Reviews of the new 10-part horror comedy series starring Matthew Rhys are full of praise
Fans of Stephen King in particular have been told this new series is a must watch.
The first couple of episodes of Widow’s Bay are streaming now and early reviews urge audiences not to miss out. In fact, some have claimed that it is the best new show of the year so far.
However, while critics have been able to make their judgement on the entire 10-part series, fans will face a wait. Only two episodes have landed on Apple TV+ so far.
Following instalments will be released on a weekly basis, each Wednesday. As a result, the finale is expected to be available sometime in June.
Star of Netflix series The Beast in Me and The Americans Matthew Rhys leads the cast as Mayor Tom Loftis. As expected, it is set in Widow’s Bay, a quaint island town 40 miles off the coast of New England where something lurks beneath the surface.
The Mayor is desperate to revive his struggling community. Not only is there no Wi-Fi, spotty cellular reception and very little to actually do, he must also contend with superstitious locals who believe their island is cursed.
They don’t respect him or his position but he is determined to build a better future for his teenage son and turn the island into a tourist destination. Even in the face of some success, unfortunately, it seems the locals were right. After decades of calm, the old stories that seemed too ludicrous to be true start happening again.
Reviews have already begun to be published online and the vast majority are extremely positive. In fact, at the time of writing, Widow’s Bay has managed to record a perfect 100% rating on website Rotten Tomatoes against 23 reviews.
Get Apple TV free for a week

TV fans can get Apple TV free for a week to stream shows like Ted Lasso, Severance and Slow Horses.
Critics have so far praised the show’s blending of the comedy and horror genres, highlighting that the series is so far a thrill for fans of both genres. As one person pointed out: “Just about every horror trope is accounted for, and they are masterfully woven together through the eyes of several of Widow’s Bay’s most quirky residents.”
Another declared: “Apple TV’s delightfully oddball horror-comedy may have a few flaws, but it’s like almost nothing else on TV at the moment.”
One reviewer penned: “A brilliant horror comedy packed with atmosphere – it’s Jaws meets The Shining meets Veep! Matthew Rhys stars in yet another great show backed up by a very strong cast. Dippold & Murai have created something special.”
Meanwhile, one verdict claimed: “While still feeling original, it riffs on supernatural legends and ghost stories that come naturally to old seafaring towns, with references to classic sea horror like The Fog, and Jaws. Amid the supernatural tension and jeopardy, it’s also a lot of fun.”
One seemed to agree as they said: “Widow’s Bay starts as a horror-comedy that is engaging, scary and entertaining from all angles. The combination of clever character development, subtle comedy and horror is a beautiful concoction that makes for must-watch TV.”
Another added: “Eerie and uniquely haunting, the outstanding visuals, coupled with the exceptional performances, ensure that the series beams like a lighthouse, waiting to welcome lost souls back home.”
While others confidently stated that Widow’s Bay should be considered a highlight of the year: “The result is a series that’s as funny as it is unsettling, with moments so genuinely scary you can’t help but laugh. Without a doubt, creator Katie Lippold has delivered one of the best new shows of 2026.”
In a similar vein, another critic put forward: “A charmingly ghoulish saga about a locale beset by the sins of the past. It’s also, to date, the best new show of the year.”
Widow’s Bay is streaming on Apple TV+.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login