Manchester United are ready to pursue hiring Michael Carrick on a permanent basis after a successful interim spell in charge
Manchester United are edging closer to appointing Michael Carrick as their permanent successor to Ruben Amorim. When he arrived on an interim basis in January, few would have imagined Carrick being the frontrunner for the job by the end of the season.
However, it is understood he wanted some assurances the job would be his if he did well enough. At the time, United wisely decided it was best to keep their options open and would therefore not offer those commitments. Carrick was happy to be merely a caretaker if needs be and that was enough to win the race.
Circumstances have since bumped Carrick up the pecking order for the permanent job. United wanted a world class head coach who had been there and done it. This summer, those candidates are missing. Thomas Tuchel committed his future to England, Carlo Ancelotti is happy with Brazil and Julian Nagelsmann is tied to Germany, at least until the World Cup ends.
Click here to find out the latest Manchester United news in our daily newsletter
Meanwhile, the likes of Luis Enrique and Zinedine Zidane were either unattainable or unrealistic. Andoni Iraola and Oliver Glasner emerged as the only likely alternatives and neither man seems vastly better suited to the role than Carrick. However, it would be unfair to suggest the 44-year-old is the favourite on a technicality.
United’s form since he returned has been remarkable. Carrick has masterminded victories over rival managers Pep Guardiola, Mikel Arteta, Unai Emery and Arne Slot. The Reds have qualified for the Champions League comfortably and the squad finds itself in an overwhelmingly good position.
Carrick deserves the opportunity to have a go next season. However, Ineos cannot repeat the mistakes of the past.
Sir Jim Ratcliffe and co. begrudgingly stuck with Erik ten Hag following the 2023/24 season. Ten Hag delivered a sensational FA Cup triumph over Manchester City that forced their hand.
After way too many weeks of indecision, United continued with Ten Hag but they did not put their full weight of support behind him. Yes, in the summer transfer window the Dutchman was given money to spend.
It was a collective decision to sell Scott McTominay and sign Manuel Ugarte, for instance. However, the Reds were starting to leave him slightly exposed.
This was evidenced by backroom staff appointments. Perhaps the most egregious was the arrival of Ruud van Nistelrooy.
United’s legendary striker made it clear he was not hired to eventually replace Ten Hag but arriving as an assistant, when he had no previous connection to the boss, was odd.
It was no surprise when patience finally ran out with Ten Hag in October 2024, it was Van Nistelrooy who stepped up to be the interim head coach. The backroom staff are arguably just as important as the players who arrive.
You would have never seen Sir Alex Ferguson undermined by backroom staff appointments made by the boardroom. They need to be people who the manager can trust.
In fairness to Ineos, they learnt their lesson when Amorim was appointed. They brought in staff who the Portuguese head coach wanted and backed him to the hills – until they didn’t.
Carrick seems to be getting the same backing now. Steve Holland (assistant manager), Jonathan Woodgate (first-team coach), Jonny Evans (first-team coach) and Travis Binnion (first-team coach) are all expected to be handed contracts, along with Carrick, should he stay.
The club are happy with the blend of experience and personalities in that set up. Sticking with the team that has worked so well up to this point is a good starting point for Carrick.
However, it is just that. A start. Amorim had all the backing but it did not work.
Carrick’s lighter touch has returned United to the Champions League. But only time will tell if he can replicate that success long-term.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login