He was found guilty of breaking electoral law after posting a false statement about a Conservative council candidate
A Reform UK councillor has said they “were taken in as much as anybody else” by another party member convicted of breaking electoral law. Andy Osborn was found guilty of publishing a false statement about a Conservative candidate in a social media post in April 2025.
The court heard he wrote on Facebook: “Samantha Hoy worked in the care industry but allegedly was sacked for fraud no wonder Wisbech is in such a state. Reform UK.”
Cllr Hoy, who works in the care industry, and has never been sacked or faced fraud allegations, called the situation “incredibly hard”.
Cambridgeshire County Council said Mr Osborn told them in writing “on two separate occasions” that he would appeal the conviction, but did not do so before the May 5 deadline. A by-election will be held in his former ward of Roman Bank and Peckover.
Speaking at a county council meeting, Cllr Hoy said: “I don’t want to pretend that what happened to me was the worst thing in the world because actually people every day go through far worse things than what happened to me. But I also don’t want us to just quietly accept that abuse in public life is okay.
“Having to explain to people on the doorstep why this is being raised – and why this lie is being told. Waiting a year and then to go to court, to go in your little witness box and take your oath, is quite a daunting experience.
“I don’t blame everyone in Reform because we’ve probably all had bad apples, but I am disappointed that I have never even privately to this day had an apology from a single member of Reform. In fact, people have defended him and said it was just a mistake.”
Cllr Mike Black expressed his sympathies and said that “councillors should not be put through what she’s been put through”. The Labour councillor said: “I think I’ll just say that I do feel that he has been an exemplary councillor for Reform.
“I thought a shocking example of the conduct was that when pointed out that this jibe was unfair, that it wasn’t withdrawn, and was just doubled down on. I fear that is the sort of thing that does course in our politics today and that we shouldn’t be carrying on with.”
Cllr Steve Tierney said that he didn’t hold Reform UK responsible for “one bad egg”. The Conservative councillor said: “It’s really tempting because we’re all politicians to make political points when things like this happen and I don’t think we should do it.
“If we use this to make political points we take away the personal, and the personal is what matters. A friend of mine was treated abominably and the man that did it has paid the consequences, rightly so.”
Cllr Des Watt, now an independent but formerly of Reform, said: “What a tangled web we weave when we choose to deceive. I would just like to say as a former colleague of Andy Osborne, he gave me a right old cock and bull story too and he took his own colleagues in as well. I’m not authorised to speak on behalf of my former colleagues but I suspect there was a lot of that going on.”
Cllr Colin Galbraith, of Reform UK, offered his personal apologies to Cllr Hoy but said he couldn’t do it on behalf of the party. He said: “Yes, Cllr Watt is correct, we were taken in – as an individual I do not condone at all what Andy Osborn did.
“Cllr Osborne took it upon himself to make these accusations – it was never discussed and we were never sure of what he’d actually said and what he’d say in court. Reform were taken in as much as anybody else.
“Yes, I will make an apology to Cllr Hoy personally – I can’t do it on behalf of the Reform party because this has nothing to do with the Reform party. What he said, he wasn’t saying it on behalf of our party – yes, it is embarrassing – yes, I don’t like it, and I hope we can move on.”
The council agreed to start preparations for a by-election.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login