New analysis by pension consultants LCP has found that only around 5.4% of Britain’s pensioners – roughly one in 18 – are likely to benefit from the scheme due to begin in 2027/28.
Perhaps most strikingly, no pensioner who reached state pension age before April 6, 2016 – those born before April 6 2016 – is expected to qualify, despite many having identical retirement incomes to those who will receive the tax break.
The findings raise fresh questions over the Government’s attempt to solve what experts say is an increasingly awkward political problem: the state pension rising above the frozen personal tax allowance.
Why pensioners could start paying tax on the state pension
Under the “triple lock”, the state pension rises each year by whichever is highest of inflation, average earnings growth or 2.5%.
At the same time, the personal allowance – currently £12,570 – remains frozen until 2030.
As a result, analysts expect the full new state pension to exceed the tax-free allowance from April 2027, meaning pensioners who rely solely on the state pension would begin receiving tax demands from HMRC.
LCP estimates those tax bills could rise rapidly:
- Around £88 in 2027/28
- Around £153 in 2028/29
- Around £220 in 2029/30
In last year’s Budget, the Government pledged to prevent these pensioners from paying tax through a special exemption.
But pensions experts say the proposal is far narrower than many retirees may realise.
Experts warn the “vast majority” will receive nothing
According to LCP’s deep-dive analysis of official pension data, the overwhelming majority of retirees will not qualify.
The consultancy estimates:
- Britain currently has around 13.2 million state pension recipients
- Around 7.7 million pensioners on the old state pension system will automatically miss out
- Of the roughly 5 million on the new state pension, most will also fail to qualify because they have additional income, protected payments or overseas residency
That leaves only around 700,000 pensioners potentially benefiting from the tax concession.
Former pensions minister and LCP partner Steve Webb said the policy creates major inequalities between pensioners on different systems.
“Two separate policies – triple lock uprating of the state pension and freezing of tax thresholds – will collide next year,” Webb said.
“From 2027 onwards, someone with just the new state pension and no other income will start getting annual tax bills from HMRC.”
He added: “The proposed solution is deeply flawed. It discriminates against those on the old state pension system, even if they have identical income to someone on the new system.”
Why nobody who retired before April 2016 will benefit
One of the biggest revelations in the report is that pensioners under the pre-2016 state pension system appear effectively excluded.
Under the Government’s proposal, the exemption only applies to pensioners whose sole income is the “basic state pension” with no additions or increments.
But the old basic state pension remains far below the tax threshold – currently around £9,614 a year – making it highly unlikely these pensioners would owe income tax anyway.
In reality, many retirees under the old system receive extra state pension income through SERPS or the State Second Pension.
However, that additional income automatically disqualifies them from the exemption.
Experts say this creates highly unusual situations where two pensioners with identical total retirement incomes are treated differently solely because their pension is structured differently.
For example:
- A pensioner receiving only the full new state pension could qualify for the tax write-off
- A pensioner receiving the same amount via the old basic pension plus SERPS would still face a tax bill
Webb said this amounted to “differential treatment” with no obvious justification.
Everyone eligible for the basic State Pension has now reached State Pension age. To get it you need to have enough National Insurance qualifying years.
You also need to be either a:
- man born before 6 April 1951
- woman born before 6 April 1953
If you were born on or after these dates, you’ll claim the new State Pension instead.
Small private pensions could trigger large tax penalties
Experts also warned the scheme creates sharp “cliff edges” that may punish pensioners with even tiny amounts of additional income.
Under the current proposal, receiving as little as £1 of taxable income outside the state pension could mean losing the entire tax exemption.
That could affect retirees with:
- Small workplace pensions
- Savings income
- Tiny annuities
- Automatic enrolment pension pots
Pensions tax specialists say some retirees could inadvertently trigger much larger tax bills simply by cashing in modest pension savings.
LCP pensions expert Alasdair Mayes said the plans risk adding complexity rather than simplifying the system.
“This is another example of a seemingly well-intentioned policy announcement adding complexity and unfairness in the tax system,” Mayes said.
“A simple and transparent tax system would be a benefit to all.”
Recommended reading:
Experts warn future governments face growing costs
Analysts say the policy may also become increasingly expensive and politically difficult to reverse.
Because the state pension is expected to continue rising faster than the frozen tax threshold, the amount of tax being waived would increase every year.
By 2029/30, the Government could be writing off more than £200 annually for each qualifying pensioner.
Experts say the measure risks becoming politically entrenched in the same way as the triple lock itself.
Webb warned the policy currently looks like a temporary “sticking plaster” rather than a lasting solution.
“It may be reasonably easy to defend not collecting £88 in tax from relatively low-income pensioners in year one,” he said.
“But as the years go by the Government would be writing off hundreds of pounds per eligible pensioner per year, at a growing cost to taxpayers.”
Could increasing everyone’s Personal Allowance be a fairer alternative?
LCP’s report suggests ministers may eventually need to consider broader reforms.
One option would be a higher tax-free allowance specifically for pensioners, ensuring the full state pension always remains below the tax threshold.
But experts estimate that could cost more than £2 billion annually by the end of the decade because it would benefit millions of pensioners already paying tax.
Another possibility would be simply writing off very small HMRC bills for all pensioners regardless of pension type.
Analysts say this would remove some of the unfairness between old and new state pension systems – although it could still create cliff-edge problems.
For now, experts say the Government still faces major unanswered questions before the policy is implemented in April 2027.
And for millions of pensioners – especially anyone who retired before April 2016 – the promised tax break may never arrive at all.
You must be logged in to post a comment Login