move now needs to work. Next week, the Reds return to pre-season training and while it will be a depleted group thanks to the World Cup, the Reds would have hoped to have their Casemiro replacement decided.
United have a long list of players they are watching. One of those is Brighton and Hove Albion midfielder Carlos Baleba.
Towards the end of last summer’s window, United enquired about signing Baleba. Brighton responded with a £100m asking price.
That figure was not plucked out of thin air. Baleba’s 2024/25 season was measured in comparison to Moises Caicedo’s before him. Brighton managed to squeeze £115m out of Chelsea for Caicedo, so nine figures was deemed a reasonable demand.
The Reds chose to bide their time. Besides, Casemiro was still around for another year and, by 2026, Baleba’s valuation could have dropped.
United’s decision not to move for Baleba looked to be vindicated as he struggled last season. Links to United persisted throughout the campaign as head coach Fabian Hurzeler attempted to protect his player.
“I saw a Carlos Baleba who stepped up,” the Brighton boss told Sky Sports prior to their trip to Old Trafford in October. “These were good actions and good behaviours he showed, but he has to make habits out of those good behaviours.
“That’s the next step in his development, to bring consistency to his performance. Carlos won’t get better if he only gets compliments and claps from outside.
“I think he will get better if he has a safe environment, but also honest feedback where he knows what he needs to improve. That’s where we try to support him and make him better.”
Brighton have not indicated they have lowered their asking price for Baleba and if that is not reason enough for United to steer clear of him, Hurzeler’s comments are. Were Baleba to join United, he would not be afforded a ‘safe environment’ to mature.
He would be arriving with United looking for him to make an immediate impact and help United compete on four fronts, including in the Champions League. That is not a ‘safe environment’ for a player to develop.
At £100m, United need to be signing the finished product, not a player who still has room to grow. Baleba could develop massively this season but right now he is an expensive risk the Reds can’t afford to take.




You must be logged in to post a comment Login